Qmetry User Interface Recommendations Ray Matsil
Issues— Tool-Tip Recommendation This “hide pane” icon does not have a tool tip on hover, all other icons do. Recommendation Add Tool Tip to this icon on hover
Issues— Dashboard There is no indication on the home dashboard that you can only add 4 graphs It has a confusing animation when you attempt to add a 5th graph Overall interaction paradigm is not intuitive
Recommendation— Dashboard Indicate that there can only be four graphs on screen at once Remove “reshuffle” animation effect
Issues—Hint Affordance Not very useful to hide a hint when the hint bar doesn’t hide The left and right arrows could be misleading Seems like they would reveal more hints Recommendations Have entire hint bar hide when hide button is clicked Have left and right arrows reveal additional tips
Issues—Hint Location Hints would be more helpful in context
Recommendation—Hint Location Focus hints in context Attach supporting document to describe steps
Issues—Deactivate Inactive Buttons Users should not be able to click buttons when they are not active
Recommendation– Deactivate Inactive Buttons “Grey out” Inactive buttons
Issues—Menu Consistency Left click in the left pane the Qmetry menu opens Left click in the right pane and the regular browser menu opens
Recommendation—Menu Consistency Standardize menus Right click menus in right pane would add additional options for users
Issues — Icon consistency Export report icons are not in the same location across the UI Cursor does not change when it rolls over these icons
Recommendations—Icon consistency Place export report icons in same location (either top left of top right) across entire UI On rollover change the cursor to indicate interactivity
Issues — Flow Consistency Clicking the blue icon brings the user to a screen with no navigation, this is the only place where this happens
Recommendation — Flow Consistency Window should be a pop-up or stay within navigation All other icons on this page bring up pop-ups
Issues — Consistency In some parts of UI “send Email” is a button and in some parts its an icon
Recommendation — Consistency Have all “Send Email” actions as a button or icon
Issue — New Pane Appears In Admin > Platform when the user clicks attributes a new pane appears Only place where this happens
Recommendation — New Pane Appears Have this icon bring up a pop-up window Stay consistent with the rest of the interface
Issue — Inline Editing In Admin > Platform when adding or editing a platform it is done inline This is the only area in the interface where this is done
Recommendation — Inline Editing Either implement this in other parts of the interface or remove it Stay consistent Could help in other parts of interface
Issues—Accordions Accordions can only be opened and collapsed by clicking the arrows in the corner
Recommendation—Accordions Make entire accordion clickable This will reduce confusion
Issues—Allow Users a Way Out Allow users to cancel or exit during an action if they decide they don’t want to do it
Recommendation—Allow Users a Way Out Add a cancel button Cancel
Issues — Sub-Tabs The sub-tabs in the right pane are difficult to notice
Recommendation—Sub-Tabs Change background contrast to make tabs more visible
Issues—Customization Flow chart revealed that a lot of action is taken from many different screens Recommendation Allow users to customize the screen they come to when they log in
Issues — System Feedback When attempting to add a TestSuite to the root folder the system displays this message Recommendation Add more detailed explanation (why can’t you add it there?)
Issues — Icon Affordance It is not obvious that Icons in Execute TestSuite sub-tab Automation column are clickable Recommendation Combine icons or change to links to stay consistent with clicking affordance
Issue — Visibility of System Status In TestReports page when the user clicks different reports there is no indication of what the system is doing
Recommendation — Visibility of System Status Have the page update the status Inform the user while loading, when complete Create animation that makes it clearer that screen is changing, such as a fade
Issue — Definitive Actions In Admin under Release and Build tab > Scope Edit sub-tab there are no definitive Save or Cancel actions
Recommendation — Definitive Actions Add a “Cancel” or save button to allow the user to take concrete action
Thank You! Questions?