A Comparative Institutional Diagnosis of Civil Service INTER-AMERICAN DEVELOPMENT BANK Regional Policy Dialogue Network on Public Policy Management and Transparency Washington DC, December 2003 A Comparative Institutional Diagnosis of Civil Service Systems Indices of 17 Countries Francisco Longo Instituto de Dirección y Gestión Pública
* Peru I: Entities subject to public law **Peru II: Entities subject to private labor laws
ARGENTINA EFFICIENCY 14,00 MERIT 12,00 STRUCTURAL CONSISTENCY 10,00 Strategic Consistency Management Consistency 8,00 Process Consistency 6,00 FUNCTIONAL CAPACITY 4,00 Competence Incentive Effectiveness 2,00 Flexibility 0,00 Argentina INTREGRATING CAPACITY
BARBADOS EFFICIENCY 14,00 MERIT 12,00 STRUCTURAL CONSISTENCY 10,00 STRATEGIC CONSISTENCY Management Consistency 8,00 Process Consistency 6,00 FUNCTIONAL CAPACITY 4,00 Competence Incentive Effectiveness 2,00 Flexibility 0,00 Barbados INTEGRATING CAPACITY
BOLIVIA EFFICIENCY 4,50 MERIT 4,00 STRUCTURAL CONSISTENCY 3,50 Strategic 3,00 Consistency Management Consistency 2,50 Process Consistency 2,00 FUNCTIONAL 1,50 CAPACITY Competence 1,00 Incentive Effectiveness 0,50 Flexibility 0,00 Bolivia INTEGRATING CAPACITY
BRAZIL EFFICIENCY 18,00 MERIT 16,00 STRUCTURAL 14,00 CONSISTENCY Strategic 12,00 Consistency Management Consistency 10,00 Process Consistency 8,00 FUNCTIONAL 6,00 CAPACITY Competence 4,00 Incentive Effectiveness 2,00 Flexibility 0,00 Brazil INTEGRATING CAPACITY
COLOMBIA EFFICIENCY MERIT STRUCTURAL CONSISTENCY Strategic Consistency Management Consistency Process Consistency FUNCTIONAL CAPACITY Competence Incentive Effectiveness Flexibility INTEGRATING CAPACITY
COSTA RICA EFFICIENCY MERIT STRUCTURAL CONSISTENCY Strategic Management Consistency Process Consistency FUNCTIONAL CAPACITY Competence Incentive Effectiveness Flexibility INTEGRATING CAPACITY
ECUADOR EFFICIENCY MERIT STRUCTURAL CONSISTENCY Strategic Consistency Management Consistency Process Consistency FUNCTIONAL CAPACITY Competence Incentive Effectiveness Flexibility INTEGRATING CAPACITY
*PERU I *Entities subject to public law EFICIENCIA EFFICIENCY 9,00 MÉRITO MERIT 8,00 CONSISTENCIA STRUCTURAL 7,00 ESTRUCTURAL CONSISTENCY Consistencia Strategic 6,00 Estratégica Consistency Consistencia Directiva Management Consistency 5,00 Consistencia de los Process Consistency 4,00 Procesos CAPACIDAD FUNCTIONAL 3,00 FUNCIONAL CAPACITY Competencia Competence 2,00 Eficacia Incentivadora Incentive Effectiveness 1,00 Flexibilidad Flexibility 0,00 Peru I CAPACIDAD INTEGRATING INTEGRADORA CAPACITY *Entities subject to public law
**PERU II ** Entities subject to private labor laws EFICIENCIA EFFICIENCY 16,00 MÉRITO MERIT 14,00 CONSISTENCIA STRUCTURAL ESTRUCTURAL CONSISTENCY 12,00 Consistencia Strategic Estratégica Consistency 10,00 Consistencia Directiva Management Consistency 8,00 Consistencia de los Process Consistency Procesos 6,00 CAPACIDAD FUNCTIONAL FUNCIONAL CAPACITY Competencia Competence 4,00 Eficacia Incentivadora Incentive Effectiveness 2,00 Flexibilidad Flexibility 0,00 Peru II CAPACIDAD INTEGRATING INTEGRADORA CAPACITY ** Entities subject to private labor laws
GUATEMALA EFFICIENCY MERIT STRUCTURAL CONSISTENCY Strategic Management Consistency Process Consistency FUNCTIONAL CAPACITY Competence Incentive Effectiveness Flexibility INTEGRATING CAPACITY
JAMAICA EFFICIENCY MERIT STRUCTURAL CONSISTENCY Strategic Consistency Management Consistency Process Consistency FUNCTIONAL CAPACITY Competence Incentive Effectiveness Flexibility INTEGRATING CAPACITY
MEXICO EFICIENCIA EFFICIENCY 12,00 MÉRITO MERIT CONSISTENCIA 10,00 STRUCTURAL ESTRUCTURAL CONSISTENCY Consistencia Strategic Estratégica Consistency 8,00 Consistencia Directiva Management Consistency 6,00 Consistencia de los Process Consistency Procesos CAPACIDAD FUNCTIONAL 4,00 FUNCIONAL CAPACITY Competencia Competence 2,00 Eficacia Incentivadora Incentive Effectiveness Flexibilidad Flexibility 0,00 Mexico CAPACIDAD INTEGRATING INTEGRADORA CAPACITY
NICARAGUA EFFICIENCY MERIT STRUCTURAL CONSISTENCY Strategic Management Consistency Process Consistency FUNCTIONAL CAPACITY Competence Incentive Effectiveness Flexibility INTEGRATING CAPACITY
PARAGUAY EFFICIENCY MERIT STRUCTURAL CONSISTENCY Strategic Consistency Management Consistency Process Consistency FUNCTIONAL CAPACITY Competence Incentive Effectiveness Flexibility INTEGRATING CAPACITY
DOMINICAN REPUBLIC EFICIENCIA EFFICIENCY 7,00 MÉRITO MERIT 6,00 CONSISTENCIA STRUCTURAL ESTRUCTURAL CONSISTENCY Consistencia Strategic 5,00 Estratégica Consistency Consistencia Directiva Management Consistency 4,00 Consistencia de los Process Consistency Procesos 3,00 CAPACIDAD FUNCTIONAL FUNCIONAL CAPACITY 2,00 Competencia Competence Eficacia Incentivadora 1,00 Incentive Effectiveness Flexibilidad Flexibility 0,00 Dominican R. CAPACIDAD INTEGRATING INTEGRADORA CAPACITY
TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO EFICIENCIA EFICIENCIA EFFICIENCY 14,00 MÉRITO MERIT 12,00 CONSISTENCIA ESTRUCTURAL CONSISTENCIA STRUCTURAL ESTRUCTURAL CONSISTENCY 10,00 Consistencia Estratégica Consistencia Strategic Estratégica Consistency Consistencia Directiva 8,00 Consistencia Directiva Management Consistency Consistencia de los Procesos Consistencia de los Process Consistency 6,00 CAPACIDAD Procesos FUNCIONAL CAPACIDAD FUNCTIONAL 4,00 Competencia FUNCIONAL CAPACITY Competencia Competence Eficacia Incentivadora 2,00 Eficacia Incentivadora Incentive Effectiveness Flexibilidad 0,00 Flexibilidad Trinidad and Tobago Flexibility CAPACIDAD INTEGRADORA CAPACIDAD INTEGRATING INTEGRADORA CAPACITY
URUGUAY EFFICIENCY MERIT STRUCTURAL CONSISTENCY Strategic Consistency Management Consistency Process Consistency FUNCTIONAL CAPACITY Competence Incentive Effectiveness Flexibility INTEGRATING CAPACITY
VENEZUELA EFFICIENCY MERIT STRUCTURAL CONSISTENCY Strategic Management Consistency Process Consistency FUNCTIONAL CAPACITY Competence Incentive Effectiveness Flexibility INTEGRATING CAPACITY