WP2 PRESENTATION May 27, 2003
Current Project Status WP1 - ANALYSIS OF Malpensa OPERATIONS 03.02.2003 26.05.2003 WP2 - IDENTIFICATION AND SELECTION OF COMMON IMPROVEMENTS 27.05.2003 30.09.2003 Steering Comittee ASSESSMENT / DECISION WP3 - IMPLEMENTATION PHASE WP4 - TRIALS AND EVALUATION to be specified
WP2 APPROACH Jun, 2003 Sept , 2003 Holidays May 27 - Presentation and Steering Committee WP1 : Analyse the state of operations at Malpensa WP2: Identify and select common improvement targets WP3 : Design and implement processes and information systems WP4 : Measure, follow up and correct Prepare operational requirements for the implementation phase PHASE 1 PHASE 2 PHASE 3 PHASE 4 Determine the WP2 scope and objectives Choice between different axes Define a CDM Project for Malpensa Design macro processes, information flows and collaborative procedures Consolidate outputs from the several parties Conduct Limited Business Case for each proposed implementation Final Presentation and report writing Jun, 2003 Sept , 2003 Holidays
Preliminary Assessment Organisational Issue : Cross Organisations Teams and Decision Making Optimisation of Airport Resources Today: “Individual Company View” Airport Airlines ATC Handling agents Tomorrow: “Extended Enterprise View” Airport Airlines ATC Handling agents Individual optimisation, often not considering the effect on other stakeholders All companies aware of cross organisational interfaces Little or no cross-organisational communication with respect to decisions with cross- organisational impact All companies balancing their economic targets in an integrated way Interfacing with other partners (e.g. handlers, AOC, etc. Non-optimal Result Cross-organisational teams and decision making Cross-organisational key performance indicators
CDM Potential Proposals WP2
CDM - Objectives
Airport CDM BARCELONA WP3 : Information System
Mission Link airport slot with flight plan data and relevant information of ARRIVING and DEPARTING flights, Link airport operations, aircraft operators and ATC systems, Provide one set of data describing the status and partners intentions on a given flight, Serve as base for information sharing between partners, Useful for collaborative procedures (pre-departure sequence). Expected Benefits : Common Situation Awareness Support the local collaborative decision-making Facilitate the implementation of collaborative procedures
Milestones Approach CDM Events / Milestones Off-Blocks TOBT-d TOBT Foreign Airspace National Airspace Outstation Hub Airport National Airspace Foreign Airspace Outstation Off-Blocks Outstation Take-Off Outstation Entering National Airspace Touchdown On-Blocks Off-Blocks Take-Off Leaving National Airspace Touchdown Outstation On-Blocks Outstation ACC ACC Airlines ATFM TWR TWR G.Handling S/G Take-Off Start Up Off Block Final Approach In Blocks Take Off TOBT-d TOBT Landing in d min Landed Start Ground Handling Ready in d min. Ready Delay All doors closed Jetways/airbridges removed Pushback truck in place (contact stand) Ready to taxi immediatel after clearance Ready to de-ice (in de-icing conditions) Aircraft will be ”landed” in d minutes (d = 30 minutes) Aircraft will be ”ready” in d minutes (d = 30 minutes) CDM Events / Milestones
AIRPORT CDM INFORMATION SYSTEM Common to Arriving / Departing Flights Aircraft registration, Flight status, Aircraft type, Flight type, Handling agent Aircraft Registration Flight Number ATC Callsign Arriving Flights Departing Flights ATC callsign for departing flight Flight Number ADES SID Boarding Gate Off Block Time (EOBT ) Estimated Ready Time (ERDT) Take Off Time (ETOT) Turn around Period (ETAP) Taxi-out Period (EXOP) Departure Runway Parking Position Number of passengers Delay and Delay Code or updated EOBT / ETOT ATC callsign for arriving flight Flight Number ADEP Schengen / Non Schengen Arrival Lounge Departure Times Flight (ETOT) Arrival Times (ELDT) On Stand Times (EIBT) Taxi-in Period (EXIP) Arrival Ruway Parking Position Number of Passengers Delay and Delay Code or updated ELDT / EIBT
Continuous Improvement SXOP = Airport Average Taxi Out Period EXOP = Location : S&G and RWY , Peak Hour .. TXOP = Flight : airport constraints Continuous Improvement of EOBT with Automatic Update at Off Block - 2h00 COBT = SLDT + SXIP + STAP ETOT = COBT + SXOP FUM Landing - 30’ COBT = TLDT + EXIP + ETAP ETOT = COBT + EXOP ATC Landing COBT = ALDT + TXIP + TTAP ETOT = COBT + EXOP TWR In Block COBT = AIBT + TTAP ETOT = COBT + EXOP Airline Real Time Constraints = Airline Contract for all Partners ~ Off Block - 30’ TOBT = EOBT + Airline Intentions ETOT = TOBT + EXOP TWR Airport Constraints TOBT- 20’ TTOT = TSDT + TXOP EOBT : Estimated Off-Block Time TTAP : Target Turn Around Period TTOT : Target Take-Off Time EXOP : Estimated Taxi-Out Period
The CDM Traffic Monitor Status OBK Off Block BRD Boarding OST On Stand FNL Final Approach FIR A/C in span. Airspace INI FPL has been received SCH Airport program The CDM Traffic Monitor Selection of user defined list operations departures arrivals combined list search for flight Operations list defined by user profile Llegada Arrival Salida Departure Orden sorting order by TOBT ID Lleg. Arr. Call-sign Id salidas Dep. Call-sign Est-Opera Operational Staus Tipo Aeron A/C type SOST Scheduled OnStandTime EOST Estimated OnStandTime ELDT Estimated LandingTime SOBT Scheduled OffBlockTime EOBT Estimated OffBlockTime TOBT Target OffBlockTime E/CTOT Estimat/Calculat OBT White Frame indicates Data recently changed Blue: Flight has CFMU slot System in testing phase RED indicates Boarding Alarm GREEN indicates Airport slot / flight plan incoherence
Airport CDM ZAVENTEM WP3 : Pre - Departure Sequence
Shared Responsibility Airport : S&G DEP ARR EOBT- 30’ TOBT- 25’ Clearance ETOT Request A.O.C Handlers Pilot EOBT Airline End of Ramp Start-Up Request TOBT Taxi Out Period At TOBT - 30 At TOBT - 25’ Start-Up Delivery Take-Off Tower New Estimates EOBT-40’ < > -20’ TOBT CTOT Regulation CFMU Delay CTOT taxi.time 15’ Taxi Period Start-Up Delivery Take-Off TWR PRE - DEPARTURE SEQUENCE
Pre-Departure Sequence EOBT ETOT Taxi = 15’ ~EOBT -30’ TOBT ETOT XOP = 18’ Airline / Handler TOBT : Target Off Block Time TOBT -25’ : AOBT- 5’ < TOBT < AOBT + 5’ SDT TOT XOP = 20’ TWR TOT : Take-Off Time : ATOT- 5’ < TOT < ATOT + 5’ Pre-Departure Sequence EOBT : Estimated Off-Block Time SDT : Start-Up Delivery Time TOT : Take-Off Time XOP : Taxi-Out Period
We have to be FLEXIBLE TOBT Procedure AOC Handler Pilot TWR CFMU CTOT ETOT -60’ or EOBT-40’ at least EOBT-20’ EOBT-15’ CTOT compliant no compliant due to airport due to airline TOBT-H TOBT-S < 5’ We have to be FLEXIBLE TOBT-H TOBT-R DPI HOPS TOBT-H TOBT-D New EOBT New CTOT ETOT -60’ or EOBT-40’ EOBT-20’ EOBT-15’ TOBT-H TOBT-S TOBT-X TOBT-S = Target Start-up Clearance Delivery Time TOBT-H = Ready Time Handlers TOBT-R = TOBT-H revised / HOPS holding point slot TOBT-D = TOBT-H denied (CFMU constraint) TOBT-X = TOBT-H or S or D revoked (airport disruption) DPI: Departure Planning Information (new-TTOT)
INCENTIVE TOBT Procedure Rules: Airline ATC Organisation Slotted aircraft get a higher priority than non slotted aircraft TOBT-H transmitted between 60’ and 40’ before estimated take off time (ETOT) or 40’ and 20’ before estimated off block time (EOBT) Without slot, TOBT-H is used to enter the flight into the pre departure sequence Without TOBT-H, flight will be treated as today Issue of a new TOBT-H results in a new TWR sequencing (S, R or D) At TOBT-S +2’, no taxi or no start-up request or no actual off block time (AOBT) the flight will be re-sequenced at the end of the queue ATC The sequenced TOBT (S, R or D) will follow within 5’ after TOBT-H TWR sends a TOBT-X in case of re-sequencing due to the airport conditions TWR evaluates a standard taxi out period according to stand position and the period of the day TWR calculates a HOPS time Organisation Punctuality steering Committee (Airport: BIAC, Belgocontrol, (Airlines, Handlers)) Performance Committee (BIAC, Belgocontrol, Airlines, Handlers, CFMU, CEE..) INCENTIVE
Airport CDM CFMU WP3 : New Messages FUM, DPIs
Air Traffic Flow and Capacity Management Specify exchange between CFMU and Airport CDM, Specify exchange in the context of: . information on the inbound flights : LDT . information on the outbound flights : TOT . disruptions . FPL - Airport Schedule consistency checking, Define the timing, trigger and content of the messages, Evaluate the benefits for CFMU, Airports and AOs.
FUM : Flight Update Message LDT The FUM is sent to advise Airport CDM and APP about the modification of ETA and to supply the APP with the new estimated time and FL over the IAF of the STAR or over the last point of the Route. AND With the DPI3 and DPI2 messages issued to the CFMU from the outstation the FUM message may be sent to advise Airport CDM and APP about the modification of ETA before the Off Block Time .
DPI : Departure Planning Information TOT CFMU : - use Take Off Time instead of ( Off Block + Taxi Time ) CDM Airport : - identified like a CFMU partner : CDM-A DPI : - are Informative Messages from CDM-A to CFMU . do not re-compute the SLOT . system to system message . triggered by system events . sent automatically DPI DATA : Take Off Time belongs to CDM-A The consistency between FPL / DPI is the responsibility of the CDM-A DPI : For all flights (regulated or not) TTOT : Target Take-Off Time SXOP : Standard Taxi-Out Period
DPI : Departure Planning Information Taxi = 17’ EOBT EOBT -3h00 -2h ETOT improvement slot pre-allocation Taxi 19’ DPI 2 ETOT DPI 2 Taxi 19’ EOBT Delay Taxi = 20’ CTOT ETOT Slot Allocation SDT SDT -20’ frozen slot DPI 1 TOT shift to first free slot or slot swapping SDT -20’ DPI 1 TOT frozen slot CFMU Today SIT1 EOBT ETOT Taxi = 15’ Airport In red : milestones EOBT : Estimated Off-Block Time TSDT : Target Start-Up Delivery Time
Airport CDM VANTAA & ARLANDA WP2 : Proposals
AIRPORT CDM INFORMATION SYSTEM Taxi Period Study (in & out) Collaborative Procedures . De-icing . Pre-Departure Sequence Post Operation Analysis based on CDM KPIs
TAAM Arlanda Airport Modelling Taxi Time Simulation
TAXI -OUT PERIOD STUDY - RATIONALE In the US, Taxi delay results in the largest direct operating costs of all delays, The average taxi-out delay per flight is approximately twice the airborne delay (ref. ATA study, 2000), Even if aircraft burn fuel 5 times faster when airborne, crew and equipment costs make the spend rate about 2/3 (taxiing aircraft versus airborne aircraft), The cost of taxi out delays in the US exceeds 1 billion USD per year, On average, Taxi out delays is 3 times larger than taxi-in delays, Non-Flexible Taxi-out Periods lead to C/ETOT uncertainty and ATC overdeliveries.
Airport CDM Malpensa WP2 : Proposals
CDM Project Proposals for Change Item Definition Improve the Information System according to the CDM requirements (milestones approach, Target Off Block Time...), Define a CDM Service Level Agreement Concept for data exchange/applications, Identify CDM processes,
CDM Project Proposals for Change Item Definition Improve the Collaboration according to the CDM requirements : Flexible Taxi Time, Pre-departure sequence, ATFM DPI messages transmission, Airlines’ priorities, Disruption recovery… Perform a light Cost Benefit Analysis for each implementation.
Post Operations Analysis Objectives (WP 4 preparation) Definition of CDM KPIs (at the Airport Level) acknowledged by all airport partners, Retrieve information from existing systems, Analysis and Compilation into understandable documents, Maintain the data quality On a regular basis, analysis of the results in a meeting with representatives of all airport partners.
Post Operations Analysis Expected Benefits Standard and common basis for all aiport partners, Better assessment of operations efficiency that would help in discussing possible improvements, Better forecasts, identification and quantification of problems, Possibility to have a better view on financial impacts.
Airport KPIs Estimates Measurements done at different milestones Comparison prior to CDM and with CDM Evaluate Turn around time Decrease S&G changes Evaluate Security Check-in Period Measure occupancy duration AOBT - AIBT Measure estimates occupancy in /out block EIBT/EOBT and EIBT/ESDT Measure the number of changes in the S&G allocation Measure and compare period between EOBT-EIBT and ESDT-EIBT Measure ESCP (Start check-in time and End check-in time) Compare ESCP and ASCP Improve Punctuality Passengers Information Change ETD information by TOBT information (no ATFM delay) Give ESCP (Start check-in time and End check-in time) information Optimise use of Available Capacity ( S&G, Checking pax and bax ) Optimize S&G occupancy Optimize check-in operations Count flights request to the TWR with earlier off block time (for waiting bay or taxi way) Count flights with earlier off block time (accepted by the TWR) Count number of ESCP end after the start boarding time Increase Efficiency Adapt S&G allocation to : - Airline preferences - Handlers preferences Measure satisfaction rate: airline, handlers Improve Bag service Count number of luggage out of allowed volume and/or weight Count number of delayed flight with handbag problem after the boarding Compare the number of Bag containers and the number of destinations
Airport KPIs Reduce Environmental Nuisance Reduce noise on ground Reduce emission from engines Measure taxi-in and taxi-out periods by runways configuration Measure waiting period by flight at the holding point Improve Safety Reduce Movements Number (trucks, bus,…) Measure number of last S&G changes due to overlapping between arrival and departure after ESDT -20’
CDM Project Proposals for Change Proposed Approach WP 1 Proposed Approach WP 2 Comments, Questions
Acronyms -IBT - IN BLOCK TIME -IFP - IN FLIGHT PERIOD (EET : Estimated Elapsed Time) -LDT - LANDING TIME -OBT - OFF BLOCK TIME -SDT - START UP DELIVERY TIME -TAP - TURN AROUND PERIOD -TOT - TAKE-OFF TIME -XIP - TAXI IN PERIOD -XOP - TAXI OUT PERIOD ADEP AERODROME of DEPARTURE ADES AERODROME of DESTINATION AGHT ACTUAL GROUND HANDLING TIME ARDT ACTUAL READY TIME (ramp operation) ASRT ACTUAL START UP REQUEST TIME HOPS HOLDING POINT SLOT REG REGISTRATION NUMBER SIW SLOT IMPROVEMENT WINDOW AATOT ANTICIPATED ACTUAL TARGET TAKE-OFF TIME (CFMU) ATTOT AIRCRAFT OPERATOR TARGET TAKE-OFF TIME (CFMU) CTOT CALCULATED TAKE OFF TIME (CFMU) SIT1 SLOT ISSUE TIME, EOBT - 2h00 (CFMU) DPI DEPARTURE PLANNING INFORMATION FSA FIRST SYSTEM ACTIVATION FUM FLIGHT UPDATE MESSAGE CDM Collaborative Decision Making CFMU Central Flow Management Unit FPL ICAO Flight Plan or Filed Flight Plan HMI Human Machine Interface DARSA Delay Analysis Report at Swedish Airports Rem : first letter -XXX S for Scheduled , I for Initial , E for Estimated , T for Target , A for Actual, C for Calculated