Clinical Performance Development in NHS Direct 2003-4 Dr Andrew Lee NAGPC Annual Conference March 2004.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Nursing Diagnosis: Definition
Advertisements

Parallel Flow Visualization/Mitigation Proposal
Single access model - past, present & future Paul Wilding - Medical Director NHS Direct West Yorkshire.
Delivering Out-of-Hours Services David Carson. My Presentation Policy Framework Who will deliver OOH services? The role of PCTs and SHAs Some cross-cutting.
Paramedic Practitioner Support Scheme for Older People with Minor Injuries or Conditions South Yorkshire Ambulance Service NHS Trust Sheffield.
Personal Medical Services in North Bradford PCT
HELP US TO PREVENT INFECTIONS SPREADING cleanyourhands campaign 2008/09.
Safer IT Systems for the NHS Dr. Maureen Baker CBE DM FRCGP Special Clinical Adviser NPSA Clinical Safety Officer CfH.
College of Occupational Therapists Annual Conference Glasgow 2003.
PRIMIS Third National Conference Tuesday 1 April 2003 Birmingham HIP for CHD Jane Matthews Practice Nurse Dr. Dai Evans PRIMIS Regional Clinical Adviser.
Early Intervention Memory Service Norfolk and Suffolk Foundation Trust (NSFT) has been commissioned by Ipswich and East Suffolk CCG to establish and run.
Safer Systems for a Safer NHS Dr. Maureen Baker CBE DM FRCGP Clinical Director for Patient Safety NHS Connecting for Health.
Seven Day Services Cost-Benefit Analysis - Approach and Key Issues David Halsall Clinical Quality and Efficiency Analytical Team 20 th January 2012.
Partner notification for chlamydia by postal kit: pilot study results Gill Bell Nurse Consultant Sexual Health Adviser.
GP Practice Data Collection Pilot LWEG Update – November 2013.
Keep Them Safe Implementation GP NSW - Mental Health State Update Meeting March 2010 Jenny Marshall, Manager, Keep Them Safe Implementation Unit NSW Health.
1 Cervical Screening Programme, England, : Graphs.
Organizational Assessment Tool (OAT) Faizah Muheb VP, Analytical Services June 2013.
F1 projects surgical handover
Bath and North East Somerset Urgent Care Service Tees Resilience Event 14 October 2014.
Five Priorities for care of the dying person
Irish National Acute Medicine Programme Patient Flow Model O’Reilly O, Courtney G, Casey A* Problem Patients requiring urgent care experienced long delays.
Local Care, Local Doctors1 Care on Call - the OOH Service for Kent & Sussex Dr Stephen Bellamy Medical Director – Susdoc.
NHS Pathways Integrating Urgent and Emergency Care Jackie Shears Programme Head, NHS Pathways CMS.
Fylde Coast Integrated Diabetes Care
NHS Fife Primary Care Emergency Service (PCES) Out of Hours Primary Care Outcomes of Service Review Open Meetings Meetings May 2013 Janette Brogan Lead.
© Imperial College LondonPage 1 Non-Clinical Hot Topics in General Practice Professor Azeem Majeed Department of Primary Care & Social Medicine.
1 “Medicines use review conducted in community pharmacy" Professor Ian Chi Kei Wong Department of Health Public Health Career Scientist The School of Pharmacy.
Achieving improved cancer outcomes- a pathway approach, engaging primary care and partners Kathy Elliott Programme Director – NHS Improving Quality (Delivery.
The Tayside Experience The Long Road To Implementation Peter Rice, Consultant Psychiatrist, NHS Tayside Alcohol Problems Service.
Acute Quality Standards Dan Beckett Acute Physician CMO Advisor for Acute & General Medicine.
Chris Town Peterborough PCT. Peterborough Doctors On Call (PDOC) Established Doctors in Rota Peterborough NHS Walk-in Centre Established 2000.
NHS Direct and Out of Hours Care Paul Jenkins Acting National Director Dr Andy Lee - National Medical Adviser.
Electronic Palliative Care Summary (ePCS) Dr Peter Kiehlmann GP, Aberdeen & National Clinical Lead Palliative Care eHealth
Sharon Barrington Deputy Director Strategy and Planning Urgent Care: NHS 111 and GP Out-of-Hours Working with the people of Camden to achieve the best.
What is a Care Pathway? Ali El-Ghorr Implementation Advisor.
St John Project Transport to the Medical Home 20,000 Days Campaign Learning Session March 2013 Project Manager: Jo Goodfellow.
West Hertfordshire Hospitals NHS Trust West Hertfordshire Hospitals NHS Trust Challenges in POA Mrs Jane Jackson SRN MPhil MCGI Consultant Nurse Honorary.
CHILDREN AND YOUNG PEOPLE’S HEALTH SUPPORT GROUP Unscheduled Care Helen Maitland National Lead.
Older People’s Services The Single Assessment Process.
Other Performance Standards A&E:- A&E performance against the 4 hour standard improved in March and the Trust achieved 97.8%. Year to date overall performance.
Strengthening the commitment
North Somerset Clinical Commissioning Group ‘You said…We did’ Dr Mary Backhouse Chief Clinical Officer.
NATIONAL INFORMATION BOARD Personalised Health and Care 2020 Using Data and Technology to Transform Outcomes for Patients and Citizens Providing citizens.
Establish consultant availability Establish a single Appointment Centre Model clinical service delivery Focus on follow ups Focus on patient information.
Andrew Copley Director Of Finance & IM&T ~ Airedale NHS FT Care Anywhere the story so far…..
Neurosciences National Framework for Service Change Criteria Options Neurological Alliance Sub group 7 th December 2004 Agenda Item 4.1.
NHS West Kent Clinical Commissioning Group West Kent Urgent Care DRAFT Strategy Delivering a safe and sustainable urgent care system by
E n h a n c e d h e a l t h i n c a r e h o m e s Rachel Binks, Nurse Consultant - Acute and Digital Care Airedale NHSFT The Art of the Possible - Enabling.
Welcome The Trauma Audit & Research Network (TARN)
26 th February "This SPAF Integrated Care Clinic Programme is funded by Bayer HealthCare as a service to medicine and delivered by Apodi Ltd" Patient.
Developing a national governance framework for health promotion in Scottish hospitals Lorna Smith Senior Health Improvement Programme Officer NHS Health.
Information for Care. Everywhere. Latest innovations from Adastra to improve patient safety Dr Alex Yeates Medical Director.
WHY USE THE RCGP OUT OF HOURS CLINICAL AUDIT TOOLKIT ? Dr. Agnelo Fernandes MBE FRCGP 6 th March 2008.
Implementing Clinical Governance COMPASS Consultant Outcome Indicators Programme.
Service-related research: Therapy outcomes audit
Ronnette Lucraft Commercial Director, NHS Direct, and
NHS Pathways (Nov 2009) Dr Peter Fox Deputy Clinical Director
Urgent and emergency care service review
NHS GG&C Police Custody Healthcare
Nottinghamshire & Derbyshire GP / Pharmacy Transformation Programme Unlocking the Potential of Community Pharmacy Cathy Quinn Pharmacist Lead Newark &
CQUINS and Dementia GOAL:
Clinical audit 2017/18 National Results
Clinical Intake Assessment
Urgent Care Consultation Update
Clinical audit 2017/18 National Results
Worcestershire Colorectal Cancer 2ww Pathway
Pulling together: transforming urgent care for the people of Scotland
A collaborative approach to support Primary Care demand management: In-hours GP Triage Lynn Huckerby, Associate Director, Service Transformation and Digital,
Transforming 111 to Integrated Urgent Care
Presentation transcript:

Clinical Performance Development in NHS Direct Dr Andrew Lee NAGPC Annual Conference March 2004

Clinical performance indicators Standard national reports replaced individual site versions Reported at national, network, site, nursing team, and individual nurse level Separate 0845 and OOH Clinical performance targets –Sorting of symptomatic calls –Use of NHS CAS

Gold Standard Sorting Study

Aims Establish a benchmark of existing NHS practice in clinical risk tolerance for primary presentations (first point of contact) by telephone Identify and quantify any appropriate difference in the sorting profile for calls made to access GP OOH services and that for other NHS Direct calls Use the results to inform target setting for NHS Direct clinical performance indicators

Gold Standard Sorting Study First Stage - Benchmarking –113 GPs from England and Wales –Random sample of 600 NHS Direct calls and 300 GP OOH –Clinical details of each call reviewed independently by 10 reviewers

Gold Standard Sorting Study Second stage – Reviewing the Differences –Cases with significant disagreement between reviewers and NHSD identified –Consensus review of these by senior NHSD medical and nursing clinicians taking account of : NHS guidelines, clinical consistency and context of service model

Gold Standard Dispositions Dispositions used to calculate Gold Standard: –NHSD actual dispositions where consensus amongst reviewers same –NHSD actual dispositions where no consensus at all amongst reviewers –Dispositions chosen by senior NHSD clinicians in Consensus review stage

GP consensus? Unanimity amongst reviewers on level of care in only 7% of cases At least 2:1 consensus amongst reviewers on a level of care in 46% of cases At least 2:1 consensus amongst reviewers on whether referral to urgent care (999/A&E/GPOOH) needed or not in 74% of cases

When GP consensus re Urgent referral/Not High concordance with NHS Direct –NHSD actual disposition was same as reviewer consensus in 78% of cases –Gold standard is same as reviewer consensus in 96% of cases

Use of NHS CAS Compared the accuracy and risk of the three patterns of assessment: –Algo used and followed –Algo used but a different disposition chosen –No algorithm used Risk measured as potentially critical misses i.e. a Gold Standard disposition of Emergency or Urgent Care (999, A&E, GP 4 or 12) with an actual NHSD disposition below this level (in hours care or self care)

NHS CAS results Algorithm content safe Algorithm delivers gold standard sorting or nearer to it than altering in over 80% of use Not using an algorithm produced a rate of potentially critical misses nearly three times higher than when an algorithm was used whether the recommended disposition was followed or not

Comparison with other studies SWOOP study of nurse-led OOH triage (1997): 49.2% referred to GP OOH service (calls before midnight) NHSD Gold standard for GP OOH (combination of GP within 2 hours and GP within 6 hours) = 43% (+ some GP next day will go to OOH at weekends) Sheffield MCRU Appropriateness Study (2003): 13% overtriage and 1% undertriage (equivalent to a net reduction in urgency of 12%) NHSD Gold standard = reduction in emergency&urgent care 9.7% (0845) and 11.1% (OOH)

NHS CAS developments Disposition wording changed to make timeframes consistent with OOH access standards (1, 2 and 6 hours) Twice yearly major clinical content version releases ongoing Version 12 (April/May 2004) contains first Gold Standard related revisions

Summary GPs have difficulty agreeing on appropriate sorting NHS Directs sorting is not very different from what GPs can broadly agree on NHS Direct has a good safety record NHS Directs sorting can improve NHS Direct is taking actions to achieve that improvement NHS CAS will help nurses deliver that improvement