No amount of open access will fix the broken job market

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Ability-Based Education at Alverno College. Proposed Outcomes for Session 1. To introduce you to Alvernos approach to designing integrative general education.
Advertisements

CHLA, Ottawa, May 2007 Presented by: Cameron Macdonald, Director, NRC Research Press.
Designing Postgraduate Curricula For Transdisciplinary Fields: The case of security and crime science Dr Hervé Borrion* and Prof Richard Wortley, UCL Security.
UCL LIBRARY SERVICES Research libraries – new approaches for library-based publishing Dr Paul Ayris Director of UCL Library Services, UCL Copyright Officer,
Professor Ian Richards University of South Australia.
Publishing options: OA monographs. OA monographs and Jisc initiatives OAPEN-UK » Researcher survey insights » Researcher guide » Matched pairs pilot National.
Information Services and Systems Getting Published Information Services & Systems Post Graduate Research Programme.
Future Journeys: Post Graduate Education in Nursing & Midwifery Professor Brian J Webster Assistant Dean, Faculty of Health Life Social Sciences Vice Chair.
Ethics in Life Sciences: From theory to the real world Lecture No. 11.
Traditional Scholarly Publishing Data Information Knowledge Lab notes Memos/letters Diary Lab/dept meetings Research notes Conversations Statistics Preprints.
Renaissance Computing Institute Scholarly Communication in a Digital World: Some Thoughts Dan Reed
Publication and impact in English
Writing and Getting Published: An Arts Perspective Dr Laura Swift The Open University.
Section 2: Science as a Process
GL14 - Fourteenth International Conference on Grey Literature National Research Council Rome, Italy November 2012 Rosa Di Cesare, Marianna Nobile.
Fostering Open Access: Strategies and Activities of SNSF Open Access Day at EPFL, October, 24, 2013 Dr Daniel Höchli, Director of the Administrative Offices.
Working with your supervisors A/Prof Sam Richardson Former HDR Coordinator School of Medical Sciences 9 th April, 2015.
OA in the Humanities and Social Sciences 5th Conference on Open Access Scholarly Publishing September 18-20, 2013, Riga Eelco Ferwerda OAPEN Foundation.
UCL LIBRARY SERVICES New models for scholarly publishing Dr Paul Ayris Director of UCL Library Services and UCL Copyright Officer President of LIBER (Association.
Dr Rupert Gatti (Trinity College, Cambridge) Open Access Research Monographs in HSS Opportunities and Challenges.
Click to edit Master subtitle style UF Open Access Week, 26 October 2011 Open Access and the Digital Humanities Sophia Krzys Acord, Ph.D. Associate Director.
J E T E N Journal of European Teacher Education Network.
Page 1 Improving Research Publication Quality at GCU Professor John Marshall Director Academic Research Development.
The First Book Complex Decisions for Emerging Scholars.
Introduction to Earth Science Section 2 Section 2: Science as a Process Preview Key Ideas Behavior of Natural Systems Scientific Methods Scientific Measurements.
Relevance and Impact of Qualitative Research Qualitative Research Methods.
Publications Dr Sarah Wendt. Context PhD conferred Oct 2005, fulltime lecturer in 2006 at UniSA (40/40/20). Promoted to Senior Lecturer (2010). Social.
Early Career Research Anne Harvey Content: Courtesy of Professor Alan Johnson – Research Management Services International Pty Ltd Dr Joseph Bevitt – Secretary.
The Scientific Method. Objectives Explain how science is different from other forms of human endeavor. Identify the steps that make up scientific methods.
Digital repositories and scientific communication challenge Radovan Vrana Department of Information Sciences, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences,
REFLECTIONS ON PUBLISHING SIMON VERDUN-JONES SCHOOL OF CRIMINOLOGY SIMON FRASER UNIVERSITY.
October 1st 2015Lars Bjørnshauge. Good Publishing Practice – Open Access journals how the Directory of Open Access Journals contributes! Presentation.
Library/Press/University Collaborations The Electronic Publishing Initiative at Columbia.
Publishing for early career researchers University of Glasgow, october 2015 Suzanne Mekking, sr. Publisher Brill April
The New Now: Institutional Repositories and Academia Institutional Repository USM April 17, 2015 Marilyn Billings Scholarly Communication Librarian.
Flipping Journals to Open Access Issues and Experiences David J Solomon, PhD Professor Emeritus College of Human Medicine Michigan State University.
Authorship and Journal Choice Sandra Gillespie (postdoc)
CAPE INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY
Professor Liam Marnane Head School of Engineering
Before you start… Make sure you are using Bilkent University’s wifi or internet, or are accessing Bilkent University’s network remotely. This is essential.
Warwick Journal of Education – Transforming Teaching
Agenda for today’s presentation
Before you start… Make sure you are using your institution’s wifi or internet, or are accessing your institution’s network remotely. This is essential.
Scientific Publishing
DTC Impact module ‘Impact’: what, where and why
Social Polices and Social Welfare Administration
Chapter 9: Reporting and Evaluating Research
Publishing Academic Work
The culture of scientific research in the UK
Manage Change and Organizational Learning
: Mid-career academic women: Choices, strategies and opportunities
Writing Competitive Research Funding Applications: Tips and Advice Early-Career Researchers Information Session Friday, 26th October, 2012 Dr Barry Dixon.
Section 2: Science as a Process
Public Library of Science (PLOS)
Dr Charlotte Mathieson Teaching Fellow
Becoming an independent researcher
Open Access Journals Perspective from a former Editor-in-Chief
Research Student Development - Supporting Progress
Research Student Development - Supporting Progress
Research Student Development - Supporting Progress
PhD journey Dr. Katie Reed and Raymond Tweheyo
What works in careers and enterprise?
Research for all Sharing good practice in research management
Transformational Leadership
Balancing acts: teaching and research priorities, challenges, strategies Dr charlotte
What works in careers and enterprise?
Early career researchers & bibliometrics
CAPE INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY
Research Solutions Sales
Presentation transcript:

No amount of open access will fix the broken job market Publishing strategies for early-career open access advocates in the humanities Dr. Samuel moore

Sam the early-career researcher Recently completed PhD at King’s College London Common Struggles: Policy-based vs. scholar-led approaches to open access in the humanities Interested in open access, the commons and governance of research infrastructures Working in ‘critical publishing studies’ – a field comprising information studies, critical theory and science & technology studies

Sam the mid-career publisher Worked in publishing for 10 years Scientific journals for PLOS (PLOS ONE and PLOS Genetics) Humanities books, journals and publishing platforms for Open Book Publishers and Ubiquity Press Supporting collaborative infrastructures for scholar-led open access through the Radical Open Access Collective

Academia as ‘side hustle’

There are very few secure academic jobs for early-career researchers in the humanities

What does this mean for how Early-career researchers publish their books? Your choice of publisher confers symbolic capital: more capital = job Precarious researchers need to think carefully about where to publish their monographs ‘First’ monograph needs to be published with a prestigious press (based on unknown criteria…)

This situation prevents all the exciting practices associated with open access!

Experimental publishing

Open peer review / collaborative authorship / anonymous authorship

Ethical / political publishing

How do we solve this problem? Open access is clearly not a solution to the lack of jobs available Nor is it fair to ask early-career researchers to bear the risk for the transition to open access books So how do we address the problem of prestige publishing and open access?

Should we change tenure/promotion guidelines to reward open access?

Senior scholars need to lead the way Scholars with stable employment are able to take on more risk Often they will be rewarded for risky/innovative scholarship in a way that their junior colleagues will not be (seen as leaders in their field) To help normalise open access for long-form scholarship, senior scholars should lead the way (The Radical Open Access Collective site contains a list of 60+ scholar-led academic publishers, for example!)

Publishing strategies are not a zero-sum game Publishing strategies comprise a range of different kinds of work: Edited volumes, articles, experimental research, blogging, etc. Short open access monographs like Forerunners, Elements or Essential Knowledge Open access through other routes (repositories, etc.) Supporting open access book publishers (as editors, reviewers, etc.)

Policies for OA monographs (i. e Policies for OA monographs (i.e., Plan s) should stimulate experimentation Rather than forcing people to publish open access, the OA policy framework should stimulate new and alternative approaches to open access monograph provision Work with the broader motivations for the open access movement (not just a lack of public access to knowledge) Policies should aim to create the conditions for scholars to experiment with open practices

Build it and they will (eventually) come…

Ultimately, open access only makes sense as part of a project to resist and transform cultures of marketisation within publishing and higher education