Comments on LC TGbb PHY Evaluation Methodology Simulation Calibration May 2015 doc.: IEEE 802.11-15/0496r1 March 2019 Comments on LC TGbb PHY Evaluation Methodology Simulation Calibration Date: March 13, 2019 Authors: Jaesang Cha (SNUST) Edward Au (Marvell Semiconductor)

Introduction Two documents proposed for PHY evaluation methodology March 2019 Introduction Two documents proposed for PHY evaluation methodology 11-19-0186-02 by Volker Jungnickel (Fraunhofer HHI) 11-19-0272-01 by Nikola Serafimovski (pureLiFi) In PHY evaluation methodology document, some PHY simulation calibration on these documents are suggested To generalize PHY evaluation methodology for possible PHY schemes Jaesang Cha (SNUST)

Comments on PHY Evaluation Methodology Simulation Calibration May 2015 doc.: IEEE 802.11-15/0496r1 March 2019 Comments on PHY Evaluation Methodology Simulation Calibration The document title used on the doc 11-19-0186-02 is “PHY Evaluation Methodology Simulation Calibration” Change to “PHY Evaluation Methodology Simulation Calibration Procedure” No description for clause “1 Introduction” Add the following description for clause “1 Introduction” Text to add “This document introduce the procedure for simulation calibration of TGbb PHY proposals.” Subclause 2.1 title is given as “802.11a” Is it right for TGbb system model block diagram or “802.11a” system model block diagram Change subclause title to “PHY TX-RX System Model Block Diagram” Jaesang Cha (SNUST) Edward Au (Marvell Semiconductor)

Comments on PHY Evaluation Methodology Simulation Calibration…Cont. May 2015 doc.: IEEE 802.11-15/0496r1 March 2019 Comments on PHY Evaluation Methodology Simulation Calibration…Cont. Figure citations used as a “Figure XX” Change to “Figure 1” Insert Figure citations and Figure Name Insert Figure citations as “Figure 1” Insert Figure name as “Figure PHY TX-RX System Model Block Diagram” Only DCO-OFDM is referenced in the PHY Evaluation Methodology in doc. 11-19-0186-02. Is it mandatory uses Only DCO-OFDM for Simulation Any other scheme can be considered like ACO-OFDM Jaesang Cha (SNUST) Edward Au (Marvell Semiconductor)

Comments on PHY Evaluation Methodology Simulation Calibration…Cont. May 2015 doc.: IEEE 802.11-15/0496r1 March 2019 Comments on PHY Evaluation Methodology Simulation Calibration…Cont. MCS referred only “QPSK” in the PHY Evaluation Methodology in doc. 11-19-0186-02. Is it mandatory to use only QPSK for Simulation How about QAM? Jaesang Cha (SNUST) Edward Au (Marvell Semiconductor)

May 2015 doc.: IEEE 802.11-15/0496r1 March 2019 References [1] https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/19/11-19-0186-02-00bb-phy-evaluation-methodology.docx [2] https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/19/11-19-0272-01-00bb-phy-evaluation-methodology-simulation-calibration.docx Jaesang Cha (SNUST) Edward Au (Marvell Semiconductor)