Ranking Tertiary Education Systems Jamil Salmi Astana 15 June 2009.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Numbers Treasure Hunt Following each question, click on the answer. If correct, the next page will load with a graphic first – these can be used to check.
Advertisements

1 A B C
Scenario: EOT/EOT-R/COT Resident admitted March 10th Admitted for PT and OT following knee replacement for patient with CHF, COPD, shortness of breath.
Variations of the Turing Machine
Angstrom Care 培苗社 Quadratic Equation II
AP STUDY SESSION 2.
1
Copyright © 2003 Pearson Education, Inc. Slide 1 Computer Systems Organization & Architecture Chapters 8-12 John D. Carpinelli.
Copyright © 2011, Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. Chapter 6 Author: Julia Richards and R. Scott Hawley.
Myra Shields Training Manager Introduction to OvidSP.
Properties Use, share, or modify this drill on mathematic properties. There is too much material for a single class, so you’ll have to select for your.
David Burdett May 11, 2004 Package Binding for WS CDL.
1 RA I Sub-Regional Training Seminar on CLIMAT&CLIMAT TEMP Reporting Casablanca, Morocco, 20 – 22 December 2005 Status of observing programmes in RA I.
Local Customization Chapter 2. Local Customization 2-2 Objectives Customization Considerations Types of Data Elements Location for Locally Defined Data.
Create an Application Title 1Y - Youth Chapter 5.
Process a Customer Chapter 2. Process a Customer 2-2 Objectives Understand what defines a Customer Learn how to check for an existing Customer Learn how.
Custom Statutory Programs Chapter 3. Customary Statutory Programs and Titles 3-2 Objectives Add Local Statutory Programs Create Customer Application For.
Custom Services and Training Provider Details Chapter 4.
CALENDAR.
1 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt BlendsDigraphsShort.
1 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt RhymesMapsMathInsects.
1 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt FactorsFactors.
1 Click here to End Presentation Software: Installation and Updates Internet Download CD release NACIS Updates.
1. PHOTO INDEX Bayside: Page 5-7 Other Colour Leon: Page 8-10 Cabrera Page Canaria Page Driftwood Page 16 Florence Florence and Corfu Page.
Break Time Remaining 10:00.
Turing Machines.
Table 12.1: Cash Flows to a Cash and Carry Trading Strategy.
PP Test Review Sections 6-1 to 6-6
1 The Blue Café by Chris Rea My world is miles of endless roads.
Bright Futures Guidelines Priorities and Screening Tables
EIS Bridge Tool and Staging Tables September 1, 2009 Instructor: Way Poteat Slide: 1.
Bellwork Do the following problem on a ½ sheet of paper and turn in.
Exarte Bezoek aan de Mediacampus Bachelor in de grafische en digitale media April 2014.
BEEF & VEAL MARKET SITUATION "Single CMO" Management Committee 22 November 2012.
TESOL International Convention Presentation- ESL Instruction: Developing Your Skills to Become a Master Conductor by Beth Clifton Crumpler by.
Copyright © 2013, 2009, 2006 Pearson Education, Inc. 1 Section 5.5 Dividing Polynomials Copyright © 2013, 2009, 2006 Pearson Education, Inc. 1.
Sample Service Screenshots Enterprise Cloud Service 11.3.
Copyright © 2012, Elsevier Inc. All rights Reserved. 1 Chapter 7 Modeling Structure with Blocks.
1 RA III - Regional Training Seminar on CLIMAT&CLIMAT TEMP Reporting Buenos Aires, Argentina, 25 – 27 October 2006 Status of observing programmes in RA.
Basel-ICU-Journal Challenge18/20/ Basel-ICU-Journal Challenge8/20/2014.
1..
CONTROL VISION Set-up. Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 5 Step 4.
Adding Up In Chunks.
MaK_Full ahead loaded 1 Alarm Page Directory (F11)
1 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt Synthetic.
Artificial Intelligence
1 Using Bayesian Network for combining classifiers Leonardo Nogueira Matos Departamento de Computação Universidade Federal de Sergipe.
Subtraction: Adding UP
Bell Busters! Unit 1 #1-61. Purposes of Government 1. Purposes of government 2. Preamble to the Constitution 3. Domestic tranquility 4. Common defense.
: 3 00.
5 minutes.
1 hi at no doifpi me be go we of at be do go hi if me no of pi we Inorder Traversal Inorder traversal. n Visit the left subtree. n Visit the node. n Visit.
Prof.ir. Klaas H.J. Robers, 14 July Graduation: a process organised by YOU.
1 Let’s Recapitulate. 2 Regular Languages DFAs NFAs Regular Expressions Regular Grammars.
Speak Up for Safety Dr. Susan Strauss Harassment & Bullying Consultant November 9, 2012.
Essential Cell Biology
1 Phase III: Planning Action Developing Improvement Plans.
Converting a Fraction to %
Clock will move after 1 minute
PSSA Preparation.
Essential Cell Biology
Immunobiology: The Immune System in Health & Disease Sixth Edition
Physics for Scientists & Engineers, 3rd Edition
Energy Generation in Mitochondria and Chlorplasts
Select a time to count down from the clock above
Copyright Tim Morris/St Stephen's School
1.step PMIT start + initial project data input Concept Concept.
The Challenge of Creating World-Class Universities Jamil Salmi Astana 16 December 2008.
1 Decidability continued…. 2 Theorem: For a recursively enumerable language it is undecidable to determine whether is finite Proof: We will reduce the.
Presentation transcript:

Ranking Tertiary Education Systems Jamil Salmi Astana 15 June 2009

Benchmarking Tertiary Education Systems Jamil Salmi Astana 15 June 2009

3

4 the power of rankings public debate –Malaysia –France –Brazil

5 institutional behavior positive reactions –increased data-based decision making –improvements in teaching and learning practices –mergers or institutional collaboration

6 institutional behavior (II) negative reactions –less interest for low-income and minority students –distorted resource allocation to favor research over teaching –neglect of established institutional research practices –managing to the rankings (cheating?)

7 outline of the presentation world-class university or world-class tertiary education system? rankings of university systems benchmarking tertiary education systems

8 the search for excellence my university is… more world-class than yours

9 the WCU disease governments institutions –strategic efforts –lobbying for resource concentration

10

11 the WCU disease governments institutions World Bank

13 how do you recognize a world-class university? everyone wants one no one knows what it is no one knows how to get one Philip G. Altbach

14

15 reality check well-performing countries without world- class universities –and vice-versa

16 top 50 universities

comparison of rankings WEFWB K4DSJTU USADenmarkUS (1) SwitzerlandSwedenUK (4) DenmarkFinlandJapan (19) SwedenNetherlandsSwitzerland (24) SingaporeNorwayCanada (24) FinlandCanadaFrance (42) GermanySwitzerlandDenmark (45) NetherlandsUKNetherlands (47) JapanUSASweden (51) CanadaAustraliaGermany (55) 17

18 reality check well-performing countries without world- class universities time dimension of alignment? –emerging economies vs. mature economies country size –Harvard vs. Canada

19 reality check institutional differentiation –different types of institutions for meeting various learning and training needs –regional engagement –technology transfer through human capital formation

20

21 evolution of Nokia income

22 outline of the presentation world-class university or world-class tertiary education system? rankings of university systems

23 SJTU ranking (2008)

adjusting for size 24

University World News 25

SJTU 26

QS SAFE National System Strength Ranking US UK Australia Germany Canada Japan France Netherlands South Korea Sweden number & ranking access to top U flagship U investment 27

28

Lisbon Council 29 ranking of university systems (17 OECD countries) beyond research multi-dimensional (access and completion, labor market outcomes, lifelong learning, responsiveness, ability to attract foreign students) pioneer work

limitations face same methodological questions as university rankings –focus on universities –research bias –composite index with arbitrary weights –statistical robustness –choice of indicators 30

31 outline of the presentation world-class university or world-class tertiary education system? rankings of university systems benchmarking tertiary education systems

32 cross-country comparisons help increase knowledge is this flower big or small? it depends on the size of neighboring flowers

33 multi-dimension comparisons enriches the diagnosis how does this flower compare with the others? wider but shorter

purpose improving performance –through comparisons competitors good practices –diagnosis (identification of areas for improvement) –definition of specific corrective interventions 34

35 purpose (II) need to understand the determinants of performance –no consensus on what countries should do to improve their performance –wide variations in system performance with similar funding levels and common country characteristics

36 Brazil and Chile public spending on tertiary education =.8% and.3% of GDP respectively enrollment rates are 24% and 38% respectively

37 why is a comprehensive benchmarking tool important? performance is more than –building world-class universities –enrolling students (equity and quality agenda) learning & labor market outcomes linked to the totality of the education experience

38 approach elaborating a theoretical framework selecting indicators finding / generating the data analysis –diagnosis (areas for improvement) –identification of possible solutions

39 preliminary step defining a system –US –EU –small states

40 elaborating the theoretical framework distinction between performance and health of system –how good are the systems actual outcomes? –does it operate under conditions known to lead to high performance? definition of outcomes / outputs / results identification of determinants and causality relationships –informed by empirical evidence

41 results framework research production technology transfer quality and relevance of education and training –labor market outcomes –measuring learning outcomes

42 results framework equity values and behaviors social and cultural engagement

determinants (inputs and processes) access and equity (enrollment, institutional diversification, pathways) quality and relevance (standards, teaching and learning, research, local engagement) 43

determinants (inputs and processes) sustainable financing (resource mobilization, allocation, efficient use) capacity to improve (system and institutional governance) 44

45 indicators and data selecting and defining the right indicators finding comparable and reliable data (statistical sources and surveys) –objective –verifiable

46

47 Benchmarking Tertiary Education Upgrade your knowledge – measure, assess and compare your universities!

48 conclusions exploratory work different type of analysis –who? governments and donors –what: system lens vs. institutional multi-dimensional

49 main challenges ahead defining and measuring multiplicity of outputs finding reliable data linking results and causes to be able to take action