Monitoring Results Rena Eichler, PhD Broad Branch Associates

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Plenary session VIII: Steps and suggestions to write the country study Marco V Sanchez (UN-DESA) Third training workshop on Assessing Development Strategies.

Advertisements

Politics and Processes of preparing National Plans and Budgets to achieve the MDGs Learning Event for members of the Policy Network on the MDGs July 19.

Poverty Monitoring - Good Practice in Selecting Indicators Presentation by Dirk U. Hahn, Consultant at the Workshop on Prioritization, Operationalization.

Data Quality Considerations

Towards a model M&E system for AIDS programs Kampala April

Maternal, neonatal, child health and nutrition

TANZANIA HEALTH SECTOR STRATEGIC PLAN III, : MIDTERM ANALYTICAL REVIEW Leonard E.G. Mboera, PhD, DIC National Institute for Medical Research Dar.

Comprehensive M&E Systems

Salud Mesoamérica Initiative Rena Eichler, PhD Broad Branch Associates.

Role of Result-based Monitoring in Result-based Management (RBM) Setting goals and objectives Reporting to Parliament RBM of projects, programs and.

Preventive Controls Phase 2 Workgroup 1.

REPUBLIC OF ZAMBIA Presentation at The Open Society Initiative for Southern Africa Southern Africa Regional Conference on ECCDE ‘Quality Matters’ 3-5 December.

HIV/AIDS Webinar Statistics and Monitoring Tessa Wardlaw Statistics & Monitoring Section/Policy & Practice 20 October 2010.

Cross Border Animal Health Plan of Action – Kenya and Uganda Four Strategic areas 1. To improve prevention, management and control of cross border animal.

1 What are Monitoring and Evaluation? How do we think about M&E in the context of the LAM Project?

What’s the Evidence: Does RBF lead to better results? Rena Eichler, PhD Broad Branch Associates Results Based Financing to Reduce Maternal, Newborn, and.

Sustaining Long Term Regional Coordinated Monitoring Programs Todd Running, H-GAC May 9, 2006.

Haiti: Paying NGOs for results January 29, 2010 Jaipur, India Rena Eichler, PhD Broad Branch Associates

 Share draft PD Plan for SY Development Process District Priorities Draft District Learning Plans for 4 core content areas  Allow time for small.

Performances Based Financing scheme in Rwanda INVESTING MORE STRATEGICALLY 1.

Primer on Monitoring and Evaluation. The 3 Pillars of Monitoring and Evaluation  Identifying the Performance Indicators  Collecting information using.

LIBERIA THE BIG PICTURE Can the Agency tell the truth about results? Can the participants tell the truth about results?

Review of the National Development Plan 9 Is it MDG Based? Botswana Presentation.

Indicators for ACSM.

RTQII Indicator Reporting

Peter Gondo. Session overview Introduction Why monitor What to monitor How to monitor Exercise: Developing a performance monitoring plan for the FI.

Results-based financing Why? What? How?. Jagaman district just erected a new health center and the health workers have started work. What are health workers.

1 Challenges and successes in maintaining gains in quality of care and institutionalizing quality improvement in Niger Maina Boucar, MD, MPH USAID - Health.

Nigeria, January 2010 Petra Vergeer Health Specialist, RBF Team.

MEASURING AND REWARDING PERFORMANCE IN PUBLIC ADMINISTRATIONS Zsuzsanna Lonti Head of Unit Statistics and Indicators Reform of the Public Sector Division.

The all important details: How to operationalize the RBF system Monique Vledder World Bank June 2008.

Monitoring Transition of Harvard Support to Management and Development for Health (MDH), Tanzania Mary Mwanyika-Sando, MD 8 th Annual CDC/HRSA Track 1.0.

OPEN DATA AND MAPPING FOR RESULTS. data freely available Open data easy to use and re-use Accessible data easy to find Searchable Key Principles of Open.

Use of Routine Feedback Reports to Site and District Staff in Cote d’Ivoire Hermann Brou Annual Meeting, M&E satellite meeting Johannesburg, July 28, 2010.

Seite 1 Page Performance Monitoring and Benchmarkıng (A Tanzania Experience) Eng. Mutaekulwa T.K Mutegeki Director of Water and.

Abt Associates Inc. In collaboration with: Aga Khan Foundation BearingPoint Bitrán y Asociados BRAC University Broad Branch Associates Forum One Communications.

Performance Management Training October , 2015 Grace Gorenflo, MPH, RN Principal Gorenflo Consulting, Inc.

Selecting performance indicators and setting targets Joseph Naimoli The World Bank October 2008 Presented by Kate Gilroy Institute for International Programs,

About District Accreditation Mrs. Sanchez & Mrs. Bethell Rickards Middle School

Overview of Steps to Design and Implement Results Based Financing Schemes Susna De, MSc, MPH Results Based Financing to Reduce Maternal, Newborn, and Child.

MicroLoan Foundation: Creating balanced staff incentives Daniella Hawkins, Social Performance Manager.

Waisea Vosa Climate Change Unit Division of Political and Treaties Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation.

World Health Organization (WHO) Health & Equity Ms. He Jing, National Program Officer WHO China Office July 9, 2013.

© Plan International Community monitoring of children’s health by “Sponsor Mothers” in Senegal Diaguily Koita, Plan Senegal, Ryan Lander, Plan International,

National Center for Homeless Education State Coordinators Meeting 2016.

SPECIAL SESSION COUNTDOWN TO 2015 IN ETHIOPIA SIX BUILDING BLOCKS OF THE HEALTH SYSTEM: PROGRESS TOWARDS THE INTEGRATION IN ETHIOPIA Dereje Mamo Tsegaye.

Quality Indicators in Residential Aged Care Services (RACS) Overview: Using Quality Indicators to make a positive difference to resident care.

Paying for Performance in Haiti Rena Eichler, PhD Broad Branch Associates Results Based Financing to Reduce Maternal, Newborn,

Endris Mohammed Seid 1,2, Arjanne Rietsema 1 1: CORDAID-Zimbabwe 2: Ministry of Health and Child Care- Zimbabwe Improving Maternal, Neonatal and Child.

Supporting measurement & improvement of primary health care (PHC) at the facility and community levels Dr. Jennifer Adams, Deputy Assistant Administrator,

Importance of Monitoring and Evaluation. Lecture Overview  Monitoring and Evaluation  How to Build an M&E System.

How can information systems help us?

Key features of an effective Compliance Strategy

Quality Improvement An Introduction

MONITORING HYGIENE AND SANITATION IN UGANDA 26th May 2015

Module 2 Basic Concepts.

BFHI Congress 2016 New Guidance on the Protection, Promotion, and Support of Breastfeeding in Maternity Facilities Laurence M. Grummer-Strawn, PhD WHO.

Zambia iCCM Experience

Monitoring and Evaluation Systems for NARS Organisations in Papua New Guinea Day 2. Session 6. Developing indicators.

Introduction Results Based Financing Workshop

NAACEmark : the ten criteria

World Health Organization

Introduction on the outline and objectives of the workshop

The Process for Final Approval: Ongoing Monitoring

Why Monitor With Our Tools?

Advancing Partnerships for Universal Health Coverage

What’s the Evidence: Does RBF lead to better results?

Data for PRS Monitoring: Institutional and Technical Challenges

Linking Payment to Results

Ambulances, Project Kiramama – June 2014

Presentation transcript:

Monitoring Results Rena Eichler, PhD Broad Branch Associates renaeichler@comcast.net Results Based Financing to Reduce Maternal, Newborn, and Child Mortality, (Session 10; October 23, 2008)

Imagine… It’s the end of a quarter, what information do you need to know if you should pay recipients for results? Did they achieve performance targets? Are there any untended effects of the incentive scheme on non-rewarded services? Any perverse effects on rewarded services? Who needs help?

Functions of your monitoring system Produces information to let you know how much to pay to whom. Produces information to inform who is lagging and needs help. Produces information on performance trends for both rewarded and other services.

“Levels” of Monitoring RBF Unit in the Ministry of Health Region 1 District A District B Facility 1 Facility 2 Facility 3 Facility 4

Consider the needed staffing and structures Facility to District : Facility collects, verifies and reports data (often based on existing HMIS) on services provided. District collects, inputs, verifies and analyzes facility data. District determines payment to facilities. District assesses district performance. Identifies low performers in need of help. Develops and implements strategy to support improvement. District provides feedback on performance to facilities.

District to Region Districts report to Regions Regions verify district reported results. Regions determine payment to districts? Regions assess district performance. Identify low performers in need of help. Develop and implement strategy to support improvement. Regions provide feedback on performance to districts.

Region to Center Center aggregates performance data for entire country. Center determines payment to regions or districts. Tracks progress toward attainment of national goals. Identifies unintended effects and implements changes policy to address them if needed. Identifies challenges and determines strategies to improve.

Is this something new? Most systems are “supposed” to work this way now! Do they? If not, why not?

Imagine if every month a district could see this… (adapted from the RBF management tool created for the RBF pilot in Zambia)

Top and bottom 5

Range of achievement across facilities for each indicator

And detail for each indicator

And for each facility

Imagine Information and feedback flows up AND down. All levels have the information needed to take action to improve. Information to trigger payment is timely and reliable. The National Ministry of Health (or other lead) knows what is working and what is not and can make changes based on solid information.

Some considerations Minimize burden: Whenever possible, use existing data collection and reporting systems. Whenever possible, enhance capabilities of existing staff. Assure resources (people, money, systems) for effective monitoring. Don’t scrimp on training.

THANK YOU!