Conclusions and Implications

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The Impact of Gendered Physical Activities and Athletic Participation on Sex Roles Jennifer Holberg, Kate Jubinville, Rebekka Lee and Elizabeth Steinberg.
Advertisements

Exploring the Gendered Space of Attributes that Predict Expectations of Success in STEM Gender in STEM Research Symposium: Pathways to Parity in STEM September.
Implication of Gender and Perception of Self- Competence on Educational Aspiration among Graduates in Taiwan Wan-Chen Hsu and Chia- Hsun Chiang Presenter.
Student Engagement Survey Results and Analysis June 2011.
Results show that participants favored females in fields of surgeons and corporate setting jobs than males. They also showed preference for males in the.
Interface agents as social models:The impact of appearance on females attitude toward engineering 指導教授: Chen, Ming-puu 報 告 者: Chen, Hsiu-ju 報告日期: 2007.
Competitive Swimmers’ Interpretation of Motivational Climate Rebecca C. Trenz, M.A. Fordham University Psychology of Motivation.
Introduction A small but growing literature points to an important connection between forgiveness and physical health (Worthington, Witvliet, Lerner, &
CATHERINE ALBISTON UC ADVANCE GRANT ROUNDTABLE APRIL 11, 2012 Empirically-Based Search Practices.
Introduction Disordered eating continues to be a significant health concern for college women. Recent research shows it is on the rise among men. Media.
Computer scientists are inaccurately stereotyped as asocial loners 1. Those in computer science state that the field involves a lot of group work. Communal.
Background There is a long literature documenting greater willingness to take risks by men than by women. This gender difference in risk taking has been.
Gender.
Supplemental to Linda L. Carli, Laila Alawa, YoonAh Lee, Bei Zhao, & Elaine Kim September 2016.
Condom Use as it Relates to Partner Perception and Self-Efficacy Taryn D. Larribas, University of San Francisco Hypotheses It was hypothesized that condom.
Buffers to Online Harassment in Women’s Pursuit of STEM Careers Rachael Bryant, Jennifer Hightower and, Bryan Dawson Ph.D Background: Women have consistently.
Deep Dyadic Friendships vs. Broad Peer Preference During Adolescence as Predictors of Adolescent and Adult Internalizing Symptoms Rachel K. Narr & Joseph.
Data Analysis & Results
An evaluation of athlete perceptions of ACE assistance upon
The Role of Biological Sex in Student Evaluation of Influential Educators’ Transformational Leadership, Emotional Intelligence, and Charisma. Katie Buntrock,
The Relationship between Nature Relatedness, Trait Emotional Intelligence and Well-Being Priscilla R. Gerofsky Supervisors: Philip A. Vernon, Ph.D. &
Are Happy People Found in Connected Neighborhoods
Loneliness in Marriage Scale
Better to Give or to Receive?: The Role of Dispositional Gratitude
Attachment style and condom use across and within dating relationships
Feminism and Life Narrative Focus: CONCLUSIONS & FUTURE DIRECTIONS
Florida International University, Miami, FL
Paul B. Ingram IV2 and Brian P. Cole1
Further Validation of the Personal Growth Initiative Scale – II: Gender Measurement Invariance Harmon, K. A., Shigemoto, Y., Borowa, D., Robitschek, C.,
Drs. Pamela B. Payne & Naomi Brower
Nicholas J. Beutell Hagan School of Business Iona College
Limitations and Future Directions
“I wanna be pretty and smart… but not, like, a scientist or anything”:
Thomas White, Stephen F. Duncan, and Jeremy B. Yorgason
Sexual Imagery & Thinking About Sex
Cross-over, Degendering, or…?
Predictors of Parenting Self-Efficacy in Parents Attending College
University of Mount Union
How Do Female and Male Faculty Members Construct Job Satisfaction?
Are masculine males attractive
Parental Status and Emergency Preparedness:
with Child Sexual Abuse Histories
Introduction Hypotheses Results Discussion Method
STEM Communal Affordances
DESCRIPTIVES AND CORRELATIONS
Disease threat increases moral vigilance across domains
Friendship Quality as a Moderator
Introduction Results Hypotheses Discussion Method
Women’s Dangerous World Beliefs Predict More Accurate Discrimination of Affiliative Facial Cues Christopher J. N. Lustgraaf, M.A.1, Mitch Brown, M.A. 1,
Which of these is “a boy”?
Attractiveness and Advertising: Reactions to Pop-up Ads
Research amongst Physical Therapists in the State of Kuwait: Participation, Perception, Attitude and Barriers Presented by Sameera Aljadi, PT, PhD Assistant.
Sociosexuality and Perceptions of Partner Over Time
Perceived versus Actual Knowledge of Autism Spectrum Disorder
Krystle Lange & Regan A. R. Gurung University of Wisconsin, Green Bay
GIRLS NOT BELONGING Professor Averil Macdonald OBE
The relationship between job-related stressors and stress responses of nurses working in intermediate nursing homes in Japan Y.Momose1, A.Fujino1, N.Amaki1,
An Exploration of the Perceived Femininity of Language Learning
SSSELF-TALK AND PERCEIVED EXERTION IN PHYSICAL ACTIVITY
Introduction Results Methods Conclusions
2University of Virginia
Assessment in Career Counseling
Emily A. Davis & David E. Szwedo James Madison University Introduction
Gender INTRODUCTION.
Korey F. Beckwith & David E. Szwedo James Madison University
Introduction Results Discussion Hypotheses Method
Why don’t you want to work with older adults?
The Effect of Font on Product Purchasing Behavior
Purpose and Hypothesis
Conclusions and Future Implications
Presentation transcript:

Conclusions and Implications Applicant Reactions to Gendered Wording in Job Advertisements Sahra Kaboli-Nejad, Eric M. Scheller, and Carey S. Ryan University of Nebraska at Omaha Introduction Results Key Takeaways Inconsistent with previous findings (e.g., Barbulescu & Bidwell, 2013), gendered wording did not affect stereotype threat, job suitability, job belongingness, or interest in applying, all ps > .407. While participants generally perceived the job to afford more agentic than communal goals, F(1, 231) = 82.63, p < .001, gendered wording affected perceived goal affordances. The job was perceived as affording more agentic (vs. communal) goals when the wording was masculine, F(2, 231) = 4.86, p = .009, and as affording more communal (vs. agentic) goals when the wording was feminine, F(2, 231) = 3.55, p = .030 (See Figure 1). Further, women (M = 3.13) experienced greater stereotype threat than did men (M = 2.02), F(1, 228) = 24.40, p < .001. For women (but not men), greater stereotype threat predicted less interest in applying for the position, F(1, 81) = 4.52, p = .040, R2 = .05 (See Figure 2). Finally, perceiving the position as affording communal goals was more strongly correlated with job suitability, Steiger’s Z-test = -1.76, p = .039, and job belongingness, Steiger’s Z = -2.24, p = .012, than was perceiving the job as affording more agentic goals. (See Table 1.) Although the correlation between communal goal affordances and interest in applying for the job was greater than that between agentic goal affordances and interest in applying, the difference between them was not significant, Steiger’s Z = -1.11, p = .134. Women account for only 28% of the STEM workforce (Neuhauser, 2014). One contributing factor may be gendered wording in advertisements (e.g., the use of more masculine wording in male-dominated fields). Masculine wording may discourage women from applying for male-dominated STEM careers. Research has shown, for example, that participants perceive there to be more men in occupations that use more masculine than feminine wording in their advertisements, resulting in women finding the jobs less appealing (Gaucher et al., 2011; Horvath & Sczesnya, 2016). The present research examined whether gendered wording in an advertisement for a male-dominated STEM career affects perceptions of interest in the job. In addition, we examined whether gendered wording affects experiences of stereotype threat and perceptions of the the job as affording communal and agentic goals. Perceptions of the types of goals afforded by careers has been shown to impact career preference. For example, STEM careers tend to be viewed as less likely to afford communal goals (Diekman et al., 2010). Because women seek roles that afford communal goals, they may be more likely to be deterred from seeking STEM careers. Male (vs. female) dominated fields more often use masculine wording, which may deter women from applying for roles in male-dominated industries (e.g., STEM; Gaucher et al., 2011). We created three job advertisements that utilized gendered wording for a position as a data analyst, examining their effects on communal and agentic goal affordances, stereotype threat, job suitability, job belongingness, and interest in the job. Regardless of wording, women experienced greater stereotype threat than did men, resulting in less interest in applying. Overall, the job was viewed as affording greater agentic (vs. communal) goals, but viewing the job as affording communal (vs. agentic) goals was associated with greater job suitability and job belongingness. Figure 1 Method Table 1 Participants Participants (N = 252; 63.4% male) completed an online questionnaire in exchange for $2. They ranged in age from 21-69 years (M = 35.58, SD = 10.42), and a majority (65.5%) had at least some college education. Procedure Participants were randomly assigned to view a job advertisement that used masculine (e.g., dominant), feminine (e.g., interpersonal skills), or neutral wording to describe a fictitious position as a data analyst (where women represent only 26% of workers; AAUW, 2015). After viewing the advertisement, participants completed the following measures. Measures Stereotype threat. Three items (Deemer, Thoman, Chase, & Smith, 2014) assessed stereotype threat (e.g., “I worry that my ability to perform well in this job would be affected by my gender;” α = .93). Goal affordances. Fifteen items (Diekman et al., 2011) assessed participant perceptions of the career fulfilling agentic (e.g., competition; α = .81) and communal (e.g., connection with others; α = .91) goals. Job suitability. Four items (Bosak & Sczesny, 2008) assessed participants’ perceived suitability for the advertised position (e.g., “I think I am very well qualified for the advertised position;” α = .94). Job belongingness. Four items (Gaucher et al., 2011) measured anticipated belongingness in the advertised job (e.g., “I could fit in well at this company;”α = .89). Interest in applying. One item assessed participants’ interest in applying for the position (i.e., “How interested are you in applying to the job?”). Interest in Applying Job Suitability Job Belongingness Communal Goal Affordances .337** .204** .270** Agentic Goal Affordances .253** .063 .093 **p < .01 Conclusions and Implications Gendered wording only affected perceived goal affordances, such that masculine (vs. feminine) wording resulted in perceptions that the role afforded more agentic (vs. communal) goals. Regardless of condition, women experienced greater stereotype threat than did men and women who experienced stereotype threat were less interested in applying for the position. Interestingly, for men, stereotype threat was not associated with decreased interest in applying. Positions that were perceived to afford communal goals (vs. agentic goals) had significantly stronger relationships with job suitability and job belongingness. Organizations may benefit from using job advertisements that suggest the jobs would afford communal goals rather than agentic goals. Perhaps wording is not be strong enough to overcome participants’ preconceived notions about a role as a data analyst. Perhaps, simply knowing that a role is in a male- dominated industry is enough to induce stereotype threat. Future researchers might conduct a similar study with various positions to determine whether findings replicate for other positions (e.g., stereotypically feminine roles). Figure 2