M. Wang, J. Wood, J. Hale, L. Petsonk, and M. Attfield

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Sociology 680 Multivariate Analysis Logistic Regression.
Advertisements

Physical Job Demand and Early Retirement Sepideh Modrek & Mark Cullen 14th Annual Joint Conference of the Retirement Research Consortium August 2, 2012.
Investigation of Coal Dust Mitigation Strategies
National Injury and Fatality Data for Aging Farmers John R. Myers Larry A. Layne Suzanne M. Marsh National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health.
OMICS GROUP 3 rd International Conference and Exhibition OHS Valencia Spain 24 June 2014 An assessment of exposure to respirable crystalline silica and.
S I L I C A HAZARDS & CONTROLS. What are the hazards associated with exposure to silica dust, as well as basic preventive and control measures.
Variability of exposure and estimation of cumulative exposure in a manually operated coal mine.(Mamuya SH et al,2006;Ann Occup. Hyg.)
OVERVIEW AUSTRALIAN BLACK COAL MINING OPERATIONS Ken Cram Project Manager Coal Services Pty Limited.
Occupational Segregation and Racial Health Disparities K Chung-Bridges, C Muntaner, LE Fleming, DJ Lee, KL Arheart, WG LeBlanc, AJ Caban Martinez, SL Christ,
EPI 809/Spring Multiple Logistic Regression.
PROPOSED DUST RULES DEPARTMENT of LABOR Mine Safety & Health Administration Coal Mine Safety & Health DEPARTMENT of LABOR Mine Safety & Health Administration.
Control of Airborne Respirable Dust Hazards: A Training Program for Underground Coal Miners The Penn State Miner Training Program University Park, PA
Statistics for Managers Using Microsoft Excel, 5e © 2008 Prentice-Hall, Inc.Chap 12-1 Statistics for Managers Using Microsoft® Excel 5th Edition Chapter.
Multiple Choice Questions for discussion
National Industrial Sand Association (NISA) Occupational Health Program Andrew D. O’Brien, CSP General Manager, Safety & Health Unimin Corporation.
1 Stakeholder Consultation Mine Safety and Health Administration (MSHA) Department of Labor (DOL) DRAFT Strategic Plan FY Draft: March 17, 2010.
Association between Systolic Blood Pressure and Congestive Heart Failure Complication among Hypertensive and Diabetic Hypertensive Patients Mrs. Sutheera.
Analysis of Qualitative Data Dr Azmi Mohd Tamil Dept of Community Health Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia FK6163.
Control of Airborne Respirable Dust Hazards: A Training Program for Underground Coal Miners The Penn State Miner Training Program University Park, PA
Going from data to analysis Dr. Nancy Mayo. Getting it right Research is about getting the right answer, not just an answer An answer is easy The right.
Black Lung February, 2009 WV Coal Association Charleston, WV TMTM The findings and conclusions in this poster have not been formally disseminated by NIOSH.
Mark J. Schultz, P.E. Chief, Environmental Assessment and Contaminant Control Branch Dust Division Mine Safety and Health Administration Pittsburgh Safety.
Evaluation of the New Jersey Silicosis Surveillance System, Jessie Gleason, MSPH CDC/CSTE Applied Epidemiology Fellow New Jersey Department of.
Industrial Health in Mining for the Non-Industrial Hygienist n Health Problems often over-shadowed by Safety Problems. n “Cumulative Trauma” injuries are.
Association between Systolic Blood Pressure and Congestive Heart Failure in Hypertensive Patients Mrs. Sutheera Intajarurnsan Doctor of Public Health Student.
PMF Chronic ‘Simple’ CWP Progressive massive fibrosis Complicated pneumoconiosis Normal Coal Workers’ Pneumoconiosis (CWP) Source: NIOSH Coal Workers’
Section of Freeze-Dried Human Lung Basically Normal.
Analysis of matched data Analysis of matched data.
HISTORY OF MINE SAFETY AND HEALTH LEGISLATION
OSHA Final Rule: Occupational Exposure to Respirable Crystalline Silica OSHA has amended its existing standards for occupational exposure to respirable.
Dr. Ashis Bhattacherjee Professor Department of Mining Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology, Kharagpur, India Dr. Bijay Mihir Kunar Sr. Lecturer.
Women’s Perceived Control of Their Birth Outcomes: Implications for the Use of Preconception Care Carol Weisman, 1 Marianne Hillemeier, 1 Gary Chase, 1.
DISCUSSION & CONCLUSIONS
Presented at CARSP Conference
UOG Journal Club: August 2017
Effectiveness of Rear Seat Safety Belt Use
Quality of Electronic Emergency Department Data: How Good Are They?
The Black Lung Megan & Matt.
Prevalence of Self-Reported Diabetes and Exposure to Organochlorine Pesticides among Mexican-Americans: Hispanic Health and Nutrition Examination Survey.
Mesfin S. Mulatu, Ph.D., M.P.H. The MayaTech Corporation
Black Lung Disease All lung diseases associated with chronic overexposure to coal dust Chronic Bronchitis Silicosis Coal Workers’ Pneumoconiosis Chronic.
Nicholas J. Beutell Hagan School of Business Iona College
Black Lung.
Height of Fatal Fall Injuries in the U. S
Exercise Adherence in Patients with Diabetes: Evaluating the role of psychosocial factors in managing diabetes Natalie N. Young,1, 2 Jennifer P. Friedberg,1,
Notes on Logistic Regression
KEY INDICATORS OF THE LABOUR MARKET - KILM
S I L I C A HAZARDS & CONTROLS.
Trena M. Ezzati-Rice, Frederick Rohde, Robert Baskin
Age at First Measles-Mumps-Rubella Vaccination in Children with Autism and School-matched Controls: A Population-Based Study in Metropolitan Atlanta F.
Silica.
Cardiopulmonary Disease Among Illinois Miners, Results of an Analysis of State Workers’ Compensation Data K.S. Almberg1, L. Friedman1, J.M. Graber2, C.
Square-root TSH (μIU/mL) Presence vs. Absence TPO Abᵈ
Influenza Vaccine Effectiveness Against Pediatric Deaths:
Coffee drinking and leukocyte telomere length: A meta-analysis
From the Indianapolis – Ibadan Dementia Research Project.
Jeffrey E. Korte, PhD BMTRY 747: Foundations of Epidemiology II
Management of perioperative hypertension
NURS 790: Methods for Research and Evidence Based Practice
Annals of Internal Medicine • Vol. 167 No. 12 • 19 December 2017
Peng-jun Lu, MD, PhD1; Mei-Chun Hung, MPH, PhD1,2 ; Alissa C
Evaluating Effect Measure Modification
Evaluating the Effectiveness of Driver Education Programs and Implementing Effective Strategies The Nebraska Experience ADTSEA Conference 2018.
Mine Health and Safety Inspectorate
Recidivism Among DWI Offenders in New Mexico (Preliminary Results)
Confounders.
Wyoming Mining Association
Journal reviews 이승호.
Effect Modifiers.
Recent Incidences and Trends of the Top Cancers in Northeast Tennessee Appalachian Region Adekunle Oke1, Sylvester Orimaye2, Ndukwe Kalu1, Dr. Faustine.
Presentation transcript:

M. Wang, J. Wood, J. Hale, L. Petsonk, and M. Attfield Risk factors associated with progressive massive fibrosis among U.S. coal miners - A case-control study M. Wang, J. Wood, J. Hale, L. Petsonk, and M. Attfield 138th APHA Annual Meeting Denver, CO Nov. 10, 2010 Good afternoon. The topic for today’s presentation is The findings and conclusions in this presentation are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the views of the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health.

Presenter Disclosure Mei Lin Wang I have no relationships to disclose.

MINING This study addresses the Occupational lung disease associated with underground coal mining in U.S.

Background ● Coal Workers’ Pneumoconiosis (CWP) is a lung disease caused by inhaling coal mine dust. ● Progressive Massive Fibrosis (PMF) is the most disabling form of pneumoconiosis. Progression to PMF is a risk factor for premature death.

Objectives ● To investigate the relationship between development of PMF and exposures to respirable coal mine dust and crystalline silica ● To identify chest radiographic appearances associated with PMF

Methods – Database sources ● NIOSH Coal Workers’ Chest X-Ray Surveillance Program (CWXSP) ● Mine Safety and Health Administration (MSHA) Coal Mine Safety and Health Information System (CMIS) ● Energy Information Administration (EIA) Coal Production Data Files (CPDF) This study based on three database sources:

Methods – Databases available (1) ● NIOSH CWXSP data from 1970 to 2000 Health outcomes of CWP, PMF, and other radiographic appearances Miner’s job history year started mining work tenure current mine location current job category The CWXSP is a NIOSH-administered occupational health program which screens miners for coal workers‘ pneumoconiosis (CWP). Job history was also taken at the time of x-ray, including year started mining, mine location and years of underground or surface mining. This study using the data from 1970 to 2000.

International Labour Office Classification of Radiographs Profusion of small opacities Large opacities ILO classification 0/- 0/0 0/1 1/0 1/1 1/2 2/1 2/2 2/3 3/2 3/3 3/+ A B C The NIOSH program uses the International Labor Office classification of the radiographs of pneumoconioses. This is a standardized system to categorize the small opacity profusion and also the large opacities. Here we can observe some examples from the standard films: this shows a normal x-ray, then category 1, 2, and 3 CWP. When the disease progresses, the small opacities tend to move together, forming large masses of fibrosis. This is called progressive massive fibrosis – PMF. We classify PMF according to the size of these large opacities: Stage A, B and C.

Methods – Databases available (2) ● MSHA CMIS data from 1970 to 1999 5,468,719 coal mine dust and quartz compliance sampling results by mine operators, and by MSHA inspectors Date Mine Job category (underground face, non-face, and surface) Respirable coal dust concentration Respirable quartz concentration The Mine Safety and Health Administration’s (MSHA) Coal’s Management Information System (CMIS) is a national database containing information on mine status, personnel, time and activity, sampling entities, respirable dust and respirable quartz sample results measured by MSHA inspectors and coal mine operators since 1970.

Methods – Databases available (3) ● EIA Coal Production Data Files Years of mine operation Mine seam height Coal rank in this study: High rank group: anthracite, low or medium volatile bituminous Low rank group: high volatile bituminous A third database from the Energy Information Administration (EIA) containing information on years of mine operation, mine seam height, and also coal rank. In the current study, we define coal rank as high and low groups, the high rank group including anthracite, low or medium volatile bituminous. The low rank group including high volatile bituminous

Methods – Define cases and controls ● Define PMF cases by last x-ray film large opacity coded as A, B, or C ● Select controls by SAS macro program ● Matching items: calendar year started mining year and age at the first x-ray ● 347 PMF cases matched with one to multiple controls, selecting only the first controls for 1-1 matching pairs

Methods – Exposure assessment ● Estimate each miner’s cumulative respirable coal dust and quartz exposure: Based on sampling results of dust and quartz concentration by mine, year, and job category Merge with job history records ● Calculate total years of mining and years worked at the underground face Using job history ● Evaluate mine seam height and coal rank Based on EIA database

Methods – Data analysis ● 314 pairs included in the analysis: 33 pairs excluded after data quality assessment ● For continuous variables - Paired T-test ● For dichotomous variables - McNemar’s test ● Explore the association of PMF to various potential risk factors using logistic regression model for 1-1 matched case-control study (SAS proc mdc)

Methods – Data analysis (Cont.) ● Logistic regression model Coal mine dust by quartiles of distribution Quartz exposure by median and Q3 values Seam height - dichotomous by median value Coal rank - high vs. low Variable Reference Level 2 Level 3 Level 4 Cumulative Dust* <43.5 43.5 – 90.2 >90.2 – 132.4 >132.4 Cumulative Quartz* <0.774 0.774 – 2.607 >2.607 Seam height > 56.5 < 56.5 Coal rank Low High Independent variables examined in the model were coal mine dust, quartz, mine seam height, and coal rank. Create three design variables for cumulative coal dust exposure by the quartiles of distribution; using the first quartile as the reference group. Similarly, create three design variables for cumulative quartz exposure, and categorize the mine seam height and coal rank as dichotomous variables. * Units for cumulative coal dust and quartz: mg-yr/m3

Methods – Data analysis (Cont.) ● Logistic regression model structure: ● Model (1) including all 314 pairs PMF (1, 0) = cum-dust cum-quartz coal-rank ● Model (2) including only 58 pairs with complete seam height values PMF (1, 0) = cum-dust cum-quartz seam-height Presented here are two final models: model one including all 314 pairs, examining for the association between PMF and cumulative dust, cumulative quartz exposure, and the coal rank high vs. low. The second model including only 58 pairs with complete seam height values, the seam height effect to PMF was examined in this model

Results ● All 314 cases were males with 94% whites. ● Cases – PMF by size of large opacity A (n=201) – smallest B (n=97) C (n=16) – largest ● Controls – Small opacity evidence of CWP No (n=205) Yes (n=109) PMF was classified by the size of the large opacity as A (n=201), B (n=97), or C (n=16) In 205 pairs, the controls without CWP, and in 109 pairs the controls also had CWP.

Paired case-control comparison (1) Cases, n=314 Controls, n=314 P value Age at first x-ray 51.0 N/A Year first x-ray 1976 Age started mining 22.1 0.4407 Year started mining 1947 Proportion with small opacity “r” shape* 44% 15% <.0001 Small opacity profusion at first x-ray 5.0 (2/1) 1.6 (0/1 – 1/0) Small opacity profusion at last x-ray 5.7 (2/1 – 2/2) 1.5 (0/1 – 1/0) Age and year at the first x-ray, and year started mining were matching items. Age started mining was similar. The proportion with small opacity “r” shape was significantly higher in cases. Small opacity profusion at the first and last x-ray was both significantly higher in cases comparing to controls. * For 109 pairs, in which both cases and controls had CWP

Paired case-control comparison (2) Cases, n=314 Controls, n=314 P value Coal mine dust (mg-yr/m3 ) 120.7 82.9 <.0001 Quartz (mg-yr/m3 ) 2.48 1.53 0.0002 Years at UG face 24.1 19.0 Tenure total 31.5 30.9 0.0474 Mine seam height (inch) 75.1 (n=119) 65.7 (n=113) 0.3488 Coal rank high (yes/no) 63 (21.4%) 41 (13.9%) 0.0023

P = 0.001 P = 0.004 P = 0.030 Based on the parameter estimates from model 1 results, this graphic shows the Odds Ratio and P values for three independent variables. Miners worked in the highest dust or quartz exposure groups or in high coal rank mine increased significantly the likelihood to develop PMF.

P = 0.018 P = 0.015 P = 0.023 Based on the model 2 results, as we can see that the Odds Ratio was significantly higher in the group miners worked in lower seam height mine.

Conclusion ● PMF cases were significantly associated with higher cumulative coal mine dust and quartz exposures; and also with lower seam height and higher coal rank ● PMF cases had higher category of small opacity profusion (category “2” or above) ● Small opacity “r” shape was highly associated with PMF

Recommendation ● Analysis using data from 1970-2000 has confirmed previously recognized risk factors ● Further studies, including more recent data, may be useful in investigating recent trends of severe and rapidly progressive lung disease in coal miners