MPA’s are a good fisheries management tool and fisheries will benefit from them     Agree Disagree.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Fishery management and interested parties
Advertisements

Marine Strategy Framework Directive: Goals and Challenges
Economics of Land Degradation Initiative Richard J. Thomas ELD Scientific coordinator United Nations University Institute for Water, Environment and Health.
Reserve design There’s a lot of crap out there We are in a position to inform how to do this intelligently.
Progress towards an Ecosystem Approach to Fisheries in Europe Simon Jennings Centre for Environment, Fisheries & Aquaculture Science, Lowestoft & School.
How to manage a sustainable small scale artisanal fishery Erik Maitz Boman – Data monitoring officer Department of Agriculture and Fisheries.
Fishery management FMSP Stock Assessment Tools Training Workshop Bangladesh 19 th - 25 th September 2005.
Outline 1.Background to the concept 2.Justification for the proposed TBCA 3.Proposed TBCA delineation 4.Possible institutional and management frameworks.
Regional Workshop 5: Improving Methods for Regional Aquaculture Development and Promotion Podgorica, October 2014 FAO Technical Cooperation Programme.
Developing a Socio-Economic Dataframe AIM: Construct, test and refine a framework for the collection and management of socio- economic fisheries data Make.
A Strategic Analysis for identifying MPA’s : - Towards a Marine Spatial Planning Method for the French MPA Agency CAML Workshop Villefranche s/mer 18th.
NATIONAL OCEAN POLICY FRAMEWORK WEALTH CREATION THROUGH A HEALTHY, SECURE AND SUSTAINABLE OCEAN BY: DATO’ DR. SHARIFAH ZARAH SYED AHMAD DEPUTY SECRETARY.
Review Afternoon 22/5/2007 Impacts of climate change and biodiversity loss.
ESPON 2.1.5: Territorial Impacts of European Fisheries Policy Third Interim Report Prepared for the Salzburg Seminar March 2006 Ove Langeland, Norwegian.
Session 4 Mainstreaming Climate Change Adaptation and Biodiversity Conservation in National, Sectoral and Donor Strategies.
Spatial Conflicts in New Zealand Fisheries: The Rights of Fishers and Protection of the Marine Environment Randall Bess, Ramana Rallapudi Marine Policy.
Our mission… We believe that the Earth’s natural heritage must be maintained if future generations are to thrive spiritually, culturally & economically.
Hydropower and the Water Environment Peter Gammeltoft European Commission DG Environment, D.1 Water 2nd Workshop on Water Management, WFD & Hydropower.
Leisure, Sport and Tourism – Year 12 Lesson 14.  What is sustainable tourism?  What might limit its success?  Will some environments have more successful.
Long Valley nature park. What is a nature park? Natural landscape protected by long-term planning Legally regulated Preserved in the present state Not.
Jurisdiction Marine Pollution International Fishing.
The Principles Governing EU Environmental Law. 2 The importance of EU Environmental Law at the European and globallevel The importance of EU Environmental.
MARINE AND COASTAL MANAGEMENT PRESENTATION TO PARLIAMENTARY PORTFOLIO AND SELECT COMMITTEE 29 May 2007.
Merete Tandstad FAO Fisheries and Aquaculture Department Rome, Italy
Theme 2 Developing MPA networks Particular thanks to: Theme 2 Concurrent Session Rapporteurs, Dan Laffoley, Gilly Llewellyn G E E L O N G A U S T R A L.
Overfishing Fisheries. Fishing Catching marine organisms.
MEKONG RIVER COMMISSION PROGRAMMES FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT.
Well-governed fisheries sector Abundant fisheries resources Healthy environment and habitats Increased jobs, profits, and improved economy Improved human.
Training course in fish stock assessment and fisheries management
Introduction to the ecosystem approach as a framework for management of ecosystem use Kevern Cochrane and Warwick Sauer.
Challenges Cyclones El Nino Tsunamis Over fishing Alien Species Tourism Political Instability Economic Development Deforestation Climate Change.
Portfolio Committee on Water & Environmental Affairs :Pelagic sector presentation: Portfolio Committee on Water & Environmental Affairs :Pelagic sector.
Aquatic Issues Research Project
Conflict and Compliance in Belizean Fisheries
Sustainability and Challenges of the World Marine Fisheries
COUNTRY REPORT of MALAYSIA
The future role of Tuna in Meeting Pacific Food Security Needs
Perspective of the Fisheries and Aquaculture Department
Draft Fisheries Plan for the Marine Resources of Palmerston
Results Oriented Program Formulation
Ecosystem Services and Biodiversity
The Biodiversity and Protected Areas Management (BIOPAMA) Programme
Sustainable Fisheries in the Black Sea
Addressing sustainable development by enhancing Black Sea fisheries
Sustainable Fisheries in the Black Sea European Committee of the Regions 7 June 2017, Brussels Sustainability of Black Sea fisheries and tools for fisheries.
NOAA-NOS International Programs Office
A legacy for you, your children, and future generations
Marine conservation and ecotourism
3. The what and why of EAFM? Version 1.
EU Biodiversity Strategy in context
Marine knowledge presentation to eighth meeting of Marine Observation and Data Expert Group presentation to eighth meeting of Marine Observation and.
Solomon Islands Sea Cucumber Management Plan Long history of commercial collection (late 1880’s) Throughout the nation Based on demand from international.
NWWAC Brown Crab Focus Group Norah M Parke Killybegs Fishermen’s Organisation Ltd Ireland Dublin, September /01/2019.
The future role of Tuna in Meeting Pacific Food Security Needs
Mitigation.
Restoration methodologies
Theme Why are biodiversity conservation and global security becoming integrated, and in what ways? What kinds of conservation does this produce on the.
Assessing Marine Protected Areas (MPAs) In Indonesia
Regional workshop on Approaches to the implementation and monitoring of community-based ecosystem approach to fisheries management (CEAFM): finding common.
Working Group on Data, Information and Knowledge Exchange
Fisheries Management and the National Marine Plan
The CFP Reform – challenges…
Financing Natura 2000 Success factors
3. The why and what of EAFM? Essential EAFM Date • Place 1.
CapeNature National MPA Forum Port Elizabeth October 2016
6. EAFM plans the link between policy and action
Links with Marine Strategy Framework Directive
Map of project area study sites in the Gulf of Mannar and Palk Bay
Common Fisheries Policy
OFMP II POLICY, REGULATORY AND INSTITUTIONAL REFORMS
Presentation transcript:

MPA’s are a good fisheries management tool and fisheries will benefit from them     Agree Disagree

MPA’s should primarily be managed by the government Agree Disagree

Scientists are the real beneficiaries of MPA’s MPA’s are scientifically interesting, which makes it difficult for scientists to regard proposed measures objectively Agree Disagree

Many MPAs are designed to benefit tourism and other economically powerful sectors, denying access of local communities to the "commons" Agree Disagree

Agree Disagree Size matters!   (Small island developing states will seldom successfully reconcile fisheries management with STRICT conservation (e.g. no-take reserves) since livelihood demands on productive marine areas for fisheries and competing uses are usually huge in contrast to fisheries and MPA management capacity that is usually inadequate). And also: for an MPA to be effective it will have to have a certain size – depending on goals Agree Disagree

Too many parties are involved in discussing governance of MPA’s Agree Disagree

MPA’s are only one of many tools in the toolbox for management of aquatic resources Agree Disagree

With good fisheries policy, MPA’s aren’t necessary Agree Disagree

There can not be one singular framework for MPA’s, due to different circumstances around the world Agree Disagree

MPA’s are inevitable!   Agree Disagree

In designing MPA’s, the P from Planet should be more important than People and Profit   (Ecology has been deteriorated by human actions, and in order to restore balance, ecology (planet) should be more important)

FAO is the only organisation that should be allowed to give directives/frameworks for MPA’s

The fishing industry shouldn’t be part of the MPA discussion, since it is (partly) responsible for the problem

Fishermen should be part of the solution Fishermen should be part of the solution. Without compliance nothing will be achieved!