Experimental test of nonlocal causality

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
I NFORMATION CAUSALITY AND ITS TESTS FOR QUANTUM COMMUNICATIONS I- Ching Yu Host : Prof. Chi-Yee Cheung Collaborators: Prof. Feng-Li Lin (NTNU) Prof. Li-Yi.
Advertisements

Entanglement and Bell’s Inequalities Aaron Michalko Kyle Coapman Alberto Sepulveda James MacNeil Madhu Ashok Brian Sheffler.
Quantum Entanglement and Bell’s Inequalities Kristin M. Beck and Jacob E. Mainzer Demonstrating quantum entanglement of photons via the violation of Bell’s.
Study and characterisation of polarisation entanglement JABIR M V Photonic sciences laboratory, PRL.
Is Communication Complexity Physical? Samuel Marcovitch Benni Reznik Tel-Aviv University arxiv
Paraty, Quantum Information School, August 2007 Antonio Acín ICFO-Institut de Ciències Fotòniques (Barcelona) Quantum Cryptography (III)
Quantum Non-locality: From Bell to Information Causality Alex Thompson Physics 486 March 7, 2016.
M. Stobińska1, F. Töppel2, P. Sekatski3,
Conformational Heterogeneity in the Activation Mechanism of Bax
Quantum Information with Continuous Variables
Volume 111, Issue 2, Pages (July 2016)
Proof of the Existence of Photons
CA3 Retrieves Coherent Representations from Degraded Input: Direct Evidence for CA3 Pattern Completion and Dentate Gyrus Pattern Separation  Joshua P.
Inactivation of Medial Frontal Cortex Changes Risk Preference
Volume 71, Issue 4, Pages (August 2011)
Radial Arrangement of Chromosome Territories in Human Cell Nuclei: A Computer Model Approach Based on Gene Density Indicates a Probabilistic Global Positioning.
Andreas Hilfinger, Thomas M. Norman, Johan Paulsson  Cell Systems 
Mechanical Distortion of Single Actin Filaments Induced by External Force: Detection by Fluorescence Imaging  Togo Shimozawa, Shin'ichi Ishiwata  Biophysical.
Volume 5, Issue 4, Pages e4 (October 2017)
Francesca Pennacchietti, Travis J. Gould, Samuel T. Hess 
Radial Arrangement of Chromosome Territories in Human Cell Nuclei: A Computer Model Approach Based on Gene Density Indicates a Probabilistic Global Positioning.
Volume 96, Issue 1, Pages e7 (September 2017)
SE Questions and progress in quantum information and causality
Conformational Heterogeneity in the Activation Mechanism of Bax
Quantum phase magnification
Volume 90, Issue 10, Pages (May 2006)
by Justin G. Bohnet, Brian C. Sawyer, Joseph W. Britton, Michael L
Fig. 1 Upward emission functions used to compute the maps.
In vivo tracking of PD-L1+NCMs in the microcirculation.
Fig. 1 Experimental setup.
Origin of the asymmetry and determination of the critical angle
Fig. 3 Electron PSD in various regions.
Fig. 4 Twist grain boundary free energies as a function of misalignment angle for the (110)-(100) crystal planes of a nanocrystal with 1135 atoms. Twist.
Full-frame single image recording the violation of a Bell inequality
Fig. 1 Imaging setup to perform a Bell inequality test in images.
Fig. 2 Full-frame images recording the violation of a Bell inequality in four images. Full-frame images recording the violation of a Bell inequality in.
Fig. 2 Reconstructed global mean temperatures.
Fig. 6 External drivers and model response.
Fig. 3 Forward model. Forward model. Summary of the resampled Monte Carlo simulations shown as histograms for epoch 1 (red), epoch 2 (green), and epoch.
Reward associations do not explain transitive inference performance in monkeys by Greg Jensen, Yelda Alkan, Vincent P. Ferrera, and Herbert S. Terrace.
by Andreas Keiling, Scott Thaller, John Wygant, and John Dombeck
Imaging Bell-type nonlocal behavior
Fast, noise-free memory for photon synchronization at room temperature
Fig. 4 Evolution of fraction of sickled RBCs under hypoxia.
Fig. 2 Results of the learning and testing phases.
Fig. 6 Global sensitivity analysis illustrates the key model parameters that determine the sickling of RBCs. Global sensitivity analysis illustrates the.
by Hiro Nimiya, Tatsunori Ikeda, and Takeshi Tsuji
Relative impacts of mitigation, temperature, and precipitation on 21st-century megadrought risk in the American Southwest by Toby R. Ault, Justin S. Mankin,
Fig. 2 Asymmetric MR of LMO within the ac plane.
Final fate of a Leidenfrost droplet: Explosion or takeoff
by Shuichi Murakami, Motoaki Hirayama, Ryo Okugawa, and Takashi Miyake
Fig. 1 Influence of SSTA on the atmosphere and its relationship with U
Relationships between species richness and temperature or latitude
Fig. 1 Fractional coverage of the mapping method used in this study.
Fig. 4 Next-generation MOF with increased productivity.
Volume 28, Issue 19, Pages e8 (October 2018)
Evolution-informed forecasting of seasonal influenza A (H3N2)‏
Optical π phase shift created with a single-photon pulse
Fig. 2 The experimental setup.
Fig. 2 Comparison of the observed DRs and the estimates by the VR model and FL. Comparison of the observed DRs and the estimates by the VR model and FL.
Fig. 4 The relationship between the total mean absolute momentum disturbance 〈∣p∣〉zB (in units of ℏ/D) and fringe visibility V. The relationship between.
Fig. 2 Finite element method (FEM) simulations of the photonic synapse with different structures. Finite element method (FEM) simulations of the photonic.
Fig. 2 Experimental setup.
Fig. 3 Wavelength and polarization tunable mirrorless lasing from the heliconical superstructure. Wavelength and polarization tunable mirrorless lasing.
Fig. 3 Interference of quantum clocks.
Fig. 2 Active diffusion studies.
Fig. 2 Evaluation of accuracy in finding the atomic positions via a deep learning model for different levels of noise. Evaluation of accuracy in finding.
Fig. 3 Global and basin-averaged sampling error compared with reconstructed temperature change. Global and basin-averaged sampling error compared with.
Fig. 1 Photonic implementation of a fractional QKT.
Fig. 5 Modeling of the ASE threshold using the kinetic equations and experimental parameter inputs. Modeling of the ASE threshold using the kinetic equations.
Presentation transcript:

Experimental test of nonlocal causality by Martin Ringbauer, Christina Giarmatzi, Rafael Chaves, Fabio Costa, Andrew G. White, and Alessandro Fedrizzi Science Volume 2(8):e1600162 August 10, 2016 Copyright © 2016, The Authors

Fig. 1 Causal structures for a Bell scenario. Causal structures for a Bell scenario. (A) Bell’s original local hidden-variable models, where X (Y) is Alice’s (Bob’s) measurement setting, and A (B) is the corresponding measurement outcome. Λ denotes the local hidden variable. (B) A relaxation of local causality, where A may have direct causal influence on B. The Bell-local models in (A) are the limiting case where the green arrow from A to B vanishes. An explicit example of such a model is given in the Supplementary Materials. (C) An intervention (I) on A forces the variable to take a specific value and breaks all incoming arrows. Martin Ringbauer et al. Sci Adv 2016;2:e1600162 Copyright © 2016, The Authors

Fig. 2 The experimental setup. The experimental setup. (A) Pairs of photons are generated via spontaneous parametric down-conversion in a periodically poled KTP crystal, using the Sagnac design of Fedrizzi et al. (48). The degree of polarization entanglement between the two photons can be continuously varied by changing the polarization angle γ of the pump laser. Alice and Bob perform measurements in the equatorial plane of the Bloch sphere using a half-wave plate (HWP) and a polarizing beam splitter (PBS). Additional quarter-wave plates (QWPs) can be used for quantum state tomography of the initial entangled state. In the interventionist experiment, an additional combination of QWP and polarizer (POL) is used between Alice’s basis choice and her measurement. Causal variables are indicated using the notation of Fig. 1A. Note that Λ can represent an arbitrary hidden variable acting as a common cause for the observed outcomes, which need not necessarily originate at the source. (B) Alice’s (red) and Bob’s (blue) measurement bases and the intervention direction (cyan) on the Bloch sphere. QRNG, quantum random number generator; APD, avalanche photodiode. Martin Ringbauer et al. Sci Adv 2016;2:e1600162 Copyright © 2016, The Authors

Fig. 3 Observed average causal effect ACE versus measured CHSH value. Observed average causal effect ACE versus measured CHSH value. Any value below the dashed red line, given by Eq. 4, is not sufficient to explain the observed CHSH violation. Note that the quantity ACE is bounded from below by 0, as indicated by the hatched area, resulting in asymmetric error distributions. The blue shaded area represents the 3σ region of Poissonian noise. All errors represent the 3σ statistical confidence intervals obtained from a Monte Carlo simulation of the Poissonian counting statistics. Martin Ringbauer et al. Sci Adv 2016;2:e1600162 Copyright © 2016, The Authors

Fig. 4 Observed values S3 for a variety of quantum states of the form cosγ|HV〉 + sinγ|VH〉. Observed values S3 for a variety of quantum states of the form cosγ|HV〉 + sinγ|VH〉. The orange data points are observed using a fixed measurement scheme (optimal for the maximally entangled state γ = 45°), with the dotted, orange line representing the corresponding theory prediction. The blue data points and blue dashed theory line correspond to the case where measurement settings were optimized for the prepared states (see the Supplementary Materials for details). The black line represents the bound of inequality (5); any point above this line cannot be explained causally by a model of the form in Fig. 1B. Error bars correspond to 3σ statistical confidence intervals. Martin Ringbauer et al. Sci Adv 2016;2:e1600162 Copyright © 2016, The Authors

Fig. 5 Comparison of various constraints on the causal structure of Bell’s theorem. Comparison of various constraints on the causal structure of Bell’s theorem. The causal links forbidden by the respective assumption are shown in dashed green lines. Note that the statistical constraints implied by causal parameter independence are asymmetric in a and b, and swapping them would result in a causal structure where the arrow between A and B is reversed. Our experimental test applies to both of these structures and any convex combination of them. Martin Ringbauer et al. Sci Adv 2016;2:e1600162 Copyright © 2016, The Authors