RCC Overview & 2018 CMCI Implementation March 12, 2018 Hotel Marciano Brgy. Real Calamba, Laguna

Overview The Cities and Municipalities Competitiveness Index is an annual ranking of Philippine Cities and Municipalities developed by the National Competitiveness Council through the Regional Competitiveness Committees (RCCs) with the assistance of the United States Agency for International Development.

About the RCCs the RCCs are tasked to: Regularly measure local competitiveness indicators Formulate programs to improve competitiveness Engage in investment promotion activities to attract investors and create new jobs

About the RCCs

CMCI Framework Economic Dynamism Government Efficiency Infrastructure Resiliency Local Economic Development Competitiveness

* Indicator with changes ECONOMIC DYNAMISM INDICATORS Size of the local economy Growth of the Local Economy Structure of Local Economy* Safety Compliant Business* Increase in Employment Cost of Living Cost of Doing Business Financial Deepening Productivity Presence of Business and Professional Organizations * Indicator with changes

GOVERNMENT EFFICIENCY INDICATORS Compliance to National Directives Presence of Investment Promotion Unit Business Registration Efficiency* Capacity to Generate Local Resource Capacity of Health Services Capacity of School Services* Recognition of Performance Compliance to Business Permits and Licensing System (BPLS) Standards* Peace and Order Social Protection * Indicator with changes

* Indicator with changes INFRASTRUCTURE INDICATORS Basic Infrastructure: Roads Basic Infrastructure: Ports Basic Infrastructure: Availability of Basic Utilities Number of PUBLIC Transportation Vehicles Education Infrastructure Health Infrastructure LGU Investment in Infrastructure Accommodation Capacity Information Technology Capacity Financial Technology Capacity * Indicator with changes

INDICATORS RESILIENCY Organization and Coordination: Land Use Plan Organization and Coordination: Disaster Risk Reduction Plan Organization and Coordination: Annual Disaster Drill Organization and Coordination: Early Warning System Resiliency Financing: Budget for DRRMP Resiliency Reports: Local Risk Assessments Resiliency Infrastructure: Emergency Infrastructure* Resiliency Infrastructure: Utilities* Resilience of System: Employed Population Resilience of System: Sanitary System

ADDITIONAL INDICATORS Cost of Freight (for Cities and Municipalities outside Metro Manila) Number of PUBLIC Transport Terminals Frequency of Trips per Day Number of Retail Companies

Ranking Categories

Updates on Global Competitiveness Report Card/ NCC Work Programs

GLOBAL COMPETITIVENESS REPORT CARD 2018 2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 CHANGE 2010/11 to LATEST SOURCE TOP 20% 1. Doing Business Report - 113/190 99/190 103/189 95/189 108/189 138/185 136/183 148/183 ↑ 35 International Finance Corporation 38 2. Economic Freedom Index 61/180 58/180 70/178 76/178 89/178 97/177 107/179 115/179 ↑ 54 Heritage Foundation 36 3. Corruption Perceptions Index 111/180 101/168 95/168 85/175 94/177 105/176 129/183 134/178 ↑ 23 Transparency International 34 4. Global Competitiveness Report 56/137 57/138 47/140 52/144 59/148 65/144 75/142 85/139 ↑ 28 World Economic Forum 27 5. Global Enabling Trade Index 82/136 64/138 n/a 72/132 *92/125 ↑ 10 6. Travel and Tourism Report 79/136 74/141 82/140 94/139 ↑ 15 7. Global Innovation Index 73/128 74/128 83/141 100/143 90/142 95/141 91/125 ↑ 18 World Intellectual Property Organization 26 Global Information Technology Report 77/139 76/143 78/148 86/144 86/142 86/138 ↑ 9 28 9. E-Government Index 71/193 95/193 -- 88/191 78/184 ↑ 7 United Nations 39 10. Fragile States Index 54/178 48/178 52/178 59/178 56/177 50/177 ↑ 4 Fund for Peace 11. Global Gender Gap Report 7/144 7/145 9/142 5/136 8/135 ↑ 2 29 12. World Competitiveness Yearbook 41/63 42/60 41/60 38/60 43/59 41/59 International Institute for Management Development 13 13. Logistics Performance Index 71/160 57/160 52/155 44/155 ↓ 27 World Bank 32 Latest Performance Reached the Top 3rd of the World Rankings

GLOBAL COMPETITIVENESS REPORT CARD 2010/2011 2017/2018 GOAL (Top 20%) CHANGE 4 to 6 yrs 1.Doing Business Report (IFC) 148/183 113/190 38 ↑ 35 2. Economic Freedom Index (HF)* 115/179 61/180* 36 ↑ 54 3. Corruption Perceptions Index (TI) 134/178 111/180 34 ↑ 23 4. Global Competitiveness Index (WEF) 85/139 56/137 27 ↑ 28 5. Global Enabling Trade Index (WEF) 92/125 82/138 ↑ 10 6. Travel and Tourism Report (WEF) 94/139 79/136 ↑ 15 7. WIPO- Global Innovation Index (WIPO) 91/125 73/128 26 ↑ 18 8. Global Information Technology Report (WEF) 86/138 77/139 28 ↑ 9 9. E-Government Index (UN) 78/184 71/193 39 ↑ 7 10. Fragile States Index (FFP) ** 50/177 54/178 ↑ 4 11. Global Gender Gap Report (WEF) 9/142 7/144 29 ↑ 2 12. World Competitiveness Report (IMD) 41/59 41/63 13 - 13. Logistics Performance Index (WB) 44/155 71/160 32 ↓ 27 *with 2016 Results, **reverse ranking (1 as worst) LATEST PERFORMANCE UPGRADE DOWNGRADE *with 2018 Result **reverse ranking (1 as worst)

GLOBAL COMPETITIVENESS REPORT PHILIPPINES and ASEAN Country/Economy 2017 (out of 137) 2016 (out of 138) 2015 (out of 140) 2014 (out of 144) 2013 (out of 148) 2012 (out of 144) 2011 (out of 142) 2010 (Out of 139) Change 2016-2017 Change 2010-2017 Singapore 3 2 -1 Malaysia 23 25 18 20 24 21 26 Thailand 32 34 31 37 38 39 6 Indonesia 36 41 50 46 44 5 8 Brunei Darussalam n/a 28 -18 Vietnam 55 60 56 68 70 75 65 59 4 Philippines 57 47 52 85 1 29 Lao PDR 98 93 83 81 -5 -17 Cambodia 94 89 90 95 88 97 109 15 Myanmar 131 134 139

GLOBAL COMPETITIVENESS REPORT 2010 - 2017 Percentile Rank Upper 1/3 Middle 1/3 Bottom 1/3 137 120 100 90 70 50 30 10 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2017 TOP THIRD Target: #27 (Top 20%) Current Ranking 2016

Doing Business Report: Philippines 2011-2018 95 99 103 108 113 Current http://databank.worldbank.org/data/reports.aspx?Code=NY.GDP.MKTP.KD.ZG&id=1ff4a498&report_name=Popular-Indicators&populartype=series&ispopular=y# 136 138 148 190 Source: Published Doing Business Report

PHILIPPINES vs ASEAN OVERALL (2011-2018) Philippines 113 103 95 108 Economy 2018 (190) 2017 (190) 2016 (189) 2015 (189) 2014 (189) 2013 (185) 2012 (183) 2011 (183) Change 2017-2018 Change 2011-2018 Singapore 2 1 -1 Malaysia 24 23 18 6 12 21 -3 Thailand 26 46 49 17 19 20 -7 Brunei Darussalam 56 72 84 101 59 79 83 112 16 Vietnam 68 82 90 78 99 98 14 10 Indonesia 91 109 114 120 128 129 121 Philippines 113 103 95 108 138 136 148 -14 35 Cambodia 135 131 127 137 133 147 -4 Lao PDR 141 139 134 159 163 166 171 -2 30 Myanmar 170 167 177 182 NDA 11 Source: Published Doing Business Report

STARTING A BUSINESS (2011-2018) PHILIPPINES vs ASEAN STARTING A BUSINESS (2011-2018) Economy 2018 (190) 2017 (190) 2016 (189) 2015 (189) 2014 (189) 2013 (185) 2012 (183) 2011 (183) Change 2017-2018 Change 2011-2018 Singapore 6 10 3 4 -2 Thailand 36 78 96 75 91 85 95 42 59 Brunei Darussalam 58 84 74 179 137 135 136 133 26 Malaysia 111 112 14 13 16 54 50 113 1 2 Vietnam 123 121 119 125 109 108 103 100 -23 Indonesia 144 151 173 155 175 166 7 11 Myanmar 146 160 189 NDA -9 43 Lao PDR 164 153 154 81 89 93 -4 -71 Philippines 171 165 161 170 158 156 -17 Cambodia 183 180 184 -3 -13 Source: Published Doing Business Report

PHILIPPINES vs ASEAN DEALING W/ CONSTRUCTION PERMITS(2011-2018) Economy 2018 (190) 2017 (190) 2016 (189) 2015 (189) 2014 (189) 2013 (185) 2012 (183) 2011 (183) Change 2017-2018 Change 2011-2018 Malaysia 11 13 15 28 43 96 113 108 2 97 Singapore 16 10 1 3 -6 -14 Vietnam 20 24 12 22 29 67 62 4 42 Lao PDR 40 47 107 87 80 115 7 75 Thailand 39 6 14 -1 -31 Brunei Darussalam 48 37 21 53 46 83 74 -11 26 Myanmar 73 66 130 150 NDA -7 77 Philippines 101 85 99 124 100 102 156 -16 55 Indonesia 116 153 88 71 60 8 -48 Cambodia 179 183 181 161 149 146 -33 Source: Published Doing Business Report

GETTING ELECTRICITY(2011-2018) PHILIPPINES vs ASEAN GETTING ELECTRICITY(2011-2018) Economy 2018 (190) 2017 (190) 2016 (189) 2015 (189) 2014 (189) 2013 (185) 2012 (183) 2011 (183) Change 2017-2018 Change 2011-2018 Malaysia 8 13 27 21 28 59 - 51 Singapore 12 10 6 11 5 -2 -7 Thailand 37 9 24 -4 Brunei Darussalam 68 42 29 -3 4 Philippines 31 22 19 16 33 57 54 -9 23 Indonesia 38 49 46 78 121 147 161 123 Vietnam 64 96 108 135 156 155 32 71 Cambodia 137 136 145 139 134 132 130 -1 Lao PDR 149 158 128 140 138 -11 Myanmar 151 148 126 NDA -25 Source: Published Doing Business Report

REGISTERING PROPERTY (2011-2018) PHILIPPINES vs ASEAN REGISTERING PROPERTY (2011-2018) Economy 2018 (190) 2017 (190) 2016 (189) 2015 (189) 2014 (189) 2013 (185) 2012 (183) 2011 (183) Change 2017-2018 Change 2011-2018 Singapore 19 17 24 28 36 14 15 -4 Malaysia 42 40 38 75 35 33 59 60 -2 18 Vietnam 63 58 51 48 47 43 -20 Lao PDR 65 66 77 76 74 72 163 98 Thailand 68 57 29 26 -49 Indonesia 106 118 131 117 101 99 12 -8 Philippines 114 112 108 121 122 102 -12 Cambodia 123 120 100 115 110 -3 -6 Myanmar 134 143 145 151 154 NDA 9 20 Brunei Darussalam 136 148 162 116 107 183 Source: Published Doing Business Report

PHILIPPINES vs ASEAN GETTING CREDIT(2011-2018) Philippines 142 118 109 Economy 2018 (190) 2017 (190) 2016 (189) 2015 (189) 2014 (189) 2013 (185) 2012 (183) 2011 (183) Change 2017-2018 Change 2011-2018 Brunei Darussalam 2 62 79 89 55 129 126 116 60 114 Malaysia 20 28 23 1 -19 Cambodia 7 15 12 42 53 98 -13 69 Singapore 29 19 17 3 8 6 -9 -23 Vietnam 32 36 40 24 -14 Thailand 82 97 73 70 67 72 30 Indonesia 71 86 61 Lao PDR 77 75 159 167 166 152 -2 Philippines 142 118 109 104 128 -24 Myanmar 177 175 174 171 170 NDA -7 Source: Published Doing Business Report

PHILIPPINES vs ASEAN PROTECTING MINORITY INVESTORS(2011-2018) Economy 2018 (190) 2017 (190) 2016 (189) 2015 (189) 2014 (189) 2013 (185) 2012 (183) 2011 (183) Change 2017-2018 Change 2011-2018 Singapore 4 1 3 2 -3 -2 Malaysia 5 -1 Thailand 16 27 36 25 12 13 11 -4 Brunei Darussalam 40 102 134 110 115 117 122 120 62 80 Indonesia 43 70 88 52 49 46 44 Vietnam 81 87 157 169 166 173 6 92 Cambodia 108 114 111 82 79 74 -34 Philippines 146 137 155 154 128 133 132 -9 -14 Lao PDR 172 165 178 187 184 182 -7 10 Myanmar 183 179 NDA Source: Published Doing Business Report

PHILIPPINES vs ASEAN PAYING TAXES (2011-2018) Philippines 105 115 126 Economy 2018 (190) 2017 (190) 2016 (189) 2015 (189) 2014 (189) 2013 (185) 2012 (183) 2011 (183) Change 2017-2018 Change 2011-2018 Singapore 7 8 5 4 1 -3 Thailand 67 109 70 62 96 100 91 42 24 Malaysia 73 61 31 32 36 15 41 23 -12 -50 Vietnam 86 167 168 173 149 138 151 124 81 38 Brunei Darussalam 104 89 16 30 20 22 -15 -82 Philippines 105 115 126 127 131 143 136 10 19 Indonesia 114 148 160 137 130 -10 Myanmar 125 119 84 116 107 NDA -6 -18 Cambodia 95 90 65 66 54 57 -79 Lao PDR 156 146 129 123 -40 Source: Published Doing Business Report

TRADING ACROSS BORDERS (2011-2018) PHILIPPINES vs ASEAN TRADING ACROSS BORDERS (2011-2018) Economy 2018 (190) 2017 (190) 2016 (189) 2015 (189) 2014 (189) 2013 (185) 2012 (183) 2011 (183) Change 2017-2018 Change 2011-2018 Singapore 42 41 1 -1 -41 Thailand 57 56 36 24 20 17 12 -45 Malaysia 61 60 49 11 5 29 37 -24 Vietnam 94 93 99 75 65 74 68 63 -31 Philippines 95 53 51 -4 -38 Cambodia 108 102 98 124 114 118 120 -6 10 Indonesia 112 105 62 54 39 47 -65 Lao PDR 156 161 160 168 170 46 Brunei Darussalam 144 142 121 40 35 52 -2 -92 Myanmar 163 159 140 103 113 NDA -50 Source: Published Doing Business Report

ENFORCING CONTRACTS(2011-2018) PHILIPPINES vs ASEAN ENFORCING CONTRACTS(2011-2018) Economy 2018 (190) 2017 (190) 2016 (189) 2015 (189) 2014 (189) 2013 (185) 2012 (183) 2011 (183) Change 2017-2018 Change 2011-2018 Singapore 2 1 12 13 11 Thailand 34 51 57 25 22 23 24 17 -9 Malaysia 44 42 29 30 33 31 59 -2 15 Brunei Darussalam 61 93 113 139 161 158 151 159 32 98 Vietnam 66 69 74 47 46 3 -35 Lao PDR 97 88 92 99 104 114 110 Indonesia 145 166 170 172 147 144 156 154 21 9 Philippines 149 136 140 124 111 112 118 -13 -31 Cambodia 179 178 174 162 142 -1 -37 Myanmar 188 187 185 NDA Source: Published Doing Business Report

RESOLVING INSOLVENCY(2011-2018) PHILIPPINES vs ASEAN RESOLVING INSOLVENCY(2011-2018) Economy 2018 (190) 2017 (190) 2016 (189) 2015 (189) 2014 (189) 2013 (185) 2012 (183) 2011 (183) Change 2017-2018 Change 2011-2018 Thailand 26 23 49 45 58 51 46 -3 20 Singapore 27 29 19 4 2 -25 Indonesia 38 76 77 75 144 148 146 142 104 Malaysia 36 42 47 53 7 Philippines 59 56 50 100 165 163 153 94 Brunei Darussalam 60 57 98 88 48 44 -18 Cambodia 74 72 82 84 152 149 183 -2 109 Vietnam 129 125 123 124 -4 -5 Myanmar 164 162 160 155 NDA -9 Lao PDR 168 169 189 185 1 15 Source: Published Doing Business Report

Thank you! cmci_calabarzon@yahoo.com