Research Oversight Statement Highlights

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Health Information Technology and Privacy: Is There a Path to Consensus? February 29, 2008 Jodi. G. Daniel, J.D., M.P.H. Director, Office of Policy and.
Advertisements

1 Bernie LaSalle Biomedical Informatics Dept University of Utah CCTS.
Farm to Fork: Exploring Stakeholder Perspectives Ivor O’ Donovan Tony Quinlan Tony Barry WIT.
Congress and Contractor Personal Conflicts of Interest May 21, 2008 Jon Etherton Etherton and Associates, Inc.
Environmental Management Systems An Overview With Practical Applications.
Data Management Awareness January 23, University of Michigan Administrative Information Services Data Management Awareness Unit Liaisons January.
Promoting Excellence in Family Medicine Enabling Patients to Access Electronic Health Records Guidance for Health Professionals.
A Robust Health Data Infrastructure P. Jon White, MD Director, Health IT Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality
HIT Policy Committee Accountable Care Workgroup – Kickoff Meeting May 17, :00 – 2:00 PM Eastern.
EFFECTING CULTURAL CHANGE IN RESEARCH ETHICS AND INTEGRITY Encouraging a culture of research integrity Andrew C. Rawnsley.
1 CREATING A LEARNING ORGANIZATION AND AN ETHICAL ORGANIZATION STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT BUAD 4980.
1 OPHS FOUNDATIONAL STANDARD BOH Section Meeting February 11, 2011.
EUTOPA Amsterdam Conference September 25/ Amsterdam conference September 25/ Multidisciplinary guideline for early psychosocial interventions.
Chapter © 2012 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall.
Designing the Microbial Research Commons: An International Symposium Overview National Academy of Sciences Washington, DC October 8-9, 2009 Cathy H. Wu.
Research Data Management Services Katherine McNeill Social Sciences Librarians Boot Camp June 1, 2012.
International Federation of Accountants April 26, 2009 Transitioning to One World in Accounting Education Robert Bunting, IFAC President The Higher Education.
1 Collaboration and Concept Exploration Nationwide Health Information Organization (NHIO) Gateway March 28, 2007.
Draft – discussion only Advanced Health Models and Meaningful Use Workgroup June 23, 2015 Paul Tang, chair Joe Kimura, co-chair.
1 Harmonisation and Alignment: Challenges for US and European donors Alex Wilks, European Network on Debt and Development GMF, 18 th December
“Guidance on the Selection and Appraisal of Geospatial Content of Enduring Value, April 2014 Draft” groups-subcommittees/hdwg/index_html.
Enterprise Risk Management for US Operations of International Banks Communication and Education.
Vision for academic geographic data access Dr David Medyckyj-Scott GRADE Project Director EDINA.
AAHRPP ACCREDITATION (Association for the Accreditation of Human Protection Programs)
CUNY Human Research Protection Program (HRPP) School of Professional Studies April 18, 2013
EPHA Briefing Paper (Part 2): High Level Reflection Process on Patient Mobility in the EU - summary of final recommendations - December 2003 (See also.
The NCI Central IRB Initiative Jacquelyn L. Goldberg, J.D. VA IRB Chair Training April 8, 2004.
Health Management Information Systems Unit 3 Electronic Health Records Component 6/Unit31 Health IT Workforce Curriculum Version 1.0/Fall 2010.
Regulation Inside Government: Approach and lessons learned Punita Goodfellow, Better Regulation Executive, Cabinet Office, UK.
1/28/2016 Prevention Research and Natioanl Aids Plans Geneva 1 Prevention Research and National AIDS Plans June 2005 Geneva, Switzerland Prof. Roy.
PHDSC Privacy, Security, and Data Sharing Committee Letter to Governors.
Providing Safe and Effective Care for Patients with Limited English Proficiency This course was developed with the support of the Josiah Macy Jr. Foundation.
ACWG Charge Make recommendations to the Health IT Policy Committee on how HHS policies and programs can advance the evolution of a health IT infrastructure.
PROTECTING THE INTERESTS OF CONSUMERS OF FINANCIAL SERVICES Role of Supervisory Authorities Keynote Address to the FinCoNet Open Meeting 22 April 2016.
Overview of Good Regulatory Practice Kent Shigetomi Office of the U.S. Trade Representative.
Challenges in Promoting RCR: Reflections from a Public Funder´s Perspective Secretariat on Responsible Conduct of Research [Canadian Institutes of Health.
CIS 170 MART Teaching Effectively/cis170mart.com FOR MORE CLASSES VISIT HCA 497 MART Inspiring Minds/hca497mart.com FOR MORE CLASSES.
ANAND PAREKH, M.D., M.P.H. BPC SENIOR ADVISOR Healthy Aging Begins at Home.
Supervision of Insurance Market Conduct in Canada
Institutional case study London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine
Principles Of Women Empowerment
Challenges in Implementing Data Sharing Principles
Summit 2017 Breakout Group 2: Data Management (DM)
Journal Club Notes.
Health Information Security and Privacy Collaborative (HISPC) Overview
CDRH 2010 Strategic Priorities
Changing Practices… Changing Values
Genevieve Morris Principal Deputy National Coordinator for Health IT
Structure of the Code – Phases 1 and 2
Manipulation of the Waitlist Priority of the Organ Allocation System through the Escalation of Medical Therapies Ethics Committee.
Branch Chief, Concerns Resolution Branch
ONC P2 FHIR Ecosystem Task Force
Research and Test Reactor Safety: The Regulatory Perspective
Creating a Culture of Open Data in Academia
Alexandros Dimitriadis
Clinical and Translational Science Awards Program
Research Data Management
Healthcare Privacy: The Perspective of a Privacy Advocate
CUNY Human Research Protection Program (HRPP)
Data and Interoperability:
We wanted to kick-off this meeting by reviewing:
Objectives Describe the purposes of the Health Information Technology for Economic and Clinical Health (HITECH) Act of 2009 Explore how the HITECH Act.
IRB Harmonization 2016 Review
Health Services for Individuals that are Deaf and Hard of Hearing
Overview of Good Regulatory Practice
Health Care Executives Statement Highlights
Generating Stakeholder Support and Demand for Health Data Sharing, Linkage, and Use: A Vision for a Health System that Shares Data for Continuous Improvement.
PORIRUA CITY COUNCIL Bay Drive Consultation
We wanted to kick-off this meeting by reviewing:
Patients and Families Statement
Presentation transcript:

Research Oversight Statement Highlights Sarah Greene Health Care Systems Research Network Russell Rothman Vanderbilt University

Post-It Note Prioritization Ritual Ethical Barriers Financial Barriers Cultural Barriers Operational Barriers Regulatory Barriers

Prioritized Barriers Lack of shared principles regarding data ownership, stewardship, governance, rights, and responsibilities. Heterogeneity in beliefs among patients, clinicians, and researchers about whether data should be freely shared or not. Uncertainty about potential future uses of data, and accompanying concerns about consequences arising from inappropriate/unauthorized use Variability across institutions and states in their interpretation of regulations and responsibilities. Operational challenges including uneven data quality, the cost to procure data, and the lag time between when data is collected and when it is available for use by researchers. *Top issues preventing widespread data sharing and linkage to improve patient care that could be addressed in the ~2-3 years.

Near Term Solutions Lack of shared principles regarding data ownership, stewardship, governance, rights, and responsibilities. Convene high-impact task force or similar panel to create a consensus statement – with signatories – to publicly affirm a set of principles and commitments on the collective benefits of data as a public good Establish a federal commission to reach agreement about data ownership and data protections Data for the public good

Near Term Solutions (continued) Heterogeneity in beliefs among patients, clinicians, and researchers about whether or not data should be freely shared Gain deeper understanding of where these beliefs coincide and conflict via national survey(s) and literature review(s) Publish high-profile journal commentary describing a model policy that incorporates a commitment to openness and sharing, enabling others to compare existing policies with the model policy to improve consistency.

Near Term Solutions (continued) Uncertainty about potential future uses of data, and accompanying concerns about consequences arising from inappropriate or unauthorized use Improve approaches to communicating with patients in plain language about how data are collected and used Clarify regulations & penalties for unauthorized data sharing, applying insights from other countries and industries as they either addressed or failed to address data sharing issues Image credit: OpenDataWatch.com

Near Term Solutions (continued) Variability across institutions and states in their interpretation of regulations and responsibilities Collectively, state governments and organization should press for clearer federal guidance on data sharing policies HHS or ONC should create a taxonomy of learning activities (research, QI, etc.) with associated legal/regulatory considerations Convene IRB chairs, regulatory officials and thought leaders to draft guidance and case studies for IRBs and compliance officers with the goal of reducing variability in the interpretation of data use/data sharing regulations

Near Term Solutions (continued) Operational challenges, including uneven data quality, the cost to procure data, and the lag between when data is collected and when it is available for use by researchers Explore creation of a repository with a curated list of datasets and related metadata to encourage reuse and reduce lag times Engage ONC and others to push greater standardization of data in electronic health records (EHRs) Identify and accelerate incentives that encourage data sharing by researchers and other data holders