Document PTI th IWG on PTI. 10 Sept Agenda item 12

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
UNECE Regulation 13 (braking) Proposed amendment to extend Annex 19 and Annex 20 to cover motor vehicles, especially a vehicle stability function Sheet.
Advertisements

Th e E u r o p e a n T y r e a n d R i m T e c h n i c a l O r g a n i s a t i o n 1 Holistic approach for rolling noise mitigation GRB 56 th Sep 3 – 5,
EP Committee on the Internal Market and Consumer Protection – 22/03/2011 EP Public Hearing: Clear Internal Market Rules for Mopeds, Scooters and Motorcycles.
Process Industries Benchmarking Professor Munir Ahmad School of Science and Engineering Teesside University NEPIC Presentation.
LED HEADLAMPS DESIGN RESTRICTIVE REQUIREMENT Regulation ECE R48 Document ECE/TRANS/WP.29/GRE/2015/21. 1 Transmitted by the representative of France Informal.
Maintaining Roadworthiness. Overview o Tyres within the DVSA Guide to Maintaining Vehicle Roadworthiness o Service Station Tyre Checks (understanding.
Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism Information on mandatory fitting of advanced safety systems in Japan Engineering Policy Division.
COPERT 4 Training 3. Activity Data – Beginner’s Guide.
European Commission Enterprise and Industry New EU Regulation for the approval of 2-3 wheel vehicles and UNECE Regulations on sound level Working party.
Electronic Braking and Aid to Vehicle StabilityBradford University1 GRRF Ad-Hoc Working Group Electronic Vehicle Stability Control “Trailers” 25 – 26 November.
1 Corporate Average Fuel Economy Rulemaking National Highway Traffic Safety Administration Informal Document No. WP th session, June.
Motor Insurance Market in Europe. CEA’s Member Associations Source CEA 33 National Member Associations: 27 EU Member States + 6 Non-EU Markets Switzerland,
Frequency analysis and scenario development
France consideration on maximum noise in Global Technical Regulation on Quiet Road Transport Vehicles ECE-TRANS-WP29-GRB-58 Informal document GRB
TYNDP SJWS #3 Demand TYNDP – 3 rd SJWS 08 March 2012 ENTSOG offices -- Brussels.
ETRTO - 56th GRRF - GTR - Tyres N°1 Global Technical Regulation for TYRES ETRTO PROPOSAL Informal document No. GRRF (56th GRRF, September 2004.
TRUST (TRADE UNION VISION ON SUSTAINABLE TRANSPORT) Conferences on “Transport and environment & Infrastructure financing and the role of states” Brussels,
1 Automotive industry Reducing Noise Emissions from Motor Vehicles: New EU Commission legislative proposal World Forum on Vehicle Regulations (WP.29) 156.
Geneva, 09 December Commission Proposal on the General Safety of Motor Vehicles Automotive Unit- F1 Geneva, 09 December Informal document No.
Modernization in Freight Truck Transport in Pakistan PhD (Transportation Planning) Assistant Professor Department of Urban and Infrastructure Engineering.
Development of Agreement Concerning the Adoption of Uniform Conditions for Periodical Technical Inspections of Wheeled Vehicles and the Reciprocal Recognition.
Current Status of Noise Regulation Review in Japan Ministry of the Environment, JAPAN Informal document GRB (55th GRB, 7-9 February 2012, agenda.
Chapter 9 VEHICLE INFORMATION. Vehicle Title and Registartion New Jersey residents who buy a new or used vehicle must title, register, and insure it before.
Air Quality Governance in the ENPI East Countries EMISSION INVENTORY September 2012 Chisinau, MOLDOVA.
Potential of electrical trailer cooling during rest periods Analysis of emission and costs.
The transport companies’ views on the roadworthiness package EPTRAN, Brussels, 22 January 2013 Marc Billiet Head EU Goods Transport.
 ROAD SAFETY: the European Union Policy European Commission, Directorate General for Mobility & Transport «Road Safety.
M O N T E N E G R O Negotiating Team for the Accession of Montenegro to the European Union Working Group for Chapter 14 – Transport Bilateral screening:
Freight Railway Integration Strategy For Inter-American Development Bank Transport Week 2009 by Transportation Technology Center, Inc. (TTCI) Subsidiary.
Agreement concerning the adoption of uniform conditions for periodical technical inspections of wheeled vehicles and the reciprocal recognition of such.
ABOUT CVH AND PTI SYSTEM IN CROATIA Tomislav Škreblin
4. Activity Data – Beginner’s Guide
Measuring the Health impacts of NHS travel
India’s Comments on EPPR (Part-B2)
Johan Sliggers Ministry of Environment The Netherlands
EWG Study Tour, Galway, 18/09/2006
Bus and coach transport for greening mobility
PRESENTATION OF MONTENEGRO
Session 2: Safety (vehicle and passenger safety, emergency services)
Transmitted by the expert from the Netherlands Informal Document No
9th Noise Experts Group meeting 30 November 2017
Kristina Dourmashkin Eurostat Unit E4
ASSESSMENT OF THE LATEST PROPOSAL BY THE NETHERLANDS AS PRESENTED
Statistical returns in respect of the carriage of goods by road
Calculation of evaporative emissions with COPERT Giorgos Mellios
ASEP IWG Report to GRB 66th
Rail transport statistics developments Agenda Item 4.1
M. Amann, W. Asman, I. Bertok, J. Cofala, C. Heyes,
Carl Bro a/s - Team Leader - IPPC-experts - Quality Assurance
Comments on IWG R55 proposal to GRRF
ETRTO proposal for UN R30 & 64 amendments Extended Mobility Tyres
Strengthening Tyre limits ! New developments (2)
Passenger Mobility Statistics 10 April 2014
Amendment to regulation UN 117 Introduction of worn tyre performances
CVTS 2015 – Draft Commission Regulation amending Regulation (EC) No 198/2006 Agenda item 2.2 DSS Meeting 3-4 April 2014.
Proposals from the Informal Working Group on AEBS
Task Force on Passenger Mobility Statistics 11 October 2018
The change of data sources in the Spanish SILC
Development of the 1997 Agreement Rule 1 and Rule 2 for PTI
Emissions and Health Unit Institute of Environment and Sustainability
Steve Pye / Mike Holland NEC-PI Working Group, 19th June 2007
Monitoring of the 3rd PCI list in view of the PCI selection
Task Force on the measurement of road traffic volumes in VKm
Water Scarcity & Droughts Policy in the EU Gap Analysis
Vehicle-to-Vehicle and Vehicle-to-Infrastructure linkages
Transmitted by the expert from the India
Transmitted by the expert from the European Commission
Tyre Industry workplan proposal to IWG Worn tyres
Comparison of key parameters of EU WLTP database and WLTC version 5
EVOLUTION OF ROAD SAFETY IN UNECE REGION ( )
Presentation transcript:

Document PTI-15-02 15th IWG on PTI. 10 Sept. 2019 Agenda item 12 Transmitted by CITA Study on the inclusion of light trailers and two- or three-wheel vehicles in the scope of the periodic roadworthiness testing EU PROJECT: MOVE/C2/SER/2017-295-SI2.772857 https://publications.europa.eu/en/publication-detail/-/publication/366a32b6-34c2-11e9-8d04-01aa75ed71a1

Index Project Consortium Highlights Trailers Two- and Three-Wheelers Cost and Benefit Analysis Conclusions

Project Consortium Highlights Trailers Two- and Three-Wheelers Cost and Benefit Analysis Conclusions

Project partners CITA – www.citainsp.org CVH – www.cvh.hr DEKRA – www.dekra.com Subcontractors IERC – www.ierc.de UC3M – www.uc3m.es

Project Consortium Highlights Trailers Two- and Three-Wheelers Cost and Benefit Analysis Conclusions

Highlights General data collection for EU Member States as well as an in-depth analysis for countries of the project partners: Croatia, Germany and Spain

Data collection consisting of: In-depth research of available data combined with survey data Light trailers as well as two- and three wheel vehicles Fleet sizes, mileage, PTI statistics and accident data Collection and analysis of national road safety measures Three scenarios have been defined: Scenario 0: base case (no PTI) Scenario 1: complete inspection Scenario 2: simplified inspection The results of a Cost and Benefit Analysis finally led to policy recommendations

Trailers: Low availability of accident data Reference country: Croatia Two- and three-wheelers: The case of Spain: comparing with and without PTI No alternative road safety measures identified

Project Consortium Highlights Trailers Two- and Three-Wheelers Cost and Benefit Analysis Conclusions

The PTI frequency for O1 trailers is: 0/3/3/3…   The PTI frequency for O2 trailers is: 0/2/1/1… The current (2017) trailer failure rate in Croatia: O1 trailers: 12.74% O2 trailers: 11.35%

The PTI frequency for O1 trailers is: 0/3/3/3…   The PTI frequency for O2 trailers is: 0/2/1/1… The current trailer failure rate in Croatia: O1 trailers: 12.74% O2 trailers: 11.35%

Scenario 0 - No PTI / Base case Scenario 1 - Full PTI This Scenario includes all inspection areas set out by 2014/45/EU Scenario 2 - Tailored PTI of trailers  (0) Identification of the vehicle; (1) Braking equipment; (4) Lighting equipment and parts of the electrical system; (5) Axles, wheels, tyres, suspension; (6) Chassis and chassis attachments.  

Proposed scenarios are feasible with current equipment Scenario 0 - No PTI / Base case Scenario 1 - Full PTI This Scenario includes all inspection areas set out by 2014/45/EU Scenario 2 - Tailored PTI of trailers  (0) Identification of the vehicle; (1) Braking equipment; (4) Lighting equipment and parts of the electrical system; (5) Axles, wheels, tyres, suspension; (6) Chassis and chassis attachments.   Proposed scenarios are feasible with current equipment

Project Consortium Highlights Trailers Two- and Three-Wheelers Cost and Benefit Analysis Conclusions

Two- and three-wheelers Accident evolution after the introduction of PTI for mopeds in Spain Period Mopeds fleet share Fatalities Injured Urban Road 2003 - 2006 7,5% 30,67% 5,43% 40,82% 9,56% 2013 6,38% 8,85% 3,16% 17,61% 5,44% PTI for Mopeds has been introduced in Spain between 2007 and 2010 depending on the region Source: Anuario estadístico de Accidentes 2013 DGT. Data presented by Luis Gutiérrez – AECA-ITV Mixed with other road safety factors

Scenario 0 - No PTI / Base case Scenario 1 - Full PTI This Scenario includes all inspection areas set out by 2014/45/EU Scenario 2 - Tailored PTI  (0) Identification of the vehicle; (4) Lighting equipment and parts of the electrical system; (5) Axles, wheels, tyres, suspension; (6) Chassis and chassis attachments; (8) Nuisance (polluting emissions).  

Proposed scenarios are feasible with current equipment Scenario 0 - No PTI / Base case Scenario 1 - Full PTI This Scenario includes all inspection areas set out by 2014/45/EU Scenario 2 - Tailored PTI  (0) Identification of the vehicle; (1) Braking equipment; (4) Lighting equipment and parts of the electrical system; (5) Axles, wheels, tyres, suspension; (6) Chassis and chassis attachments; (8) Nuisance (polluting emissions).   Proposed scenarios are feasible with current equipment

Project Consortium Highlights Trailers Two- and Three-Wheelers Cost and Benefit Analysis Conclusions

CBA: 2 Paths Two- and three-wheelers Trailers Low data availability Empirical data set 18 Spanish regions Time period: 2007 – 2016 Benefits from environmental improvement not considered Dependent variable: moped accidents Independent variables: Number of Mopeds PTI PTI caused on average a reduction of The 18% of total fatalities Level of significance is 1% Low data availability Assumptions are needed Germany with no PTI and Croatia with PTI 2,448 kilometers per year and trailer (statistics in Germany) 2,188 kilometers per year and trailer (Survey in Croatia) Estimation of the likelihood of an accident caused by trailer BCR for Croatia: 6.32

Trailers O-Vehicles (Croatia) The average cost per PTI in Croatia is around 20 Euros for trailers. Given that there have been 28,884 checks, around 577,680 Euros of costs can be estimated. Using the derived benefits from the previous chapter, a maximum benefit-cost ratio of 6.32 can be estimated.

Two- and Three-Wheelers (Spain) Given the benefit of 99 Euros per moped checked and considering the 21 Euros cost for a PTI after taxes, a benefit-cost ratio of around 4.73 is the outcome.

Project Consortium Highlights Trailers Two- and Three-Wheelers Cost and Benefit Analysis Conclusions

Conclusions Regardless of the availability of data, the benefit of inspecting light trailers is greater than the cost The case of Spain allow to compare the scenarios with and without PTI for L vehicles, with a positive impact Both proposals are feasible with the equipment already defined in Directive 2014/45/EU

Thank you for your attention!!!