Willing to learn : being a student in an age of uncertainty Ronald Barnett Institute of Education, University of London ‘ Improving Student Learning –

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Either We own our attitude; Or Our attitude Owns us. Its amazing but true that more people are denied promotions because of Attitude and Habits rather.
Advertisements

My English Language Assistant Experience Scott Jordan talks about his experiences as a language assistant in the fairytale city of Venice. For many years.
Academic assessment of work placement – made easy?
I would like if I may.....to take you on a strange journey The Rocky Horror Picture Show. This is the truth of my last 4 years! Many moons ago my mummy.
HFM SAN Distance Learning Project DL Aide - Assistant Survey 2005 – 2006 School Year... BOCES Distance Learning Program Quality Access Support.
Existentialism Overview
‘Skill Focus: Self Confidence & Fulfilling your Potential’ Sonia Bate, Director & Executive Coach, Edit Development.
INTERMEDIATE CLASS MODALS IN PAST.  Certainty e.g. I can't have lost my keys! (I'm sure I didn't) Can't have.
Increasing student motivation
10 Practical Ways a Live Your Life.
Existentialism and Jean-Paul Sartre
What you learn from experience relates to the quality of your thinking Jenny Moon, Centre for Excellence in Media Practice, Bournemouth University, UK.
1 Know Your Students Teaching Effectively in Higher Education in Hong Kong.
I have always had a natural ability and a love of teaching. I want to impart and gain knowledge from children. Some great teachers taught me and because.
Bring Success in Beliefs. You don’t have to wait for someone to accept, to promote, to select... to somehow "discover." Access is nearly unlimited;
SELF ESTEEM. Self Esteem What is Self Esteem ? –Self esteem is the opinion you have of yourself. It is based on your attitude to the following: Your value.
A CHAT WITH GOD God: Hello. Did you call me? God: Hello. Did you call me? Man: Called you? No.. who is this? Man: Called you? No.. who is this?
A SUGGESTED APPROACH TO PORTFOLIO BUILDING Step one: Select a portfolio topic by writing down a number of topics (i.e. brainstorm preferably with a colleague)
Managing Change and Transition Rita Burgett (800)
Security vs. Anxiety Definition: Structuring my life around that which cannot be destroyed or taken away.
Why Coaching? SEC Church Growth Department. To help us become and accomplish all that God wants us to be and do. The Purpose of Coaching.
Calling Flexibility to Account: Pitfalls and Possibilities Ronald Barnett, Institute of Education, London HEA Wales conference: Global Graduates – enabling.
Inner Critic 1.Internal voice that judges us as inadequate.
On Course, Copyright © Houghton Mifflin Company. All rights reserved.Interdependence - 1 Interdependence No man is an island, entire of itself; every man.
Finding And Staying On God’s Path. Joshua 1:6-8 "Be strong and courageous, for you shall give this people possession of the land which I swore to their.
CIT Town Meeting How do we Lead and Work in times of continuous CHANGE
thinking hats Six of Prepared by Eman A. Al Abdullah ©
Introducing CLT While Avoiding Classroom Culture Shock Marla Yoshida.
Dr Ann Luzeckyj, Flinders University Dr Russell Brinkworth, University of South Australia Karen Burke da Silva, Flinders University A/Prof, Ben McCann,
15 Powerful Habits Make You The Winner!!!.
(La Trobe University Primary Mathematics Method Competency Test: Question 34) What is the value of 1-5 x (-2)?
Rev Jack Bryant The Epistle of James Triangle Bible Institute 1.
9 Choices Winners Behave Daily. The secret of winning in life lies in seeing life differently - in its different shades and outcomes. Life becomes a path.
Unit 2 We believe in the Holy Spirit. Pentecost 50 days after the Resurrection, God came down to the disciples in the form of the Holy Spirit. The coming.
Faith Faith vs. Presumption Confidence that actions rooted in good character will yield the best outcome, even when I cannot see how.
Well for starters, my names Tony but everyone calls me Tone; whatever goes better for you I guess. I was born and raised in Michigan and I I’m proud to.
TLE Challenge – Session 2
Word of Life June 2015 “Martha, Martha, you are worried and distracted by many things; there is need of only one thing.” (Lk 10:41-42)
Motivation What is motivation? Why motivation? Importance of motivation Better motivation How to be motivated?
MY E-PORTFOLIO (WHAT I’VE LEARNED DURING THESE MEETINGS, WHAT IS NOT SO CLEAR, WHAT I DON’T GET AT ALL)
The Golden Circle, Dating and Building a Cathedral
Change The Way You Think. When you feel like quitting, remember that sometimes things have to go very wrong before they can be right. Sometimes you have.
Building A Positive Attitude “ A little ability combined with a positive attitude often goes further than a great talent teamed with a negative viewpoint.
EXISTENTIALISM.
The Skills Students Need To Succeed
Personal Mission Statement Education for Careers.
Everyone Communicates Few Connect
I am a postdoc at Baylor College of Medicine with an NIH K12 award (IRACDA). We are hosting the annual national IRACDA conference in Houston this year.
Geoset 1 G Student Feedback Houston. I am a postdoc at Baylor College of Medicine with an NIH K12 award (IRACDA). We are hosting the annual national IRACDA.
Making Healthful Choices Building Health Skills Chapter 2 – Lesson 1.
“Done with Bullying”. Session 4 - Buddying What can you do instead of bullying?
‘I am David’ Answers to booklet. Chapter 3 Chapter 3 1.At this point in the story, it is not clear as to why ‘the man’ in the camp helped David to escape.
How to Maximize Learning from a “Failure”! Any questions Contact: Mr. Ballard.
Marking and Feedback CPD Student approach to marking.
In the process of his or her personal development, a human being meets a lot of educators. The first educators are the parents. The family has the greatest.
Unit 2: Poetry. Before we begin… Most of you are groaning in your seats, and thinking inappropriate words about this poetry unit. – So go ahead… give.
EXAMINERS’ COMMENTS RAPHAEL’S LONG TURN GRAMMAR Accurate use of simple grammatical structures and also of some complex sentences: ‘they could also be preparing.
TA Conference May 19 th 2016 Tom Robson TRedu TRedu (c)
Greetings general public who listen to me. My name is Glorybel Marín Fontánez, I am a student of National University College, On-line. I thank God first,
This I Believe Essay Writer’s Workshop: Introductions, Juicy Details, & Conclusions 8 th ELA St. Joseph School.
Becoming a Twenty-first Century Student Ronald Barnett, Institute of Education, London Roehampton University, Annual Teaching and Learning Conference,
Leadership Presentation By Asim Lodhi Hi! My name is Asim Lodhi and I am a English 12 student at Fraser High School. I am a Senior and will be attending.
At Baylor College of Medicine with an NIH K12 award (IRACDA) we are hosting the annual national IRACDA conference in Houston.
Becoming a Fair-Minded Thinker
Chemistry careers in SMEs
Workshop for ART mentors
Building Girls’ Confidence
Colin Bray, Service Development Manager
Coaching for the Soul Connecting School Improvement with what matters most in School Leadership.
Our aims are: Every child has inspiring life experiences.
Presentation transcript:

Willing to learn : being a student in an age of uncertainty Ronald Barnett Institute of Education, University of London ‘ Improving Student Learning – for what? ’, Dublin, 5 Sept 07

Worlds of uncertainty Uncertainty refers surely not just to the world out there but the inner world How we respond to uncertainty. We see unpredictability – but we also feel uncertain So uncertainty is both cognitive and experiential. Uncertainty refers to our being in a world of unpredictability U is both perception and response (this reflection is crucial for us here) It looks two ways at once.

Two students’ reflections: anxiety is the very essence of being a student in an age of uncertainty ‘ (beginning the student journey) is a scary, exciting and fascinating world ’ ‘ I remember thinking … this is amazing, exciting, exhilarating and downright terrifying. ’ ‘… working with a complex world is also about attitude … not giving up when you feel overwhelmed …’ ‘ you can never be totally prepared ’. ‘ we need … self belief to survive and prosper …’ ‘ skills [of being creative, critical enquirers] need to go alongside absolute perseverance and dogged determination …’ (Natacha Thomas, ‘ Preparing Students for a Complex World – the Harsh Reality of being a student. ’, University of Surrey, June 2006 ‘… what ’ s fascinating about Alison ’ s courses is the amount of panic, you know, that surrounds the essays and I felt it personally … It was a very, very scary thing to do because … there were no right answers ’. (postgraduate student, University of Glasgow, commenting on courses taught by Alison Phipps)

Students: being-in-time Students normally arrive on time and in time; but they are also in time in another sense. Why do students keep going? (an extraordinary phenomenon) My own students – 2 recent instances Students see themselves in time They project themselves forward - and are not overwhelmed (even if daunted) ‘… being-towards-possibilities … is itself a potentiality-for-being. It has its own possibility – that of developing itself ’. (188) ‘… as Being-possible, … Dasein is never anything less; this is to say, it is existentially that which, in its potentiality-for-Being, it is not yet. ’ (186). (Heidegger, Being and Time)

A will to learn Why do we get up in the morning? Not because we have lots of knowledge - or many skills But because we have a will to do so, to take on the world in all its infinite complexity and uncertainty. A student persists because she has a will to learn ( ‘ learn ’ understood generously)

Two problems (‘research questions’) 1 Which is more important – the intellect or the way in which a student is? ‘ The will is the substance of man, the intellect the accident ’ (Schopenhauer) – is that right? Ontology trumps epistemology ( perhaps ) Can we supply any warrant for this belief? 2 But is the will to learn general or specific?

‘Being has not been given its due’ (Sartre) Being is the foundation of what it is to be a student ‘ Being a student ’ But today, we have to think of being-for- uncertainty ‘ Being-for-complexity ’ But also, complexity-in-being Cf a degree course in Music Design Technology

Becoming (cf ‘Improving Student Learning – for what?’) ‘ Become what you want to be ’ (univ advert) ‘ To be a subject means to transcend. ’ (Heidegger) But the becoming and the transcendence come out of the wrestling with hard and complex material – not dilettante; not ‘ becoming oneself ’ in a facile sense Strange juxtaposition – self-becoming and the standards inherent in the ped activities. Not a happening to oneself – but a happening into which one places oneself; & subjects oneself to the demands before one. ‘ Whoever has preserved a strong will together with an ample spirit has more favourable opportunities than ever. ’ (Nietzsche) - A will to become – amid uncertainty

The bunjee jumper The student hurls herself forward Takes risks Leaps into space of her own Her words and her actions are hers ( not plagiarised ) She flies Is energized Is exhilarated Confronts her fears But is unlikely to come to harm Not just living with but for uncertainty (The pedagogical situation provides exhilarating spaces.)

A Will to Offer The student not just puts herself forward She puts her offerings forward They are gifts & the response isn ’ t known in advance (so courage is required ( cf Natcha ’ s reflections )) So pure gifts A gentle rebuke to Derrida? ( ‘ The gift annuls the gift ’ ) These are, therefore, truly precious gifts – and deserve our thanks.

Losing the will to learn Int: ‘ The modules that you failed – do you think anybody could have done anything to help you? ’ A: ‘ No, it was me. I just lost interest in the modules. Looking back on it, I just wasn ’ t trying to understand it. I had lost interest. I believed it wasn ’ t for me and I didn ’ t want to do it. ’ Int: Tell me about the process by which you left. A:It was gradual and my attendance dwindled out. It wasn ’ t an abrupt end, it was gradual. I started thinking about the options. As I attended some of the classes my mind became more made up and I realised it wasn ’ t for me. ’ ( ‘ Re-thinking working class drop-out ’, Jocey Quinn et al, Joseph Rowntree report (2006))

Gaining the will to learn ‘ I had no awareness of my ability, so when you get an inspiring teacher that has faith in you, or helps you understand a topic then, you know, it ’ s amazing. ’ (4 th yr student, post 92 univ) ‘ The only thing I can say that this yr has done to me is that it ’ s given me a bit of independence and confidence. Before I was one of those people who didn ’ t used to talk to many people. Now, I ’ m really open. … I ’ m quite happy now about going to university. ’ (student who had left univ soon after joining.)

The will to learn – a schema ( and answers to our earlier two questions ) SpecificGeneral S W to L Epistemology X Ontology

A pedagogy of inspiration ‘ You get excited … if a teachers inspires you … (you) feel that drive to get involved. ’ (4th yr student) The inspiring teacher literally in-spires the student, breathes new life, new energy in. But the student has to take it in; to be open to it. This is new spirit; the spirit of higher education. ‘ Spirit lives and moves whereever our striving for clarity is a striving for fullness of insight ’ »Karl Jaspers, ‘ The Idea of the University ’ This is a critical spirit – open to new and even alarming frames of understanding, which the student makes her own.

Conclusion: ‘Teaching is more difficult than learning’ ‘ The teacher is ahead of his apprentices in this alone … (he) is far less assured. ’ But teaching is also more difficult than research. Teaching that brings about inspiration, and ‘ being-for-complexity ’, is demanding; impossible even. But there can hardly be a more significant human calling.