How to Identify Best Practices Dr. Lawrence (Larry) Martin Professor of Public Affairs University of Central Florida.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Consensus Building Infrastructure Developing Implementation Doing & Refining Guiding Principles of RtI Provide working knowledge & understanding of: -

Advertisements

Linking regions and central governments: Indicators for performance-based regional development policy 6 th EUROPEAN CONFERENCE ON EVALUATION OF COHESION.

The Budget The device that allocates the shortage of public money There is never enough money to do all the things people want done.

The Teacher Work Sample

K-6 Science and Technology Consistent teaching – Assessing K-6 Science and Technology © 2006 Curriculum K-12 Directorate, NSW Department of Education and.

Research Capacity Strengthening

HELP Water Law and Policy Dr. Patricia Wouters Director, Water Law and Policy Programme University of Dundee, Scotland Member of HELP Task Force.

Understanding Public Private Partnerships in Canada John Gamble, CET, P.Eng. OSPE Policy Series June 1, 2011.

Del Mar College Planning and Assessment Process Office of Institutional Research and Effectiveness January 10, 2005.

Access to Public Information in Georgia Presentation of research project results Tbilisi, 22 June 2010.

Ian Freeston. ENAEE Conference, Porto, 12 and 13 November 20121/14 Ian Freeston Where is the Forefront in Accredited Engineering.

Regulatory Frameworks in OECD countries and their Relevance for India Nick Malyshev Senior Counsellor Public Governance and Territorial Development OECD.

First Evaluation of Good Governance for Medicines Programme Brief Summary of Findings.

Springfield Public Schools 1 Project Management Methodologies in Support of Student Achievement.

Exhibit 5.1: Many Ways to Create Internal Structure

Evaluation. Practical Evaluation Michael Quinn Patton.

Purpose of the Standards

Washington Accord Graduate Attributes: A Metric for the Quality of Engineering Education Worldwide Dr. Malcolm J. Reeves, FEC, FGC, P.Eng., P.Geo. Chair.

CURRENT PROPOSALS FOR FURTHER INTRODUCTION OF DISPUTE BOARDS WITHIN THE CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY IN ROMANIA.

Internal Auditing and Outsourcing

© OECD A joint initiative of the OECD and the European Union, principally financed by the EU Martin Oder, LL.M. The Emerging Role of the Competitive Dialogue.

John Molson School of Business... the future. EIDMC Entrepreneurship Institute for the Development of Minority Communities.

Adviser, Ministry for State Reform, Lebanon

1 Algemene Rekenkamer | Postbus | 2500 EA Den Haag Audit of Public Private Partnerships Introduction and international Experiences Freek Hoek, Netherlands.

Professional Certificate – Managing Public Accounts Committees Ian “Ren” Rennie.

Information Seminar on the Framework for Public Private Partnerships in Ireland Alexander Hotel, Dublin 3 rd June 2003.

James Aiello PricewaterhouseCoopers Africa Utility Week 06 International Good Practice in Procurement.

BSBPMG404A Apply Quality Management Techniques Apply Quality Management Techniques Unit Guide C ertificate IV in Project Management Qualification.

Rome Energy Meeting 2008 Rome, November 2008 Investments Opportunities and Project Finance in the Energy Market Luigi Marsullo President Finpublic.

The European standards and guidelines for quality assurance Séamus Puirséil, Vice – President, ENQA.

Assessment on the implementation of the Mediterranean Strategy for Sustainable Development Dr Nicola Cantore Overseas Development Institute,

1 Developing and Structuring PPP projects in Lithuania 2006/11/22.

Wearing their shoes How to understand and influence Public Sector Commissioners - Find out what really makes them tick Mark Algar, Owner 60sticks Ltd.

Principles of Local Governance: Covering local governmental legislations and compliance issues IMFO WOMEN IN LOCAL GOVERNMENT FINANCE CONFERENCE 07/02/13.

March 26-28, 2013 SINGAPORE CDIO Asian Regional Meeting and Workshop on Engineering Education and Policies for Regional Leaders Programme Evaluation (CDIO.

BSBPMG405A Apply Human Resource Management Approaches Apply Human Resource Management Approaches Unit Guide C ertificate IV in Project Management

BSBPMG505A Manage Project Quality Manage Project Quality Unit Guide Diploma of Project Management Qualification Code BSB51507 Unit Code BSBPMG505A.

© OECD A joint initiative of the OECD and the European Union, principally financed by the EU Ensuring Good Quality PPP Projects Martin Darcy United Kingdom.

Promoting Partnerships between Public and Private EPEC PRIVATE SECTOR FORUM Jean-Claude Banon Chairman of BUSINESSEUROPE’s Services of General Economic.

1 Key elements of a good project ECVET contact seminar October 2010 Brussels LEONARDO DA VINCI.

Getting There from Here: Creating an Evidence- Based Culture Within Special Education Ronnie Detrich Randy Keyworth Jack States.

Professional Certificate in Electoral Processes Understanding and Demonstrating Assessment Criteria Facilitator: Tony Cash.

 PPP for Infrastructure Financing in the MENA region Istanbul, November 8, 2006 PPP P ublic P rivate P artnerships * Nuran Durmaz *connectedthinking.

Writing Policy for SBDM Councils. Goals of this Session provide an overview of Senate Bill 1 requirements related to writing provide guidance in reviewing.

MARY-ALICE PATON Partner Network of Procurement Professionals Procuring Locally: Supplier Relationships, the Law and Tensions.

PPP Legal & Regulatory Framework. PPP Policy In July 2008 GOK approved the PPP policy directive through which: PPPs are identified as a method for investing.

Arts in Education: The intersection of advocacy, research, policy, and practice March/April, 2008 S301.

1 Assessing quality in systematic reviews of the effectiveness of health promotion and public health (HP/PH): Areas of consensus and dissension Dr Jonathan.

BSBPMG501A Manage Application of Project Integrative Processes Manage Project Integrative Processes Unit Guide Diploma of Project Management Qualification.

Ruth Martin The SII Perspective on T&C Development Developments APCIMS Conference 26 th June 2008.

Fundamentals of Governance: Parliament and Government Understanding and Demonstrating Assessment Criteria Facilitator: Tony Cash.

Search Engine Optimization © HiTech Institute. All rights reserved. Slide 1 Click to edit Master title style What is Business Analysis Body of Knowledge?

Helping Teachers Help All Students: The Imperative for High-Quality Professional Development Report of the Maryland Teacher Professional Development Advisory.

Presentation to the Joint Oireachtas Committee on Transport Assessment, Approval, Public Sector Benchmark and Procurement of PPPs 23rd September 2003.

Planning Instruction A Review of the Cognitive Domain and Performance Objectives.

Council of Europe Child Participation Assessment Tool Agnes von Maravic Children’s Rights Division Council of Europe Based on slides prepared by Gerison.

Advocacy Activity of the Eastern Partnership Territorial Cooperation Support Programme November 5, 2014 Tbilisi, Georgia Lyubov Palyvoda, Advocacy Expert.

BIMILACI 2007 Partners for Quality Infrastructure: The FIDIC Vision Washington, May 10, 2007 Dr. Jorge Díaz Padilla FIDIC President.

Technology Services – National Institute of Standards and Technology Conformity Assessment ANSI-HSSP Workshop Emergency Communications December 2, 2004.

BSBPMG404A Apply Quality Management Techniques Apply Quality Management Techniques Unit Guide C ertificate IV in Project Management Qualification.

Dr Ama Eyo Lecturer and Public Procurement Specialist Institute for Competition and Procurement Studies, Bangor University, North.

GUIDELINES Evaluation of National Rural Networks

P3 EVIDENCE PROJECT Jonathan L. Gifford George Mason University

P3 EVIDENCE PROJECT Jonathan L. Gifford George Mason University

Which type of claim does this represent?

Which type of claim does this represent?

Council of Europe Child Participation Assessment Tool

Business Relationship Management

A Framework for the Governance of Infrastructure - Getting Infrastructure Right - Jungmin Park, OECD Budgeting & Public Expenditures Division 2019 Annual.

SECURITY AND RISK MANAGEMENT CONSULTANT

Presentation transcript:

How to Identify Best Practices Dr. Lawrence (Larry) Martin Professor of Public Affairs University of Central Florida

What is a Best Practice? Best practices research has yet to achieve consensus on what constitutes a best practice!!

What is a Best Practice? Herbert Simon’s “Satisfying” Trap 1. People (especially elected officials) look for solutions that appear to work 2. The research to support a claim of best practice is almost never done.

What is a Best Practice? The selective observation of a set of exemplars across different contexts.

What is a Best Practice? Exemplars: the “best of the best” Contexts: across multiple settings

What is a Best Practice? Hierarchy of Evidence 1.Evidence Based Practices (EBPs) 2.Best Practices (BPs) 3.Emerging Practices (EPs)

What is a Best Practice? Evidence Based Practices (EBPs): Practices supported by a substantial body of outcomes based research.

What is a Best Practice? Best Practices (BPs): Practices supported by a substantial body of research findings generally acknowledged as superior or state of the art.

What is a Best Practice? Emerging Practices EPs): Practices believed by at least some knowledgeable professionals or professional organizations to represent superior approaches.

Rules for Identifying & Reporting on Best Practices Rule 1: A definition of “best practices” should be provided

Internationally Recommended Best Practices in Transportation Financing Public-Private Partnerships (P3s) Any policy, procedure, process, or activity for infrastructure P3s in general, transportation P3s in particular or transportation financing P3s in specific that have been recommended as a standard operating practice by governments internationally or by international organizations that have studied P3s.

Rules for Identifying & Reporting on Best Practices Rule 2: The decision criterion or criteria used to determine a best practice should be made explicit

Rules for Identifying & Reporting on Best Practices Rule 3: The evidence level (EBPs, BPs, EBs) should be specified

Internationally Recommended Best Practices in Transportation Financing P3s The use of value for money (VfM) analysis is an international best practice (BP) The ex post conduct of a value for money (VfM) analysis is an emerging practice (EP)

Rules for Identifying & Reporting on Best Practices Rule 4 : Exemplars should be drawn from multiple contexts

Internationally Recommended Best Practices in Transportation Financing P3s Value for money (VfM) analysis has been adopted by : Australia Canada France South Africa Spain United Kingdom

Rules for Identifying & Reporting on Best Practices Rule 5 : When exemplars have major sub- components, they should be identified

Major Sub-Components: Internationally Recommended Best Practices in Transportation Financing P3s 1.Size & Complexity 2.Structured Process 3.Stakeholder Consultation & Support 4.Creation of Dedicated P3 Units 5.Risk Assessment & Allocation 6.Value for Money (VfM) analysis 7.Special Purpose Vehicle 8.Project Financing 9.Procurement 10.Contracting

Communicating Best Practices To Policy Makers & Stakeholders Define best practice Specify the criterion/criteria used Explain the evidence level (EBPs, BPs, EPs) Identify any sub-components Use examples from multiple contexts Make limitations explicit