Sustainability Metrics

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Monitoring the Transition Towards a Green Economy
Advertisements

Ralf Becker United Nations Statistics Division
European Economic and Social Council Brussels, 26 January 2012 Martine Durand OECD Chief Statistician and Director of Statistics Measuring well-being and.
European State of the Environment and Outlook Report 2010 – Part C Barbara Clark – SOER Part C Team Coordinator.
Developing ESD: what role for indicators? William Scott Centre for Research in Education and the Environment University of Bath
– European-level thematic State of Environment (SOE) information
Ecological Economics Lecture 08 Rui Mota Researcher Tiago Domingos Assistant Professor Environment and Energy Section Department of Mechanical Engineering.
Progress, Well-Being and Sustainable Development Results of the ESS Sponsorship Group S June 2012, Paris Walter Radermacher, Eurostat.
Environment and Sustainable Development René Kemp UNU-MERIT Phd Programme Innovation Studies and Development ( )
Towards an integrated South African Green Economy Model (SAGEM)
Enhancing Data Quality of Distributive Trade Statistics Workshop for African countries on the Implementation of International Recommendations for Distributive.
UNSD Energy-related indicators to inform on Green Growth issues.
World Geography 3202 Development Indicators. Gross National Product (GNP) GNP- Refers to the total value of all goods and services produced by a country.
Functionalities of indicators and role of context Robert Joumard & Henrik Gudmundsson 1. Definition of an ‘indicator’ 2. Characteristics of indicators.
An Empirical Environmental Sustainability Index derived solely from Nighttime Satellite Imagery and Ecosystem Service Valuation Paul Sutton
Communication on "Land as a Resource" Jacques DELSALLE Head of sector Land & Soil European Commission, DG Environment FoEE Conference "Putting resource.
1 WORKSHOP ON THE PREPARATION OF THE FOURTH NATIONAL COMMUNICATION FROM ANNEX I PARTIES Dublin, 30 September – 1 October 2004 National circumstances in.
Concept of Development
Working Party on Transport Trends and Economics, 21 st session Geneva, 9-10 September 2008 Supply chain challenges for transport.
SEEA Experimental Ecosystem Accounts: A Proposed Outline and Road Map Sixth Meeting of the UN Committee of Experts on Environmental-Economic Accounting.
RSBM Business School Research in the real world: the users dilemma Dr Gill Green.
RESOURCE EFFICIENCY IN LATIN AMERICA: ECONOMICS AND OUTLOOK 1.
Performance Measurement and Analysis for Health Organizations
Dutch Enviromental Accounts and policy demands Geert Bruinooge Deputy Director General Statistics Netherlands.
ECONOMIC CONVERGENCE OF BALKAN REGION TO EUROPEAN UNION
 The number of people (organisms) that can be supported by a given ecosystem, based on their consumption of natural resources.  Each species has requirements.
Australian Government Economic Goals. Economic Goals 1.The goal of strong and sustainable economic growth 2.The goal of low inflation 3.The goal of full.
Human development concept and index The practical application in regional context.
Institutionalizing Sustainability Performance Metrics Smart & Sustainable Campuses Conference 2013 Presented by Keri Enright-Kato Yale Office of Sustainability.
RESOURCE EFFICIENCY IN LATIN AMERICA: ECONOMICS AND OUTLOOK 1.
ESPON 2013 Programme Internal Seminar Evidence-based Cohesion Policy: Territorial Dimensions Kraków, Poland ESPON EU-LUPA.
Additional Measures of Progress for Scotland? Dr Karen Turner Senior Lecturer, Department of Economics and Fraser of Allander Institute University of Strathclyde.
ECON 3508 Human Development: Concepts and Measurement A. R. M. Ritter September 2007.
1 Two points 1.From local to global consumer – the challenge of rising and unsustainable consumption 2.What can we do to reach sustainable consumption.
Accounting for Sustainability Kirk Hamilton Environment Department The World Bank.
Sustainability Metrics  Lecture 1-Weak Sustainability Metrics Dr Bernadette O’Regan  Lecture 2-Strong Sustainability Metrics Prof Richard Moles  Lecture.
Sustainable Development, Energy and Environment Lecture 05 Paulo Ferrão Full Professor Tiago Domingos Assistant Professor Rui Mota Researcher IN+, Centre.
DEFINING AND MEASURING METRO REGIONS FOR INTERNATIONAL COMPARISONS Monica Brezzi, OECD IAOS/SCORUS Conference Santiago, Chile 20 October 2010.
The Development of Regional Hybrid Environment Accounts Tsunenori Ashiya Data & Analysis division, Policy Planning &
1 st INFASA Symposium and Workshop Synthesis March 16 and 17, 2006 Bern, Switzerland As presented at the Symposium and Workshop by Dr. Fritz Häni, SHL.
Goals and Indicators. Sustainable Measures Goals, Principles, Criteria, and Indicators  Goal – a description of future condition community members wish.
Presented by: Edoardo Pizzoli - HANDBOOK ON RURAL HOUSEHOLD, LIVELIHOOD AND WELL-BEING: STATISTICS ON RURAL DEVELOPMENT AND AGRICULTURE HOUSEHOLD INCOME.
Practical Experience with Small-scale Projects: Issues and Suggestions Johannes Heister, Lasse Ringius Carbon Finance Unit, World Bank Bonn, 9-10 March.
TOWARDS THE EVALUATION OF THE SUSTAINABILITY OF A REGION, TAKING DIFFERENT SUSTAINABILITY CRITERIA INTO ACCOUNT. Bàrbara Sureda J.J. de Felipe Josep Xercavins.
The Social Report: Monitoring Social Wellbeing in New Zealand
© OECD/IEA INTERNATIONAL ENERGY AGENCY Worldwide Trends in Energy Use and Efficiency Key Insights from IEA Indicator Analysis ENERGY INDICATORS.
Agricultural and environmental indicators and models por Rubén De la Sierra Rosario Peyrot.
Productivity Micro-economic Analysis Division 1 Productivity Micro-economic Analysis Division Statistics Canada January 2008.
Measuring Progress towards Green Growth through indicators OECD work UNCEEA Sixth meeting New York, June 2011.
Measuring Sustainable development: Achievements and Challenges Enrico Giovannini OECD Chief Statistician June 2005.
The Environment in Introductory Economics Three Global Development and Environment Institute textbooks: Microeconomics in Context Macroeconomics in Context.
What constitutes a fair level of effort for individual Parties? Ben Gleisner: Post-2012 Emission Reduction Targets.
African Development Bank Tunis, Tunisia March, 2011 Dr. Anthony NYONG Manager, ORQR.3 SESA Workshop AfDB’s Green Growth Strategy: What Role can SESA.
METHODS OF SPATIAL ECONOMIC ANALYSIS LECTURE 06 Δρ. Μαρί-Νοέλ Ντυκέν, Αναπληρώτρια Καθηγήτρια, Τηλ Γραφείο Γ.6 UNIVERSITY.
Green Growth in the Netherlands Sjoerd Schenau Department of National accounts Statistics Netherlands.
Sustainable Development Indicators Session Objectives: l Develop relevant SD indicators l Suggest policies to improve SD indicators.
Priorities for further development of (component accounts for) EU ecosystem accounting system Food for thought in three steps: a)Reflection on the overall.
EEA proposals for developing EU ecosystem (capital) accounts Jan-Erik Petersen 1 October 2015.
EEA priorities on circular economy Multi-annual work programme OutputsTime frame Briefing on progress towards a circular economy in EuropeAnnual.
Outlines: Basic concepts
Dr. Olivier Thunus UNECE Task Force Vice-Chair
Quality criteria for official statistics
The concept and approach of European Quality of Life survey
Sustainable Development reporting and the SEEA
Eurostat Working Group Regional Statistics
Expert Group on Quality of Life Indicators
GDP and beyond Robin Lynch
In the Eastern Partnership Index
GDP and beyond Robin Lynch
LAUNCHING THE 2019 REGIONAL COMPETITIVENESS INDEX RCI 2019
Presentation transcript:

Sustainability Metrics Lecture 1-Weak Sustainability Metrics Dr Bernadette O’Regan Lecture 2-Can we decouple growth or development from environmental impact? Dr Bernadette O’Regan Lecture 3-Strong Sustainability Metrics Prof Richard Moles Reading: http://www.epa.ie/downloads/pubs/other/indicators/irlenv/ http://www.foeeurope.org/publications/2009/seri_foee_measuring_eu_resource_use_final.pdf http://www.eea.europa.eu/publications/signals-2009 http://www.eea.europa.eu/publications/signals-2010 http://www.oecd.org/sustainabledevelopment http://www.oecd.org/progress

Weak Vs Strong Sustainability The meaning of sustainability is the subject of intense debate among environmental and resource economists. The debate currently focuses on the substitutability between the economy and the environment or between “natural capital” and “man-made capital”-- a debate captured in terms of “weak” vs. “strong” sustainability. “Weak” sustainability, based on the work of neoclassical economists Robert Solow and John Hartwick, suggest that sustainability is based on the aggregate stock of man-made and natural capital, i.e. that there is a certain amount of substitutability between man-made and natural capital. Proponents of “strong” sustainability insist that natural capital cannot be substituted with other forms of capital. Sustainability Indicators are measures of “weak” sustainability as socio-economic issues are included. Ecological Footprints are measures of “strong” sustainability as they only include environmental parameters.

Why we need to measure sustainability General agreement now that we need to manage for a more sustainable development…whatever definition is used. Sustainability being included as policy at most levels nationally, at EU level and globally. Cannot manage what we cannot measure, therefore need to measure and monitor sustainability performance. Need to be able to benchmark progress, identify which policies and actions have been successful. Policy-makers need justification especially if something new is proposed and this justification must be documented and come from a trustworthy source.

Why we need to measure sustainability Policy-makers will be more likely to create achievable policies if they understand the importance of interactions between the environment or society and the implications of choosing one objective over another. However, policy-makers often require ‘one number’ and this is problematic as it leads to oversimplification…and benchmarking against what has happened elsewhere is important for justification. Many variables in sustainability, these often have complex interactions. Difficult/impossible and very expensive to measure everything. Therefore need to use indicators Aggregated Indices

What are Indicators? Indicators are pieces of information which simplify complex phenomena and highlight the trends of system functioning, through summarising or typifying the characteristics of particular systems. Sustainability indicators aim at monitoring key aspects of the interactions between society and nature, to generate information regarding current state and underlying causes. In order to achieve sustainability, it is necessary to have appropriate performance indicators of the economy and natural systems that give us appropriate information about the status of those systems. Indicators are useful tools to communicate simplified, concise and scientifically credible information on problems of sustainable development, which are too complex to measure directly.

Functions and Advantages of Indicators The three basic functions of indicators are simplification, quantification and communication. By translating the concept of sustainable development into numerical terms which are simple to understand, indicators can be used to raise environmental awareness among the public, as well as to strengthen public support for policy measures. Sustainability indicators differ from classical indicators; they do not simply reflect environmental conditions or pressures on the environment, but indicate interactive characteristics between socioeconomic and ecological systems. Indicators can chart and track progress towards or away from sustainable development. See OECD Factbook 2009

Identifying the Right Indicators Criteria for selection of indicators: Data for indicator development should be readily available. Indicator should be easy to understand and communicate. Indicators should relate to data that can be measured. Indicators should be specific and appropriate, illustrating key aspects of relevant issues. There should be a short time-lag between aspects being measured and presentation of developed indicators referring to these, to enable indicators to be used for effective policy-making. Indicators should be based on information that can be used to compare what happens at different times, developments and geographical areas. Indicators should facilitate international comparisons.

Hierarchy of Information It is important to distinguish indicators from measurements or statistics. Although indicators rely on measurements and statistics as a starting point, comprehensive indicators contain measurements, trends in measurements over time, roles and contributions of various stakeholders and specific targets. Although primary data are the basis for analysis, raw data are seldom meaningful to the general public, policy-makers or even scientists themselves, meaning usually emerges through further analysis. Indicators therefore, are interpretations of reality, providing a quantitative account of a complex situation or process.

Examples of Sustainability Indicators Environment: Per Capita Waste Volume, %Sewerage Connection, Transport CO2 Emissions, Electricity CO2 Emissions, Level of Wastewater Treatment, % Recycling, %Green Energy Interest. Socio-economic: Population Density, Annual Income, %Households in Social Housing, %Primary Education as Highest Level, %Cert./Dipl. as Highest Level. Quality of Life: Distance to Nearest Hospital (Km), %45+ Hours Employment, GPs per 1000 Population. See OECD Factbook 2009 http://www.sustainabilitya-test.net/

Increasing Aggregation International Level Policy Aggregated Metrics National Level Policy Component Metrics Regional Level Policy Indicators Local Level Policy UN Human Development Index (HDI); the Environmental Sustainability Index (ESI); the Environmental Performance Index (EPI); the Genuine Progress Index (GPI); and Green GDP.

Problems with Aggregation Detail can be lost Resultant policies may not be specific enough to achieve goals Can be misleading and result in bad policies