I N S T I T U T F Ü R S O Z I O Ö K O N O M I K D E R F O R S T - U N D H O L Z W I R T S C H A F T Karl Hogl, September 2003 National Forest Programmes.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Frame Strategy. The overall objective of the Barents strategy is to generate economic growth and social development by a knowledge driven and sustainable.
Advertisements

DECENTRALIZATION AND FINANCING OF SERVICES Gordana Matković Sofia, July 2007.
The territorial implications of demographic change in the North Sea Region – scope for a transnational planning approach? Stefanie Dühr, Radboud University.
1 Lessons learned – success factors for biodiversity projects Peter Tramberend Environment Agency Austria.
Linking research to policy in Vietnam: how can complexity concepts help?
Procedural justice and a constructive approach to negotiating with stakeholders Jill Howieson.
Future Earth: Research for global sustainability in Asia
Compensation Strategy Extent of Pay for Performance –type of performance rewarded –individuals vs groups Market comparisons –Who is the reference group?
Alfons Balmann A new dimension of structural change in European agriculture.
New opportunities for regional development through cross-border cooperation Ministry of Environmental Protection and Regional Development November 16,
Changing Global Environment
Theorizing Policy Making Session 2 Asst. Prof. Dr. Alexander Bürgin.
Institutions and their role in shaping European Security
Introducing Governance.  Much used term especially ‘good governance’ and ‘democratic governance’  From Greek word kubernân = to pilot or steer  Originally.
Financially sustainable universities through full costing and income diversification Thomas Estermann Head of Unit Governance, Autonomy and Funding EUA.
INTERREG IIIB North Sea Northern Periphery. INTERREG IIIB North Sea Northern Periphery Vision The Northern Maritime Corridor - a means of efficient, safe.
STAGES OF THE POLICY PROCESS
UNDERSTANDING BUSINESS ORGANISATIONS WITH REFERENCE TO MANAGEMENT THEORIES Topic 2.2: (HSC topic 1) BUSINESS MANAGEMENT AND CHANGE Stage 6 Business Studies.
Copyright 2004 Prentice Hall
Research Paper 1. Hand in hard copy by 1pm on Wed. 2. copy of paper to 3. Submit copy to Turn It In (see Research Paper.
PAD190 PRINCIPLES OF PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION
European Territorial Cooperation Sustainability Transferability Capitalisation Pietro Celotti EIPA European Instituto of Public Administration 11 December.
New ways of steering and governance in the public sector – and the impact of EU on welfare Lecture 5.
Chapter 15 Comparative International Relations. This (that is the LAST!) Week.
A project implemented by the HTSPE consortium This project is funded by the European Union SUSTAINABLE GROWTH LIFE
Focus Groups, Citizens’ Juries and Open Space method: Innovative tools of public involvement in water management Kati Kangur Peipsi Center for Transboundary.
I N S T I T U T E O F F O R E S T S E C T O R P O L I C Y A N D E C O N O M I C S Peter Glück University of Natural Resources and Applied Life Sciences,
International Business 9e By Charles W.L. Hill McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2013 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Return to Literature on Third Sector Research Return to Literature on Third Sector Research Return to Literature on Third Sector Research Return to Literature.
Technology preparation and conclusion of foreign trade turnover. Selection of the foreign partner..
FIVE CONFLICT MODES The Thomas-Kilmann Conflict Mode Instrument*
Modeling Market Failure Chapter 3 © 2004 Thomson Learning/South-Western.
CONFERENCE COMPETITION POLICY IN TWO-SIDED MARKETS University of Toulouse June 30 Dr Valérie RABASSA* EUROPEAN COMMISSION DG COMPETITION CHIEF ECONOMIST.
European Union Public Policy Professor John Wilton Lecture 4 Policy formulation 1: the policy communities and policy networks models.
Connecting European Chambers: 26th March 2015 KNOWLEDGE ALLIANCES SECTOR SKILLS ALLIANCES A PRIORITY FOR CHAMBERS.
Negotiation and Mediation Presented by Ms. Asha Menon Additional District Judge & Member Secretary, Delhi Legal Services Authority Business Session –II.
Glasgow, 17 May 2012 Mike Coles Developments in the validation of learning in the EU.
The Market Economy Process of voluntary exchange Specialization
Good Enough Governance Revisited Summary of Merilee Grindle’s contribution to the Governance TSP review. Africa Governance Retreat May 2005.
Stakeholders
Organisational culture, leadership and knowledge management
Focus on Governance and territorial achievements in Leader Plus period European Commission Évora, Portugal, 2007 Jela Tvrdonova.
/13_2 APRIS-ASEAN Workshop Singapore 1 ASEAN Regional Workshop on Standards in Services Strategic Development of Service Standards Horizontal.
Contemporary Tourism Governing the Contemporary Tourism Product © Chris Cooper & C M Hall 2016 Contemporary Tourism 3e, Goodfellow Publishers Ltd.
1 SOCIAL DIALOGUE IN THE IT SECTOR 2 SOCIAL PARTNERSHIP People and organizations from some combination of public, business, and civil constituencies.
Evidence of Quality and Equity in Education Péter Radó Belgrade,
Motivating and Managing People and Groups in Business Organizations © 2007 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., All Rights Reserved. McGraw-Hill/Irwin Introduction.
International Network Of Basin Organizations topic 3.1: “Basin Management and Transboundary Cooperation”. Operational tools  Long term basin management.
STROI network – project presentation. Discussion seminar February Results for the P5: Customer Orientation and Marketing Olga Tretyak, Marina.
IR306 FOREIGN POLICY ANALYSIS INTERDEPENDENCE IN INTERNATIONAL SYSTEM - LIBERALISM.
Conflict, Power, and Politics
POSITIVE ENGAGAMENT AS A PATH TOWARD PEACEBUILDING: NORTH KOREA CASE.
Summary of Learning Objectives
International Business 9e
Svein Olav Nås Special advisor, Division for innovation
International Business 9e
European Union Public Policy Professor John Wilton Lecture 5 Policy formulation 1: the policy communities and policy networks models.
Theorizing Policy Making
Kari Kiesiläinen Heikki Liljeroos
The Policy Process: Policy networks and coordination
Consultation & Participation
Regions for Economic change
ENI CBC Joint Operational Programme Black Sea Basin
Foreign Direct Investment
Financing Natura 2000 Success factors
The Policy Process: Policy networks and coordination
Professor (ret.), PhD, Stockholm University/ Resilience Center
Project DIRECT Final Summary
International Business 9e
International Business 9e By Charles W.L. Hill McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2013 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Presentation transcript:

I N S T I T U T F Ü R S O Z I O Ö K O N O M I K D E R F O R S T - U N D H O L Z W I R T S C H A F T Karl Hogl, September 2003 National Forest Programmes Opportunities and limits of co-ordination in policy networks Karl Hogl Forest Tourism Industry Environment

I N S T I T U T F Ü R S O Z I O Ö K O N O M I K D E R F O R S T - U N D H O L Z W I R T S C H A F T Karl Hogl, September 2003 Demands, Problems and Approach Demands: Demands: National Forest Programmes shall... --> co-ordinate several levels of governance, --> co-ordinate all relevant sectors, --> involve private actors, --> proceed iterative, adaptive, long term Problem: Problem: Decision systems comprising many interdependent actors and arenas tend towards deadlock Question: Question:Approaches to co-ordinate –> Strengths / Weaknesses

I N S T I T U T F Ü R S O Z I O Ö K O N O M I K D E R F O R S T - U N D H O L Z W I R T S C H A F T Karl Hogl, September 2003 Outline Theory, empirical evidence Meaning of „C-ordination“ Co-ordination by hierarchy Co-ordination through negotiations Opportunities and Limits of Co-ordination in actor networks

I N S T I T U T F Ü R S O Z I O Ö K O N O M I K D E R F O R S T - U N D H O L Z W I R T S C H A F T Karl Hogl, September 2003 Theoretical Approach Theories Approaches of multi-level governance Joint-Decision Theory („joint-decision trap“; F. W. Scharpf) Generally, approaches about (policy-)co-ordination (e.g. negotiations-, administrations-, and organisation theories)

I N S T I T U T F Ü R S O Z I O Ö K O N O M I K D E R F O R S T - U N D H O L Z W I R T S C H A F T Karl Hogl, September 2003 Empirical Approach Empirical evidence Own research and cases from literature NFP processes in European countries / regions; reports to this action EU policies, in particular regional policy and rural development policy

I N S T I T U T F Ü R S O Z I O Ö K O N O M I K D E R F O R S T - U N D H O L Z W I R T S C H A F T Karl Hogl, September 2003 The meaning of „co-ordination“ Redundancy Incoherence, contradictory policies Policy gaps Forest Tourism Industry Environment Forest Environment Tourism Industry Co-ordination State / degree of c-ordination: Co-ordination as a process: Co-ordination as a process: sectors, time frame, stages,...

I N S T I T U T F Ü R S O Z I O Ö K O N O M I K D E R F O R S T - U N D H O L Z W I R T S C H A F T Karl Hogl, September 2003 How to co-ordinate ? (markets) hierarchy negotiations Basically by

I N S T I T U T F Ü R S O Z I O Ö K O N O M I K D E R F O R S T - U N D H O L Z W I R T S C H A F T Karl Hogl, September 2003 Hierarchy Co-ordination by Hierarchy Motivational problem (“misuse of power”) Informational problem  Risk: decision do not meet the problems  Limited range of coverage, in particular in case of complex problems that effect many different domains within hierarchical structures

I N S T I T U T F Ü R S O Z I O Ö K O N O M I K D E R F O R S T - U N D H O L Z W I R T S C H A F T Karl Hogl, September 2003 Negotiations Co-ordination through negotiation If Side payments are allowed And transaction costs are ignored  Egoistic rational actors exploit the potential welfare gains BUT:multi level problems / “joint-decision trap” “negotiators’ dilemma” “problem of high numbers”

I N S T I T U T F Ü R S O Z I O Ö K O N O M I K D E R F O R S T - U N D H O L Z W I R T S C H A F T Karl Hogl, September 2003 Negotiations Negotiators’ dilemma Actors shall at the same time a) Find the best common solutions b) and solve distributional problems a) and b) evoke incompatible actor orientations (co-operative vs. competitive).  blockade + Problem of high numbers --> co-ordination through negotiations has narrow limits!

I N S T I T U T F Ü R S O Z I O Ö K O N O M I K D E R F O R S T - U N D H O L Z W I R T S C H A F T Karl Hogl, September 2003 Negotiations Solutions suggested by theory and political practice: a) negotiations embedded in hierarchies b) negotiations in actor networks a)Negotiations in the „Shadow of Hierarchy“ In principle, decisions would be finally taken by a superior entity Archetypes of interaction “negative” co-ordination “positive” co-ordination

I N S T I T U T F Ü R S O Z I O Ö K O N O M I K D E R F O R S T - U N D H O L Z W I R T S C H A F T Karl Hogl, September 2003 Negotiations MoF MoZ MoY MoX NGO c NGO b NGO a MoF MoZ MoY MoX NGO c NGO b NGO a positive co-ordinationnegative co-oordination central actor; low density; bilateral; -> Pareto Criterion; cumulation of veto positions „more co-operation“, high density, multilateral, -> Kaldor Criterion; narrow limits as regards # of actors

I N S T I T U T F Ü R S O Z I O Ö K O N O M I K D E R F O R S T - U N D H O L Z W I R T S C H A F T Karl Hogl, September 2003 Negotiations b) Negotiations in actor networks Governance theory Co-operation in actor networks as a certain kind of co-ordination Networks Medium degree of coupling Mutually dependent stability over time Regularly exchange

I N S T I T U T F Ü R S O Z I O Ö K O N O M I K D E R F O R S T - U N D H O L Z W I R T S C H A F T Karl Hogl, September 2003 Negotiations b) Negotiations in actor networks within stable actor networks voluntary co-operation becomes rational („shadow of the future“) Advantages of co-operation in actor networks Mutual trust can develop High density of information flow, good access to information --> mutual learning

I N S T I T U T F Ü R S O Z I O Ö K O N O M I K D E R F O R S T - U N D H O L Z W I R T S C H A F T Karl Hogl, September 2003 Co-operation in networks Preconditions depends on the kind and the number of topics common motive / problem reference “favourable” topics at the start with Number of topics (broad or narrow)

I N S T I T U T F Ü R S O Z I O Ö K O N O M I K D E R F O R S T - U N D H O L Z W I R T S C H A F T Karl Hogl, September 2003 Preconditions Arena and sufficient opportunities for interaction Hardly occurs without „external“ incentives “weight” only if relevant actors participate legitimation needed Co-operation in networks

I N S T I T U T F Ü R S O Z I O Ö K O N O M I K D E R F O R S T - U N D H O L Z W I R T S C H A F T Karl Hogl, September 2003 Weaknesses participation voluntary --> only if potential gains outweigh losses Costs are clear soon, benefits often arguable Fear for loosing autonomy and influence need to compromise --> tendency towards symbolic results --> conflicts adjourned Co-operation in networks

I N S T I T U T F Ü R S O Z I O Ö K O N O M I K D E R F O R S T - U N D H O L Z W I R T S C H A F T Karl Hogl, September 2003 A Actor A Actor B Status Quo Kaldor- Criterion Pareto- Criterion A B C E D