Membership Voting Rights. Executive Council is an elected body Members are expected to vote and elect EC members. Currently APNIC follows proportional.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

ASO Address Council NRO Number Council LACNIC VIII Lima/Perú, Junho 2005 Hartmut Glaser – AC Co Chair

Advertisements

Axel Pawlik. 4 th ASO GA Meeting, 24 April 2003, Santiago. Open Policy Process in the RIPE Region Axel Pawlik RIPE NCC.

ICANN ASO Address Council LACNIC III Mexico City, November 2002.

Address Council Operations Santiago, Chile – April 2003.

APNIC Executive Council Report to APNIC Members Meeting March 2002.

APNIC Executive Committee Report to APNIC Members Meeting August 2001.

A S I A P A C I F I C N E T W O R K I N F O R M A T I O N C E N T R E APNIC Work Plan 2000 APNIC Annual Member Meeting Seoul, 3 March 2000.

A S I A P A C I F I C N E T W O R K I N F O R M A T I O N C E N T R E APNIC Member Meeting Taipei, 31 August 2001.

NIR SIG Update – APNIC22 7th Sep 2006, Kaohsiung Chairs: David Chen Izumi Okutani.

A S I A P A C I F I C N E T W O R K I N F O R M A T I O N C E N T R E APNIC Members Meeting 27 October 2000 Brisbane, Australia.

A Proposal for a Revised Policy Development Process (prop-001-v001) APNIC16 – Address Policy SIG Seoul, Korea 20 August 2003.

Vincent Ngundi Interim AfriNIC PDP-MG Co-chair

1 Standards Development: An Overview Discovery to Delivery Topic Committee Meeting October 30, 2007 Karen A. Wetzel NISO Standards Program Manager

Model No ACM Bylaws changed; use existing authority of ACM EC SGB policy on when SGB EC will recommend a by-laws change to ACM EC without membership vote.

Parliamentary Procedure: An Overview. History of Parliamentary Procedure Parliamentary Procedure arose from the early days of English Parliamentary Law.

ARIN Advisory Council ARIN 32 October 10-11, 2013 Phoenix.

Doc.: IEEE 802 EC Submission July 2014 Adrian Stephens, Intel CorporationSlide 1 Formalizing the Wireless Chair’s Meeting Date: xx Authors:

1 APNIC Executive Council Report APNIC 30 Meeting Gold Coast 27 August 2010.

APNIC Executive Council (EC) Election 1. Overview About 2011 EC Election Voting entitlement Online voting On-site voting Proxy appointment Counting procedure.

1 APNIC Member Meeting NRO Number Council Election.

1 REGION E CONFERENCE Future Planning Timelines. 2 Planning Timeline – FY08 Nov 1, 2007 – Put out call for hosting interest for FY09 region conference.

October 2009North American Regional Gathering - Montreal, Canada1 WAAAUB Nominations Committee Presented by Maha Zabaneh and Dr. Tewfik Zein North American.

Change in the criteria for the recognition of NIRs in the APNIC region Prop-060-v001 Author: Kusumba Sridhar.

NAMES COUNCIL MEETINGS PROCESS AND PROCEDURAL RULES.

ARIN Advisory Council John Sweeting. 15 elected members, 3 year terms The Advisory Council.

1 Future of NamGIS Johan van Rensburg Polytech 14 October 2005.

APNIC Executive Council (EC) Election APNIC EC Election Four vacant seats on the APNIC EC –Two-year term starting from being elected on 6 March.

Update on RIPE NCC Inter- RIR Transfer proposal Adam Gosling APNIC 38 Policy SIG Meeting 18 September 2014.

APNIC Membership Fee — The History Che-Hoo CHENG APNIC 23 in Bali 1 Mar 2007.

Role of the Past President Chair the Nominations Committee Nomination/election process begins in August and concludes in October Identify and qualify potential.

NRO update Adiel Akplogan NRO Executive Council. What is the NRO? Number Resource Organization –Vehicle for RIR cooperation and representation –Lightweight,

AREA INVENTORY AND PLANNING. WHY PLAN? Planning helps us better carry the message to the addict who still suffers. If there is no planning, often a service.

ICANN ASO Address Council ICANN Rio do Janeiro, March 2003.

A S I A P A C I F I C N E T W O R K I N F O R M A T I O N C E N T R E Welcome and orientation APNIC Member Meeting 27 October 2000 Brisbane, Australia.

Election procedure for ICANN ASO Address Council in APNIC Region Sept. 5, 2002 ASO Meeting The 14th APNIC Open Policy Meeting APNIC Executive Council.

Getting Involved in the Research Data Alliance Stefanie Kethers

Working Group In-progress Report to APNIC Member Meeting (AMM) APNIC 31, Hong Kong 25 th February 2011 Naveen Tandon – Chair Shyam Nair – Co-Chair Yi Lee.

Collegiate Constitution Changes SPRING 2012 Presented by Constitutional Review Committee Members: Chelsea Rae Czechowski ’12 – Chair Brenna Toomey ’13.

A proposal to lower the IPv4 minimum allocation size and initial criteria in the AP region prop-014-v001 Policy SIG APNIC17/APRICOT 2004 Feb

EC proposal: Formation of a Cooperation SIG Akinori Maemura APNIC 38 Brisbane, Australia Tuesday, 16th September 2014.

All laws are intended to be a reflection of what the majority of Canadian society wants. These societal ideals start out as an idea. These ideas are called.

Cooperation SIG APNIC 39 Fukuoka, Japan 3 March 2015.

Proposed Motions to change R10 Bylaws Janina Mazierska 8 March 2015, Dhaka.

APNIC Fee Structure Result of fee structure vote.

A Review of Policy Development Processes in the Asia Pacific Region Address Policy SIG APNIC 15, Taipei, Taiwan 27 February 2003.

Changes from -07 to -08 ISSUE 11 (and 23): Should clarifying text indicate that the Confirmed candidates, chosen by the standard process, as opposed to.

ARIN Advisory Council ARIN XXVI October 6-8, 2010 Atlanta, GA.

Address Supporting Organization Seoul, Korea – August 2003.

ARIN Advisory Council ARIN XXIV October 21-23, 2009 Dearborn, MI.

Policy Development Processes in the APNIC Region 4 th ASO General Assembly Santiago, Chile 24 April 2003.

ICANN ASO Address Council Status Report APNIC 14, Open Policy Meeting Kitakyushu, Japan September 5 th, 2002.

SECTION BYLAWS APROVAL PROCESS Five Easy Steps. Step 1: Collect Data Obtain Template from SWE Communities Professional Section Bylaws Community Collegiate.

1 Welcome to the Policy SIG Policy SIG 1 March 2007 APNIC 23, Bali, Indonesia Kenny Huang.

BoF: Membership Changes. Proposal 1: 1 vote per member Many international organisations have one vote per member APNIC not a country, but company 1 Vote.

1 Welcome to the Policy SIG APNIC 21 Thursday 2 March 2006.

Doc.: IEEE /0592r0 Report May 2014 Adrian Stephens, Intel CorporationSlide 1 IEEE 802 Wireless Chairs – Formalization of Meeting Date:

Ealing Council Leaseholder Association AGM Introduction by the current Chair of ECLA Current ECLA Committee Members step down Pat explains that Committee.

1 Welcome to the Policy SIG 6 Sep 2006 APNIC 22, Kaohsiung, Taiwan.

Agenda item 7 Election of officers

Patient Participation Group Representative Elections

Report of Open NIR Meeting

School Council Election Process.

The LCWR Governance Model

Representative Council Conference Committee Orientation

Policy Development Processes in the APNIC Region

Santa Clara Valley Section

DNS Operations SIG APNIC , Kyoto

School Council Election Process.

ICANN ASO Address Council

ICANN ASO AC report 27 August 2010 APNIC 30, Gold Coast

Presentation transcript:

Membership Voting Rights

Executive Council is an elected body Members are expected to vote and elect EC members. Currently APNIC follows proportional voting system. Membership TierNumber of Votes Associate1 Very small2 Small4 Medium8 Large16 Very Large32 Extra Large64

A new proposal on membership voting strengths was proposed by the proposer, Pavan Duggal. – Proposed during APNIC 30, Gold Coast. – Problem sited A large section of the membership community are being rundown due to proportional voting system. – Proposal to introduce equal voting rights for all members in APNIC. One member one vote system. A member can cast votes equal to number of posts.

A recommendation to form a WG was made by members. Desi Valli & Dr. Kenny Huang were made as co-chairs of the WG – Objective - To discuss possible changes to APNIC membership voting rights and report back. – Number of members – 67 – Number of postings online – 225 (approx) – Number of active participants – 27* – In progress report was produced to members during APNIC 31

Members were called for a meeting at APNIC venue 32. – Around members participated – Resignation of Dr. Kenny Huang was announced. – Skeeve Stevens was nominated as the new cochair. – Members who oppose, support and also those who wanted to propose new formats were asked to deliberate their views.

Members have expressed that the issues in the current system are not explicit. It is deliberated that the issues be derived out of a detailed analysis on the past & future of APNIC and Internet. There are views that the proposal may not be good enough to fix the issues that may prevail now. There were debates about the implications on NIR, and so the voting strengths of the members of NIR. Given the datum it is debated that the change in voting system will not shift the balance of regions, hence it is pondered that the change is not required. It is also been referred that the counterparts like ARIN, RIPE NCC follow the proposed method. It is viewed that the voting be restricted only through online methods, as it will eliminate cartelisation.

Three new proposals are posted – Recommending to maintain the status-quo. – A Nominations Committee be created to put forward suitably Qualified candidates for the various EC positions. Each APNIC member be provided with at most two votes in each election. – One vote if they are an APNIC member; and – One additional vote if they hold APNIC or NIR resources. – Voting strengths shall be changed from 1 to 64 votes, to 1 to 4.

There is a general agreement that there is a need for more analysis on the existing system and the issues that prevail for various sections. Also there is an agreement that there is a need for more ideas & more thoughts. More options shall be deliberated among members so that a model can be built after understanding the demerits and merits.

A member has asked for a data that provides a census report on any of the past elections that helps to gather the information regarding participating tiers, by the secretariat. The current member data on various tiers of every economy, by the secretariat. The same be made available for better analysis of the problems.

Finally; As expressed please post more ideas, thoughts & views to help the WG to make the recommendations. The details of the Working Group & the archives of the discussion can be found here… – discussions/sigs/wgs discussions/sigs/wgs