Evaluation of the New Rural Cooperative Medical Scheme Outpatient Capitation Payment Reform in Qianjiang District of Chongqing, China Qu, Qian (1);  Sun,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Partnerships for Health Reform Utilization and Expenditures on Outpatient Health Care by HIV Positive Individuals in Rwanda PHR Rwanda - Abt Associates.
Advertisements

Accra, Ghana October 19-23, Extending Health Insurance: How to Make It Work DESIGN ELEMENT 8: M&E OF HEALTH INSURANCE SCHEMES - China Case October.
The Impact of Drug Benefit Caps Geoffrey Joyce, PhD.
The Economic Crisis: The Toll on the Patients and Communities Hospitals Serve April 27, 2009.
TABLE OF CONTENTS CHAPTER 4.0: Trends in Hospital Financing Chart 4.1: Percentage of Hospitals with Negative Total Margins, 1981 – 2006 Chart 4.2: Aggregate.
THE COMMONWEALTH FUND Figure 1. Health Insurance Coverage and Uninsured Trends Data: Analysis of the U.S. Census Bureau, Current Population Survey Annual.
Update on Recent Health Reform Activities in Minnesota.
NH Insurance Department NH Research and Evaluation Group October 21, 2013 Tyler Brannen Health Policy Analyst.
HOW THE NON-STATE SECTOR ENGAGE TO STEWARDSHIP OF MIXED SYSTEM IN IN VIETNAM Health Strategy and Policy Institute - Vietnam.
IMPLEMENTATION OF HOSPITAL AUTONOMY: VIETNAM EXPERIENCES Health Strategy and Policy Institute - Vietnam.
Chapter_12.indd 13/17/11 5:16 PM. Chapter_12.indd 23/17/11 5:16 PM.
Chapter_15.indd 13/17/11 5:25 PM. Chapter_15.indd 23/17/11 5:25 PM.
Chapter_11.indd 13/17/11 5:11 PM. Chapter_11.indd 23/17/11 5:11 PM.
Chapter_3.indd 13/17/11 4:30 PM. Chapter_3.indd 23/17/11 4:30 PM.
Community Medic Initiative. Community Medic Fulfilling our mission statement: DGEMS provides for the health and well-being of our communities with a team.
REACH Healthcare Foundation Prepared by Mid-America Regional Council 2013 Kansas City Regional Health Assessment.
CAMBODIAN COUNTRY PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION Towards consolidating the existing social health protection schemes in Cambodia: assessment of best practices.
Brief Introduction of Community Healthcare Reform in China Shanlian Hu. MD. MSc. Professor School of Public Health Fudan University June 5, 2009 Shanghai.
THE IRRATIONAL USE OF DRUGS IN RURAL CHINA: EVIDENCES FROM TWO PROVINCES Qiang SUN, Jia YIN, Genyong ZUO, Qingyue MENG Center for Health Management & Policy,
THE INAPPROPRIATE SALE OF MEDICATION FOR PEDIATRIC USE IN SIEM REAP PROVINCE, KINGDOM OF CAMBODIA AUTHORS: Sothearith Tiv Ph., Rathi Guhadasan MBBS MRCP.
CapitationCapitation. Determination of Premium Rates Benefit Payments –Paid to providers Risk Premiums –Profit earned by payer as a function of accepting.
ECONOMIC ASSESSMENT OF IMPLEMENTATION TREATMENT GUIDELINES OF HYPERTENSION IN OUT-PATIENT PRACTICE Kulmagambetov IR Karaganda State Medical Academy, Kazakhstan.
TRAINING FOR ANTIMICROBIAL STEWARDSHIP PROGRAMMES IN HOSPITALS JUNE 2014.
Health Care Delivery and Referral System in Thailand
Improving Access to ACTs Through Licensed Chemical Sellers in Ghana David Ofori-Adjei 1, Sylvester Segbaya 2, Kwadwo Koram 1, Kwame Adogboba 3, and Nana.
Trends In Health Care Industry KNH 413. Difficult questions What is health insurance? What is health care versus health insurance? Is one or both a right.
Healthcare Reform in China and Its Impact on the Pharmaceutical Industry Hengpeng Zhu Institute of Economics Chinese Academy of Social Sciences
Impact of Hospital Provider Payment Mechanism on Household Health Service Utilization in Vietnam (preliminary results) Sarah Bales Public Policy in Asia,
HEALTH CARE IN THE U.S..  The U.S. government does not pay any part of the medical expenses for international students studying here.  The average cost.
Impact on prescribing patterns of a fee per drug unit versus a fee per drug item Kathleen Holloway 1, Karkee SB 2, Tamang AL 2, Gurung YB 2, Pradhan R.
Current status, problems, and challenges in public health in Thailand Dr. Phusit Prakongsai, MD. Ph.D. International Health Policy Program – IHPP Ministry.
Healthcare Reforms and Pharmaceuticals Lessons from Turkey Prof. Dr. Mehtap Tatar Hacettepe University Faculty of Economics and Administrative Sciences.
The Business Case for Bidirectional Integrated Care: Mental Health and Substance Use Services in Primary Care Settings and Primary Care Services in Specialty.
P4P and China’s Health Care Reform: Current State, Opportunities and Challenges Winnie Yip Reader in Health Policy and Economics University of Oxford “Incentives.
Access to Care Where Are We All Going to Get Care? Bruce A. Bishop Senior Counsel/Director of Compliance Northwest Permanente, P.C., Physicians and Surgeons.
Increasing the sample: How can state-based estimates help monitor healthcare reform? 2012 National Conference on Health Statistics Monitoring Health Care.
Economic Burden and Health Consequences of Antibiotic Resistance in Patients at a Tertiary Care Hospital, Vellore, South India Sujith J Chandy (1,2), Thomas.
 Health insurance is a significant part of the Vietnamese health care system.  The percentage of people who had health insurance in 2007 was 49% and.
FAMILY STRENGTHENING PROGRAMME An approach to prevent children from losing care of their families of origin.
APHA – 132nd Annual Meeting - 1 District of Columbia Department of Health Health Care Safety Net Administration First Three Years in Review and Plans for.
Key issues in health care financing Di McIntyre. Objectives Introduce some key concepts Introduce a useful analytic framework Illustrate the analytic.
Performances Based Financing scheme in Rwanda INVESTING MORE STRATEGICALLY 1.
 C HAPTERS 14 & 15 Code Blue Health Science Edition 4.
IMPACT OF AN ESSENTIAL DRUGS LIST AND TREATMENT GUIDELINES ON PRESCRIBING IN SOUTH AFRICA In 1998 the National Department of Health (NDOH) published standard.
Policy track summary ICIUM 2011 – 18 Nov Policy track topics 1.The pharmaceutical policy process 2.Quality and safety of medicines in LMIC 3.Policy.
Role of Private Village Clinics in Tuberculosis Control in Three Counties of Shandong, China Jingbo Yu 1 ; R. Paul Duncan, PhD 1 ; Qingyue Meng, PhD 2.
Chapter 7.2 Examination and Treatment Prepared by Nguyen Trong Khoa.
Uses of NH’s Claims Database: Comprehensive Health Care Information System (CHIS) Christine Shannon Office of Medicaid Business & Policy, NH DHHS July.
HEALTH FINANCING MOH - HPG JAHR UPDATE ON POLICIES Eleventh Party Congress -Increase state investment while simultaneously mobilizing social mobilization.
A FORMATIVE STUDY TO DESIGN AN INTERVENTION INVOLVING MOTHERS, DRUGS VENDORS AND HEALTH WORKERS IN A SELF-PROCESS OF BEHAVIORAL CHANGE FOR RATIONAL DRUG.
Health social system in China Lian Tong Doctoral student (D3) Sep 29, 2010 Lab of International Community Care and Lifespan Development.
Impacts of Direct Fee-For- Service Payment Insurance on Access and Use of Drug: An Interrupted Time Series Study on Diabetic Care Inthira Kanchanaphibool,
Overview of China’s health care reform Wen Chen, Ph.D., Professor Fudan School of Public Health March 21, 2016.
-Building a Student Run Free Clinic in Beijing Xiaoxiao Jiang Wenzhuo Feng Cheng Qian Kan Xue Jingyi Liu Ying Han Zed Zha.
Coordinator of Project management Unit of Global fund and MAP projects
© Plan International Xu Jian, Country Health Advisor, Plan China Piloting Children’s Medical Insurance in Rural China: The Experience of Plan China.
Presentation to the Health Portfolio Committee Presentation to Health Portfolio Committee Free State Department of Health 15 APRIL 2003.
Understanding Health Systems: The Organization of
Do Village Revolving Funds Improve Access and Rational Use of Drugs in Laos?
Logez S, Hutin Y, Somda P, Thualt J, Holloway K
Harmoko, MD#, Edward, MD #Institut Kesehatan Helvetia
The primary health-care system in China
Availability, cost, and prescription patterns of antihypertensive medications in primary health care in China: a nationwide cross-sectional survey Meng.
Making Healthcare Affordable
Kandeke C, Chibuta C, Banda D
Chapter 2: Health Care Economics
A pragmatic stepped intervention cluster randomized trial
PH Dung, NTK Chuc and Dennis Ross Degan
Toktobaeva B, Karymbaeva S Drug Information Centre Kyrgyzstan
More Than One-Third of Women in the U. S. Skip Care Because of Cost vs
Presentation transcript:

Evaluation of the New Rural Cooperative Medical Scheme Outpatient Capitation Payment Reform in Qianjiang District of Chongqing, China Qu, Qian (1);  Sun, Jing (2); Kang, Jun (3); Zhang, Weibin (1); Tan, Yongqian (4); Xiang, Wenxian (4) 1: Chongqing Health Bureau, P.R. China; 2: National Institute of Hospital Administration, MOH, P.R. China;  Corresponding author: 3: Chongqing Medical University, P.R. China; 4: Qianjiang District Health Bureau, Chongqing, P.R. China 16 Nov Antalya, Turkey 13c-Economics: Health Insurance Coverage for Medicines in LMIC

Background There has been an increasing cost containment pressure for the New Rural Cooperative Medical Scheme in China The fee-for-service payment and other factors create perverse incentives, which drive the irrational provider behaviours 2 3c-Economics: Health Insurance Coverage for Medicines in LMIC 16 Nov Antalya, Turkey

Setting Capitation payment reform is piloted in Qianjiang where there are 30 township/community health centres and 169 village clinics 3 3c-Economics: Health Insurance Coverage for Medicines in LMIC 16 Nov Antalya, Turkey

Study Aims This study evaluates if the capitation payment reform in Qianjiang: -Contained the cost -Rationalized the providers’ behaviour -Caused income losing of the health workers and facilities 43c-Economics: Health Insurance Coverage for Medicines in LMIC 16 Nov Antalya, Turkey

Methods-1 The effect of the policy is measured with the changes of the following indicators before and after the reform in Qianjiang : -cost per visit; -quality of care; -income of facilities and health workers 53c-Economics: Health Insurance Coverage for Medicines in LMIC 16 Nov Antalya, Turkey

Methods-2 ● The effect of the policy is also showed by comparing the cost and hospitalization data of Qianjiang with that of Southeast Chongqing where has similar social and economical development situations with Qianjiang 63c-Economics: Health Insurance Coverage for Medicines in LMIC 16 Nov Antalya, Turkey

Methods-3 Quality of care is evaluated with: -Prescription indicators to show medicines use status; -Referral rate, proportions of appropriate referrals and hospitalization rate show if patients are selected and shifted from outpatient to inpatient 73c-Economics: Health Insurance Coverage for Medicines in LMIC 16 Nov Antalya, Turkey

Methods-4 Cost is measured with: - Annual average cost of all facilities of Qianjiang and compared with Southeast Chongqing during ; - Annual median cost of all and sample facilities in Qianjiang during ; - Both costs are compared with the prescription caps 83c-Economics: Health Insurance Coverage for Medicines in LMIC 16 Nov Antalya, Turkey

Methods-5 Quality of care and income data of Qianjiang are collected from sample facilities Interviews provide complementary information 93c-Economics: Health Insurance Coverage for Medicines in LMIC 16 Nov Antalya, Turkey

Results-1 The average cost per visit of all THC/CHCs and village clinics in Qianjiang is at the same level of Southeast Chongqing in 2006, getting much lower in c-Economics: Health Insurance Coverage for Medicines in LMIC 16 Nov Antalya, Turkey

Results-2 The median cost per visit of all THC/CHC and sample THC/CHC in Qianjiang both are with an increasing trend during Both increases are statistically significant ( Ⅹ ² = , P< and Ⅹ ² = , P<0.0001) 113c-Economics: Health Insurance Coverage for Medicines in LMIC 16 Nov Antalya, Turkey

Results-3 Both average and median cost of Qianjiang keep within the prescription caps during , when costs of Southeast Chongqing far exceed 123c-Economics: Health Insurance Coverage for Medicines in LMIC 16 Nov Antalya, Turkey

Results-4 There are no significant changes of referral and prescription data in Qianjiang during ( Ⅹ ² test, P>0.05) 133c-Economics: Health Insurance Coverage for Medicines in LMIC 16 Nov Antalya, Turkey Ⅹ²Ⅹ² P Referral rate in township/community health centers (%) Appropriate referral rate in township/community health centers (%) % of essential medicines township/community health centers village clinics % of prescriptions with steroids in township/community health centers % of prescriptions with antibiotics in township/community health centers % of prescriptions with infusions in township/community health centers

Results-5 The qualitative interviews and group discussions show that, doctors are more likely to adopt less costly alternative treatments, and are more willing to provide outreach services for preventive care 143c-Economics: Health Insurance Coverage for Medicines in LMIC 16 Nov Antalya, Turkey

Results-6 There are no significant differences between the average hospitalization rates of sample township/community health centers of Qianjiang and Southeast Chongqing in 2006 and 2009 ( Ⅹ ² test, P>0.05) 153c-Economics: Health Insurance Coverage for Medicines in LMIC 16 Nov Antalya, Turkey

Results-7 The monthly income of the health workers and the outpatient revenue of facilities in Qianjiang keep growing during There are no overruns in all the sample facilities in Qianjiang 163c-Economics: Health Insurance Coverage for Medicines in LMIC 16 Nov Antalya, Turkey

Summary-1 The cost containment objective is achieved Provider behaviours are partially improved but with limited affect on prescriptions 173c-Economics: Health Insurance Coverage for Medicines in LMIC 16 Nov Antalya, Turkey

Summary-2 The reform does not bring financial loss to both the facilities and the individuals, but creates incentive for less costly alternative treatments and more attention to prevention 183c-Economics: Health Insurance Coverage for Medicines in LMIC 16 Nov Antalya, Turkey

Policy Implications and Conclusions Capitation payment dose raise the cost awareness of providers Comprehensive performance assessment system and other supporting policies could help address the unexpected side effects of the capitation payment Changing prescription behaviors needs more comprehensive interventions 193c-Economics: Health Insurance Coverage for Medicines in LMIC 16 Nov Antalya, Turkey