Evaluating Economic Policy Instruments for Sustainable Water Management in Europe The research leading to these results has received funding from the European.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Ensuring financial sustainability of health system in Estonia Hannes Danilov Head of Management Board JOINT OECD AND WHO MEETING ON FINANCIAL SUSTAINABILITY.
Advertisements

The project has received funding from the European Union. The Dilemma of Targeting Support with CAP post 2013 Tata, April, 2010 Wanda Chmielewska-Gill.
Open days 06. Cutting the Red Tape Practical difficulties in actions co-financed by EU structural funds: proposals for a better management and complementariness.
1 Regional Policy investing in ecosystems & green infrastructure for regional development Mathieu Fichter Policy Analyst Environment European Commission.
1 SG C Smart Regulation: Regulatory Fitness High Level Group on Administrative Burden 17 October 2013 Elizabeth Golberg, Secretariat-General, European.
Price Ceilings and Floors
A few thoughts on fair, efficient and sustainable management of agricultural water Warsaw – 14 Sep 2011 David Zetland Senior Water Economist Wageningen.
© 2007 Thomson South-Western. Supply, Demand, and Government Policies In a free, unregulated market system, market forces establish equilibrium prices.
Lecture 4 Part-1 Impact of govt. policies. Supply, Demand, and Government Policies In a free, unregulated market system, market forces establish equilibrium.
International Economics Tenth Edition
Assess the Market for Your Business Idea
Global Perspective The Price War Setting the right price for a product or service can be the key to success or failure An offerings price must reflect.
Evaluating Economic Policy Instruments for Sustainable Water Management in Europe The research leading to these results has received funding from the European.
Evaluating Economic Policy Instruments for Sustainable Water Management in Europe The research leading to these results has received funding from the European.
Water pricing for sustainability and the poor David Zetland Senior water economist Wageningen University The Netherlands.
Technical Workshop on Tools and Measures to Inform Inclusive Green Economy Policies 2-4 July 2013 UNEP Joy A. Kim.
Towards More Sustainable and Market-based Payment for Ecosystem Services A Pilot Project in Lijiang, China Lu Zhi.
HR 09 IB EN 02 – German Proposal, Zagreb, 10 June 2011 Page 1 April 12, Strengthening the Ministry of Nature Protection of the Republic of Armenia.
McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2010 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. Global Business and Accounting Chapter 15.
Why Turkey is interested in NCA? Arzu ÖNSAL Ministry of Development 29 June 2014.
Demand, Supply and Economic Policy Lecture 4 – academic year 2014/15 Introduction to Economics Fabio Landini.
1. 2 Content Principles of the Water Framework Directive WFD and Agriculture WFD and CAP.
McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright  2006 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. POLITICS AND ECONOMICS: THE CASE OF AGRICULTURAL MARKETS POLITICS.
Chapter 16 – Dividends and Dividend Policy  Learning Objectives  Understand the dividend paying process  Differentiate the types of dividends  Explain.
1 A few of my favorite things. James Hines, University of Michigan Paying taxes is not the same as bearing tax burdens. Capital taxes are the most distortionary.
Taxation, income distribution, and efficiency
1 Trade Facilitation A narrow sense –A reduction/streamlining of the logistics of moving goods through ports or the documentation requirements at a customs.
Copyright © 2011 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall Ch 3 -1 External Strategic Management Audit – Environmental Scanning – Industry Analysis.
Copyright © 2005 Pearson Education Inc. The Marketing Environment Chapter 5 PowerPoint slides Express version Instructor name Course name School name Date.
The Scope and Challenge of International Marketing
The Multinational Corporation and Globalization
Full Cost Pricing Including External Costs. External and Internal Costs Internal cost: Included in the price. Raw materials, labor, shipping, profits.
Public funding of NGOs in Romania Budapest, Hungary November, 2010 Octavian Rusu, Legal adviser.
EEP 101/Econ 125 lecture 7 Property rights David Zilberman.
Water.europa.eu Assessment of the River Basin Management Plans – preliminary findings Conference on River Basin Management Planning Ankara, 28 February.
Legal, Regulatory, and Political Issues
The Legal Basis of Volunteering in Italy Renzo Razzano President SPES Volunteer Support Centre Lazio Region Vice President of CEV Parliament of Lithuania,
Towards Sustainability: Challenges and Demands for Environmental Education in Hungary Márton HERCZEG&Noémi NAGYPÁL Ph.D. Student and Assistant Lecturer.
The Congress, the President, and the Budget: The Politics of Taxing and Spending.
Copyright © 2004 South-Western/Thomson Learning Today’s Warm Up Imagine a law was passed that prevented the price of bottled water from increasing above.
KEY TERMS: Sin tax Tax loophole Sales tax Proportional tax
Conception for lands of high natural value – international agreements.
Development of Environmental Law in China: Prof. Dr. Qin Tianbao Research Institute of Environmental Law Wuhan University.
Entrepreneurship in a Market Economy. Needs and Wants  Needs: things you must have  Wants: things you think you must have.
Environmental Management System Definitions
SAYRE | MORRIS Seventh Edition Monopoly CHAPTER © 2012 McGraw-Hill Ryerson Limited.
International Business Environment
Overview of Integrated Solid Waste Management (ISWM) Presentation made at the European Commission 7 th Framework Programme on Capacity Building Workshop.
Public Finance by John E. Anderson Power Point Slides to Accompany:
Green tariff for solar energy: practical legal aspects and legislative barriers ROUND TABLE «UKRAINIAN SOLAR ENERGY MARKET: REMOVING BARRIERS FOR GROWTH»
Study Unit 9 Decision Analysis and Risk Management.
Dzidra Hadonina Ministry of the Environment of the Republic of Latvia Kiev, Ukraine, November 22-24, 2004 Legal Framework for Cooperation in the River.
Feasibility Study.
Demand, Supply and Economic Policy Lecture 4 – academic year 2015/16 Introduction to Economics Dimitri Paolini.
Date/event: Water accounts and economics workshop, 7-8/10/2010, Copenhagen Author: Dr Manuel Lago (Ecologic Institute, Berlin) ETC/Water 2010 Overview.
Welfare Impacts of Agri-Environmental Policies in an Open Economy: A Numerical General Equilibrium Framework by: Farzad Taheripour Madhu Khanna Carl Nelson.
7-1 Copyright © 2009 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall Chapter Seven Governmental Influence On Trade International Business Part Three.
1 Ecologic Institute Science and Policy for a Sustainable World Berlin – Brussels Washington DC – San Mateo CA Ecologic.eu EIUS.org.
INTERNATIONAL FINANCE
Unpacking the term politics
POLITICAL ENVIRONMENT OF BUSINESS
The EUROPEAN UNION’S BUDGET
Kevin Smits
Chapter 4 © Routledge/Taylor & Francis 2014
Art. 17 EGTC Indicators 13th Meeting of the Expert Group on Delegated and Implementing Acts for the ESI Funds 4th July 2013.
ECONOMICS IN THE WFD PROCESS
EP Pilot project Comparative study of pressures and measures
Water Framework Directive, Habitats Directive and Inland Waterway Transport Marieke van Nood WFD Team, DG ENV.D.2, European Commission.
Chapter Seven Governmental Influence On Trade
Enabling environments for technology transfer under the UNFCCC
Presentation transcript:

Evaluating Economic Policy Instruments for Sustainable Water Management in Europe The research leading to these results has received funding from the European Community’s Seventh Framework Programme (FP7/ ) / grant agreement n° – project EPI-WATER “Evaluating Economic Policy Instrument for Sustainable Water Management in Europe”. Institutions, transaction costs & the Dutch groundwater tax ecologic Berlin, 26 Jan 2012 David Zetland, WUR

1 1. Institutions and Transaction Costs Institutions are exogenous to the EPI. They affect its design and performance, e.g., ``Dutch habit of honestly paying taxes." Transaction costs are endogenous to the EPI. They are fixed and variable, e.g., cost of buying water meters and reading the meters It's possible to overlook both, as they are not overtly part of the policy discussion or economic theory. Bottom Line: Institutions and TCs can break an EPI that sounds good from an economic or environmental perspective. They can interact with distribution of costs and benefits to improve/worsen the social impact of an EPI -- and thus its political acceptability.

2 2. Complications with Institutions Need to describe (in)formal physical, political, cultural, legal and administrative exogenous factors affecting the EPI's design, implementation and function. A description of laws may miss factors affecting those laws or their implementation. A “partial equilibrium” approach may explain primary forces but miss secondary influences. Failure to understand institutions means we may misunderstand the potential to implement an EPI elsewhere.

3 3. Complications with Transaction Costs Some authors paid careful attention to TCs, tracing them from beginning to end, but most authors listed TCs without quantification (e.g., staff, time to trade). Quantification was easier when earlier studies has established TCs. TC evaluation was complicated when EPIs were additional to existing policies. The marginal TC was small due to institutions. We may have had a problem with survivor bias in ex-post studies. Significant TCs may mean the difference between a good and bad EPI.

4 4. The Dutch groundwater tax Enacted in Ended in Reduce burden on productive activities and “green” environment. Applied to drinking water companies (75 %) and industry. Agriculture mostly exempt (small impact plus lobbying) Opaque impact on customers; companies loathed it. Small shift from ground- to surface water. No tracking of groundwater impact; “prevented” higher income taxes. Bottom Line: Hard to see benefit on productive activities OR environment (no double dividend). Special interest benefits from repeal (EUR millions).

5 5. Institutional factors Wrong scale: Dutch don't want groundwater in some places. Ineffective: Exemption of farmers and lack of monitoring gutted environmental component. Unnecessary: Provincial groundwater fees funded monitoring and management since Fee revenue was 10 percent of GWT. Fees varied by location; everyone paid. Considered effective. Unpopular: Special interest got hit by narrowing of tax base. Final consumers had zero elasticity of response, but less than 50 percent pass through (EUR 70 to company vs 40 million to customers) Existing institutions handled groundwater and gutted the “green” component of the GWT. Ended when ineffectiveness became obvious.

Thanks! The research leading to these results has received funding from the European Community’s Seventh Framework Programme (FP7/ ) / grant agreement n° – Project EPI-WATER “Evaluating Economic Policy Instrument for Sustainable Water Management in Europe”.