TeraGrid Science Gateways Nancy Wilkins-Diehr TeraGrid Area Director for Science Gateways University of Michigan CI Days, November 2,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
INDIANAUNIVERSITYINDIANAUNIVERSITY GENI Global Environment for Network Innovation James Williams Director – International Networking Director – Operational.
Advertisements

LEAD Portal: a TeraGrid Gateway and Application Service Architecture Marcus Christie and Suresh Marru Indiana University LEAD Project (
Designing Services for Grid-based Knowledge Discovery A. Congiusta, A. Pugliese, Domenico Talia, P. Trunfio DEIS University of Calabria ITALY
Software change management
Distributed Data Processing
Xsede eXtreme Science and Engineering Discovery Environment Ron Perrott University of Oxford 1.
1 US activities and strategy :NSF Ron Perrott. 2 TeraGrid An instrument that delivers high-end IT resources/services –a computational facility – over.
TeraGrid Science Gateways Nancy Wilkins-Diehr TeraGrid Area Director for Science Gateways NBCR Summer Institute, August 4, 2009.
TeraGrid Science Gateways Nancy Wilkins-Diehr TeraGrid Area Director for Science Gateways Computing in Atmospheric Sciences, September.
(e)Science-Driven, Production- Quality, Distributed Grid and Cloud Data Infrastructure for the Transformative, Disruptive, Revolutionary, Next-Generation.
1 Software & Grid Middleware for Tier 2 Centers Rob Gardner Indiana University DOE/NSF Review of U.S. ATLAS and CMS Computing Projects Brookhaven National.
1 Supplemental line if need be (example: Supported by the National Science Foundation) Delete if not needed. Supporting Polar Research with National Cyberinfrastructure.
April 2009 OSG Grid School - RDU 1 Open Science Grid John McGee – Renaissance Computing Institute University of North Carolina, Chapel.
EZID (easy-eye-dee) is a service that makes it simple for digital object producers (researchers and others) to obtain and manage long-term identifiers.
Core Services I & II David Hart Area Director, UFP/CS TeraGrid Quarterly Meeting December 2008.
1 Building National Cyberinfrastructure Alan Blatecky Office of Cyberinfrastructure EPSCoR Meeting May 21,
TeraGrid Gateway User Concept – Supporting Users V. E. Lynch, M. L. Chen, J. W. Cobb, J. A. Kohl, S. D. Miller, S. S. Vazhkudai Oak Ridge National Laboratory.
Moving forward our shared data agenda: a view from the publishing industry ICSTI, March 2012.
IPlant Collaborative Powering a New Plant Biology iPlant Collaborative Powering a New Plant Biology.
TeraGrid Science Gateways Nancy Wilkins-Diehr TeraGrid Area Director for Science Gateways TeraGrid Rount Table, October 7, 2010.
TeraGrid Science Gateways Nancy Wilkins-Diehr Area Director for Science Gateways TeraGrid 09 Education Program, June 22, 2009.
Open Science Grid For CI-Days Internet2: Fall Member Meeting, 2007 John McGee – OSG Engagement Manager Renaissance Computing Institute.
18:15:32Service Oriented Cyberinfrastructure Lab, Grid Deployments Saul Rioja Link to presentation on wiki.
Effective User Services for High Performance Computing A White Paper by the TeraGrid Science Advisory Board May 2009.
CI Days: Planning Your Campus Cyberinfrastructure Strategy Russ Hobby, Internet2 Internet2 Member Meeting 9 October 2007.
National Center for Supercomputing Applications The Computational Chemistry Grid: Production Cyberinfrastructure for Computational Chemistry PI: John Connolly.
PCGRID ‘08 Workshop, Miami, FL April 18, 2008 Preston Smith Implementing an Industrial-Strength Academic Cyberinfrastructure at Purdue University.
Department of Biomedical Informatics Service Oriented Bioscience Cluster at OSC Umit V. Catalyurek Associate Professor Dept. of Biomedical Informatics.
CloudCom Software for Science Gateways: Open Grid Computing Environments Marlon Pierce, Suresh Marru Pervasive Technology Institute Indiana University.
TeraGrid Science Gateways Nancy Wilkins-Diehr TeraGrid 10, August 2-5, 2010 South Tenth Street Bridge, Pittsburgh.
Gateways Tutorial Outline: Morning Session Overview: Marlon Pierce OGCE Introduction: Marlon Demos for OGCE Gadget Container, GFAC Application Factory,
SAN DIEGO SUPERCOMPUTER CENTER NUCRI Advisory Board Meeting November 9, 2006 Science Gateways on the TeraGrid Nancy Wilkins-Diehr TeraGrid Area Director.
IPlant Collaborative Tools and Services Workshop iPlant Collaborative Tools and Services Workshop Collaborating with iPlant.
1 Preparing Your Application for TeraGrid Beyond 2010 TG09 Tutorial June 22, 2009.
Open Science Grid For CI-Days Elizabeth City State University Jan-2008 John McGee – OSG Engagement Manager Manager, Cyberinfrastructure.
IPlant cyberifrastructure to support ecological modeling Presented at the Species Distribution Modeling Group at the American Museum of Natural History.
What is Cyberinfrastructure? Russ Hobby, Internet2 Clemson University CI Days 20 May 2008.
IPlant Collaborative Tools and Services Workshop iPlant Collaborative Tools and Services Workshop Collaborating with iPlant.
The Future of the iPlant Cyberinfrastructure: Coming Attractions.
TeraGrid Science Gateways Nancy Wilkins-Diehr TeraGrid Area Director for Science Gateways EGU, Vienna, May 3, 2010.
GEM Portal and SERVOGrid for Earthquake Science PTLIU Laboratory for Community Grids Geoffrey Fox, Marlon Pierce Computer Science, Informatics, Physics.
Geosciences - Observations (Bob Wilhelmson) The geosciences in NSF’s world consists of atmospheric science, ocean science, and earth science Many of the.
National Center for Supercomputing Applications Barbara S. Minsker, Ph.D. Associate Professor National Center for Supercomputing Applications and Department.
IPlant Collaborative Hands-on Cyberinfrastructure Workshop - Part 1 R. Walls University of Arizona Biodiversity Information Standards (TDWG) Sep. 28, 2015,
Scalable Systems Software for Terascale Computer Centers Coordinator: Al Geist Participating Organizations ORNL ANL LBNL.
Ruth Pordes November 2004TeraGrid GIG Site Review1 TeraGrid and Open Science Grid Ruth Pordes, Fermilab representing the Open Science.
NEES Cyberinfrastructure Center at the San Diego Supercomputer Center, UCSD George E. Brown, Jr. Network for Earthquake Engineering Simulation NEES TeraGrid.
Biomedical and Bioscience Gateway to National Cyberinfrastructure John McGee Renaissance Computing Institute
1 NSF/TeraGrid Science Advisory Board Meeting July 19-20, San Diego, CA Brief TeraGrid Overview and Expectations of Science Advisory Board John Towns TeraGrid.
TeraGrid Gateway User Concept – Supporting Users V. E. Lynch, M. L. Chen, J. W. Cobb, J. A. Kohl, S. D. Miller, S. S. Vazhkudai Oak Ridge National Laboratory.
7. Grid Computing Systems and Resource Management
Distributed Data for Science Workflows Data Architecture Progress Report December 2008.
Cyberinfrastructure Overview Russ Hobby, Internet2 ECSU CI Days 4 January 2008.
Cyberinfrastructure: Many Things to Many People Russ Hobby Program Manager Internet2.
Fire Emissions Network Sept. 4, 2002 A white paper for the development of a NSF Digital Government Program proposal Stefan Falke Washington University.
NICS Update Bruce Loftis 16 December National Institute for Computational Sciences University of Tennessee and ORNL partnership  NICS is the 2.
Science Gateways What are they and why are they having such a tremendous impact on science? Nancy Wilkins-Diehr
Northwest Indiana Computational Grid Preston Smith Rosen Center for Advanced Computing Purdue University - West Lafayette West Lafayette Calumet.
TG ’08, June 9-13, State of TeraGrid John Towns Co-Chair, TeraGrid Forum Director, Persistent Infrastructure National Center for Supercomputing.
Building PetaScale Applications and Tools on the TeraGrid Workshop December 11-12, 2007 Scott Lathrop and Sergiu Sanielevici.
Data Infrastructure in the TeraGrid Chris Jordan Campus Champions Presentation May 6, 2009.
Purdue RP Highlights TeraGrid Round Table November 5, 2009 Carol Song Purdue TeraGrid RP PI Rosen Center for Advanced Computing Purdue University.
ENEA GRID & JPNM WEB PORTAL to create a collaborative development environment Dr. Simonetta Pagnutti JPNM – SP4 Meeting Edinburgh – June 3rd, 2013 Italian.
Transforming Science Through Data-driven Discovery Workshop Overview Ohio State University MCIC Jason Williams – Lead, CyVerse – Education, Outreach, Training.
INTRODUCTION TO XSEDE. INTRODUCTION  Extreme Science and Engineering Discovery Environment (XSEDE)  “most advanced, powerful, and robust collection.
CyVerse Tools and Services
Tools and Services Workshop
Joslynn Lee – Data Science Educator
MATLAB Distributed, and Other Toolboxes
Storing and Accessing G-OnRamp’s Assembly Hubs outside of Galaxy
Presentation transcript:

TeraGrid Science Gateways Nancy Wilkins-Diehr TeraGrid Area Director for Science Gateways University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010 Entrance gate to the “Big House”, Ann Arbor, MI

You’ve heard a lot about the TeraGrid Here’s a one-slide recap of the resources University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010

TeraGrid resources today include: Tightly Coupled Distributed Memory Systems, 2 systems in the top 10 at top500.org –Kraken (NICS): Cray XT5, 99,072 cores, 1.03 Pflop –Ranger (TACC): Sun Constellation, 62,976 cores, 579 Tflop, 123 TB RAM Shared Memory Systems –Cobalt (NCSA): Altix, 8 Tflop, 3 TB shared memory –Pople (PSC): Altix, 5 Tflop, 1.5 TB shared memory Clusters with Infiniband –Abe (NCSA): 90 Tflops –Lonestar (TACC): 61 Tflops –QueenBee (LONI): 51 Tflops Condor Pool (Loosely Coupled) –Purdue- up to 22,000 cpus Gateway hosting –Quarry (IU): virtual machine support Visualization Resources –TeraDRE (Purdue): 48 node nVIDIA GPUs –Spur (TACC): 32 nVIDIA GPUs Storage Resources –Wide area filesystems( Lustre, GPFS) –Archival storage –Data replication service University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010 Source: Dan Katz, U Chicago But change is constant - new systems: Data Analysis and Vis systems Longhorn (TACC): Dell/NVIDIA, CPU and GPU Nautilus (NICS): SGI UltraViolet, 1024 cores, 4TB global shared memory Data-Intensive Computing Dash (SDSC): Intel Nehalem, 544 processors, 4TB flash memory, Gordon (SDSC): FutureGrid Experimental computing grid and cloud test-bed to tackle research challenges in computer science Keeneland Experimental, high-performance computing system with NVIDIA Tesla accelerators

So how do Gateways fit into this? Gateways are a natural result of the impact of the internet on worldwide communication and information retrieval Implications on the conduct of science are still evolving –1980’s, Early gateways, National Center for Biotechnology Information BLAST server, search results sent by , still a working portal today –1989 World Wide Web developed at CERN –1992 Mosaic web browser developed –1995 “International Protein Data Bank Enhanced by Computer Browser” –2004 TeraGrid project director Rick Stevens recognized growth in scientific portal development and proposed the Science Gateway Program –Today, Web 3.0 and programmatic exchange of data between web pages Simultaneous explosion of digital information –Growing analysis needs in many, many scientific areas –Sensors, telescopes, satellites, digital images, video, genome sequencers –#1 machine on Top500 today over 1000x more powerful than all combined entries on the first list in 1993 University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010 Only 18 years since the release of Mosaic!

vt100 in the 1980s and a login window on Ranger today University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010

Why are gateways worth the effort? Increasing range of expertise needed to tackle the most challenging scientific problems –How many details do you want each individual scientist to need to know? PBS, RSL, Condor Coupling multi-scale codes Assembling data from multiple sources Collaboration frameworks University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010 #! /bin/sh #PBS -q dque #PBS -l nodes=1:ppn=2 #PBS -l walltime=00:02:00 #PBS -o pbs.out #PBS -e pbs.err #PBS -V cd /users/wilkinsn/tutorial/exercise_3../bin/mcell nmj_recon.main.mdl +( &(resourceManagerContact="tg- login1.sdsc.teragrid.org/jobmanager-pbs") (executable="/users/birnbaum/tutorial/bin/mcell") (arguments=nmj_recon.main.mdl) (count=128) (hostCount=10) (maxtime=2) (directory="/users/birnbaum/tutorial/exercise_3") (stdout="/users/birnbaum/tutorial/exercise_3/globus.out") (stderr="/users/birnbaum/tutorial/exercise_3/globus.err") ) ======= # Full path to executable executable=/users/wilkinsn/tutorial/bin/mcell # Working directory, where Condor-G will write # its output and error files on the local machine. initialdir=/users/wilkinsn/tutorial/exercise_3 # To set the working directory of the remote job, we # specify it in this globus RSL, which will be appended # to the RSL that Condor-G generates globusrsl=(directory='/users/wilkinsn/tutorial/exercise_3') # Arguments to pass to executable. arguments=nmj_recon.main.mdl # Condor-G can stage the executable transfer_executable=false # Specify the globus resource to execute the job globusscheduler=tg-login1.sdsc.teragrid.org/jobmanager- pbs # Condor has multiple universes, but Condor-G always uses globus universe=globus # Files to receive sdout and stderr. output=condor.out error=condor.err # Specify the number of copies of the job to submit to the condor queue. queue 1

Gateways democratize access to high end resources Almost anyone can investigate scientific questions using high end resources –Not just those in the research groups of those who request allocations –Gateways allow anyone with a web browser to explore Opportunities can be uncovered via google –My then 11-year-old son discovered nanoHUB.org when his science class was studying Bucky Balls Foster new ideas, cross-disciplinary approaches –Encourage students to experiment But used in production too –Significant number of papers resulting from gateways including GridChem, nanoHUB –Scientists can focus on challenging science problems rather than challenging infrastructure problems University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010

Today, there are approximately 35 gateways using the TeraGrid University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010 This just in 35% of TeraGrid users charging jobs (June-Sept, 2010) were gateway users!

Not just ease of use What can scientists do that they couldn’t do previously? Linked Environments for Atmospheric Discovery (LEAD) - radar data coupled with on demand computing Large Synoptic Survey Telescope (LSST) – access to sky surveys Ocean Observing Initiative (OOI) – access to sensor data PolarGrid – access to polar ice sheet data SIDGrid – expensive datasets, analysis tools GridChem –coupling multiscale codes How would this have been done before gateways? University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010

3 steps to connect a gateway to TeraGrid Request an allocation –Only a 1 paragraph abstract required for up to 200k CPU hours Register your gateway –Visibility on public TeraGrid page Request a community account –Run jobs for others via your portal Staff support is available! University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010

Tremendous Opportunities Using the Largest Shared Resources - Challenges too! What’s different when the resource doesn’t belong just to me? –Resource discovery –Accounting –Security –Proposal-based requests for resources (peer-reviewed access) Code scaling and performance numbers Justification of resources Gateway citations Tremendous benefits at the high end, but even more work for the developers Potential impact on science is huge –Small number of developers can impact thousands of scientists –But need a way to train and fund those developers University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010

When is a gateway appropriate? Researchers using defined sets of tools in different ways –Same executables, different input GridChem, CHARMM –Creating multi-scale workflows –Datasets Common data formats –National Virtual Observatory –Earth System Grid –Some groups have invested significant efforts here caBIG, extensive discussions to develop common terminology and formats BIRN, extensive data sharing agreements Difficult to access data/advanced workflows –Sensor/radar input LEAD, GEON University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010

How to get started? Conduct a needs assessment –Should I build a gateway? –Can I use an existing gateway? –What problems am I trying to solve? All gateways don’t need high end computing Decide on a software approach –Recommended software at Targeted effort by a few can benefit many –Could a pool of developers design gateways for different domain areas? Yes! TeraGrid staff assistance University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010

Expressed Sequence Tag (EST) Pipeline Take raw genome data in the FASTA format and run a series of applications on it –RepeatMasker, PaCE, CAP3 and BLAST used to generate the final assembled output –Very variable run times (milliseconds to days) EST Pipeline based on the SWARM Web Service that provides a web service interface to clients and also manages the bulk job submission using the Birdbath API to submit to Condor 2M jobs run in 49 hours, only a handful of failures Workflow is configured using a PHP based gateway that allows users to upload input data and select programs to run University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010 Source: Archit Kulshrestha, IU

Cyberinfrastructure for Phylogenetic Research (CIPRES) Enables large-scale phylogenetic reconstructions Parallel “fastest in the west” versions of applications such as MrBayes, Raxml and Garli Easy to use graphical user interface Over 800 users, June-Sept –27% of all active TG users!! 5M CPU hours awarded University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010

Intellectual Merit: the CIPRES portal is cited in at least 35 publications this includes publications in Nature, PNAS, and Cell. highlights of scientific findings: New Family Tree for Arthropoda: A team of scientists compared genetic sequences from 75 arthropod species and drew a new family tree for the most successful phylum of animals on Earth. This work represents an important advance in the century-old problem of arthropod evolution. Genome Sequence of a Transitional Eukaryote: A group of scientists sequenced the genome of Naegleria gruberi, a single-cell organism that is a key transitional species between prokaryotes and eukaryotes. This work provides new insights into the origins of subcellular organelles. Co-evolution of Beetles and Flowering Plants: A group of researchers studied the evolutionary history of angiosperms and the beetles that interact with them. The work provided compelling experimental evidence for the long- postulated co-evolution of these two symbiotic groups. Source: Mark Miller, SDSC University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010

Broad Impacts: 77% of all jobs have been submitted from locations in the USA. Submissions are received regularly from researchers at top-tier institutions such as Harvard, Yale, and Stanford. Jobs are received regularly from academic institutions in 17 EPSCOR states. Job submissions have been received from 34 countries on 5 continents. At least 5 undergraduate classes are known to use the portal routinely. This is likely an underestimate (based on Web log patterns). More than 45,000 jobs have been run on the Portal over its lifetime. Between Dec 1, 2010 and June 30, 2010, users ran 6,108 parallel jobs on the TeraGrid. Source: Mark Miller, SDSC University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010

Additional Gateways for Biology –List of all TeraGrid gateways Biodrugscore RENCI Science Portal Open Life Sciences Gateway Robetta University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010

Biodrugscore Derive and validate scoring functions Create training sets using structural and binding data from multiple databases including PDBbind and PDBcal Define the components of scoring functions by picking from among a list of pre-computed terms – Partial least-squares regression analysis Validate scoring functions Apply custom scoring functions for the ranking of chemical libraries that are pre-docked against a large set of binding cavities from the human proteome If the receptor of interest is not available, biodrugscore makes it possible for users to dock libraries against their target on the TeraGrid using their own account. University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010

NBCR Compute resources Service projects –Quantum to Continuum Mechanics Tools –Data Analysis Tools for Molecular Sequences –Heart Modeling –Visualization and multi- scale modeling –Grid services and Telescience Tools and downloads –40+ packages, databases, services University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010

RENCI Science Portal biology applications –From Antigenic to WordMatch and everything in between –RENCI Science Desktop –BlastMaster desktop University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010

Open Life Sciences Gateway Bioinformatics applications and data collections Portal access, direct Web services calls, workflows with Taverna –And now google gadgets! –igoogle.google..com, “add stuff”, search for TeraGrid University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010

Robetta University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010 Protein structure prediction server –Rosetta code from the David Baker laboratory Also available –RosettaAntibody Server –RosettaDesign Server –RosettaDock Server –Rosetta Commons –FoldIt –Human Proteome Folding Project

Linked Environments for Atmospheric Discovery (LEAD) Providing tools that are needed to make accurate predictions of tornados and hurricanes Meteorological data Forecast models Analysis and visualization tools Data exploration and Grid workflow University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010

Highlights: LEAD Inspires Students Advanced capabilities regardless of location A student gets excited about what he was able to do with LEAD “Dr. Sikora:Attached is a display of 2- m T and wind depicting the WRF's interpretation of the coastal front on 14 February It's interesting that I found an example using IDV that parallels our discussion of mesoscale boundaries in class. It illustrates very nicely the transition to a coastal low and the strong baroclinic zone with a location very similar to Markowski's depiction. I created this image in IDV after running a 5-km WRF run (initialized with NAM output) via the LEAD Portal. This simple 1-level plot is just a precursor of the many capabilities IDV will eventually offer to visualize high-res WRF output. Enjoy! Eric” ( , March 2007) University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010

Community Climate System Model (CCSM) Makes a world-leading, fully coupled climate model easier to use and available to a wide audience Compose, configure, and submit CCSM simulations to the TeraGrid Used in Purdue’s POL 520/EAS 591: Models in Climate Change Science and Policy –Semester-long projects, 100 year CCSM simulations, generate policy recommendations based on scientific, economic, and political models of climate change impacts University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010

Analytical Ultracentrifugation Emerging computational tool for the study of proteins The Center for Analytical Ultracentrifugation of Macromolecular Assemblies, UT Health Sciences –Major advances in the characterization of proteins and protein complexes as a result of new instrumentation and powerful software –Monitoring the sedimentation of macromolecules in real time in the centrifugal field allows their hydrodynamic and thermodynamic characterization in solution –Observations are electronically digitized and stored for further mathematical analysis – University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010 Source: Modern analytical ultracentrifugation in protein science: A tutorial review, Wikipedia

UltraScan provides a comprehensive data analysis environment Management of analytical ultracentrifugation data for single users or entire facilities Support for storage, editing, sharing and analysis of data –HPC facilities used for 2-D spectrum analysis and genetic algorithm analysis TeraGrid (~2M CPU hours used) Technische University of Munich Juelich Supercomputing Center Portable graphical user interface MySQL database backend for data management Over 30 active institutions TeraGrid advanced support –Fault tolerance, workflows, use of multiple TG resources, community account implementation University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010

Social Informatics Data Grid Collaborative access to large, complex datasets SIDGrid is unique among social science data archive projects –Streaming data which change over time Voice, video, images (e.g. fMRI), text, numerical (e.g. heart rate, eye movement) –Investigate multiple datasets, collected at different time scales, simultaneously Large data requirements Sophisticated analysis tools University of Michigan CI Days, November 2,

Viewing multimodal data like a symphony conductor “Music-score” display and synchronized playback of video and audio files –Pitch tracks –Text –Head nods, pause, gesture references Central archive of multi-modal data, annotations, and analyses –Distributed annotation efforts by multiple researchers working on a common data set History of updates Computational tools –Distributed acoustic analysis using Praat –Statistical analysis using R –Matrix computations using Matlab and Octave University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010 Source: Studying Discourse and Dialog with SIDGrid, Levow, 2008

Future Technical Areas Web technologies change fast –Must be able to adapt quickly Gateways and gadgets –Gateway components incorporated into any social networking page –75% of 18 to 24 year-olds have social networking websites iPhone apps? Web 3.0 –Beyond social networking and sharing content –Standards and querying interfaces to programmatically share data across sites Resource Description Framework (RDF), SPARQL University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010

Gateways can further investments in other projects Increase access –To instruments, expensive data collections Increase capabilities –To analyze data Improve workforce development –Can prepare students to function in today’s cross-disciplinary world Increase outreach Increase public awareness –Public sees value in investments in large facilities –Pew 2006 study indicates that half of all internet users have been to a site specializing in science –Those who seek out science information on the internet are more likely to believe that scientific pursuits have a positive impact on society University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010

But gateways can only be truly effective if they are persistent Gateway Sustainability Study Characteristics of short funding cycles –Build exciting prototypes with input from scientists –Work with early adopters to extend capabilities –Tools are publicized, more scientists interested –Funding ends –Scientists who invested their time to use new tools are disillusioned Less likely to try something new again –Start again on new short-term project Need to break this cycle EAGER grant to look at characteristics of successful gateways and domain areas where a gateway could have a big impact Working with Katherine Lawrence, UM University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, focus group meetings over 2 years First 2 held June,

University of Michigan CI Days, November 2, 2010 Thank you for your attention! Questions? Nancy Wilkins-Diehr,