1 An Assessment of the First Three Years Consultative Group meeting Brussels 8 October 2002 Development Planning Unit.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 A Framework for Common Action around shared goals Presentation by Harald Lossack, GTZ on Behalf of OECD/DAC ENVIRONET PEP Meeting 15 June 2006.
Advertisements

Mutual Accountability and Aid Transparency - Rwanda – IATI Partner Country Meeting, 4th July 2011 Paris, France Ronald NKUSI Director, External Finance.
Guidance Note on Joint Programming
Maryse Robert, Director Department of Economic and Social Development Executive Secretariat for Integral Development San Pedro Sula, Honduras, September.
World Bank and SPS With special emphasis on the recently established multi-donor Standards and Trade Facility Cees de Haan Agriculture and Rural Department,
Slovenian experience MEASURES TO STRENGHTEN THE CIVIL DIALOGUE AND PARTNERSHIP Irma Mežnarič Brussels - 10 October 2006.
European Commission DG Research SMcL Brussels SME-NCP 23 October 2002 THE 6th FRAMEWORK PROGRAMME Economic & Technological Intelligence S. McLaughlin.
Harmonized support to scaling up the national AIDS response Ini Huijts 7 th June 2006 ODI meeting, London.
Policies and Procedures for Civil Society Participation in GEF Programme and Projects presented by GEF NGO Network ECW.
1 World Bank Support TFSCB STATCAP Monitoring systems / Core Welfare Indicators Questionnaire (CWIQ) Readiness Assessment.
1 PAB PRESENTATION TO CG 16 th October 2003 Organizational issues Organizational issues  PAB: Role & Function Membership & Rotation Membership & Rotation.
© GEO Secretariat Capacity Building Committee experience of resource mobilisation Alan EDWARDS EUROPEAN COMMISSION Research Directorate General Environment.
Group 3 Financing EFA: Domestic resource mobilization and external support Facilitator: Robert Prouty, The World Bank.
IFAD Reform towards a better development effectiveness How can we all do better? Mohamed Béavogui Director, West and Central Africa January 2009.
African Project on the Implementation of the 2008 System of National Accounts National Accounts Status report on SADC ( April – November 2014 ) Ackim Jere.
Bologna and the Third Cycle Anthony J Vickers UK Bologna Expert.
U n i t 6 Multisectoral collaboration. © WHO, │ By the end of this unit, the trainee should be able to: explain why there is a need for multisectoral.
Education and Culture LESSONS LEARNED FROM THE FORMER GENERATION OF HIGHER EDUCATION PROGRAMMES IN RUSSIAN FEDERATION José Gutierrez Erasmus+ : Higher.
Country Support Programme (CSP) GEF Expanded Constituency Workshop 1 to 3 November 2011 Cape Town, South Africa.
Intergovernmental Network on Atmospheric Pollution Objectives of the Intergovernmental Network on Atmospheric Pollution: –Promote the exchange of research.
STRENGTHENING the AFRICA ENVIRONMENT INFORMATION NETWORK An AMCEN initiative A framework to support development planning processes and increase access.
Helping to ensure sustainability of outputs in Tempus Projects Dr Carol Marrow Emeritus Reader: University of Cumbria Associate Professor: RKC, Zurich,
CTCN ORIGINS 2 COP 15 (Copenhagen): agreement to establish a “Technology Mechanism” COP 16 (Cancun): Technology Mechanism further elaborated (TEC and.
THE ROLE OF STOP TB GHANA PARTNERSHIP Chief Austin A. Obiefuna National Coordinator SECRETARIAT CO-HOSTED BY AFRO GLOBAL ALLIANCE (GH) & GHANA SOCIETY.
Title Consultation on the 7 th replenishment of IFAD’s resources IFAD’s operating model : overall structure and components Consultation on the 7th replenishment.
INTOSAI Public Debt Working Group Updating of the Strategic Plan Richard Domingue Office of the Auditor General of Canada June 14, 2010.
Sub-regional Workshop for GEF Focal Points Eastern and Southern Africa Sandton, South Africa, 3-4 November 2010 Sub-Regional Workshop for GEF Focal Points.
Michalis Adamantiadis Transport Policy Adviser, SSATP SSATP Capacity Development Strategy Annual Meeting, December 2012.
Smaller housing associations’ capacity to develop new homes Mark Lupton.
World Meteorological Organization Working together in weather, climate and water EC-WGCD 1 - Dec 2011 Regional Programme and South-South Cooperation WMOwww.wmo.int.
Regional Developments for Improving Statistics in the Pacific Islands Presentation by the Pacific Islands Forum Secretariat, Luxembourg, 6 May 2008.
Towards a European network for digital preservation Ideas for a proposal Mariella Guercio, University of Urbino.
European Commission Introduction to the Community Programme for Employment and Social Solidarity PROGRESS
United Nations Volunteers Volunteerism for Development in the context of CBA Adeline Aubry CBA Volunteerism & Community Adaptation Specialist United Nations.
PACIFIC AID EFFECTIVENESS PRINCIPLES. Purpose of Presentation Provide an overview of Pacific Principles on Aid Effectiveness Provide an overview of Pacific.
The CG on ECCD: Developing Our Strategy.
BEYOND MKUKUTA FRAMEWORK: Monitoring and Evaluation, Communication and Implementation Guide Presentation to the DPG Meeting 18 th January, 2011.
Country Support Programme GEF Expanded Constituency Workshop March 22 – 24, 2011 Kyiv, Ukraine.
Tracking national portfolios and assessing results Sub-regional Workshop for GEF Focal Points in West and Central Africa June 2008, Douala, Cameroon.
Elements of an Effective Regional Strategy for Development of Statistics - SADC Ackim Jere SADC Secretariat Gaborone, Botswana PARIS 21 Forum on Reinforcing.
WHO EURO In Country Coordination and Strengthening National Interagency Coordinating Committees.
OVERVIEW OF MACROECONOMIC & HEALTH KEY POINTS FROM THE OCTOBER 2003 GLOBAL CONSULTATION Briefing for Permanent Mission Representatives.
1 International Energy Agency Elmer C. Holt, Jr. CTI Executive Committee Vice Chair Recent Activities of the CTI.
Creating Innovation through International collaboration Melanie Relton & Helen Kidd, British Council 7 April 2013, Qatar.
Commission proposal for a new LIFE Regulation ( ) Presentation to Directors Meeting DK 22 May 2012.
Local Area Agreement Strengthening delivery Improving Outcomes Jon Bright Director of Policy and Delivery Birmingham City Council.
27/04/2017 Strengthening of the Monitoring and Evaluation system for FTPP/FTTP in FAO /SEC December 2015 FTPP/FTFP Workshop, Bishkek, Kyrgyzstan.
Proposal for the development of an Inter-American Cooperation Network for Migration Special Committee on Migration Issues November 22, 2010.
Identifying, Evaluating and Prioritising Urban Adaptation Measures.
Bangladesh Joint Country Assistance Evaluation: Assessing Total ODA at the Country Level Presentation to OECD DAC November 2006 Bruce Murray Director General.
Department of Social Development National Conference Early Childhood Development Conference “Tshwaragano Ka Bana” 29th March 2012 The National Integrated.
Tools for Mainstreaming Disaster Risk Reduction: Guidance Notes for Development Organisations Charlotte Benson and John Twigg Presented by Margaret Arnold.
DIPECHO Advocacy Network Initiative (DANI) LESSONS LEARNT & THE WAY FORWARD DMWG Meeting, April 25 th 2008 Presented by Vu Xuan Viet Project Manager CARE.
Richard Escritt, Director – Coordination of Community Actions DG Research, European Commission “The development of the ERA: Experiences from FP6 and reflections.
Project: EaP countries cooperation for promoting quality assurance in higher education Maria Stratan European Institute for Political Studies of Moldova.
Donor Coordination Process
Institutional Strengthening Support
Country Support Programme (CSP)
WHO’s prioritised research agenda for the prevention and control of NCDs prioritises
Country Support Programme GEF Expanded Constituency Workshop
9/16/2018 The ACT Government’s commitment to Performance and Accountability – the role of Evaluation Presentation to the Canberra Evaluation Forum Thursday,
Roles of NLO, CP and RDC’s
The Role of Bilateral Donors in supporting capacity-building in the area of ICT Open Consultations on Financing Mechanisms for Meeting the Challenges.
Helene Skikos DG Education and Culture
GEF Expanded Constituency Workshop Country Support Programme (CSP)
GEF Expanded Constituency Workshop
GEF Expanded Constituency Workshop
Commission proposal for a new LIFE Regulation CGBN meeting
MONITORING PROGRESS ON JOINT EVALUATION AND PARTNER COUNTRY INVOLVEMENT February th meeting.
Presentation transcript:

1 An Assessment of the First Three Years Consultative Group meeting Brussels 8 October 2002 Development Planning Unit

2 Problems of method premature judgement in terms of impact need to develop robust indicators for evaluation in the process of evaluating, turning aims into what can be assessed using these indicators to test: relevance efficacy efficiency in achieving the aims

3 Context and development CA developed very swiftly as: a successful mechanism to change the climate of opinion on urban poverty through slum upgrading city development strategies a vehicle for the funding of innovative proposals in these two fields recruitment of a multiplicity of partners (CG) which became the governing council of the CA

4 Raised problems CG could not properly fulfil its original role as a public policy forum, nor was it equipped to supervise the Secretariat the role of the learning alliance was as a result neglected

5 Remedies were spin off the “external” role of public policy forum to the PAB create a Steering Committee to supervise the work of the Secretariat

6 Allowed the CG to concentrate on the central tasks of creating a learning alliance, an “internal” public policy forum, through: pooling the experience of all the partners in urban development on the two priority themes expanding and aligning, in a complementary fashion, the programmes and experience of all the partners seeking to further enhance collaboration between the partners evaluating the lessons of this multi-agency experience, particularly that of cities in developing countries disseminating the lessons of best practice, and supporting the appropriate capacity-building to strengthen cities

7 Current challenge Target audience and the source of learning are the cities of the developing countries with a focus on the poorest cities (who show a capacity to change) city managers NGOs and slum dwellers associations slum-dwellers themselves The style of the CA has to be transformed for this much larger task

8 The central tasks of the CG become evaluation combining the respective capacities of all the partners to identify best practice in SU and CDSs dissemination on a mass basis and an ‘indigenised’ form (cheap publications; web sites) capacity building move from funding projects to financing the capacity for cities to undertake projects – i.e. major programme in training

9 Local Government Associations are central to this shift of direction great experience and expertise among their members direct links to the cities LGAs have other central responsibilities so special efforts are required e.g. exchange of staff joint-evaluation of LGA experience creation of registers of experts from the LGAs strengthening of in-country LGAs. Importance of supporting in-country CAs as the base for local evaluation, dissemination and capacity building. key role of strengthened in-country LGA. in-country donor offices vital part of national CAs to encourage alignment of urban development programmes, collaboration and mutual support. NGOs also a valuable part of local CAs.

10 The Secretariat should be less concerned with the volume of projects funded, more emphasis on: quality innovation in the context of the urban development programs of all the partners prioritising cities – e.g. the poorest facilitating the preparation of applications

11 Other points A detailed review of the projects undertaken is presented. Need for a review of the range of CDSs (not only CA supported) to identify what has been useful and sustainable