An overview of Cold War Historiography

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
PI5501 European Security Strategic Studies. From where does the European security infrastructure arise? Why has it settled in this way? What lasting impact.
Advertisements

British cartoon, 2 nd March 1948  starter activity Who is being blamed for Cold War in this British cartoon of the 1940s? What are the limitations in.
 starter activity By the 1970s the US and the USSR each had enough nuclear weapons to blow the world up several times over. Can you explain this cartoonist’s.
Cold War Origins. Long Term Causes Bolshevik Revolution Marxist-Leninists take power in Russia and form Soviet Union 1921 Western powers had sent troops.
The Origins of the Cold War Yalta and the end of WW II Germany and Berlin Crisis Containment and the Truman Doctrine NATO and the Marshall Plan Red Scare.
President Harry S. Truman The Presidency of Harry S. Truman.
GO131: International Relations Professor Walter Hatch Colby College Cold War.
Essential Question: What led to the Cold War between the United States and Soviet Union?
SOVIET UNION VS THE UNITED STATES The Cold War. The End of World War 2 As the war was ending cracks in the Grand Alliance were beginning to grow. USSR.
The Cold War. Confrontation of the Super Powers Suspicious of one another’s motives the US and USSR became rivals US and G. Britain pushed for self determination.
You can type your own categories and points values in this game board. Type your questions and answers in the slides we’ve provided. When you’re in slide.
IB Study Suggestions and Strategies. Paper 1—Communism in Crisis, China under Deng Xiaoping: economic policies and the Four Modernizations.
The Cold War The Cold War Why was it ‘cold’? Because there was no direct fighting between the USSR and the USA – just an awful lot of propaganda,
An Overview of the War that Never Happened…... Differing Post-War Plans  United States  Encourage the spread of democracy  Rebuild European governments.
The Cold War International clash of ideologies. What was the Cold War? A conflict between the world’s two super- powers – the U.S. and the Soviet Union.
The First Cold War IB History: The Cold War. About the Unit... In the unit we will explore various aspects of the Cold War which was a global political.
The Soviet Union Falls Apart Chapter 21. A New Phase By the 1970’s the Cold War had entered a new phase called detent Detent – a relaxation of tensions.
Australia in the Vietnam War Era … or how we learned to stop fearing the domino effect.
The post-WWII battle for world domination between the forces of capitalism & democracy led by the U.S., The Cold War was: and the forces of communism.
Interpreting the origins of the Cold War Historical perspectives.
Canada in 1945 A New World Order. Post War Europe Many countries are rebuilding In need of aid from North America Germany divided into 4 zones occupied.
The Cold War. A new international conflict emerged after World War II called the Cold War – The Cold War was mostly an ideological conflict between the.
Stalin’s Foreign Policy. Stalin’s FP Peaceful Co-existence Peaceful Co-existence Attitude to Chinese Communists Attitude to Chinese Communists Response.
Cold War Vocab. Cold War : the ideological conflict between the United States and the Soviet Union during the second half of the 20 th century Superpower.
Post WWII Germany: Divided into 4 zones. West Germany- United States, Britain, France. East Germany- Soviet Union Soviet Union & United States: Competing.
Recognize cause and effect relationships about the Cold War.Cold War Describe examples of the Cold War.
Cold War Era SSUSH20. Bellringer Look at Causes and Effects of the Cold War. Pg 784 Look at Causes and Effects of the Cold War. Pg 784 What do you think.
Member Nations The end of WWII in 1945, marked a turning point in U.S. history by taking an active role in world affairs The USA became a leader in the.
Monday April 6 th, 2009 Bell Work What was SDI? Pg. 557 Who was Leonid Brezhnev? Pg. 555 What Year did Hungary Revolt?
Lee W. Eysturlid, Ph.D. Source:
LG211: America and the Wider World Lecture 9: From ‘bearing any burden’ to the ‘end of history’
Key Concept 8.1: The United States responded to an uncertain and unstable postwar world by asserting and working to maintain.
Emergent Nationalism in Asia Chinese Foreign Policy:
External Assessment Paper 2 – World History Topics Paper 3 – Regional Option Paper 2 – World History Topics Paper 3 – Regional Option.
Exam Paper 2 Topic 5 Cold War
CHAPTER 32 THE COLD WAR AND DECOLONIZATION
Essential Question: What led to the Cold War between the United States & Soviet Union? CPUSH Agenda for Unit 12.1: “Causes of the Cold War” notes.
Paper 2: Cold War The breakdown of the grand alliance and the emergence of superpower rivalry in Europe and Asia (1943–1949): role of ideology; fear and.
Who is to blame for the Cold War?
Welcome! Please take out a chromebook and open the documents about the Cold War that are posted in Mr. Percy’s exam prep website. Please also have Mr.
Essential Question: What led to the Cold War between the United States & Soviet Union? Warm Up Questio:
Interpreting The Origins of the Cold War
Historiography, approaches, and primary sources in Cold War Studies
American Military Forces & the Cold War
The Origins of the Cold War
Emergent Nationalism in Asia
Global Reconstruction and the Bipolar World
The Cold War ( ) From Containment to the Korean War
Task on Entry Using the source below and your own knowledge, create a spider diagram with the reasons for the origins of the Cold War Martin McCauley (2003)
Cold War.
The Cold War Abroad US Foreign Policy:
Origins of the Cold War.
Harry Truman and the Cold War

Warm up Truman Doctrine: Marshall Plan. Satellite States:
Stalin in Power, Collectivization of agriculture
The Cold War.
The end of World War II led to important changes in the world:
Essential Question: What led to the Cold War between the United States & Soviet Union? CPUSH Agenda for Unit 12.1: “Causes of the Cold War” notes.
What country is more responsible for ending the Cold War?
To learn about and assess the impact of WWII on America and the world
Truman Doctrine & Marshall Plan
COLD WAR THE COLD WAR WAS THE GEOPOLITICAL, IDEOLOGICAL, AND ECONOMIC STRUGGLE BETWEEN TWO WORLD SUPERPOWERS, THE USA AND THE USSR, THAT STARTED IN 1945.
The Cold War Begins.
Cold War Historiography
 starter activity By the 1970s the US and the USSR each had enough nuclear weapons to blow the world up several times over. Can you explain this cartoonist’s.
Hotline between Washington and Moscow= communication improves
10-1: The Early Cold War
Essential Question: What led to the Cold War between the United States & Soviet Union?
The 1970’s and 1980’s.
Presentation transcript:

An overview of Cold War Historiography

Cold War Historiography The orthodox interpretation The revisionist interpretation Moderate revisionist view The post-revisionist view Revival of orthodoxy Return to orthodoxy in the Putin-Medvedev era???

The orthodox interpretation Why the Cold War? Soviet aggression Why the aggression? Ideological evangelism? Russian imperialism? Does not matter Its monolithic nature The US reaction? US sought to continue wartime cooperation Forced to stand up to Soviet behaviour The Truman Doctrine? All the Soviets’ fault

Why the orthodox interpretation? Breakdown of the anti-Nazi alliance Soviet domination of Eastern Europe Complete by 1948 Berlin (1948) Spread of the Cold War to Asia: The “loss of China” Korea (1950-53) Indochina McCarthyism

The revisionist interpretation Breakdown of the wartime alliance US fault Soviet behaviour? What would you expect? US imperialistic- why? Markets/ investment/ raw materials Regimes to look after US interests

Why the revisionist interpretation? The Vietnam War Questioning of the war led to questioning of the bases of US foreign policy The 60s: an era of protest and challenge Nixon engendered opposition thinking The man The Pentagon Papers Watergate

The moderate revisionist interpretation Personality focussed If only FDR and not Truman Truman surrounded by fanatically anti-Russian advisors Kennan Clifford Nitze Acheson

Why the moderate revisionist interpretation? FDR’s willingness to trust and work with Stalin Truman’s hardline approach His inexperience? Beholden to his advisors? But blame still on US

Revival of orthodoxy When? What? Why? The 1980s Back to it’s all the fault of the Soviets Why? The Reagan era “the evil empire” Soviet invasion of Afghanistan End of détente

The post-revisionist interpretation Washington and Moscow Both sides had their faults Both sides pushing their national interests Ignorance of each other Led to misunderstanding Nearly nuclear war Stalin? Security his concern But: couldn’t be sure Gaddis particularly hard on the role of Stalin

Why the post-revisionist interpretation? Opening up of the Soviet archives But do not overplay this The Cold War was now over Allows a non-partisan approach Avoids the Soviet apologist approach