Comment on Bruegel Policy Brief: Elements of Europe‘s Energy Union Daniel Fürstenwerth, Agora Energiewende BRUSSELS, 01.10.2014.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Energy Financing Energy Efficiency Philip Lowe Director General Directorate-General for Energy.
Advertisements

A New Dash for Gas? Future Energy Strategies 29 th May 2012 at Allen & Overy David Odling, Energy Policy Manager Oil & Gas UK.
A 2030 framework for climate and energy policies Marten Westrup
The challenge in UK power generation Steve Riley, Executive Director, Europe London, 3 December 2010.
INVESTMENTS IN POWER SECTOR
Dokumentname > Folie 1 > Vortrag > Autor Potentials for Renewables in Europe Wolfram Krewitt DLR Institute of Technical Thermodynamics Systems.
Energy in the U.S. - Why Wind? Financing Wind Power: The Future of Energy Institute for Professional and Executive Development Santa Fe, N.M. July 25,
State Policy Initiatives Financing Wind Power: The Future of Energy May 7-9, 2008 Richard Cogen.
The UK Low Carbon Transition Plan Leila Pourarkin Seoul, South Korea March 2010.
Smart instruments for a smarter Europe – Intelligent Energy for Europe Christiane Egger O.Ö. Energiesparverband Landstraße 45, A-4020 Linz, Austria T:
The innovation challenge STAKEHOLDER CONFERENCE "Post-2012 climate policy for the EU" 22 NOVEMBER 2004 Niklas Höhne ECOFYS Cologne,
EU LEGISLATION ON WASTE European Commission WORKSHOP ON EU LEGISLATION WASTE © 2010 Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved. Waste in EU economy.
The Future of the Strategy with regard to the Outermost Regions - Brussels, 15 May 2008Note: document not legally binding 1 José RUIZ ESPI RTD.K.3 New.
INTERNATIONAL ENERGY AGENCY AGENCE INTERNATIONALE DE LENERGIE Energy Technology Policy Progress and Way Forward Fridtjof Unander Energy Technology Policy.
Vision for the internal electricity market
ECCP II Stakeholder meeting Oct 2005 Slide n° 1 The European Climate Change Programme ECCP II The European Climate Change Programme ECCP II Angel Perez.
1 European Union Regional Policy – Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion Addressing challenges in a changing world: -The future Cohesion Policy- Wolfgang.
August 31- September 1, 2011 Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
Dirk Scheelje Executive Board Member
Strategic Overview of policies to deliver the 80% emissions reduction target Cameron Maxwell Climate Change Division, the Scottish Government Sustainable.
CRed carbon reduction Reader Emeritus in Environmental Sciences; Energy Science Adviser Norwich Business School, University of East Anglia:
CRed carbon reduction Reader Emeritus in Environmental Sciences; Energy Science Adviser Norwich Business School, University of East Anglia:
1 Recipient of James Watt Gold Medal Keith Tovey ( ) : MA, PhD, CEng, MICE, CEnv Reader Emeritus in Environmental Science, University of East Anglia Wenhaston:
1 Recipient of James Watt Gold Medal Keith Tovey ( ) : MA, PhD, CEng, MICE, CEnv Reader Emeritus in Environmental Science, University of East Anglia Rotary.
Recipient of James Watt Gold Medal for Energy Conservation Keith Tovey ( ) M.A., PhD, CEng, MICE, CEnv Reader Emeritus: University of East Anglia 1 Pathways.
Why we need the Energy Transition… 1 Renewables No Coal No Nuclear Energy Security Safety Low Prices Climate Protection Energy Transitsion.
The German Energiewende: Implications for Europe Climate and Energy Package. Myths and costs in the context of the road map 2050 Warsaw, September 27th.
1 There is a major risk that Europe gets off-track in the 2020s The current policies will not achieve the EU ambition as CO 2 intensity will rise without.
District heating year District heating and cooling 2013 Heat sales (incl. taxes)2 330 mill. Sold heat energy31,6 TWh Average price of.
BREAKOUT SESSION 2 Smart Grid 2-B: Grid Integration – Essential Step for Optimization of Resources Integrating Intermittent Wind Generation into an Island.
Community Energy Solutions David Lacey Operations Director.
KOOTHS | BiTS: International Economics (winter term 2013/2014), Part 4 1 International Economics Part 4 Dr. Stefan Kooths BiTS Berlin (winter term 2013/2014)
Renewable Energy Workshop 2012 Global Market Impacts on Wind and PV Technologies A Presentation to the Bucknell University Renewable Energy Workshop –
University of Flensburg/Germany International Institute of Management Energy and Environmental Management in Developing Countries (former SESAM) MEng (Industrial.
Local Renewables Freiburg 2007 June 14, 2007 Tobias Kelm Centre for Solar Energy and Hydrogen Research Renewable Energy Law: Stimulating Investment in.
© OECD/IEA 2010 Carbon pricing and complementary mechanisms Christina Hood, International Energy Agency ECF Roundtable From Roadmaps to Reality Brussels.
UK enabling Legislation Renewable Energy Strategy.
1 Meeting carbon budgets – 5th Progress Report to Parliament Committee on Climate Change, June If you want to tweet about this report.
Transform PV to Load Capacity Status by Coupling PV Plants to CAES Plants James Mason Renewable Energy Research Institute ASES Forum on Solar and the Grid.
Oceans of opportunity Harnessing Europes largest domestic energy resource European Offshore Wind Conference September 2009 Justin Wilkes Head of.
Analysis of the electric energy storage in different renewable energy scenarios Wayne Götz, Tobias Tröndle, Ulrich Platt und Werner Aeschbach-Hertig University.
Renewable Energy and Europes New Energy Policy The next steps Presentation of Mr Christopher Jones Director New and Renewable Sources of Energy, Energy.
Europe's priorities Our goals Why a 2030 framework now?
© Vattenfall AB The Swedish Power Market Presented for Invest in Sweden Agency and Sun Microsystems Stockholm 20 March, 2009 Sandra Grauers Nilsson, Vattenfall.
The environmental and policy context for crowd-funding in the UK LSE Seminar on Crowd-Funding for Renewables 2 May 2013 Sam Fankhauser Grantham Research.
The Landscape of Solar Industry in China 1. 2 Landscape of Solar Industry in China  8 IPO’s since 2005,100+ solar fab’s built  In 2009, volume of polysilicon.
Agenda 5-6 December December Joint understanding on the PA 8 targets (10:30– 11:35) -Subgroups for the Priority Area 8 and Concept development.
“Energiewende” and cost mechanisms Charlotte Loreck Energy and Climate Division Öko-Institut e.V. Berlin for Heinrich Böll Foundation 5 December 2012.
Craig Morris Petite Planète Ukraine’s Energy Future Sep 13, 2012 “Energiewende” The German energy transition – what can other countries.
Renewable Energy Development in Germany (Status and Outlook) Rainer Hinrichs-Rahlwes, Board Member BEE - German Renewable Energy Federation Berlin, 3 rd.
Electricity distribution and embedded renewable energy generators Martin Scheepers ECN Policy Studies Florence School of Regulation, Workshop,
UK Renewable Energy Policy
HOW IS 100% RENEWABLE ENERGIES POSSIBLE IN SOUTH KOREA BY 2020 ? 1.
Bell Schedules Club Time is available from 8:05-8:20  1 st 8:20 – 9:15  2 nd 9:20 – 10:10  3 rd 10:15 – 11:05  4 th 11:10 – 12:50 A(11:10)
Vorstand FB Tarif industriAll-Europe, Basic Metals Committee, Luxembourg, Collective Agreements of the European Steel Industry.
Efficient and Sustainable Use of Biomass for Energy
Seite 1 4. Juni 2009 The Challenge of Power System Operation with Large Amounts of Wind Power Dr. Kurt Rohrig IWES Institut für Windenergie und Energiesystemtechnik.
What is “socket” parity and is rooftop solar PV there yet without subsidies? Shelly Hagerman Advisors: Granger Morgan and Paulina Jaramillo May 20, 2014.
Energy Year 2014 Electricity Finnish Energy Industries.
1 NBS-M017 – 2013 CLIMATE CHANGE: GOVERNANCE AND COMPLIANCE Electricity Market Reform Aims to integrate both the Wholesale and Low Carbon Electricity Markets.
The Energy Report © Wild Wonders of Europe / Inaki Relanzon / WWF Connecting the grid with RES Dr Stephan Singer Director Global Energy Policy WWF Brussels,
Renewable Power Generation Costs 2012: An Overview 14 January 2013 Michael Taylor IRENA Innovation and Technology Centre.
Renewables Go Big Big Wind Christian Kjaer Chief Executive Officer European Wind Energy Association European Parliament, 2 September 2009.
WIND ENERGY Is there a Latvian Master Plan? CHRISTIAN KJÆR Chief Executive Officer European Wind Energy Association SSE Riga, 4 December 2008 © EWEA/L.
The German Electricity Market in the European context Bocconi University Karsten Neuhoff German Institute for Economic Research / Technical University.
Why a share of 80% electricity from renewable energy sources is no utopia and why a share of 80% fossil fuels will soon be history. International Forum.
World Energy Outlook 2006 Scenarios for the World and the European Union Presentation to European Wind Energy Conference Milan, Italy, 7-10 May 2007.
IFIEC Europe International Federation of Industrial Energy Consumers 1 Promotion of Renewable Energies in the EU Member States Consequences on the Price.
08/12/2015 Developing renewable energy cost effectively EUROPEAN COMMISSION Tom Howes European Commission.
Energy Transition – Energiewende - in Germany
Presentation transcript:

Comment on Bruegel Policy Brief: Elements of Europe‘s Energy Union Daniel Fürstenwerth, Agora Energiewende BRUSSELS,

Agora Energiewende – an Overview 2 →Financed by Mercator Foundation and European Climate Foundation, →Independent and non-partisan →Think Tank based in Berlin →Mission: How to make the Energiewende a success story?

Focus of this comment: EU support for low-carbon technologies 3 - Innovation vs. Deployment -Targets and Markets

Innovation vs. Deployment? 4 Cost of Power per Technology (LCOE 2014, new build, Germany) Wind and PV are cost competitive today - with new conventional and nuclear power plants Future* *“Future Cost of PV until 2050“, Agora Energiewende/Fraunhofer ISE, forthcoming ct/kWh

Other European countries have similar, some even better conditions for Wind and PV power production 5 Quality of WindQuality of Solar Cost competitive technology is available for Wind onshore and PV Focus should be on removal of market barriers and appropiate market design

Technology-specific analysis required: cost varies between renewable technologies 6 Price (ct/kWh) Power Generation (TWh) ~11 TWh Biomass Wind offshore Wind onshore & PV Price and Quantity of yearly deployment of renewables in Germany, 2015 (Objective) Focus on innovation appropiate for new renewable energy technologies (e.g. geothermal, tidal, wave)

Targets help policy to fulfill its role: enable the market to find efficient solutions Brussels, | Daniel Fürstenwerth 7 Power Market, Germany% 100% %25%40-45% 2025 Targets enable investors to make efficient investment decisions Renewable Non - Renewable Building Investment payback Example: Investment in new fossil power plant Investment decision Research Question: What are cost of suboptimal investment decisions? Year

Summary -Stronger deployment of Wind onshore and PV does not increase cost of the power system until 2030 – removal of market barriers is key -Stronger focus on innovation is appropiate for new renewable technologies (geothermal, tidal, etc) -Renewable targets allow market actors to make efficient investment decisions – for both non-renewable and renewable investments 8

Comments and questions: Agora Energiewende Rosenstraße Berlin T +49 (0) F +49 (0) Brussels, | Daniel Fürstenwerth 9

Innovation vs Deployment 10

: „Solar Years“ Success Story for Technology, Challenge for Policy Makers Brussels, | Daniel Fürstenwerth 11 Feed-in Tarif (EUR/MWh) Cost (EUR/MWh, illustrative) Build-up of Solar (GW/a) Increased margin leads to massive investment in solar „Race“ between investors and policy: market moved faster ~ 30 GW solar build in 5 years Cost was >2 times higher than today

12 Remuneration of new nuclear power in the UK, and large PV and wind onshore in Germany after accounting for inflation, in real Euro 2013 /MWh Note: Wind onshore remuneration in Germany is presented here in a simplified way by showing average payments. In reality, remuneration at the beginning differs from remuneration at the end. Source: EEG 2012, UK Government 2013a, calculations by Prognos AG.

13 Comparison of average remuneration for new nuclear power in the UK, and PV and wind in Germany, in Euro 2013 /MWh * Hinkley Point C agreement ** Wind offshore 2013 without grid costs; in Germany, the regulatory approach excludes grid costs from being covered by the remuneration. Offshore grid costs are estimated to be between 25 and 35 EUR/MWh, depending on the distance to shore. Source: DECC 2013; ECB 2014a; EEG 2012; Prognos AG 2013; UK Government 2013a; calculations by Prognos AG. -34% -50% -15% Remuneration, in Euro 2013 /MWh

14 Comparison of annual system costs, in million Euro 2013 Source: ECB 2014a; EEG 2012; Prognos AG 2013; UK Government 2013a; calculations by Prognos AG. Annual system cost, million Euro %