Prediction Markets at Yahoo! David Pennock Yiling Chen, Tej Kasturi, Havi Hoffman, Dan Reeves Chao-Hsien Chu, Sandip Debnath, Mike Dooley, Rael Dornfest,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
C HAPTER Elasticity of Demand and Supply price elasticities of demand and supply, income and cross elasticities of demand, and using elasticity to forecast.
Advertisements

The 4 P’s of Marketing consumer The Marketing Mix.
Edition Vitale and Giglierano Chapter 6 Assessing and Forecasting Markets Prepared by John T. Drea, Western Illinois University.
The Evolution of P2P Technology Robert Levitan, CEO Pando Networks P2P MEDIA SUMMIT, CES 2008.
1 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt Wants.
Money, Banking & Finance Lecture 4 The Theory and Practice of Equity Trading.
Part 1 Marketing Dynamics
Hang Gui Xi Xia Ying Du. Steel producer Worlds tenth largest by sales Found in employees Market cap: 3.82 Billion Traded as NYSE: X.
1 Project 2: Stock Option Pricing. 2 Business Background Bonds & Stocks – to raise Capital When a company sell a Bond - borrows money from the investor.
Creating and Capturing Customer Value
Lesson 1.3 Unit 1, Lesson 3. Set:A collection of distinct objects Elements:All of the objects that make up a set.
Copyright © 2008 Pearson Addison-Wesley. All rights reserved. Chapter 10 Information and Financial Market Efficiency.
Performance Evaluation Sponsored Search Markets Giovanni Neglia INRIA – EPI Maestro 4 February 2013.
Futures markets. Forward - an agreement calling for a future delivery of an asset at an agreed-upon price Futures - similar to forward but feature formalized.
Research Virtual Currency Case Study: Prediction Markets David M. Pennock Yahoo! Research.
1 Yahoo! Research Overview Marcus Fontoura Prabhakar Raghavan, Head.
© newsfutures 1 Prediction Markets: Collective Work Prediction Markets Collective Work Emile Servan-Schreiber, PhD NewsFutures.
Prediction Markets & Information Aggregation Yiling Chen, Harvard SEAS.
Common Stocks Stock that ordinarily has no preference in the matter of dividends or assets and represents the residual ownership of a corporate business.
A Heuristic Bidding Strategy for Multiple Heterogeneous Auctions Patricia Anthony & Nicholas R. Jennings Dept. of Electronics and Computer Science University.
Does Money Matter? Emile Servan-Schreiber NewsFutures, Inc.
1 Information Markets & Decision Makers Yiling Chen Anthony Kwasnica Tracy Mullen Penn State University This research was supported by the Defense Advanced.
Prediction Markets: Tapping the Wisdom of Crowds Yiling Chen Yahoo! Research February 3, 2008.
Information Aggregation: Experiments and Industrial Applications Kay-Yut Chen HP Labs.
CPS Securities & Expressive Securities Markets Vincent Conitzer
1 Computation in a Distributed Information Market Joan Feigenbaum (Yale) Lance Fortnow (NEC Labs) David Pennock (Overture) Rahul Sami (Yale)
©2012 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. May not be scanned, copied or duplicated, or posted to a publicly accessible website, in whole or in part.
Economic Natural Selection David Easley Cornell University June 2007.
Zocalo and Prediction Markets Design Chris Hibbert Principal Investigator CommerceNet Prediction Markets Summit UCSF Mission Bay December 2, 2005.
Introduction to OpenXcell & AppN2O
S LIDE 1.1 The Language of Financial Markets Quiz Bowl Game Board Invest in This Potent Investments Index or Exchange Earn It Who am I? Financial Markets.
1 The Black-Scholes-Merton Model MGT 821/ECON 873 The Black-Scholes-Merton Model.
Equity Trading Game and Tutorial May 7, 2004 Directors: Sanjiv Parekh, John Kogel Assistant Directors: J.P. Carlucci, Andrew Lisy, Juthica Mallela, Raja.
Research Computational Aspects of Prediction Markets David M. Pennock, Yahoo! Research Yiling Chen, Lance Fortnow, Joe Kilian, Evdokia Nikolova, Rahul.
A limit order market is a real world institution for characterizing the financial sector, and it is also a paradigm for describing trading mechanisms more.
An Example: Buying and Selling on a Market (Instructions) In the following experiment you are either a buyer or a seller. The experiment is partitioned.
Economics of Information
Research Prediction Markets and the Wisdom of Crowds David Pennock, Yahoo! Research Joint with: Yiling Chen, Varsha Dani, Lance Fortnow, Ryan Fugger, Brian.
A tractable combinatorial market maker using constraint generation MIROSLAV DUDÍK, SEBASTIEN LAHAIE, DAVID M. PENNOCK Microsoft Research Thanks: David.
Equity Trading Game and Tutorial Sanjiv Parekh, John Kogel September 19, 2003.
1 BM410: Investments Portfolio Construction 2: Market Anomalies and Portfolio Tilts.
Is It a Puzzle, Or Is It a Mystery? Three Tools For Solving Mysteries…… with The Wisdom of Crowds David E. Schnedler
Good Afternoon – 10/18/05. Review from last time Behavioral finance and technical analysis A yahoo example Begin Chapters 14 – 18 – Fed stuff.
Equity & Options Trading Game and Tutorial For SEBC May 8, 2004 Sanjiv Parekh.
Research Combinatorial Betting David Pennock Joint with: Yiling Chen, Lance Fortnow, Sharad Goel, Joe Kilian, Nicolas Lambert, Eddie Nikolova, Mike Wellman,
App Development by Platform.  $$$ Profit  Windows 8  Ubuntu  Android  Mac  iOS.
© 2010 IBM Corporation 1 day contest for TUKE students Finance and Planning Center Bratislava.
Prediction Markets at Google MIS 501. Googles: Prediction Markets What are Prediction Markets? –What are their components? –How do they work? –What is.
FBD Holdings plc 2007 Interim Results August 2007 A.
Fixed Income Trading Game and Tutorial For SEBC May 8, 2004 Sanjiv Parekh.
BizWiz Lesson 6 Investment Teams. What are investment teams?  Group of people  Agree to combine their money  Goal is financial gain  Buy stocks, bonds,
Government and the Economy Chapter 23. Roles of the Government Providing public goods Maintaining Competition Regulating market Activity.
Just Don’t Do It Minority Games and the Stock Market.
Managing a large accountAdWords API. Google AdWords API. Want a more tailored AdWords Account? Here’s an automatic solution.
Marketing Strategies Chapter 7. What is Marketing Process of planning & executing the conception, pricing, promo, and distribution of ideas, goods and.
Market Madness: Implementing a 9.2 quintillion outcome prediction market David Pennock.
1 Computation in a Distributed Information Market Joan Feigenbaum (Yale) Lance Fortnow (NEC Labs) David Pennock (Overture) Rahul Sami (Yale) To appear.
T H E F I R S T A N N U A L E – B U S I N E S S A P P L I C A T I O N C O N F R E N C E P A R I SFEBRUARY 1 1 – 1 5, N E W O R L E A N SF E B R.
1 1 Ch20&21 – MBA 566 Options Option Basics Option strategies Put-call parity Binomial option pricing Black-Scholes Model.
An Introduction to Prediction Markets (a.k.a. Idea Futures, Decision Markets, Information Markets, and Event Markets) alex kirtland / UsableMarkets 25.
Bid, Ask and Transaction Prices in a Specialist Market with Heterogeneously Informed Trades Lawrence Glosten Paul Milgrom.
Copyright © 2002 Pearson Education, Inc. Slide 10-1.
High Frequency Trading Chapter One Supplement. What is it? HFT – Algo trading – Auto market maker – Program Trading Fast trading – How quickly By micro.
Chapter 1 Introduction to Social Commerce. Learning Objectives 1.Define social computing and the Social Web. 2.Describe the Social Web revolution. 3.Describe.
Middle School Math High School Math Carmela Bertrand Rippon Middle School.
Google AdWords API. Want a more tailored AdWords Account
About us Expert Technologies has been delivering software solutions for enterprise and middle market customers across multiple target industries.
US Election Prediction Markets: Applications of Parimutuel Call Auction Mechanisms Mark Peters November 25, /22/2018.
Prediction Markets Collective Work
CH14 Operating-Income-Based Valuation
Presentation transcript:

Prediction Markets at Yahoo! David Pennock Yiling Chen, Tej Kasturi, Havi Hoffman, Dan Reeves Chao-Hsien Chu, Sandip Debnath, Mike Dooley, Rael Dornfest, Joan Fiegenbaum, Gary Flake, Lance Fortnow, Brian Galebach, Lee Giles, Joe Kilian, Steve Lawrence, Bernard Mangold, Tracy Mullen, Rahul Sami, Emile Servan-Schreiber, Michael Wellman, Justin Wolfers

Prediction Y! *not to scale microeconomicsprediction markets

Prediction Y! DesignBuildAnalyze HSX NF TS WSEX FX PS

Case Study I Design Analyze Dynamic parimutuel –Market maker –Cross btw stock market and horse race betting Build

Parimutuel market

Dynamic parimutuel market C(1,2)=2.2 C(2,2)=2.8 C(2,3)=3.6 C(2,4)=4.5 C(2,5)=5.4 C(2,6)=6.3 C(2,7)=7.3 C(2,8)=8.2 C(3,8)=8.5 C(4,8)=8.9 C(5,8)=9.4 Share-ratio cost function: C(q 1,q 2 )= q 1 2 +q 2 2 Properties No arbitrage price i /price j = q i /q j price i < $1 payoff if right = C/q o > $1

Research Share-ratio price function One can view DPM as a market maker Cost Function: Price Function: Properties No arbitrage price i /price j = q i /q j price i < $1 payoff if right = C(Q final )/q o > $1

Yahoo!,OReilly launched Buzz Game Research testbed for investigating search futures Buy stock in hundreds of technologies Earn dividends based on actual search buzz API interface Exchange mechanism is new Yahoo!R invention Cross btw stock market and horse race betting

Technology forecasts iPod phone Google Calendar Another Apple unveiling 10/12; iPod Video search buzz price 9/8-9/18: searches for iPod phone soar; early buyers profit 8/29: Apple invites press to secret unveiling 8/28: buzz gamers begin bidding up iPod phone 9/7: Apple announces Rokr 9am 10/5

Forecast Accuracy Average forecast error across 352 stocks end of phase 1 contest period forecast error rapidly declines as traders zero in on correct predictions

Early Lessons Learned Forecasts point in right direction Market closing deadline focuses traders Dividend levels matter Intelligent strategies work –Randomized bots lost money to real traders –Contest winner followed optimal buzz trading strategy (prices buzz); Went from 4 th to 1 st place in final days –Forecast error does decrease over time

Analysis

Design | Delivery | Operations | Analysis Highly Customized Solutions Business-value markets since 2002, as covered in: Sample Customers « Trading uncertainty for collective wisdom » Prediction Market Competitive Forecasting TM Idea Pageant TM One Platform – Many Solutions

Whats next? What the buzz game thinks will grow –Web app framewks: Ruby on Rails –VOIP: Skype –Blinkx Desktop Search –Blog Services: WordPress –AJAXframeworks: scriptaculous –Linux: Ubuntu

Case Study II DesignBuild Yootopia: Y!Internal economy for favors, predictions, grp decisions Analyze

More Design Betting mechanisms –Combinatorics –Infinite/continuous –Linear programming backbone Market makers Applications BuildAnalyze Computational complexity Does money matter? Wisdom of crowds: Combining experts IOU social network Ledger system Buzz Game: Tech stock horse race