Why Engineers are Especially Vulnerable to Claims and Common Mistakes to Avoid. Timothy D. Woodward Forizs & Dogali, P.A. 2012 Transpo Conference October.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Legal Issues for Arizona Design Professionals January 25, 2007 Dennis I. Wilenchik Tyler Q. Swensen.
Advertisements

Home Owners Insurance Basics What is it and why do we need it.
Giving and Receiving Feedback
Social Media for Business IFSA March Considering Your Options.
Word List A.
Civil & criminal law Civil Law.
It was mid-year, I’d say around November when I would have to face the consequences of a life time. I was off on my own a lot more and having fun. More.
WHAT SHOULD YOU DO IF YOU THINK YOUR DISTRICT MAY BE SUED? Crotzer & Ormsby, LLC 130 S. Bemiston, Suite 300 Clayton, MO
And some other tips. Society of Government Travel Professionals Educational Conference September 5, 2012 Washington DC Tim Hay State of Oregon.
Immunity to Change, Lisa Lahey, Ed.D. Leader as Reader ™ Virtual Book Club for ILA Members May 11, 2012 mindsatwork.com The Leader as Reader ™ is a trademark.
HELPING YOUR COMMUNITY WITHOUT ENGAGING IN THE UNAUTHORIZED PRACTICE OF LAW.
+ HEALTH INSURANCE: UNDERSTANDING YOUR COVERAGE Navigator Name Blank County Extension UGA Health Navigators.
Andrew J. Chávez NMSBA - Master Board Member Candidate 2012 NMSBA Leadership Retreat.
2 Breakout Session #104 Tom Reid Chief Problem Solver Certified Contracting Solutions, LLC Louisville, CO April 15, :45.
Telling lies * Things to think about * What are lies?
Law I Chapter 18.
Litigation and Alternatives for Settling Civil Disputes CHAPTER FIVE.
Chapter 16 Lesson 1 Civil and Criminal Law.
Contracts and Communication John G. Huisman Fleissner Davis and Johnson
INTERNATIONAL MARINE CLAIMS CONFERENCE 2004 BILL MILLIKEN HAYDEN AND MILLIKEN P.A. FLORIDA.
Jeffrey W. Puryear WOMACK, LANDIS, PHELPS & McNEILL.
Chapter 25 So You Want to Be a Lawyer: Economics and the Law Copyright © 2010 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.McGraw-Hill/Irwin.
Cooperative Extension Support Staff Workshop Professionalism in Today’s Workplace October 2006 Lorie A. Smith, Training and Organizational Development.
What a Company Needs (Essentials) and Why in the Start- up Phase of Growth – and What They can Expect as They Become Successful Marc Honorof Costello Insurance.
Risky Business: Understanding Risk Management and Malpractice Protection Webinar March 27,
STATEN ISLAND PERSONAL INJURY LAWYERS A personal injury lawyer in Toronto provides legal representation to those people claiming that they have been injured.
Continuity Clinic Liability Insurance 101 Modified from information on
Risk Management & Insurance
Career Jump Start Class Mr. Work Based Period 4
Insurance Questions.
OUR ATTORNEY LEGAL AND INSURANCE ISSUES
Part I Sources of Corrections Law. Chapter 4 - Going to Court Introduction – Chapter provides information on appearing in court, either as a witness or.
Chapter 6. When do you need a lawyer It is critical to know when to call an attorney It is not the job of law enforcement to advocate for you if you are.
Lawyers. Some background info There are more than 1 million lawyers in the U.S. Most lawyers rarely go to court –They give advice, negotiate settlements,
The Court System Chapter 5.
Negligent Hiring/ Negligent Retention
ATTITUDE. Not-My-Job Nathan Back Stabbin’ Brian.
Settling Disputes Chapter 4. Conflict Natural part of everyday life - inevitable Natural part of everyday life - inevitable –Some type of unfriendly encounter.
Survive and Thrive Your First Three Years Presenter: Jerrod Elmar.
NAEP AUSTIN TX APRIL 8, AGENDA  Why we want certificates.  Types of insurance and limits  How to read a certificate.
Frequently Asked Questions about Strikes and Job Security If the union gets in here I can’t ever lose my job because the union will get it back for me.
What You Should Know About INSURANCE Created by Matt Wagner.
Joe Ferguson Mrs. Miller Career Tech Foundation 5/8/14 3 rd Hour.
Insurance Terms Business Essentials. Term Insurance An insurance policy that provides coverage for a limited period, the value payable only if a loss.
Torts.
Contracting Tips… especially for very small businesses Gene Stout – Gene Stout and Associates.
Building A Positive Attitude “ A little ability combined with a positive attitude often goes further than a great talent teamed with a negative viewpoint.
The Claire Davis Safety Act What does it mean for Charters?
INSURANCE Terms and Overview Created in part by The Texas Department of Insurance.
RISK MANAGEMENT ISSUES AND CONTRACTUAL OBLIGATIONS Curt Sumner, LS Executive Director, ACSM.
Chapter 16.1 Civil Cases. Types of Civil Lawsuits In civil cases the plaintiff – the party bringing the lawsuit – claims to have suffered a loss and usually.
Analyzing A Medical Malpractice Case. Who Drives the Litigation Machine? Plaintiffs' lawyers have the burden of finding and bringing the cases Running.
© 2013 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. Ch 6 Defenses to Liability Suits.
What is a PEO and how can they help my business? THE PEO EMPEROR SOLUTION ! THE PEO EMPEROR SOLUTION !
Reptile Theory in Insurance Coverage and Bad Faith Litigation
TOPIC G: CLIENTS’ RIGHTS 2016 P.R. Prof. Janicke.
CHAPTER 14, 14-2 Insurable Risks.
Attorney is another name for a Lawyer. There are more than 1 million lawyers in the United States –More than 70% have their own private practice –10%
© 3M All Rights Reserved. The Legal Ramifications of Errors in Patient Care 3M™ Attest™ Sterile U Web Meeting November 19, 2009.
Chapter 1 Choosing Which Debts to Pay First. First Steps to Dealing with Debt Problems Most people in financial distress will first want to deal with.
What We Will Talk About Today Terms – Mortgage, Lien, Foreclosure, Lender, Servicer Foreclosure Alternatives –Bankruptcy, Obama’s Plan, Deed in Lieu of.
TORTS: A CIVIL WRONG Chapter 18. TORTS: A CIVIL WRONG Under criminal law, wrongs committed are called crimes. Under civil law, wrongs committed are called.
Contemporary Legal and Ethical Challenges in Counseling Law and Ethics in Counseling Conference 2016 New Orleans, Louisiana.
Homeowners Insurance: Coverage & Claims
Calgary RIMS Chapter Meeting March 1, :00 am-9:00 am
Reasons You Need An Attorney After A Car Accident.
Explain the nature of liability insurance
Claims handling costs and quality of experts
Homeowners Insurance: Coverage & Claims
Differences and similarities
Presentation transcript:

Why Engineers are Especially Vulnerable to Claims and Common Mistakes to Avoid. Timothy D. Woodward Forizs & Dogali, P.A Transpo Conference October 30, 2012

Who am I? A lawyer who deals with this everyday Lawyers Perspective Practical Tips

Am I YOUR lawyer? Not forming Attorney/Client relationship here today

Why are claims for engineering malpractice/negligence common? Your insurance is different It is easy to take advantage of engineer’s natural instincts Defense is usually technical and confusing to non-engineer jurors The law is bad for engineers in Florida

Can engineers be sued for professional negligence by someone other than their client? Yes Florida has expanded risk for engineers. It is open season in any type of claim so long as it was “foreseeable” that claimant could be damaged

Can Florida engineers protect themselves by using limitation of liability provisions? Yes and No, but mostly No Only ever applied to claims from your client Newer law says probably enforceable for company, but not for individuals…which means it is essentially useless Law is in state of flux

The Question You Should Be Asking Yourself! So... if this Woodward guy is right and I am: (1)exposed to professional negligence claims by everybody and their brother; (2)I can’t enforce a limitation of liability provision in my contract (even if I were lucky enough to find a client who would agree to it); (3)my insurance is like a claims magnet; and

The Question You Should Be Asking Yourself! (4)I am genetically predisposed to be an easy mark for Plaintiff’s lawyers, then what are some things I can do to help myself... even just a little?

Report the Claim Report the claim to your in house lawyers and/or insurance company ASAP If you have to think about whether you should, then the answer is Yes Set up a claim number or give it a name Practical reasons for this: Privilege, Coverage, Defense Costs

Appoint Appoint somebody internally in charge of claim management Unworkable, costly, stupid, inefficient and counterproductive to have too many cooks in the kitchen

Remove Anybody with a personality conflict should be reassigned or minimized Use the Appointed person to control further substantive communications

Support Don’t vote the engineer (or subconsultant) who s/s the plans off the island Don’t allow negativity Drama = You Losing Money

Demand Demand to have the right people in the right places Don’t just take an insurance company’s word for it when they “assign” you a lawyer they tell you is a “bulldog” You should recommend or at least endorse experts Truth is your insurance company wants profit

Preserve what you’ve got…now! Immediately inform records IT folks to preserve records in the file Big $$$ issue if lawsuit Sworn statement, especially of lower level employees or employees of subconsultants

Stay Awake! If continuing work on a Project, be very careful because it is a common practice for Owners to take advantage of your relationship. Examples  Asking for advice regarding a contractor’s claim or involvement with forensic analysis of “problem” (that might be your problem). Even if you don’t want to look down, you should know when you are walking on a tightrope.

Don’t be Afraid to Negotiate Always be willing to listen – you have the power of NO! First negotiations should be about rules of negotiations – engineers need to get comfortable with the logistics of the negotiation process Think outside the box regarding settlement Understand your insurance policy and get to know adjuster Before you try to settle know (1) your “upside” (rare) and (2) what a win will cost you in terms of money, time and reputation

Thank you for your time.