Scaling of Elliptic Flow for a fluid at Finite Shear Viscosity V. Greco M. Colonna M. Di Toro G. Ferini From the Coulomb Barrier to the Quark-Gluon Plasma,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
M. Oldenburg Probing QCD with High Energy Nuclear Collisions, Hirschegg, Austria, January Directed Flow in Au+Au Collisions Markus D. Oldenburg.
Advertisements

Multi-strange Hadron v2 and Partonic Collectivity
PID v2 and v4 from Au+Au Collisions at √sNN = 200 GeV at RHIC
Multi-Particle Azimuthal Correlations at RHIC !! Roy A. Lacey USB - Chem (SUNY Stony Brook ) What do they tell us about Possible Quenching?
Mass, Quark-number, Energy Dependence of v 2 and v 4 in Relativistic Nucleus- Nucleus Collisions Yan Lu University of Science and Technology of China Many.
R. Lacey, SUNY Stony Brook 1 Arkadij Taranenko Quark Matter 2006 November 13-20, Shanghai, China Nuclear Chemistry Group SUNY Stony Brook, USA PHENIX Studies.
R. Lacey, SUNY Stony Brook 1 Arkadij Taranenko Helmholtz International Summer School: “Dense Matter In Heavy Ion Collisions and Astrophysics” Dubna, Russia,
Marcus Bleicher, ISMD 2005 Elliptic and Radial Flow in High Energetic Nuclear Collisions Marcus Bleicher (& Xianglei Zhu) Institut für Theoretische Physik.
Marcus Bleicher, Berkeley, Oct Elliptic Flow in High Energetic Nuclear Collisions Marcus Bleicher & Xianglei Zhu FIAS & Institut für Theoretische.
W. A. Horowitz Quark Matter 2005 A Promising Solution to the Elliptic Quench Puzzle at RHIC William A. Horowitz Columbia University August 4-5, 2005.
Supported by DOE 11/22/2011 QGP viscosity at RHIC and LHC energies 1 Huichao Song 宋慧超 Seminar at the Interdisciplinary Center for Theoretical Study, USTC.
TJH: ISMD 2005, 8/9-15 Kromeriz, Czech Republic TJH: 1 Experimental Results at RHIC T. Hallman Brookhaven National Laboratory ISMD Kromeriz, Czech Republic.
Effects of Bulk Viscosity on p T -Spectra and Elliptic Flow Parameter Akihiko Monnai Department of Physics, The University of Tokyo, Japan Collaborator:
First Alice Physics Week, Erice, Dec 4  9, Heavy  Flavor (c,b) Collectivity at RHIC and LHC Kai Schweda, University of Heidelberg A. Dainese,
ISMD’05, Kromeriz, Aug 09  15, Heavy  Flavor (c,b) Collectivity – Light  Flavor (u,d,s) Thermalization at RHIC Kai Schweda, University of Heidelberg.
1Erice 2012, Roy A. Lacey, Stony Brook University.
Phase transition of hadronic matter in a non-equilibrium approach Graduate Days, Frankfurt, , Hannah Petersen, Universität Frankfurt.
First Results From a Hydro + Boltzmann Hybrid Approach DPG-Tagung, Darmstadt, , Hannah Petersen, Universität Frankfurt.
DNP03, Tucson, Oct 29, Kai Schweda Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory for the STAR collaboration Hadron Yields, Hadrochemistry, and Hadronization.
Nu XuInternational Conference on Strangeness in Quark Matter, UCLA, March , 20061/20 Search for Partonic EoS in High-Energy Nuclear Collisions Nu.
Roy A. Lacey, Stony Brook; 24 th Winter Workshop on Nuclear Dynamics, April 5-12, Roy A. Lacey Prospects for locating the QCD Critical End Point.
Marcus Bleicher, WWND 2008 A fully integrated (3+1) dimensional Hydro + Boltzmann Hybrid Approach Marcus Bleicher Institut für Theoretische Physik Goethe.
Collective Flow Effects and Energy Loss in ultrarelativistic Heavy Ion Collisions Zhe Xu USTC, Hefei, July 11, 2008 with A. El, O. Fochler, C. Greiner.
Space time evolution of QCD matter Parton cascade with stochastic algorithm Transport rates and momentum isotropization Thermalization of gluons due to.
The centrality dependence of elliptic flow Jean-Yves Ollitrault, Clément Gombeaud (Saclay), Hans-Joachim Drescher, Adrian Dumitru (Frankfurt) nucl-th/
WWND, San Diego1 Scaling Characteristics of Azimuthal Anisotropy at RHIC Michael Issah SUNY Stony Brook for the PHENIX Collaboration.
Perfect Fluid: flow measurements are described by ideal hydro Problem: all fluids have some viscosity -- can we measure it? I. Radial flow fluctuations:
Viscous hydrodynamics DPF 2009 Huichao Song The Ohio State University Supported by DOE 07/30/2009 July 27-July 31, Detroit, MI with shear and bulk viscosity.
University of Catania INFN-LNS Heavy flavor Suppression : Langevin vs Boltzmann S. K. Das, F. Scardina V. Greco, S. Plumari.
Strange and Charm Probes of Hadronization of Bulk Matter at RHIC International Symposium on Multi-Particle Dynamics Aug 9-15, 2005 Huan Zhong Huang University.
Nonequilibrium Dynamics in Astrophysics and Material Science YITP, Kyoto, Japan, Oct. 31-Nov. 3, 2011 Tetsufumi Hirano Sophia Univ./the Univ. of Tokyo.
Collective Flow in Heavy-Ion Collisions Kirill Filimonov (LBNL)
Longitudinal de-correlation of anisotropic flow in Pb+Pb collisions Victor Roy ITP Goethe University Frankfurt In collaboration with L-G Pang, G-Y Qin,
Workshop for Particle Correlations and Femtoscopy 2011
November 18, Shanghai Anomalous Viscosity of an Expanding Quark-Gluon Plasma Masayuki ASAKAWA Department of Physics, Osaka University S. A.
M. Oldenburg Strange Quark Matter 2006 — March 26–31, Los Angeles, California 1 Centrality Dependence of Azimuthal Anisotropy of Strange Hadrons in 200.
Flow fluctuation and event plane correlation from E-by-E Hydrodynamics and Transport Model Victor Roy Central China Normal University, Wuhan, China Collaborators.
Does HBT interferometry probe thermalization? Clément Gombeaud, Tuomas Lappi and J-Y Ollitrault IPhT Saclay WPCF 2009, CERN, October 16, 2009.
Partial thermalization, a key ingredient of the HBT Puzzle Clément Gombeaud CEA/Saclay-CNRS Quark-Matter 09, April 09.
Masashi Kaneta, First joint Meeting of the Nuclear Physics Divisions of APS and JPS 1 / Masashi Kaneta LBNL
Peter Kolb, November 18, 2003Momentum Anisotropies1 Momentum Anisotropies -- Probing the detailed Dynamics Department of Physics and Astronomy State University.
Scaling of Elliptic Flow for a fluid at Finite Shear Viscosity V. Greco M. Colonna M. Di Toro G. Ferini From the Coulomb Barrier to the Quark-Gluon Plasma,
Elliptic flow and shear viscosity in a parton cascade approach G. Ferini INFN-LNS, Catania P. Castorina, M. Colonna, M. Di Toro, V. Greco.
Results from an Integrated Boltzmann+Hydrodynamics Approach WPCF 2008, Krakau, Jan Steinheimer-Froschauer, Universität Frankfurt.
School of Collective Dynamics in High-Energy CollisionsLevente Molnar, Purdue University 1 Effect of resonance decays on the extracted kinetic freeze-out.
Roy A. Lacey, Stony Brook, ISMD, Kromĕříž, Roy A. Lacey What do we learn from Correlation measurements at RHIC.
Multi-Parton Dynamics at RHIC Huan Zhong Huang Department of Physics and Astronomy University of California Los University Oct
24 Nov 2006 Kentaro MIKI University of Tsukuba “electron / photon flow” Elliptic flow measurement of direct photon in √s NN =200GeV Au+Au collisions at.
Kirill Filimonov, ISMD 2002, Alushta 1 Kirill Filimonov Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory Anisotropy and high p T hadrons in Au+Au collisions at RHIC.
Squaw Valley, Feb. 2013, Roy A. Lacey, Stony Brook University Take home message  The scaling (p T, ε, R, ∆L, etc) properties of azimuthal anisotropy.
Intermediate pT results in STAR Camelia Mironov Kent State University 2004 RHIC & AGS Annual Users' Meeting Workshop on Strangeness and Exotica at RHIC.
June 4, Tokyo Anomalous Viscosity of an Expanding Quark-Gluon Plasma Masayuki ASAKAWA Department of Physics, Osaka University S. A. Bass,
Flow and Dissipation in Ultrarelativistic Heavy Ion Collisions September 16 th 2009, ECT* Italy Akihiko Monnai Department of Physics, The University of.
Hadron Spectra and Yields Experimental Overview Julia Velkovska INT/RHIC Winter Workshop, Dec 13-15, 2002.
1 Roy A. Lacey, Stony Brook University; ICFP 2012, June, Crete, Greece Essential Question  Do recent measurements at RHIC & the LHC, give new insights.
Comparisons between hydrodynamics and transport calculations Zhe Xu WPCF, Krakow, Sept. 11, 2008.
Production, energy loss and elliptic flow of heavy quarks at RHIC and LHC Jan Uphoff with O. Fochler, Z. Xu and C. Greiner Hard Probes 2010, Eilat October.
R. Lacey, SUNY Stony Brook 1 Arkadij Taranenko XVIII Baldin ISHEPP September 25-30, JINR Dubna Nuclear Chemistry Group SUNY Stony Brook, USA Scaling Properties.
What do the scaling characteristics of elliptic flow reveal about the properties of the matter at RHIC ? Michael Issah Stony Brook University for the PHENIX.
Duke University 野中 千穂 Hadron production in heavy ion collision: Fragmentation and recombination in Collaboration with R. J. Fries (Duke), B. Muller (Duke),
Workshop on Modeling of the Parton-Hadron Phase Transition The Summary
The puzzling relation between the RAA and the v2 for heavy mesons in a Boltzmann and in a Langevin approach F. Scardina, S.K. Das, S. Plumari, V.Greco.
Hydro + Cascade Model at RHIC
Collective Dynamics at RHIC
Anisotropic flow at RHIC: How unique is the NCQ scaling ?
Quantifying the properties of Hot QCD Matter – INT Seattle, July 2010
Outline First of all, there’s too much data!! BRAHMS PHOBOS PHENIX
Introduction of Heavy Ion Physics at RHIC
What have we learned from Anisotropic Flow at RHIC ?
Dipartimento Interateneo di Fisica, Bari (Italy)
Presentation transcript:

Scaling of Elliptic Flow for a fluid at Finite Shear Viscosity V. Greco M. Colonna M. Di Toro G. Ferini From the Coulomb Barrier to the Quark-Gluon Plasma, Erice (Sicily) 22 Sept University of Catania INFN-LNS

 Reminder of v 2 at RHIC  Evidences for non-ideal hydrodynamics  Transport approach with only 2  2 scatterings  /s  time dependent cross section renormalized to fix  /s v 2 (p T )/ v 2 (p T )/   Relation between v 2 (p T )/ and v 2 (p T )/  scaling ?  effects of freeze-out  /s  Relation of  /s with coalescence (QNS)  /s hints at  /s < 3/4  + coalescence at intermediate p T Outline Momentum anisotropy measure of  /s Ferini et al., [nucl-th]

A measure of the Interaction: Elliptic Flow x y z pxpx pypy v 2 is the 2nd harmonic Fourier coeff. of the distribution of particles. Perform a Fourier expansion of the momentum space particle distributions Free streaming v 2 =0 The analysis can be extended ! Good probe of early pressure c 2 s =dP/d  CASCADE  =10 mb Similar trend in hydro  

Hydrodynamics No microscopic details (mean free path -> 0,  =0) + EoS Parton cascade v 2 saturation pattern reproduced Large  =10-15mb (coalesc.includ.) Good description of hadron spectra and v 2 (p T ) Mass ordering of v 2 versus p T D. Molnar & M. Gyulassy, NPA 697 (02) First stage of RHIC Parton elastic 2  2 interactions

It’s not that perfect …  Is it really zero ideal hydro (zero shear viscosity) ? B. I. Abelev et al., (STAR), PRC77 (08) STAR, J. Phys. G34 (2007) Not too peripheral Not too high p T Not too high harmonics

Relation between   x  and v 2 Ideal Hydrodynamics Ideal Hydrodynamics: Independent of - impact parameter - system size Bhalerao et al., PLB627(2005) 2v   time Effect of finite  s ?! Data show evidence for deviation from hydro scaling v 2 /  Hydrodynamics GeV STAR, PRC77(08)

Small viscosity  Large cross sections  Strong couplings  beyond pQCD Shear Viscosity 1)Quantum mechanism  s > 1/15 : R. Lacey et al., PRL99(2006) 2) 4 SYM + Gauge theory g  ∞: Smaller than any other known fluid! Can we constrain  /s with v 2 ? Kinetic Theory

Study of dissipative effects on Study of dissipative effects on How sensitive is elliptic flow to finite  /s? Z. Xu & C. Greiner, PRL 101(08) Agreement for  s =0.3 – 0.6  /s=0.15 – 0.08 Dependence on freeze-out Viscous HydroCascade ( 2 2,2 3 ) P. Romatschke, PRL99 (07) Dependence on   relaxation time II 0 order expansion with green terms ( D. Rischke )

Transport approach Solved discretizing the space in  x, y   cells Collision integral not solved with the geometrical interpretation, but with a local stochastic sampling Z. Xhu, C. Greiner, PRC71(04) In the limit  t  0 and  3 x  0 exact solutions of the Boltzmann equation Convergency of v 2 results tested against variable  t and  3 x discretization and test particle number. 3x3x

Cross section for fixed  /s Cross section for fixed  /s We simulate a constant shear viscosity during the HIC Relativistic Kinetic theory Cascade code We have used pQCD-like cross section with screening mass The viscosity is kept constant varying  s  = cell index in the r-space

Evolution of cross section with Temperature A rough estimate of  (T) can be done using Neglecting  and inserting in (*) At T=200 MeV  tr  10 mb In our code it is evaluated locally (different from D. Molnar arXiV: ) (*)

Elliptic flow sensitive to the Shear Viscosity 200 AGeV b=9 fm b=7 fm b=5 fm b=3 fm Sensitivity increasing at larger p T Intermediate p T can say more about  /s  50% increase

“strong evidence for hydrodynamic scaling of v 2 over a broad selection of the elliptic flow data” Does v 2 / scaling validate ideal hydro? PHENIX PRL 98, (2007) Scaling with Centrality and System Size Such scalings holds also at finite viscosity?  Scaling outside the hydro region

v 2 /  and v 2 / as a function of p T bothboth  Scaling for both v 2 / and v 2 /  for both Au+Au and Cu+Cu  Small  /s does not break v 2 /  the scaling  Agreement with PHENIX data for v 2 / Violation of the scaling at higher  /s  /s  1/4  closer to data, but… Au+Au & AGeV  /s=1/2   /s=1/ 

PHENIX, PRL98 (2007) Of course it is more complex… STAR, PRC77 (2008)  v 2 /  does not scale! Can a cascade approach account for this? Freeze-out is crucial! v 2 / scales!

Elliptic flow sensitive to freeze out Effect of freeze-out increasing with b For  <  c =0.7 GeV/fm 3 collisions are switched off b=3 fm  /s=1/4  Effect of freeze-out

v 2 /  and v 2 / with freeze-out V 2 /   V 2 /  broken in a way similar to STAR data  Agreement with PHENIX and STAR scaling of v 2 /  The freeze-out lowers the V 2 (p T ) at higher p T … (about 40% in b=3-9 fm) No freeze-out  /s=1/4  v 2 /  scaling brokenv 2 / scaling kept! Cascade can get both features:

Short Reminder … Enhancement of v 2 Quark Number Scaling Molnar and Voloshin, PRL91 (03) Fries-Nonaka-Muller-Bass, PRC68(03) Considering only momentum space x - p correlation neglected narrow wave function  v 2 for baryon is larger and saturates at higher p T v 2q fitted from v 2  GKL, PRC68(03) v 2q (p T ) fitted. Is it reasonable the v 2 needed by coalescence?

v 2 (p T ) as a measure of  /s v 2 / scaling reproduced, what about v 2 absolute value?   /s >3/4   too low v 2 (p T ) at p T  1.5 GeV/c  for quantitative estimate an EOS with phase transition (  ≠ 3p) needed!  lower the estimate the  /s PHENIX  /s  freeze-out Open the room to need coalescence in the region of QNS Finite  /s  shape for v 2 (p T ) consistent with that needed by coalescence

Freeze-out with  /s from QGP  HG Smooth transition of  /s from minimal value (1/4  ) to the value typical of a pion-kaon gas (7/4  ) Previous results with sudden freeze-out confirmed  GeV/fm 3 ]  /s 1/4  8/4   HG QGP   = 0.7GeV/fm 3 Preliminary

 v 2 / (  ) scaling holds at finite  /s up to  0.15  Freeze-out at    =0.7 GeV/fm 3 or   /s change from 1/4   7/4  (in cross-over region): Transport at finite  /s pave the way for consistency:  breaking of v 2 (p T )/  scaling  persistence of v 2 (p T )/ scaling  v 2 (p T ) need presence of coalescence at p T > 1.5 GeV with  /s<3/4  Summary