Valley Import Constraint John Dumas 1. Objective Establish an appropriate Shadow Price for the Valley Import limit – Consistent with the methodology established.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 Radio Maria World. 2 Postazioni Transmitter locations.
Advertisements

Números.
Bill Blevins Management of the West-North Stability Limit Under the Nodal Market.
Trend for Precision Soil Testing % Zone or Grid Samples Tested compared to Total Samples.
Trend for Precision Soil Testing % Zone or Grid Samples Tested compared to Total Samples.
AGVISE Laboratories %Zone or Grid Samples – Northwood laboratory
Trend for Precision Soil Testing % Zone or Grid Samples Tested compared to Total Samples.
Real GDP USs Real GDP EUs Real GDP Japans Real GDP.
3.6 Support Vector Machines
/ /17 32/ / /
Reflection nurulquran.com.
EuroCondens SGB E.
Worksheets.
Slide 1Fig 26-CO, p.795. Slide 2Fig 26-1, p.796 Slide 3Fig 26-2, p.797.
Addition and Subtraction Equations
1 When you see… Find the zeros You think…. 2 To find the zeros...
Add Governors Discretionary (1G) Grants Chapter 6.
CALENDAR.
Summative Math Test Algebra (28%) Geometry (29%)
2.11.
ASCII stands for American Standard Code for Information Interchange
Who Wants To Be A Millionaire? Decimal Edition Question 1.
The 5S numbers game..
1 Credit Cards Avoid the Minimum Payments Trap! 3% examples Revised November 2012.
突破信息检索壁垒 -SciFinder Scholar 介绍
A Fractional Order (Proportional and Derivative) Motion Controller Design for A Class of Second-order Systems Center for Self-Organizing Intelligent.
Sampling in Marketing Research
Break Time Remaining 10:00.
The basics for simulations
PP Test Review Sections 6-1 to 6-6
The Pecan Market How long will prices stay this high?? Brody Blain Vice – President.
MM4A6c: Apply the law of sines and the law of cosines.
Figure 3–1 Standard logic symbols for the inverter (ANSI/IEEE Std
MCQ Chapter 07.
1 Prediction of electrical energy by photovoltaic devices in urban situations By. R.C. Ott July 2011.
TCCI Barometer March “Establishing a reliable tool for monitoring the financial, business and social activity in the Prefecture of Thessaloniki”
Progressive Aerobic Cardiovascular Endurance Run
Visual Highway Data Select a highway below... NORTH SOUTH Salisbury Southern Maryland Eastern Shore.
Charging at 120 and 240 Volts 120-Volt Portable Vehicle Charge Cord 240-Volt Home Charge Unit.
Area under curves Consider the curve y = f(x) for x  [a, b] The actual area under the curve is units 2 The approximate area is the sum of areas.
Making Landmark or Friendly Numbers. Category 1 Designed to be one away from a landmark or friendly number.
MaK_Full ahead loaded 1 Alarm Page Directory (F11)
TCCI Barometer September “Establishing a reliable tool for monitoring the financial, business and social activity in the Prefecture of Thessaloniki”
When you see… Find the zeros You think….
2011 WINNISQUAM COMMUNITY SURVEY YOUTH RISK BEHAVIOR GRADES 9-12 STUDENTS=1021.
Before Between After.
2011 FRANKLIN COMMUNITY SURVEY YOUTH RISK BEHAVIOR GRADES 9-12 STUDENTS=332.
Slide R - 1 Copyright © 2009 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Pearson Prentice Hall Active Learning Lecture Slides For use with Classroom Response.
Subtraction: Adding UP
: 3 00.
5 minutes.
Numeracy Resources for KS2
1 Non Deterministic Automata. 2 Alphabet = Nondeterministic Finite Accepter (NFA)
Static Equilibrium; Elasticity and Fracture
ANALYTICAL GEOMETRY ONE MARK QUESTIONS PREPARED BY:
Converting a Fraction to %
Resistência dos Materiais, 5ª ed.
Clock will move after 1 minute
Lial/Hungerford/Holcomb/Mullins: Mathematics with Applications 11e Finite Mathematics with Applications 11e Copyright ©2015 Pearson Education, Inc. All.
Congestion Management Settlement Credits December, 2002.
Select a time to count down from the clock above
1 Dr. Scott Schaefer Least Squares Curves, Rational Representations, Splines and Continuity.
1 Non Deterministic Automata. 2 Alphabet = Nondeterministic Finite Accepter (NFA)
Introduction Embedded Universal Tools and Online Features 2.
úkol = A 77 B 72 C 67 D = A 77 B 72 C 67 D 79.
Schutzvermerk nach DIN 34 beachten 05/04/15 Seite 1 Training EPAM and CANopen Basic Solution: Password * * Level 1 Level 2 * Level 3 Password2 IP-Adr.
January 21, 2010 Security Constrained Economic Dispatch Resmi Surendran.
Congestion Management Work Group 2008 Overview CMWG Marguerite Wagner, Reliant Energy Inc.
Valley Import Constraint Resmi Surendran. Valley Import Constraint Range of SFs – to in valley area – 0.03 to outside valley area Not.
Presentation transcript:

Valley Import Constraint John Dumas 1

Objective Establish an appropriate Shadow Price for the Valley Import limit – Consistent with the methodology established in the Board Approved ERCOT Business Practice “Setting the Shadow Price Caps and Power Balance Penalties in Security Constrained Economic Dispatch” 2

Current Methodology 3.4 Methodology Outline The methodology for determination of maximal Shadow Prices for transmission constraints could be based on the following setting: (a)Determine Shift Factor efficiency threshold (default x%) – All generators in the valley have a shift factor of 0.95 or greater (b) Determine maximal LMP congestion component (default $y/MWh) – Non-competitive constraint therefore offer is limited to mitigated offer in the valley (c) Calculate maximal Shadow Price for transmission constraints: SP(max) = highest offer/lowest shift factor threshold (d) Determine Shift Factor cutoff threshold (default z%) – not applicable due to all generation in the valley having a very high shift factor impact on the import constraint (e) Evaluate settings on variety of SCED save cases. 3

Current Methodology For the network transmission constraints, the Shadow Price Cap may vary for each constraint, or may be a unique value applicable to all constraints, or may be values unique to subsets of the full constraint set. Generating units with small Shift Factors (i.e. below Shift Factor threshold) will not be as effective in resolving constraints as will generators with higher shift factors on the constraint. If there is no efficient generating units then Shadow Price must be increased to get enough contribution from inefficient units. Therefore, high Shadow Prices indicate inefficient congestion management. - All generators in the Valley have a very high shift factor impact on the Valley constraint therefore increasing the shadow price does not result in additional generation (i.e. all generators are at maximum output) 4

Valley Import Constraint Range of SFs – to in valley area – 0.03 to outside valley area Not a competitive constraint and hence the Resources are moved based on offers capped by higher of Reference LMP & Mitigated Offer Cap curve Base Case constraint are assigned the system- wide value of $5,000 per MWh for the Max Shadow Price 5

Price Related Factors Highest Shadow Price when observed when the Valley Import constraint is binding but not violated is less than $100/MWh (more than 16 hr in the first 4 months) – Constraint cannot be resolved many times even with all the generation available South LZ SPP when the constraint is violated ranges from $1500/MWh to $1850/MWh (more than 7 hr in the first 4 months) – Demand response in majority of that load zone with the high price has no impact on resolving the constraint violation. Constraint is managed by Operator action after it has been violated for more than an hour in SCED (roughly 43 hrs in the first 4 months) 6

Current Planning Process Ensures that all parts of the system are reliable based on the planning criteria Planning has reviewed the area and they are proposing solutions that will ensure that the valley area will be secure under the outage of a single element and a generator Preliminary planning studies with the TDSP show that there is possibility of increasing the limit on the interface in the short term, which should reduce the extent of dependence on the regional generator to meet the valley load. The planning process ensures that the area is secure for the next 5 years even without any import from the DC ties and considering the estimated load growth, planned generator outages for more than 6 months and other system changes The valley constraint will be overloaded in RT only outside the planning criteria. i.e. if the load is considerably higher and if there are multiple generator or line outages. 7

Hours of Binding/Violation DecemberJanuaryFebruaryMarchsumviolated hrs Hours active in SCED Hours binding in SCED Hours violated in SCED Hours with Violated & overridden Active in SCED – Constraint is passed to SCED Binding in SCED – Constraint is resolved by SCED – Flow = Limit Violated in SCED – Constraint was not resolved by SCED – Flow > Limit Violated & Overrriden – LDL was overriden and Flow > Limit Congestion Cost = (Flow MW * Shadow Price * 1/12) per 5 min

Congestion Cost DecemberJanuaryFebruaryMarchsumviolated hrs Hours active in SCED Hours binding in SCED Hours violated in SCED Hours with Violated & overridden SP*MW FlowDecemberJanuaryFebruaryMarchSumSum in SCED VALIMP binding in SCED$3,089.05$56,224.85$33,959.97$2,011.26($95, VALIMP violated in $46,640,833.33) = $46,736, Violated & SP5000$469,121.70$17,241,771.70$281,173,247.58$0.00$298,884, Violated & SP3000$281,473.02$10,345,063.02$168,703,948.55$0.00$179,330, Violated & SP2000$187,648.68$6,896,708.68$112,469,299.03$0.00$119,553, Violated & SP1000$93,824.34$3,448,354.34$56,234,649.52$0.00$59,776, Violated & SP500$46,912.17$1,724,177.17$28,117,324.76$0.00$29,888, Violated & SP350$32,838.52$1,206,924.02$19,682,127.33$0.00$20,921, Violated & overridden with 2 step limits $200 & $2000 MSP$18,764.87$1,465,179.63$97,588,665.34$0.00$99,072, Violated & overridden with 2 step limits $200 & $2000 MSP – One constraint at limit + margin with Max Shadow Price at $200 and another at limit with Max Shadow Price at $200 0

South Load Zone Extra Payment Average $/MW for hours when constraint was violated in SCED = ( )*( )=50.6* = $88, STLPNT_NAMEAVG(LMP) Average Load LZ_SOUTH$1, LZ_HOUSTON$ LZ_NORTH$ LZ_WEST$ Avg N H W$

ERCOT Proposed Max Shadow Price - $350/MWh Determine the highest Shadow Price cap necessary to fully utilize existing and potential new valley generation to relieve the overload The highest offer from a new resource with no verifiable cost that could be moved is – 14.5 heat rate* $10 FIP/ lowest SF = 14.5 *10 /0.95 ~ 150/MWh The highest offer from a new resource with verifiable cost that could be moved is – (high Heat Rate * $10 FIP + corresponding high O&M) * highest multiplier/ lowest SF – (14.5* )*1.5/0.95 ~ $350/MWh 11

Conclusion Current Business Practice – Establishes shadow price caps that can vary per constraint in order to dispatch generation efficiently – Gives latitude to increase the Shadow Price Caps if doing so would dispatch less efficient generation to help solve the constraint Current Planning Process – Ensures that enough transmission is built in order to maintains system security under the loss of one line and one generator scenario The recent real-time limit violations were due to multiple outages (outside the planning criteria) Demand response in the South Zone that is physically north of the constraint will not help resolve a Valley import limit 12