The Role of Wetland, Riparian, and Floodplain Water Storage in Montana’s Water Supply Initiative in the context of a warming climate Montana Wetland Council Meeting Lynda Saul, MDEQ Bruce Sims, USFS Bruce Sims, USFS

Values Wetlands feed downstream waters, mitigate floodwaters, recharge groundwater supplies, remove pollution, provide fish and wildlife habitat, and extend the periods of available water.

Climate Change Sets the Context global temperatures are increasing In 2010, global temperatures continued to rise. A new analysis from the Goddard Institute for Space Studies shows that 2010 tied with 2005 as the warmest year on record and was part of the warmest decade on record. (Image credit: NASA/Earth Observatory/Robert Simmon)

Glacial Retreat in Glacier National Park Predictions suggest all glaciers in Glacier National Park will have melted by Should the name then be changed to Glaciated National Park?

River flows in Montana depend mostly on snow pack, infiltration of melted snow into soil surfaces, and ground water movement to streams. Snow packs may be melting earlier. Snow packs may be melting earlier. Total water in the snow packs may be on the decline. Total water in the snow packs may be on the decline.

Throughout western United States – 72% of stations show a decline in April 1 snow water equivalent. Throughout western United States – 72% of stations show a decline in April 1 snow water equivalent. Klos et al., Indicators of Climate Change in Idaho: The intersection of biophysical change with social perception across a diverse landscape. Paper presented at the Pacific Northwest Climate Conference, Boise, Idaho, 10/02/2012. Klos et al., Indicators of Climate Change in Idaho: The intersection of biophysical change with social perception across a diverse landscape. Paper presented at the Pacific Northwest Climate Conference, Boise, Idaho, 10/02/2012. Snow Water Equivalent Trends Snow Water Equivalent Trends

Declining summer flows of Rocky Mountain rivers: Changing seasonal hydrology and probable impacts on Floodplain forests Steward B. Rood, Jason Pan, Karen M. Gill, Carmen G. Franks, Glenda M. Samuelson, Anita Shepherd Journal of Hydrology 2008

Earlier runoff may force construction of more storage reservoirs & heavier reliance on ground water. Earlier runoff may force construction of more storage reservoirs & heavier reliance on ground water. Encouraging natural riparian floodplains and wetlands “natural infrastructure” can complement built infrastructure or even preclude the need for new construction. Encouraging natural riparian floodplains and wetlands “natural infrastructure” can complement built infrastructure or even preclude the need for new construction.

low Regime, and scale. Percentage of increase (relative to 1950 to 2003) in median area burned for Western United States ecoprovinces for a 1 °C temperature increase. Color intensity is proportional to the magnitude of the projected increase in area burned (PNW=GTR- 870, Peterson, D, and J.S. Littell). Percentage of increase (relative to 1950 to 2003) in median area burned for Western United States ecoprovinces for a 1 °C temperature increase. Color intensity is proportional to the magnitude of the projected increase in area burned (PNW=GTR- 870, Peterson, D, and J.S. Littell).

Fire even without a warming climate can cause earlier snow melt… Copper Bottom snow water equivalent as compared to other Snotel sites before fire in 2000 vs. Copper Bottom after fire in 2006 NRCS figures from Scott Oviatt 12

Can forests be managed to augment water yield?

Multiple studies show that total discharge increases from relatively small research watersheds are statistically significant when ~20 to 25% of a basal area is removed from forests. Basal area reduction may happen by mechanical treatment, wind, insect and disease, or by fire. Insects and fire are now reducing basal area on 10s of thousands of acres. Duration of water yield increase is related to the vegetative recovery rate.

Middle Fork Boise River Watershed Area square miles 45% burned between 1992 & 2003 Runoff increase of ~5% is attributed to fires. Runoff increase of ~5% is attributed to fires. Runoff had declined ~18% since Runoff had declined ~18% since Basin scale flooding did not increase. Basin scale flooding did not increase. Luce and others, USDA Forest Service RMRS-GTR

au Farnes, Phillip E., Ward W. McCaughey, Katherine J. Hansen Hydrologic and Geologic Characterization of Tenderfoot Creek Experimental forest, Montana. U.S.D.A. Forest Service Intermountain Research Station and Montana State University, Department of Earth Sciences. Final report RJVA-INT Farnes, Phillip E., Ward W. McCaughey, Katherine J. Hansen Hydrologic and Geologic Characterization of Tenderfoot Creek Experimental forest, Montana. U.S.D.A. Forest Service Intermountain Research Station and Montana State University, Department of Earth Sciences. Final report RJVA-INT Water Yield

Farnes, Phillip E., Ward W. McCaughey, Katherine J. Hansen Hydrologic and Geologic Characterization of Tenderfoot Creek Experimental forest, Montana. U.S.D.A. Forest Service Intermountain Research Station and Montana State University, Department of Earth Sciences. Final report RJVA-INT

Effects of Alternative Silvicultural Treatments on Snow Accumulation in Lodgepole Pine Stands, Montana S.W.Woods, W. Mcaughey, R.Ahl, and J. Sappington Western Snow Conference, ~60% of basal area was removed using two treatments in the Tenderfoot Creek Experimental Forest and compared against the uncut control: ~60% of basal area was removed using two treatments in the Tenderfoot Creek Experimental Forest and compared against the uncut control: Even thinning Even thinning Group-retention thinning (<2 hector corridor- like openings) Group-retention thinning (<2 hector corridor- like openings)

Results from Woods and Others Even thinning treatment significantly increased snow water equivalent, up to 35% as compared to the control. Even thinning treatment significantly increased snow water equivalent, up to 35% as compared to the control. Group retention did not significantly increase snow water equivalent. Group retention did not significantly increase snow water equivalent. Wind scour is likely the reason, some bare areas were observed. Wind scour is likely the reason, some bare areas were observed. Wind effects extended into uncut areas. Wind effects extended into uncut areas. However, areas protected from scour melted the most slowly (likely a snow fence effect). However, areas protected from scour melted the most slowly (likely a snow fence effect).

How Much Water Can a Floodplain or Wetland Hold? Porosity (the amount of void space in rock or soil) varies depending on geology and/or soil type. Porosity (the amount of void space in rock or soil) varies depending on geology and/or soil type. 10% - 20% for glacial till 10% - 20% for glacial till 25% - 50% for well-sorted sands or gravels 25% - 50% for well-sorted sands or gravels 33% - 60% for clay 33% - 60% for clay Brooks and others Hydrology and The Management of Watersheds. Iowa State Univ. Press. Pg. 89 & 91.

Binarche Creek RNA

Elkhorn Creek Riparian Wetland Beaverhead-Deerlodge National Forest

Pete Bengeyfield photo Upper Yellowstone River above Yellowstone Lake Pete Bengeyfield photo

Missouri River Floodplain Cotton Wood Regeneration following June 2011 Snowmelt Runoff

Clark Fork River Flooding Missoula, June 2011

Tower Street Missoula June 2011

Binarche RNA Beaver Dam

from Google Earth Scott Dyer Rio Cibola, Santa Fe NF

Discharge before and after failure of a beaver dam shows the water table dropped about 8 cm during 14 hours after of the dam failed, water table before dam failure. This water level is suitable for persistent wetlands formation before dam failure. Westbrook et.al. WATER RESOURCES RESEARCH, VOL. 42, 2006

Examples of beaver-influencd channel form. Photos a, c, and e show channel avulsions or splits where an abandoned beaver dam is present. Examples of beaver-influencd channel form. Photos a, c, and e show channel avulsions or splits where an abandoned beaver dam is present. Photos b and d show island formation at the site of an abandoned beaver dam. Photos b and d show island formation at the site of an abandoned beaver dam. Photo f shows a bank reinforced by beaver-chewed wood, possibly an abandoned dam, which caused a sharp meander bend. White arrows indicate main flow direction. Photo f shows a bank reinforced by beaver-chewed wood, possibly an abandoned dam, which caused a sharp meander bend. White arrows indicate main flow direction. From: Polvi and Wohl, Earth Surf. Process. Landforms 37, 332–346 (2012)

From Polvi and Wohl Earth Surf. Process. Landforms, Vol. 37, 332–346 (2012) From Polvi and Wohl Earth Surf. Process. Landforms, Vol. 37, 332–346 (2012)

Some Benefits of Beaver Dams: Some Benefits of Beaver Dams: increase floodplain accessibility to flows, increase floodplain accessibility to flows, raise water tables & increase water storage, raise water tables & increase water storage, increase the extent of riparian & wetland vegetation, increase the extent of riparian & wetland vegetation, increase pool frequency and depth, increase pool frequency and depth, increase stream sinuosity and storage of sediment, and increase stream sinuosity and storage of sediment, and lower stream temperatures. lower stream temperatures. Michael M. Pollock and others, Using Beaver to Reconnect Floodplains and Restore Riparian Habitat in an Incised Stream. AWRA 2012 Specialty Conference Study done in Bridge Creek, a tributary to the John Day River in eastern Oregon

Water Quality Benefits of Riparian Areas Multiple studies have reported nitrate removal efficiencies > 90% in riparian zones (Hill, 1996; Vidon and Hill, 2006). Multiple studies have reported nitrate removal efficiencies > 90% in riparian zones (Hill, 1996; Vidon and Hill, 2006). Riparian areas may also limit transport of other water quality contaminants such as: sediment, ammonium, soluble reactive phosphorus, sulfate, dissolved organic nitrogen, dissolved organic carbon, and some pesticides. Riparian areas may also limit transport of other water quality contaminants such as: sediment, ammonium, soluble reactive phosphorus, sulfate, dissolved organic nitrogen, dissolved organic carbon, and some pesticides. Vidon, Phillippe Craig Allen, and Richard Lowrance Generalizing and others Riparian Zone Function at the Landscape Scale. Water Resources Impact Vol. 10, Number 3 Vidon, Phillippe Craig Allen, and Richard Lowrance Generalizing and others Riparian Zone Function at the Landscape Scale. Water Resources Impact Vol. 10, Number 3

With so many unknowns due to climate change, monitoring and adaptive management becomes crucial. Needs: 1. increased education both inside and outside land management agencies, 2. set up effective monitoring of key indicators, 3. identify areas of vulnerability, 4. quantify benefits and costs of addressing vulnerabilities, and 5. put in place mechanisms to adapt our management to changing conditions.

Management Adaptations for National Forests Anticipate increased likelihood of continued warming, severe drought, increased wildfire, and more flooding. Anticipate increased likelihood of continued warming, severe drought, increased wildfire, and more flooding. Increase wildland fire use, continue fuels treatments in priority areas, and repeat at appropriate intervals. Increase wildland fire use, continue fuels treatments in priority areas, and repeat at appropriate intervals. Create a watershed restoration program that has the ability and funding to react in a timely manner. Create a watershed restoration program that has the ability and funding to react in a timely manner. Design all facilities for the likelihood of higher more frequent floods and debris torrents. Design all facilities for the likelihood of higher more frequent floods and debris torrents. National Forests have been reducing the miles of road system, improving fish passage, and upsizing culverts. National Forests have been reducing the miles of road system, improving fish passage, and upsizing culverts.

Possible Adaptations to Ensure Water Supplies More storage facilities to capture earlier snow melt may be inevitable, but first: More storage facilities to capture earlier snow melt may be inevitable, but first: provide water storage through natural infrastructure; provide water storage through natural infrastructure; increase efforts to identify and protect flood plains and wetlands; increase efforts to identify and protect flood plains and wetlands; maintain healthy flood plains accessible to flood flows; maintain healthy flood plains accessible to flood flows; plant drought tolerant crops; and plant drought tolerant crops; and encourage beavers, nature’s wetland/flood plain developer and flood flow mitigation specialist. encourage beavers, nature’s wetland/flood plain developer and flood flow mitigation specialist.

Example of Riparian Restoration Willow Planting - Pueblo Canyon Santa Fe NF, 2008 In this example both channel narrowing and aggradation have occurred. Eventually beaver could establish a population once there is sufficient willow for food and dam construction.

Resiliency Flood plains and wetlands can be quite resilient following wildfires or other disturbances because: Flood plains and wetlands can be quite resilient following wildfires or other disturbances because: generally resistant to wildfire or flooding and quick to recover; generally resistant to wildfire or flooding and quick to recover; may mitigate post fire flooding and debris torrents by spreading out flows and capturing sediment and debris; may mitigate post fire flooding and debris torrents by spreading out flows and capturing sediment and debris; benefit/cost ratios of protecting, enhancing or developing floodplains and wetlands are potentially huge when compared to building storage reservoirs. benefit/cost ratios of protecting, enhancing or developing floodplains and wetlands are potentially huge when compared to building storage reservoirs. Recognize that current built infrastructure is often old, may be under-designed and may not be resilient; future maintenance costs may continue to increase. Recognize that current built infrastructure is often old, may be under-designed and may not be resilient; future maintenance costs may continue to increase.

Post Fire Debris Torrent in British Columbia Omen of the Future? “Only two things are infinite, the universe and human stupidity, and I'm not sure about the former.” Albert Einstein