The Meaning of 60 Fe: A Nearby Supernova Injected Short-Lived Radionuclides into our Protoplanetary Disk Steve Desch Nicolas Ouellette Jeff Hester Laurie.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Origin & Evolution of Habitable Planets: Astronomical Prospective D.N.C. Lin University of California, Santa Cruz, KIAA, Peking University, with Pathways.
Advertisements

CHAPTER 5: Formation of the Solar System and Other Planetary Systems.
Can Photo-Evaporation Trigger Planetesimal Formation? Henry Throop John Bally SWRI Univ.Colorado / CASA DPS 12-Oct-2004.
arvard.edu/phot o/2007/m51/. Confronting Stellar Feedback Simulations with Observations of Hot Gas in Elliptical Galaxies Q. Daniel Wang,
Astromineralogy of Protoplanetary Disks (and other astrophysical objects) Steve Desch Melissa Morris Arizona State University.
Protostellar/planetary disk observations (and what they might imply) Lee Hartmann University of Michigan.
Protoplanetary Disks: The Initial Conditions of Planet Formation Eric Mamajek University of Rochester, Dept. of Physics & Astronomy Astrobio 2010 – Santiago.
Observing How Habitable Conditions Develop (Or Not) in Protoplanetary Disks Colette Salyk National Optical Astronomy Observatory Credit: JPL-Caltech/T.
Canterbury The problem of star formation is not how to make stars. The problem of star formation is how not to make stars.
BB 1,2 H 3,4 He 7 Li Intergalactic medium Interstellar medium Galaxy formation inflowGal. winds, stripping, mergers Cosmic rays Small stars D, Li Middling.
1 The Search for Other Earths Ray Villard STScI August 17, 2009.
A Study of the 30 P(p,  ) 31 S Reaction via the 32 S(d,t) 31 S Reaction and its Astrophysical Relevance Dan Irvine McMaster University CAWONAPS 2010Dec.
The Birth of Stars Chapter Twenty. Guiding Questions 1.Why do astronomers think that stars evolve? 2.What kind of matter exists in the spaces between.
T.P. Idiart  and J.A. de Freitas Pacheco   Universidade de São Paulo (Brasil)  Observatoire de la Côte d’Azur (France) Introduction Elliptical galaxies.
John Bally Center for Astrophysics and Space Astronomy Department of Astrophysical and Planetary Sciences University of Colorado, Boulder Star Formation.
The Astrophysical Origins of the Short-Lived Radionuclides in the Early Solar System Steve Desch September 15, 2006 U. of Toronto with a shout-out to my.
Stellar Death Astronomy 315 Professor Lee Carkner Lecture 14 “I am glad we do not have to try to kill the stars. … Imagine if a man each day should have.
Origins of the Short-Lived Radionuclides and the Astrophysical Environment of the Solar System’s Formation Steve Desch Arizona State University Gordon.
Chapter 12. Star Stuff (mostly different from book) I. Birth of Stars from Interstellar Clouds Young stars near clouds of gas and dust Contraction and.
Protostars, nebulas and Brown dwarfs
The Deaths of Stars Chapter 13. The End of a Star’s Life When all the nuclear fuel in a star is used up, gravity will win over pressure and the star will.
Oxygen Isotopes Anomalies of the Sun and the Original Environment of the Solar System Jeong-Eun Lee UCLA.
Extinct nuclides in and chronology of the early solar system Can extinct nuclides be used for chronology? Were extinct nuclides distributed homogeneously.
Ge/Ay133 In what sort of region did our own solar system form?
Radioactivity in the early solar system Maria Lugaro (Monash University) Amanda Karakas (ANU, Australia) Mark van Raai (Utrecht, NL) Anibal Garcia-Hernandez.
The Milky Way PHYS390 Astrophysics Professor Lee Carkner Lecture 19.
Susan CartwrightOur Evolving Universe1 Star Birth n Most of the bright stars we see have lifetimes much less than the age of the Solar System l l star.
Death of Stars I Physics 113 Goderya Chapter(s): 13 Learning Outcomes:
Star and Planet Formation Sommer term 2007 Henrik Beuther & Sebastian Wolf 16.4 Introduction (H.B. & S.W.) 23.4 Physical processes, heating and cooling.
The University Experience Dr. Steve Desch Dept. Physics & Astronomy Arizona State University Pathways to College Arizona State University April 22, 2006.
Superbubbles, Wolf-Rayet Stars, and the Origin of Galactic Cosmic Rays W.R. Binns, M.H. Israel, L.M. Scott: Washington University M.E. Wiedenbeck: Jet.
New Developments in the Formation of the Solar System Steve Desch Arizona State University.
Isotopic constraints on nucleosynthesis, Solar System composition & accretion Nikitha Susan Saji Centre for Star and Planet Formation, Natural History.
Science with continuum data ALMA continuum observations: Physical, chemical properties and evolution of dust, SFR, SED, circumstellar discs, accretion.
Meteoritic Constraints on Astrophysical Models of Star and Planet Formation Steve Desch, Arizona State University.
Seeing Stars with Radio Eyes Christopher G. De Pree RARE CATS Green Bank, WV June 2002.
Solar System Shifts in Oxygen Isotopes Associated with Supernova Injection of Aluminum 26 Carola Ellinger, Patrick Young & Steve Desch School of Earth.
AIMS OF G ALACTIC C HEMICAL E VOLUTION STUDIES To check / constrain our understanding of stellar nucleosynthesis (i.e. stellar yields), either statistically.
Sun, Moon, Earth, What kind of life cycle does a star have?
Clicker Question: In which phase of a star’s life is it converting He to Carbon? A: main sequence B: giant branch C: horizontal branch D: white dwarf.
What's in our galaxy?.
Gas mixing and Star formation by shock waves and turbulence Claudio Melioli Elisabete M. de Gouveia Dal Pino (IAG-USP)
HBT 28-Jun-2005 Henry Throop Department of Space Studies Southwest Research Institute (SwRI) Boulder, Colorado John Bally University of Colorado Portugal,
Feedback Observations and Simulations of Elliptical Galaxies –Daniel Wang, Shikui Tang, Yu Lu, Houjun Mo (UMASS) –Mordecai Mac-Low (AMNH) –Ryan Joung (Princeton)
Philamentary Structure and Velocity Gradients in the Orion A Cloud
The Fossil History of the Solar System: Links to Interstellar Chemistry Edwin A. Bergin University of Michigan Jeong-Eun Lee UCLA James Lyons UCLA.
From Stars to Planets Gainesville 14 April 2007 Short-lived radioisotopes: A cosmochemical connection between star and planet formation Eric Gaidos 1,3.
Low-Mass Star Formation, Triggered by Supernova in Primordial Clouds Masahiro N. Machida (Chiba University) Kohji Tomisaka (NAOJ) Fumitaka Nakamura (Niigata.
- HW Ch. 10, EXTENDED Mon. Nov. 8 - HW Ch. 11 & 12, due Mon. Nov HW Ch. 13 & 14 due Mon. Nov. 22 Exam 3 on Tuesday Nov. 23.
Stars, galaxies and planets Dept. of Physics, Bangalore University Bangalore B. A. Kagali.
Efficiency of Mixing of Supernova Ejecta into Nearby Protoplanetary Disks Nicolas Ouellette & Steve Desch Arizona State University.
The Chemistry of PPN T. J. Millar, School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Manchester.
Imaging a galaxy-scale molecular outflow
Stars. Distance to Stars Proxima Centauri: nearest star to Earth – 4.2 light years awaylight years Polaris 700 light years away.
ISM & Astrochemistry Lecture 1. Interstellar Matter Comprises Gas and Dust Dust absorbs and scatters (extinguishes) starlight Top row – optical images.
John Bally Center for Astrophysics and Space Astronomy Department of Astrophysical and Planetary Sciences University of Colorado, Boulder Recent Developments.
 A nebula is a cloud of gas and dust in space.  Some nebulas are regions where new stars are being formed, while others are the remains of dead or dying.
Astromineralogy of Protoplanetary Disks (and other astrophysical objects) Steve Desch Melissa Morris Arizona State University.
Star Formation Nucleosynthesis in Stars
Outline of Ch 11: The H-R Diagram (cont.)
Friday 5/18/18 Notebook Entry: If you could travel to any object in our Universe where would you go and WHY?
Monday 5/22/17 Fill out your assignment notebook for the week for your period. Notebook Entry: If you could travel to any object in our Universe where.
Nucleosynthesis and stellar lifecycles
Mackenzie James Mentor: Dr. Jinyoung Serena Kim
Observations: Cosmic rays
The Deaths of Stars.
Origin of 17,18O-rich materials from Acfer 094
by W. R. Binns, M. H. Israel, E. R. Christian, A. C. Cummings, G. A
Spallation l-process (spallation):
Presentation transcript:

The Meaning of 60 Fe: A Nearby Supernova Injected Short-Lived Radionuclides into our Protoplanetary Disk Steve Desch Nicolas Ouellette Jeff Hester Laurie Leshin Arizona State University

Outline Our early Solar System contained 60 Fe It wasn’t created by in-situ spallation... It wasn’t inherited from our molecular cloud... It wasn’t injected by an AGB star... It had to come from a supernova... It was probably injected directly into our protoplanetary disk

Early Solar System Contained 60 Fe 60 Fe/ 56 Fe ~ x Semarkona + Bishunpur pyroxene chondrules (Tachibana et al 2005) 60 Fe/ 56 Fe ~ 9 x Semarkona troilites + magnetites (Mostefaoui et al 2005) 60 Fe/ 56 Fe ~ 7 x Semarkona troilites + pyroxenes (Mostefaoui et al 2004) 60 Fe/ 56 Fe ~ x Bishunpur + Krymka troilites (Tachibana & Huss 2003) Tachibana & Huss (2003) 60 Fe/ 56 Fe ~ 5 x 10 -7

60 Fe wasn’t created by spallation Irradiation of rocky material at 0.1 AU in principle can produce radionuclides like 60 Fe Only 64 Ni(p,p  ) 60 Fe reaction can happen, but 64 Ni is rare and cross section is < 0.1 mbarn Predicted yields: 60 Fe/ 56 Fe ~ (Lee et al 1998; Leya et al 2003) Shu et al (1996)

60 Fe wasn’t inherited from our molecular cloud Harper (1996) Supernovae, Wolf-Rayet winds, novae, AGB stars maintain steady-state levels of 60 Fe, etc., in the Galaxy 60 Fe 26 Al 129 I Steady-state “average” abundance of 60 Fe is 60 Fe/ 56 Fe ~ 3 x (Harper 1996) or 60 Fe/ 56 Fe ~ 3 x (Wasserburg et al 1996) But then 129 I/ 127 I ~ 10 -2, 182 Hf/ 180 Hf ~ 10 -3, etc.

60 Fe wasn’t inherited from our molecular cloud Our molecular cloud was isolated from sources of radionuclides for >> 10 7 yr (Wasserburg et al 1996; Harper 1996) Much of the radionuclides produced by supernovae go into hot phase, and don’t enter molecular clouds for ~10 8 yr M 109 supernova new star-forming molecular clouds In the meantime, 60 Fe completely decays

60 Fe wasn’t injected by an AGB star AGB outflows do eject 60 Fe, but only for ~ 1 Myr, after star has evolved for > 2 Gyr AGB stars randomly distributed in Galaxy: no reason to associate them with star-forming regions Odds per 1 Myr that a parcel of gas in a molecular cloud will be contaminated with AGB material: < 3 x (Kastner & Myers 1994) AGB stars also do not eject appreciable 53 Mn, 182 Hf (Gallino et al 1998)

60 Fe is ejected by supernovae associated with star-forming regions! Live 60 Fe discovered in ocean crust 3 Myr old (Knie et al 2004) Only plausible source is supernovae in Scorpius-Centaurus star-forming region (Maiz-Appelaniz 2001; Fields et al 2004) P. Frisch, U. Chicago 60 Fe Fe

60 Fe will be injected into disks associated with those supernovae ~ 0.2 pc  1 Ori C: 40 M  star will supernova in < 1 Myr protoplanetary disks HST image, Orion Nebula

Sufficient 60 Fe can be injected without destroying disk Iron likely in form of dust grains: gas-phase Fe disappeared from SN 1987A ejecta at same time (1-2 years post-explosion) that M  of dust formed (Colgan et al 1994) Mass of 60 Fe ejected by 25 M  supernova ~ 8 x M  (Woosley & Weaver 1995) Fraction intercepted by 30 AU radius disk at 0.3 pc away ~  (30 AU) 2 / 4  (0.3 pc) 2 ~ 6 x Mixed with 0.01 M  of solar composition material, 60 Fe / 56 Fe ~ 1 x 10 -6

Sufficient 60 Fe can be injected without destroying disk Worst-case scenario: fast cooling Ouellette et al (2005), in prep

Sufficient 60 Fe can be injected without destroying disk Ouellette et al (2005), in prep With realistic cooling

Conclusions 60 Fe in early solar system could not be inherited, could not be produced by spallation, almost certainly was not from AGB star Only plausible source of the 60 Fe is a nearby supernova Protoplanetary disks are observed near (~ 0.3 pc) massive stars that will soon go supernova Supernova ~0.3 pc away can inject 60 Fe-bearing dust grains into a protoplanetary disk, yielding 60 Fe/ 56 Fe ~ in the disk material, without destroying disk