Excise tax increases, cigarette consumption and government revenue: A win-win-win situation in South Africa Corne van Walbeek School of Economics University.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Chapter 11 An Introduction to Open Economy Macroeconomics.
Advertisements

Tobacco Control Policy The Challenge of Raising Tobacco Taxes
Tobacco Control Policy The Challenge of Raising Tobacco Taxes Global and Regional Experience by Ayda A. Yurekli, Ph.D World Bank World Bank ECA Regional.
AS/A2 The national economy The UK Economy: a Health Check How well has the economy been performing, and whats round the corner? The UK Economy: a Health.
1 Syria at a Turning Point Trends in the Syrian Economy University of Reading 23 rd February 2005 Dr Ken Charman.
International Economics By Robert J. Carbaugh 9th Edition
International Economics Tenth Edition
Trade Restrictions: Tariffs Chapter 8
An Introduction to International Economics
Trade Policy (Tariffs, Subsidies, VERs)
Eco 3024F Krugman & Obstfeld Ch 8
What are tariffs? DEF1: Tariffs are taxes that are imposed on nations’ import goods and/or export goods DEF2: Tariffs are taxes or duties levied on the.
Copyright ©2004, South-Western College Publishing International Economics By Robert J. Carbaugh 9th Edition Chapter 4: Tariffs.
Carbaugh, Chap. 5 1 Why restrict trade? Benefits of free trade in final goods are spread widely Tariffs on intermediate inputs tend to be low Costs of.
International Economics Tenth Edition
Meaning of Tariffs Types of Tariffs Effects of Tariffs
Brazil: Sustainable Growth, income distribution and social inclusion Miami Minister Paulo Bernardo April 6th, 2008.
Taxes levied on Cigarettes By Ayda A. Yurekli, PhD. Program Leader, Research for International Tobacco Control (RITC) at International Development Research.
The illicit trade in cigarettes: Can we determine large increases in illicit activity from excise revenue data? A case study of South Africa Corne van.
Unit 3: Aggregate Demand and Supply and Fiscal Policy
Copyright © 2004 South-Western Mods 17-21, 30 Macro Analysis Part IV.
SHORT-RUN ECONOMIC FLUCTUATIONS
The effect of rapidly increasing cigarette prices on smoking patterns across the income spectrum: Some evidence from South Africa Corne van Walbeek School.
Tobacco-Free Ireland 2025: What kinds of investments are needed? Professor Luke Clancy WCTOH 2015.
PRESENTATION 1 Why do governments tax tobacco products? Workshop on tobacco prices and tax World Health Organization (WHO) and International Union Against.
Homework #11 Government Finance. Some suggest that states are addicted to their vice taxes. This certainly might be true with a unit excise tax on cigarettes.
Kidane Asmerom and Teh wei-Hu
A study of the causes of the real net- of-tax cigarette price increases in South Africa ( ) Diana Nyabongo.
Global Burden of Tobacco
CONFERENCE ON TOBACCO CONTROL. SCHOOL OF ECONOMICS JULY 2014 Alcohol tax, price and consumption Alcohol tax, price and consumption Corné van Walbeek.
South African/SACU Experience with Tobacco Taxation: Lessons Learned and Relevance for other SADC countries Corne van Walbeek Associate Professor, School.
Negative externalities: smoking
Evan Blecher and Corné Van Walbeek School of Economics University of Cape Town South Africa Tobacco Control and Research in Developing Countries: Lessons.
1 The economics of tobacco control in Jamaica: Will the pursuit of public health place a fiscal burden on the government? Presentation to the Public Forum,
Taxation and income distribution Today: Some basic tax theory.
Taxation, income distribution, and efficiency
+ Taxation & price issues Burke Fishburn Technical Adviser International Union Against Tuberculosis & Lung Disease April 2011.
Tobacco Control Policy The Challenge of Raising Tobacco Taxes Global, Regional and Hungarian Experience By Ayda A. Yurekli, Ph.D World Bank Tobacco Dissemination.
11 TAXATION OF TOBACCO PRODUCTS GENERAL DIRECTORATE OF REVENUE POLICIES (28/08/2012)
 2007 Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health Tax and Health Promotion Bungon Ritthiphakdee Southeast Asia Tobacco Control Alliance (SEATCA) Action.
Corné Van Walbeek, PhD School of Economics University of Cape Town Increasing cigarette taxes and prices as a tobacco control strategy in South Africa.
 2007 Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health Section B A Look Ahead: Summary of Main Findings.
1 Industry responses to the rapid excise tax increases in South Africa since 1994 Departmental seminar, School of Economics, 1 August 2005 Corné van Walbeek.
 2011 Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health Best Practices in Tobacco Taxation Frank J. Chaloupka, PhD University of Illinois at Chicago International.
ECONOMICS OF TOBACCO CONFERENCE SCHOOL OF ECONOMICS, UCT JULY 2014 Illicit trade in South Africa: Can we trust the industry rhetoric? Corné van Walbeek.
Tobacco: Health and Economics Dr. Joy de Beyer World Bank International Meeting on Economic, Social and Health Issues in Tobacco Control Kobe, Japan, December.
1 The role of tobacco price on consumption Dr. Corné van Walbeek Senior Lecturer, School of Economics University of Cape Town.
Do tax increases on tobacco hurt the poor? Some findings from South Africa Corné van Walbeek School of Economics University of Cape Town.
Indirect taxes and subsidies Chapter 12. Taxes and Subsidies An indirect tax is…. A subsidy is….
PRESENTATION 4 Types of taxes that can be applied to tobacco products Workshop on tobacco prices and tax World Health Organization (WHO) and International.
Excise Taxes, Unit Taxes, Ad Valorem Taxes
Excise taxes as a mechanism for tobacco control : South Africa’s experience Corné van Walbeek Chief researcher of the Economics of Tobacco Control Project,
International Economics International Economics Tenth Edition Trade Restrictions: Tariffs Dominick Salvatore John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Salvatore: International.
Regional Seminar: Tobacco prices and taxes, and Illicit trade of tobacco products | July 2012, Panama City 1 |1 | Lessons learned from worldwide.
VIETNAM TOBACCO TAX REFORM
The South African Experience
Fiscal Policy: Spending & Taxing
International Economics Tenth Edition
ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING
International Economics By Robert J. Carbaugh 9th Edition
International Economics By Robert J. Carbaugh 9th Edition
Global Experience And Framework For Fiscal Decentralization
Is there scope for further unilateral trade reform in South Africa
ACCELERATING PROGRESS ON EFFECTIVE TOBACCO TAX POLICIES IN MONTENEGRO
Tobacco Taxation Policy in Georgia
The role of tobacco price on consumption
Global Burden of Tobacco
Fiscal Policy: Spending & Taxing
A Look Ahead: Summary of Main Findings
Ministry of Health of the Republic of Uzbekistan
Presentation transcript:

Excise tax increases, cigarette consumption and government revenue: A win-win-win situation in South Africa Corne van Walbeek School of Economics University of Cape Town This research was made possible with funding from the American Cancer Society

Win-win-win in South Africa Win 1: Public health Win 2: Government revenue Win 3: Tobacco industry benefits through their pricing strategy and this pricing strategy has had a positive impact on public health and government revenue

Why are excise tax increases so effective in reducing tobacco consumption? Despite its addictiveness, people respond to changes in the price of cigarettes Price elasticity of demand for cigarettes in SA (and many low- and middle-income countries is around -0.6) Thus a 10% increase in cigarette prices reduces consumption by 6% Not all people respond to changes in cigarette prices, but the poor and youth are typically more responsive than the better-off and the old Some indicative numbers: – 1000 smokers initially – If price increases by 10%, we would expect 3% (= 30) smokers to quit – Remaining smokers will cut down their consumption by an average of 3% (some more and some less)

Lesson 1 from South Africa Specific taxes are good, but they have to be updated regularly, especially in inflationary times Excise tax increases do not keep up with inflation

Since 1994 rapid excise tax increases followed the small nominal increases in the 1970s and 1980s Government commits to a TC policy based on keeping the tax burden at 50% of the retail price

Lesson 2 from South Africa Don’t make the tobacco industry your tax advisor on excise tax matters Minister of Finance, 1983: “The Tobacco Board has presented justified arguments for the maintenance of the status quo regarding the excise taxes on tobacco, and I do not intend to wake sleeping dogs” Minister of Finance, 1986: “any increases in excise duties at present could be counter-productive, since it could in fact – on account of the potentially adverse effect on consumption – lead to a reduction of revenue from this source” Article 5.3 of the FCTC: In setting and implementing their public health policies with respect to tobacco control, Parties shall act to protect these policies from commercial and other vested interests of the tobacco industry in accordance with national law

Lesson 3 from South Africa Keep the tax system simple Specific tax is administratively best, and does not actively encourage the creation of low-price market Complicated tax systems are likely to be used by the tobacco industry to their benefit, and against the public health and/or fiscal interests of the government Example of a complicated excise tax regime: Jamaica – Special consumption tax (SCT): A specific amount per 100 cigarettes PLUS An ad valorem tax of X % on cigarettes in excess of specified benchmark value – “Excise levy” payable to the National Health Fund: 23 % of the sum of the ex factory price and the SCT – General Consumption Tax (GCT): Like VAT, an ad valorem tax

Lesson 4 from South Africa The math is quite simple Ignoring the impact of changes in income, the impact of a 20% increase in the (specific) excise tax is as follows: Excise tax as percentage of retail price Price elasticity Excise tax increase (percentage) Net-of-tax price increase (percentage) % change quantity % change govt revenue

Lesson 5 from South Africa Big increases in the excise tax have resulted in big increases in tax revenue Between 1993 and 2011 real excise tax increases by 487% and real excise tax revenue increases by 249%

Lesson 6 from South Africa The industry has a very strong interest in exaggerating the threat of illicit trade – “The increase in the excise tax will encourage illicit trade” (TISA and BAT, numerous years) – “The illicit market has grown from nothing ten years ago to 20% of the total SA market” (TISA, 2006) – “Illicit trade has doubled over the past two years” (BAT CEO, 2010) – “The government loses R2.6 billion each year to illegal sales” (TISA, 2011)

The evidence for a large increase in illicit sales is not convincing In an environment of rapidly increasing average prices and strong tobacco control legislation it seems unlikely that total cigarette consumption would increase by 11% between 2003 and 2009 Bottom line: While illicit trade may be a real issue in many countries, and one should always be vigilant, the industry is not a credible source about the magnitude of the problem 11% increase in total (legal and illicit) sales 4.3% increase in legal sales Aggregate cigarette consumption in SA

Lesson 7 from South Africa The tobacco industry’s pricing model may have beneficial long-run fiscal and public health consequences The third WIN in the equation: Tobacco industry in SA is more profitable now than before, despite the decrease in cigarette consumption Sharp increase in the net-of-tax price (and thus profit) per cigarette Can do this because tobacco industry in SA, as in most countries, is highly concentrated Low price elasticity works in the industry’s favour Excise tax in SA is specific but set such that tax burden is 52% of the retail price Substantially increasing the excise tax initiated a cycle of 1.Increasing retail price (excise tax being passed through) 2.Decreasing consumption (as consumers respond to higher prices) 3.Increasing net-of-tax price (as industry wants to maintain/expand its profitability) 4.Increasing retail price (as the net-of-tax price increases) 5.Decreasing consumption (as consumers respond to higher prices) 6.Increasing excise tax (as government wants to maintain the 52% tax burden) 7.Increasing retail price (back to point 1)

A gradual upward ratchet of the real price of cigarettes, with a corresponding decrease in consumption