LaRC Office of Chief Counsel (OCC) Provides legal support, advice, representation to LaRC personnel on wide range of legal matters Business Law (Contracts,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 WHO Conflicts of Interest Policy for WHO Experts.
Advertisements

Policies and Processes for Limiting Conflict of Interest Patrick N. Breysse, PhD, CIH Johns Hopkins University Bloomberg School of Public Health Vice-Chair,
Proper Use of GSA Contracts Emile Monette
Acquisition Planning and Adequate Market Research National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Acquisition and Grants Office Oversight and Compliance.
Effective Contract Management Planning
Contract Fundamentals at Fresno State Doug Carey, Grants Administrator Office of Research and Sponsored Programs California State University, Fresno.
PROCEDURE FOR TRANSFER OF A MEMBER OF THE CIVIL SERVICE CORPS TO THE POST OF DEPARTMENTAL DEPUTY DIRECTOR IN THE CENTRAL STATISTICAL OFFICE WITHOUT CONDUCTING.
CONDUCTING MARKET RESEARCH Fred Lagunas Procurement Center Representative SBA Office of Government Contracting 4 Mar 09.
Tim A. Di Guiseppe
Contracting Officer Representative (COR) Refresher “Mock Technical Evaluation Panel (TEP)” Brian K. Goodger Associate Director, OLAO November 20, 2014.
1 UMass Dartmouth Conflicts of Interest Policies UMass Dartmouth Liz Rodriguez February 17, 2011.
Organizational Conflicts of Interest (OCI)
Mr. Seth Cowell Ethics Counselor ESC/JA (781)
Procurement Integrity Act (PIA) Overview
DII Best Practices Forum: New Developments Peter J. Eyre Crowell & Moring © Crowell & Moring LLP All Rights Reserved. June 23, 2011.
1 Basics of Government Contracting. Federal Procurement Background The U.S. Government is the world’s largest purchaser of goods and services 2.
April 25–27, 2005 Phoenix Civic Plaza/Hyatt Regency Phoenix Phoenix, AZ NCMA World Congress 2005 “Prime Time: Contract Management at the Core of the Enterprise”
Ethics for an Outsourced Government Kathleen Clark Washington University in St. Louis Board of Contract Appeals Bar Association December
ICS 417: The ethics of ICT 4.2 The Ethics of Information and Communication Technologies (ICT) in Business by Simon Rogerson IMIS Journal May 1998.
Federal Advisory Committee Act (FACA)
Organization Conflict of Interest (OCI) under FAR March 2012.
ACCOUNTING ETHICS Lect. Victor-Octavian Müller, Ph.D.
Vendor Engagement Tips. Pre-solicitation Discussion 2  Review Federal Acquisition Regulation Subpart ” Exchanges with industry before receipt of.
Congress and Contractor Personal Conflicts of Interest May 21, 2008 Jon Etherton Etherton and Associates, Inc.
BETHESDA NORTH MARRIOTT HOTEL & CONFERENCE CENTER  BETHESDA, MD.
Organizational Conflict of Interest Highlights Damien Walsh, Attorney Advisor, USJFCOM Tidewater Government Industry Council Panel Discussion 3 February.
GOVERNMENT CONTRACTING HOT TOPICS: COMPLIANCE, OCI, BID PROTESTS, AND NEW SBA RULES HOT TOPICS.
National Contract Management Association – Norfolk Chapter Contracting Ground Rules.
3rd session: Corporate Governance
ZHRC/HTI Financial Management Training
[Program Name] ORGANIZATIONAL CONFLICT OF INTEREST TRAINING
Professional Codes of Ethics Professionalism and Codes of Ethics.
Five Activities Contracting Officers and Government Contractors Should Avoid Presented by: James F. Moseley, Jr. of Moseley, Prichard, Parrish, Knight,
Internal Auditing and Outsourcing
The Brooks A&E Act National Oceanic & Atmospheric Administration Acquisition & Grants Office January 24, 2006.
I n t e g r i t y - S e r v i c e - E x c e l l e n c e Headquarters U.S. Air Force 1 Organizational Conflicts of Interest in Services Contracts James.
Professional Ethics: Should Software Engineers Adhere to a Professional Code of Conduct? Jonathan Schiff CS 301.
CURRENT STATE OF PLAY: ORGANIZATIONAL CONFLICTS OF INTEREST Alison L. Doyle McKenna Long & Aldridge LLP NCMA Cape Canaveral Chapter Workshop May 14, 2008.
Department of Energy June 16, 2015 Executive Order (EO) 13673: Fair Pay and Safe Workplaces Jean Seibert Stucky Assistant General Counsel for Labor and.
Technical Data Rights- Who Cares………. Introduction n Why Do I Need To Know This? – Acquiring Tech Data is expensive – Dynamic environment, each situation.
Understand responsible actions for conducting business. 1.
Of XX Data Rights, Intellectual Property, Information Technology and Export Controls in Government Contracting Fernand Lavallee, Partner, Jones Day ©2015.
Department of Education Race to the Top Assessment Program January 14, 2009 Public Meeting Procurement Issues Mark D. Colley 555 Twelfth Street, NW. Washington,
JE-RDAP INDUSTRY DAY W911QY-16-R-0010 Kevin Parker 08 DEC 2015
RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE GOVERNOR ’ S TASK FORCE ON CONTRACTING AND PROCUREMENT REVIEW Report Overview PD Customer Forum September 2002.
PAKISTAN CONFLICTS OF INTEREST Nadeem Shah, Office of Acquisition & Assistance Priya Cariappa, Resident Legal Officer.
CSO Observer Member of the Evaluation Committee. Civil Society Organization May have representation in the Evaluation Committee As a member of the Evaluation.
Safety & Health Considerations in Accommodating Commercial Activties David Loyd, JSC Safety & Test Operations 2013 NASA Safety Directors & Occupational.
Organizational Conflicts of Interest in Services Contracts Ms. Beatrice K. Foster, Esq. Air Combat Command/JAB Deputy Chief, Commercial Law 25 MAY 2010.
MISSION ORIENTED BUSINESS INTEGRATED SERVICES (MOBIS) ACQUISITION MANAGEMENT SUPPORT ORDERING GUIDE ACQUISITION PLANNING SUPPORT ACQUISITION DOCUMENT PREPARATION.
NAVAIR Patuxent River Services Contracting February 2008 Pam Gray.
Ethics Issues in Contracting Naval Acquisition Development Program 2016 Annual Symposium March 24, 2016 Tom Frankfurt Assistant General Counsel (Research,
US Army Corps of Engineers BUILDING STRONG ® Thumbs Off the Scales: Identifying and Addressing Organizational Conflicts of Interest in Today’s Acquisition.
December 8–9, 2003 Sheraton Premiere, Tysons Corner, VA NCMA 22nd Annual East Coast Educational Conference Understanding Competition, Enhancing Small.
1 Changes to Regulations Governing Personal Conflicts of Interest and Organizational Conflicts of Interest Breakout Session # C08 Name: Barbara S. Kinosky,

Internal and Governmental Financial Auditing and Operational Auditing
OH&S Management System
Professional Codes of Ethics
Cost or pricing data John Cancellara 7 March 2018.
Chapter 8 Developing an Effective Ethics Program
Ethics Issues in Contracting Naval Acquisition Development Program 2016 Annual Symposium March 24, 2016 Tom Frankfurt Assistant General Counsel (Research,
ACCOUNTING ETHICS Conf.univ.dr. Victor-Octavian Müller.
ACCOUNTING ETHICS Conf.univ.dr. Victor-Octavian Müller.
ACCOUNTING ETHICS Conf.univ.dr. Victor-Octavian Müller.
ACCOUNTING ETHICS Conf.univ.dr. Victor-Octavian Müller.
ACCOUNTING ETHICS Lect. Victor-Octavian Müller, Ph.D.
Conflict of Interest FDP TRAINING FOR [YOUR ORGANIZATION]:
Conflict of Interest FDP TRAINING: Organizational Conflict of Interest
S AMCOM EXPRESS INDUSTRY DAY
Presentation transcript:

LaRC Office of Chief Counsel (OCC) Provides legal support, advice, representation to LaRC personnel on wide range of legal matters Business Law (Contracts, Grants, Fiscal Law, Agreements) Human Relations & Ethics Law (HR, Non-contract claims, Stds of Conduct) Intellectual Property Law (Patents, Licensing, Copyright, Software, IP) 1

2

Organizational Conflicts of Interest (OCI) LaRC Office of Chief Counsel NOTE: This presentation is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice to the recipients, who should consult with their counsel on OCI issues. 3

4 What is an OCI? OCIs are a subset or type of a Conflict of Interest (COI) The conflicted party is an organization – not an individual The conflict relates to the organization’s competing interests (Corporation’s first interest: To enhance its current and future business opportunities) There are two important assumptions: 1)Organizations want to further their own interests 2)All people and bodies associated with an organization will treat the organizations interests as their own and want to further them Useful reference – Dan Gordon article, “Organizational Conflicts of Interest: A Growing Integrity Challenge”, 35 Public Contract Law Journal 25 (Fall 2005)

5 What is an OCI? OCIs are distinct from personal conflicts of interest (PCIs) PCIs involve personal motives (acting in the best interests of self or certain family members and not one’s employer) E.g., stock ownership, spouse’s employer PCIs for contractors are not covered by the FAR…..yet FAR Case (Nov. 2009) “Preventing Personal Conflicts of Interest” (Comments due Jan. 12, 2010) New FAR Clause will require Contractors to identify and prevents PCIs of “covered employees” Contractors must develop procedures to screen employees at least annually “Covered employees” includes employees that perform “acquisition function[s] closely associated with inherently governmental functions” Waiver by HCA (non-delegable) and flow down to subs (Ks >100K)

6 Why are OCIs increasing? Increased use of contractors Consolidation within industry Types of services increasingly entail the exercise of judgment Increase in the use of umbrella (IDIQ) contracts

7 OCIs - Regulatory Guidance FAR Part 9.5 (Organizational and Consultant Conflicts of Interest) Government Accountability Office/Court of Federal Claims case law on OCIs

8 OCI – FAR Requirements FAR Part (General Rules) Multiple examples of OCIs…however, the list is not exhaustive, and the FAR requires that each situation be examined on the particular facts and the nature of the proposed contract. 2 underlying principles –Preventing conflicting roles that could bias a contractor’s judgment; and –Preventing an unfair competitive advantage

9 OCI – FAR Requirements FAR Part (CO Responsibilities) The contracting officer shall: –Identify and evaluate potential OCIs as early as possible… –Avoid, neutralize or mitigate potential OCIs before contract award –Recommend a course of action to the HCA before issuing a solicitation that may involve a significant potential conflict

10 Biased Ground Rules Refers to situations where a company sets the ground rules for a future competition ex: Writing specifications –Nature of the conflict is setting the best ground rules for Agency’s future requirement versus winning the future requirement Harm: Future competition may be unfair Future competition reflects best solution for contractor’s business opportunities and not best solution for NASA Potential Solutions: Bundle requirements development and delivery of the “end item” Have multiple contractors develop requirements documents Disqualify the contractor that prepared the specifications from the future competition (Limitation of Future Contracting)

11 Unequal Access to Information Refers to situations where a company has access to nonpublic information that gives it an unfair advantage relative to a future competition ex: Program configuration management, scheduling and database administrative support – Nature of the conflict is performing with access to non-public information versus obtaining a competitive advantage for a future requirement. Harm: Access to information not readily available to competitors Use of non-public information for competitive advantage in violation of Procurement Integrity Act, Trade Secrets Act, other laws/regulations Potential Solutions: Disseminate the non-public information before the competition Establish a firewall so contractor cannot use data in future competitions Prevent contractor from using sensitive information in future related competitions (Limitation of Future Contracting)

12 Impaired Objectivity Refers to situations where a company performs evaluations and assessments of the work/proposals/performance of itself or its competitors ex: Contractor submits a proposal in a competition where it is also assisting with evaluation of proposals Harm: Evaluations and recommendations may be flawed inadvertently reflecting contractor’s method of performance or recommending its services over those proposed by others Potential Solutions: Disqualify contractor that performs the evaluation/assessments from performing future work (Limitation of Future Contracting) Establish a process for limited reviews/assessments Establish “firewalled” subcontractors

13 Addressing OCIs in the Contract NFS Clauses Limitation of Future Contracting (NFS ) Access to Sensitive Information (NFS ) OCI Avoidance Plan Requirement triggered by Access to Sensitive Information clause Requires the contractor to explain how it will address OCIs during performance Specially Drafted OCI Clauses LaRC Unique Clauses (IDIQ Contracts) Specific OCI Issues/concerns (impaired objectivity) Certification of “no OCIs” by contractor (ex: NRC Contract)

14 Additional Thoughts Contractors are increasingly used in roles traditionally performed by civil servants- this increased influence in agency decision-making presents challenges Increased access to information Opportunities to affect agency procurements or gain a competitive edge Ultimately Contractors have best information as to OCIs they may encounter – critical they do the investigations and inform CO ASAP OCI Avoidance Plan is key method to ensure a process is in place We risk programs and LaRC/NASA reputation if we fail to identify and mitigate OCIs