Vygotsky on Human Nature and Human Development James V. Wertsch Department of Anthropology Washington University in St. Louis St. Louis, MO, USA.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Sociocultural Theory and Mediated Learning
Advertisements

Theoretical Perspectives
LEV VYGOTSKY.
 Distributed Cognition emphasizes the distributed nature of cognitive phenomena across individuals, artifacts, and representations that are both internal.
Features of SLA In this lecture, we are going to set the main general concluding features of SLA under the question: What are the main features of SLA?
CHANGING VIEWS ABOUT KNOWLEDGE Lecture 14 January 2010.
Activity theory. Outline Introduction Philosophical background Evolution of Activity theory –from Vygotsky to Engeström Main concepts and principles Implications.
HCC class lecture 5 comments John Canny 2/2/05. Administrivia.
HCC class lecture 28 John Canny 5/4/05. Administrivia 10-minute project presentations next Monday and Weds at this time. Volunteers for Monday? Or alphabetical…
Lev Vygotsky A Russian psychologist (1896 – 1934) A Russian psychologist (1896 – 1934) Introduced to American audiences in the 1960’s Introduced to American.
A Constructivistic Approach to Learning William G. Huitt, Ph.D. Valdosta State University Last revised: August 2000.
Mental Development Piaget and Vygotsky’s Developmental Theories
Chapter 1 What is Psychology?.
© 2011 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Chapter 1 What is Psychology?
HUMAN DEVELOPMENT 1 PSYCHOLOGY 3050: Social Construction of Mind
Title of Presentation: Children’s Temporal Cognition and the History Curriculum of the Primary School Eileen O’ Sullivan, Department of Learning, Society.
SOCIALIZING FORCES WORK BEST WHEN THEY ARE IN TUNE WITH INNER MATURATIONAL PRINCIPLES ARNOLD GESELL A CHILD IS THE PRODUCT OF THE ENVIRONMENT... BUT DEVELOPMENT.
“Psychology today seems less capable than ever of providing a coherent account of the human mind”
Theorist research Megan Ng & Ashlyn Seeley. Sociocultural  This theory stresses the interaction between developing people and the culture in which they.
ANTH 331: Culture and the Individual Kimberly Porter Martin, Ph.D. Theory.
UNIT 2: COGNITIVE DEVELOMENT CHAPTERS 6 & 7 Reading: Responsible for all the sections of both chapters.
Structuralism and Functionalism
HCC class lecture 4 comments John Canny 1/31/05. Administrivia.
+ Psychology’s Roots Founding & History of Psychology.
Copyright McGraw-Hill, Inc Defining Psychology Psychology The scientific study of behavior and mental processes Key terms: Science: psychology.
Cultural-historical theory and genetic research methodology Nikolai Veresov, University of Oulu, Finland,
Where do you stand?  How much is Psychology a real science like Physics, Chemistry or Biology?  How much of Psychology’s facts (like the bystander effect)
HISTORY & APPROACHES. Psychology has its roots in philosophy and biology. Early “practitioners” were physicians or had background in medicine/biology,
Lev Semenovich Vygotsky Vygotsky A person’s interpersonal, or internal processes, have their roots in interactions with others. Emphasized.
Contemporary Psychological Perspectives. Psychological Perspectives Method of classifying a collection of ideas Also called “schools of thought” Also.
 Yesterday you learned:  A history of psychology  Schools of Psychology ▪ Structuralism- Wilhelm Wundt ▪ Functionalism- William James ▪ Behaviorism-
 A perspective is a way of viewing phenomena  Psychology has multiple perspectives: ◦ Behavioral Perspective ◦ Humanistic Perspective ◦ Biological Perspective.
Vygotsky’s Sociocultural Theory Dr. K. A. Korb University of Jos.
Lev Vygotsky ( ). Vygotsky was born in Russia in the same year as Piaget. Vygotsky was not trained in science but received a law degree from Moscow.
A Brief History of Psychology Mr. Young 1st and 6th Period
Meditations on Mediation Universitetet i Oslo May 2004 James V. Wertsch Washington University in St. Louis
Sociocultural Theory Week 4, “Sociocultural Approaches to Learning and Development”
Class Starter for Read “Exploring Psychology” p. 14. Answer the following question: –Why is phrenology called a pseudoscience?
The History of Psychology Chapter 1 Section 2. Where did the scientific method come from? Wilhelm Wundt – 1879 – Leipzig, Germany – First psychology laboratory.
Unit 1: Scope, History, and Methodology By: J. Mulder AP Psychology.
Unit 1. History and Approaches
Lev Vygotsky ( ) Importance of culture and social interaction.
A Brief History of Psychology
 Defining Psychology.  Review surveys taken – public perception of psychology.  What role do you think psychology will have on your future career?
Psychology Contemporary Perspective (1:4). Six Perspectives ► Biological ► Cognitive ► Humanistic ► Psychoanalytic ► Learning ► Sociocultural.
Roots, History, Approaches. Roots Early questions: Connection between mind & body? Ideas – innate or experiential? “Psych” – mind; “ology” – study (Aristotle)
Who was Lev S. Vygotsky? Born in the Belarus region of Russia in Family was Jewish. Earned 2 degrees simultaneously from Moscow University: Law and.
Ways of Studying Religion. The Academic Study of Religion - Assumptions - One religion is neither better nor worse than another religion; they are simply.
The Psychodynamic Perspective: Psychodynamic theorists, most notably Sigmund Freud, argued that thought and behavior are determined by unconscious conflicts.
Activity theory Olivier Georgeon April 8 th
Socio-cultural Theory: A Short Primer Professor Gary Moorman Appalachian State University.
Chapter 1: What Is Psychology?. Learning Outcomes Define psychology. Describe the various fields of psychology.
Theories and Theorists By Jasmyn Powell. Psychodynamics Which is known as dynamic psychology.its an approach to psychology that emphasises systematic.
Vygotsky in the Classroom Cultural-Historical Activity Theory in Teaching. Dr. Natalia Gajdamaschko, October 6, VCC, Vancouver, Canada. Vygotsky 1: Introduction,
Activity theory Shaoke Zhang Olivier Georgeon Frank Ritter March
Section 3 – A History of Psychology A. Ancient Greece 1. Socrates suggested much can be learned by examining our thoughts and feelings. a. This is called.
Situated Cognition and Vygotsky Dr. K. A. Korb University of Jos.
LOOKING THROUGH A VYGOTSKIAN LENS: NEW OPPORTUNITIES FOR PRACTICE BASED RESEARCH Esther Joosa – Independent Researcher and Practitioner ESTHER JOOSA ISCAR.
Psychology: History and Approaches
Crap…more application
INTRODUCTION TO PSYCHOLOGY
Contemporary Psychological Perspectives
Bell Ringer What are the four goals of psychology (try not to look at your notes)? What is psychology? How are intelligence and affluence related?
Lev Vygotsky's: Sociocultural Theory
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCING PSYCHOLOGY
KNOWLEDGE AND MEANING ARE CONSTRUCTED BY THE INDIVIDUAL
History of cognitive psychology
Introduction to Psychology
Developmental Psychology
“…The unexamined life is not worth living…”
Presentation transcript:

Vygotsky on Human Nature and Human Development James V. Wertsch Department of Anthropology Washington University in St. Louis St. Louis, MO, USA

“Sociocultural Approach” to Mind Sociocultural Approach Sociocultural Approach –Human mental functioning is shaped by:  Cultural context  Historical context  Institutional context –“Sociocultural”: cultural is not reduced to historical context and difference Mental functioning of investigators and practitioners also socioculturally situated Mental functioning of investigators and practitioners also socioculturally situated

Sociocultural Approach to Mind Sociocultural situatedness of one American mind in Moscow Sociocultural situatedness of one American mind in Moscow –Mid 1970s in the Cold War –Interested in Soviet psychology and linguistics –He thought he was open to new approaches –Background in Piaget, Chomsky, Vygotsky, George Herbert Mead –Product of American individualism –Wrong “mental habits” for understanding

Vygotsky and Mead Similar claims about social origins of human mind Similar claims about social origins of human mind Even similar philosophical roots: e.g., Hegel Even similar philosophical roots: e.g., Hegel But completely different reception and impact in Russia and U.S. But completely different reception and impact in Russia and U.S. –Vygotsky made sense in Russia and had impact –Mead left little influence in U.S.

Vygotsky and Mead

Vygotsky Vygotsky – –1934: Myshlenie i Rech’ –A founder of socio- historical approach to mind Mead Mead – –1932: Mind, Self, and Society –A founder of Pragmatism along with William James and John Dewey

Mead on Social Origins of Consciousness “We are rather forced to conclude that consciousness is an emergent from [socially responsive behavior]; that so far from being a precondition of the social act, the social act is the precondition of it.” “We are rather forced to conclude that consciousness is an emergent from [socially responsive behavior]; that so far from being a precondition of the social act, the social act is the precondition of it.”

Vygotsky on Social Origins of Consciousness “The social dimension of consciousness is primary in time and in fact. The individual dimension of consciousness is derivative and secondary.” “The social dimension of consciousness is primary in time and in fact. The individual dimension of consciousness is derivative and secondary.”

Social Origins Argument Consistent with critique of “atomism” in philosophy and social theory Consistent with critique of “atomism” in philosophy and social theory Contradicts: Contradicts: –“Methodological individualism” (i.e., explanation of social phenomena must start with individual) –American cultural individualism

Sociocultural Approach of Vygotsky Not a theory in strict sense Not a theory in strict sense Shares much with ideas of other thinkers of his time Shares much with ideas of other thinkers of his time Includes unique contributions Includes unique contributions Three basic themes Three basic themes

Theme 1: Genetic (developmental) method Parallels with: Parallels with: –Sigmund Freud –Jean Piaget –Wolfgang Köhler –Heinz Werner –Kurt Lewin

1. Genetic (developmental) Method Seeks explanation in origins and developmental transformation Seeks explanation in origins and developmental transformation More than contemporary developmental psychology More than contemporary developmental psychology –“Genetic domains” with different laws  Phylogenesis  Sociocultural history  Ontogenesis  Microgenesis

2. Social Origins of Higher Mental Functions in Individual Reflects genetic method Reflects genetic method “General genetic law of cultural development” “General genetic law of cultural development” –All higher mental functions appear twice, on two planes, first on the “intermental” plane, between people, and then on the “intramental” plane, within the individual  Applies to thinking, memory, attention, etc.

2. Social Origins of Higher Mental Functions in Individual Parallels with other thinkers (e.g., Mead), but more radical claim in Vygotsky Parallels with other thinkers (e.g., Mead), but more radical claim in Vygotsky –Not just social origins, but “quasi-social nature” of mental functioning on intramental plane Border between social and individual is “porous” Border between social and individual is “porous” Same mental function appears on intermental and intramental plane Same mental function appears on intermental and intramental plane

2. Social Origins of Higher Mental Functions in Individual First sense in which “mind extends beyond the skin” First sense in which “mind extends beyond the skin” Can be “socially distributed” Can be “socially distributed” –Productive to examine how dyads, groups use discourse to think, remember Adult-child dyad as agent in remembering Adult-child dyad as agent in remembering Other- to self-regulation Other- to self-regulation –Different intermental functioning => different intramental outcomes

3. Mediation of Mental Functioning Most important and unique contributions of Vygotsky in this realm Most important and unique contributions of Vygotsky in this realm Started his career in philology, literary studies Started his career in philology, literary studies Especially interested in language as a cultural tool/mediational means Especially interested in language as a cultural tool/mediational means

3. Mediation of Mental Functioning “Mediated action” as unit of analysis “Mediated action” as unit of analysis Active-agent-using-cultural-tool Active-agent-using-cultural-tool –Cultural tool does some of our thinking, remembering for us –“Remembering” title of a book by using internet as cultural tool –Intelligence = Mastery of socioculturally valued tools

3. Mediation of Mental Functioning Using a cultural tool before we understand it Using a cultural tool before we understand it –“Performance before competence” –Illustrated by Vygotsky/Leont’ev on “forbidden colors task” –Inititial use/misuse of a sign form in intermental functioning => Mastery on intermental plane through over estimation

3. Mediation of Mental Functioning Based on Vygotsky’s clear understanding of distinction between sign form and sign meaning Based on Vygotsky’s clear understanding of distinction between sign form and sign meaning In intermental functioning can use a sign form or vehicle without full understanding of meaning In intermental functioning can use a sign form or vehicle without full understanding of meaning Not the case that we must understand a sign on the intramental plane before using it on intermental Not the case that we must understand a sign on the intramental plane before using it on intermental

3. Mediation of Mental Functioning Mediation as key to understanding: Mediation as key to understanding: –Developmental stages and transformation –Link between intermental and intramental functioning –“Importing” of social life into intramental functioning

An American in Moscow American habits of thought: American habits of thought: –Methodological individualism –Neat distinction between individual and social processes –Mental processes (memory, cognition) exist in individual mind unless marked otherwise Hard to resist “grooves/ruts of thinking” when encountering Vygotsky’s genius Hard to resist “grooves/ruts of thinking” when encountering Vygotsky’s genius