Expert Testimony in Child Sexual Abuse Cases Bad News Good News More Bad News Potential Good News Bad News Good News More Bad News Potential Good News.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Building a Trial Notebook the Paralegal Way
Advertisements

Q UINCY COLLEGE Paralegal Studies Program Paralegal Studies Program Interviewing & Investigation Foundations of Investigating.
Criminal Justice 2011 Chapter 18: Preparation for Court Criminal Investigation The Art and the Science by Michael D. Lyman Copyright 2011.
The Forensic Interviewer at Trial Strategies for Defending the Interview in Court.
ADJUDICATION HEARING Factfinding Trial. Before the Adjudicatory Hearing  Advisement hearing  Often the parent’s chance to either enter a denial or an.
Experts & Expert Reports  Experts and the FRE  FRCP, Rule 26 and experts  How are experts used in patent litigation?  What belongs in a Rule 26 report?
Law in Society The Courtroom.
The Roles of Judge and Jury Court controls legal rulings in the trial Court controls legal rulings in the trial Jury decides factual issues Jury decides.
FRAUD EXAMINATION ALBRECHT, ALBRECHT, & ALBRECHT Legal Follow-Up Chapter 18.
CJ227 Criminal Procedure Welcome to our Seminar!!! (We will begin shortly) Tonight – Unit 4 (Chapter 9 – Pretrial Motions, Hearings and Pleas) (Chapter.
Green Light? No violation if the declarant is subject to cross at trial within the meaning of Crawford Is the declarant “subject to cross at trial” if.
Crawford v. Washington US Supreme Court, March 2004 Implications for Elder Abuse Investigations Adapted from material presented June 30, 2004 by Sean Morgan.
TERMINATION OF THE PARENT CHILD LEGAL RELATIONSHIP.
Confrontation Clause The right to confront and cross exam your accusers.
 Judge  Prosecutor  Defense Attorney 2 Copyright Texas Education Agency (TEA)
CIVIL LITIGATION CLINIC Children and Families.  Always in court  Always advocating  Using every legal skill taught in law school  Using every legal.
Mock Trial This is your FINAL EXAM! Take it seriously! There will be two cases –Battered Woman Syndrome –Crack Baby I need 12 total Attorneys –3 defense.
 Generates competition between Crown and defence  Aim of both is to seek justice  Crown- Burden of proof is on the Crown to “prove case beyond a reasonable.
Use it or lose it. Know the Rules  T.R.Cr.P. 5.1  Evidence- hearsay not allowed ( except proof of ownership or expert reports)  Defense right to cross.
Testifying in Child Abuse Cases: APSAC June 1996 James E. Butler, J.D. Catherine W. Gouldin, M.D. Charles J. Schubert, M.D. Robert A. Shapiro, M.D. Children’s.
Trial Procedures II CLN4U. The Judge, The Crown, The Defence Judge: Judge: Impartial and unbiased Impartial and unbiased Applies law to case, instructs.
Chapter 7 – The adversary system Key Knowledge
Interviewing Witnesses: Who, What, Where, When, Why & How Markus H. Meier Assistant Director African Competition Forum March 26, 2013.
Crawford v. Washington US Supreme Court, March 2004 Implications for Elder Abuse Prosecutions Adapted from material presented June 30, 2004 by Sean Morgan.
ADJUDICATION HEARING Factfinding Trial. Before the Adjudicatory Hearing  Advisement hearing  Often the parent’s chance to either enter a denial or an.
Chapter 20 Writing Reports, Preparing for and Presenting Cases in Court.
Unit 3 Seminar! K. Austin Zimmer Any question from Unit 2! Please make sure you have completed your Unit 1 & 2 Papers!
The Trial Process and the Investigator as a Witness.
Trial. Trial: broken down  Pre-Trial hearings: Judge makes decisions on various motions  Opening statement: attorneys tell the story of the case. No.
REFLECTIONS ON EXPERT WITNESS TRAINING ACADEMY Mona Behl, Ph.D. Texas Sea Grant College Program Texas A&M University College Station, TX.
Criminal and Civil Cases
FRAUD EXAMINATION ALBRECHT, ALBRECHT, & ALBRECHT Legal Follow-Up Chapter 18.
The Use and Admissibility into Evidence of Learned Treatises and Other Expert Writings September 10, 2009 David M. Cook, Attorney at Law The Hardison Law.
Presentation by Jim and Josh McGuire Permission granted for any education use in connection with MBA Mock Trial Program November 18, 2002 Pirated and modified.
How To Prepare A Team For Mock Trial Presenters: Jean Wentz and Lourdes Morales.
Following a Case Through the Federal Courts. Overview A case begins when a lawyer or individual files a formal complaint with the clerk’s office of District.
Unit 6 The Trial: Players, Motions, Hearings, and Pleas Or I am getting my day in court.
Planning & Conducting Investigations Markus H. Meier Assistant Director African Competition Forum March 25, 2013.
Crawford v. Washington US Supreme Court, March 2004 Implications for Courts NYC Elder Abuse Training Project.
1 The Examiner’s Role in Developing the Fair Lending Case Debra Pearlman, FLEX JoAnna Gekas, Counsel.
Unit 6  What needs to be done this week SeminarSeminar QuizQuiz Discussion boardDiscussion board Unit 9 Analysis and ApplicationUnit 9 Analysis and Application.
Criminal Arrest Procedure What happens from crime to trial?
March 4, 2011 Civil Procedure.
1 What Is Scientific Evidence? Scientific evidence is most often presented in court by an expert witness testifying on expert opinions. It also includes.
APPELLATE INVESTIGATION PROJECT SERVICES PROVIDED AND HOW TO REQUEST SUPPORT Katherine Marcuz, Principal Attorney Andrew.
BUSINESS LAW CIVIL PROCEDURE Session 3 Lakeshore Technical College Richard Opie, JD, MA copyright 2014.
STEPS OF A TRIAL. AGENDA March 14, Today’s topics:  Steps of A Trial  Intro to Mini Mock Trial 2.Administrative:  Glossary 3.Homework due next.
The Trial Civ Lit I: Unit 9. 2 Preparing for Trial.
PROCEDURES IN THE JUSTICE SYSTEM, 8 th ed. Roberson, Wallace, and Stuckey PRENTICE HALL ©2007 Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, NJ
CJ305 Criminal Evidence Welcome to our Seminar!!! (We will begin shortly) Tonight – Unit 3 (Chapter 5 – Witnesses -- Lay & Expert) (Chapter 6 – Credibility.
DAY #3: The Legal System: Trying a Criminal Case 1.What do lawyers do BEFORE a trial? 2.What are some reasons why a judge may dismiss or suppress evidence?
Seven Steps of the DWI Trial Process El Paso DWI Attorney Help Guide.
TERMINATION OF THE PARENT CHILD LEGAL RELATIONSHIP.
CJ227: Criminal Procedure Unit 6 Seminar Mary K Cronin.
Comparing the Inquisitorial and Adversarial Systems.
Resolution of Fraud FRAUD EXAMINATION ALBRECHT & ALBRECHT Legal Follow-Up Chapter 16.
MOTIONS and HEARINGS DEFENSE INVESTIGATORS TRAINING ACADEMY II Case Development and Procedures Regina A. Laughney Law Offices.
Week Nine Seminar 1.  By the time that the pleadings have been settled, discovery has been completed, and motions have been resolved, everyone has a.
Fraud Examination, 3E Chapter 18: Legal Follow-Up
Forensic Science NAS Report
Chapter Twelve Civil Procedure Before Trial
Outline of the U.S. and Arizona Criminal Justice Systems
Mock Trials Court Systems and Practices.
Judges and Juries The Courtroom Players.
Lab 1: Courtroom Testimony
The Mechanics of Getting Your Own Expert
Chapter 3 Judicial, Alternative, and E-Dispute Resolution
What is involved in a civil lawsuit?
Judges and Juries The Courtroom Players.
I made the CPS report: now what?
Presentation transcript:

Expert Testimony in Child Sexual Abuse Cases Bad News Good News More Bad News Potential Good News Bad News Good News More Bad News Potential Good News

Bad News Expert Vouching Expert Assistance Access to the Complainant Defense Expert Testimony Discovery

Good News The Law Does Change – Hearsay – Vouching – Admissibility of Expert Opinion

More Bad News You have to change the message – Motions – Offers of Proof – Cross examination

Potential Good News The science is changing. Rule 702 Discovery Resources

Pretrial Preparation Interview State’s witness Discovery Motion Motion for your own expert Motion for exam of complainant Find treatise-cross exam material Investigate collateral proceedings Give notice of your witness’ opinions Motion for pretrial hearing

Trial Treatise cross examination Listen for “stealth vouching” Object to opinions not in notice Present your witness Interested expert witness instruction Frady instruction