world development report 2004 Making Services Work for Poor People.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Abt Associates Inc. In collaboration with: Aga Khan Foundation BearingPoint Bitrán y Asociados BRAC University Broad Branch Associates Forum One Communications.
Advertisements

Making Services Work for Poor People: Water and Sanitation December 18, 2004 Junaid Ahmad OECD, Paris.
Reaching the marginalized Samer Al-Samarrai Child Friendly Budgets for 2010 and Beyond Policy Forum New York, February EFA Global Monitoring Report.
RE-THINKING ACCOUNTABILITY Social Accountability and the Search for More Effective Public Expenditure Jeff Thindwa Participation and Civic Engagement.
© 2005 POPULATION REFERENCE BUREAU Improving the Health of the Worlds Poorest People.
21 July 2005 UNDG Policy Network On the MDGs UNDG Policy Network on the MDGs.
Eric A. Hanushek Stanford University
Diseases without borders What must the Global Development Community Do? World Bank Seminar Series Tawhid Nawaz, Operations Advisor Human Development Network.
1 The Global Education Challenge: A View from the World Bank Global Seminar Series 18 October 2006 Washington DC.
1 Integrating to the world economy: El Salvador Manuel Hinds Madagascar, June
1 A relationship of accountability has five features Actors (principals) including clients, citizens, policy- makers Accountable actors (agents) including.
Rural Poverty, Food Security, and Trade Liberalization: Exploring the Linkages WTO Symposium on Trade and Sustainable Development October, 2005.
Good governance for water, sanitation and hygiene services
Open Aid Partnership Open Aid Partnership visualizes the sub-national location of donor-financed projects Bjorn-Soren Gigler
Quantitative Service Delivery Surveys: Some lessons from schools surveys Deon Filmer Development Research Group The World Bank Kampala, Uganda July 29,
G LOBAL S ERVICES Lesson 4: Delivery of Public Services.
THE COMMONWEALTH FUND Figure 1. Nine of 10 Health Care Opinion Leaders Think Fundamental Change Is Required to Achieve Gains in Quality and Efficiency.
World development report 2004 Making Services Work for Poor People.
“From Shouting to Counting” - Introducing the Concept of Social Accountability Participation and Civic Engagement Group, Social Development Department,
Health Systems and Actors Tom Merrick, World Bank.
Managing Public Expenditures to Make Services Work for Poor People Discussion with Public Expenditure Thematic Group Shanta Devarajan, Shekhar Shah WDR.
When we started this project we believed that … … regional governments have limited resources which are distributed unevenly. … Indonesia needs more resources.
HEALTH EQUITY: THE INDIAN CONTEXT Subodh S Gupta.
Human development and public finances Servaas van der Berg Dept of Economics, University of Stellenbosch Presentation to first ERSA Public Economics Workshop,
Making Services Work for Poor People world development report 2004 Making Services Work for Poor People Youth Open House, The World Bank New Delhi, March.
Building Community Orientated Primary Care in Mali Group One.
Country Ownership for Reproductive Health; An NGO perspectiveSLIDE 1 “ACCESS FOR ALL: SUPPLYING A NEW DECADE FOR REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH ” Country Ownership.
DECENTRALIZATION AND RURAL SERVICES : MESSAGES FROM RECENT RESEARCH AND PRACTICE Graham B. Kerr Community Based Rural Development Advisor The World Bank.
Achieving Our Goals Through Partnerships Women’s World Banking Mary Ellen IskenderianSeptember 7,2010.
Making Services Work: Indicators, Assessments and Benchmarking of Governance in Health and Education Dena Ringold, Senior Economist, The World Bank APPAM.
World development report 2004 Making Services Work for Poor People.
Moving towards the goal of Universal Health Coverage (UHC) in Bangladesh Md. Ashadul Islam Director General Health Economics Unit Ministry of Health and.
Public Expenditure Analysis for Education Deon Filmer DECRG January 2004.
Consultative Meeting on Accelerating the Attainment of MDG 5 in Kenya – August 27-28, 2014 Investing in Primary Health Care for reducing maternal & child.
Tracking Public Expenditure: A Guide Waly Wane Development Research Group The World Bank Are You Being Served? June 2009.
STRENGTHENING HEALTH SYSTEMS Anne Mills DCPP Editor London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine.
Public Financial Accountability at the Local Level : The role of PFM in Service Delivery and Accountability Rama Krishnan, Senior Financial Management.
Tackling Health Care Corruption and Governance Woes in Developing Countries Maureen Lewis Advisor, HD Vice Presidency Nonresident Fellow, CGD.
Measurement Matters: The Use of PETS and QSDS Public Expenditure Analysis and Management Course Ritva Reinikka Development Research Group (DEC) Public.
RWANDA PERFORMANCE BASED SYSTEM: PUBLIC REFORMS Claude SEKABARAGA, MD, MPH Director policy, planning and capacity building Ministry of Health October 2008.
1 African Development Bank Agnes Soucat, MD, Ph.D Director Department of Human Development African Development Bank Agnes Soucat, MD, Ph.D Director Department.
Closing the policy implementation gap Dr Mickey Chopra UNICEF, New York.
Girls’ Education for All Jeopardy! Social-Cultural Barriers to Education Education Facts and Figures Good Practices in getting girls to school Organizations.
Making Services Work for Poor People Shanta Devarajan World Bank.
Cambodia1. 2 Cambodia Assessment Ung Phirun Chroeng Sokhan.
Assessing Frontline Service Delivery in Education Ritva Reinikka World Bank - DECRG HD week 2002.
Organizational Reforms Gaston Sorgho, Harvard School of Public Health Reproductive Health and Health Sector Reform.
THE WORLD BANK ECD PORTFOLIO The World Bank has increased its investment in ECD programs from approximately US$ 126 million in 1990 to a total of about.
Public Social Expenditures Education (2.3 percent of GDP) Health (1 percent of GDP) Social protection (1 percent of GDP) -- equal to $12 per capita and.
World development report 2004 Making Services Work for Poor People.
Kiichiro Fukasaku Development Centre
Political Economy and Results Based Financing: Client’s Power, Voice, and the challenge of monitoring Agnes Soucat, World Bank and Gaston Sorgho, World.
Building Public/Private Partnership for Health System Strengthening Social Franchising Dominic Montagu Bali Hyatt Hotel, Sanur, Bali June 2010.
Decentralization and service delivery. The problem Disappointing health and education outcomes, especially for poor people.
Economic Analysis of Education: Public-Private Roles E. Jimenez March 2008.
Open Aid Partnership Open Aid Partnership visualizes the sub-national location of donor-financed projects
Making services work for poor people: What’s decentralization got to do with it? World Development Report 2004 Shanta Devarajan and Shekhar Shah Decentralization.
Making Services Work for the Poor in Rwanda. WDR04 Messages Services are failing poor people. But they can work. How? By empowering poor people to –Monitor.
Political Economy and Results Based Financing: Client’s Power, Voice, and the challenge of monitoring Agnes Soucat, World Bank and Gaston Sorgho, World.
Public Expenditure Tracking and Service Delivery Surveys 11 th International Anti-Corruption Conference Seoul May 26, 2003 Magnus Lindelow Development.
Can performance-based incentives be used to tackle inequalities in the health sector? Abdo Yazbeck, Lead Health Economist Africa Human Development World.
Gender, Health and Poverty: Critical Factors Beyond the Health Sector Arlette Campbell White World Bank Institute.
Evaluating Social Funds: A Cross- Country Analysis of Community Investments February 2004 Laura Rawlings, Lynne Sherburne-Benz, Julie Van Domelen.
EDUCATION AND THE PUBLIC BUDGET Emmanuel Jimenez Budgetary Processes & Public Expenditure Course May 2000.
Making Services Work for Poor People
Improving Service Delivery for Children
Making Services Work for Poor People
World Development Report 2004 Making Services Work for Poor People
Making Services Work for Poor People
Measurement Matters: The Use of PETS and QSDS
Presentation transcript:

world development report 2004 Making Services Work for Poor People

Messages Services are failing poor people. But they can work. How? By empowering poor people to –Monitor and discipline service providers –Raise their voice in policymaking By strengthening incentives for service providers to serve the poor

Outcomes are worse for poor people Deaths per 1000 births Source: Analysis of Demographic and Health Survey data

Growth is not enough Percent living on $1/day Primary completion rate (percent)Under-5 mortality rate Target2015 growth alone Target2015 growth alone Target2015 growth alone East Asia Europe and Central Asia Latin America Middle East and North Africa South Asia Africa Sources: World Bank 2003a, Devarajan Notes: Average annual growth rates of GDP per capita assumed are: EAP 5.4; ECA 3.6; LAC 1.8; MENA 1.4; SA 3.8; AFR 1.2. Elasticity assumed between growth and poverty is –1.5; primary completion is 0.62; under-5 mortality is –0.48.

But increasing public spending is also not enough * Percent deviation from rate predicted by GDP per capita Source: Spending and GDP from World Development Indicators database. Under-5 mortality from Unicef 2002 Making Services Work for Poor People

Vastly different changes in spending can be associated with similar changes in outcomes. Sources: Spending data for 1990s from World Development Indicators database. Child mortality data from Unicef Other data from World Bank staff

How are services failing poor people? Public spending usually benefits the rich, not the poor

Expenditure incidence HealthEducation Source: Filmer 2003b

Public spending benefits the rich more than the poor Money/goods/people are not at the frontline of service provision –Public expenditure tracking results on what reaches or is at the facility level How are services failing poor people?

Nonwage funds not reaching schools: Evidence from PETS (%) CountryMean Ghana Madagascar Peru 2001 (utilities) 30 Tanzania Uganda Zambia 2001 (discretion/rule) 76/10 Source: Ye and Canagarajah (2002) for Ghana; Francken (2003) for Madagascar; Instituto Apoyo and World Bank (2002) for Peru; Price Waterhouse Coopers (1998) for Tanzania; Reinikka and Svensson 2002 for Uganda; Das et al. (2002) for Zambia.

Access to primary school and health clinics in rural areas Distance to nearest primary school (km) Distance to nearest medical facility (km) GNI per capita Poorest fifth Richest fifth RatioPoorest fifth Richest fifth Ratio Chad Nigeria CAR Haiti India Bolivia Morocco Source: Analysis of Demographic and Health Survey data. Note: GNI per capita is in 2001 US$. Medical facility encompasses health centers, dispensaries, hospitals, and pharmacies.

Public spending benefits the rich more than the poor Money/goods fail to reach frontline service providers Service quality is low for poor people How are services failing poor people?

Percent of staff absent in primary schools and health facilities

But services can work Motivating health workers reduced infant mortality in Ceará, Brazil Contracted services in Johannesburg, South Africa improved transport and water delivery Cash transfers to families in Mexico increased enrollment, lowered illness Citizen report cards improved services in Bangalore, India Publicizing what schools were supposed to get resulted in more money reaching primary schools in Uganda Delegating project choice and management to villagers improved infrastructure in Indonesia

A framework of relationships of accountability Poor peopleProviders

Short and long routes of accountability

The relationship of accountability has five features

A framework of relationships of accountability Poor peopleProviders Policymakers

Client-provider Strengthen accountability by: Choice Participation: clients as monitors

FSSAP Bangladesh Criteria: –Attendance in school –Passing grade –Unmarried Girls to receive scholarship deposited to account set up in her name School to receive support based on # of girls Making Services Work for Poor People

Client-provider: EDUCO Program in El Salvador Parents’ associations (ACEs) –Hire and fire teachers –Visit schools on regular basis –Contract with Ministry of Education to deliver primary education

EDUCO promoted parental involvement… Source: Adapted from Jimenez and Sawada 1999 …which boosts student performance

The Bamako Initiative Community managed services Partnership between state and community organizations Financial contributions from users locally retained, owned and managed Government contract and subsidy

Making Services Work for Poor People Client-Provider: Bamako Initiative Evolution of antenatal care coverage Mali Evolution of national immunization coverage

Making Services Work for Poor People Under five mortality decrease ….among the poor in Mali Client-Provider: Bamako Initiative

No blanket policy on user fees

Poor people Policymakers A framework of relationships of accountability Providers

Citizen-policymaker Political economy of public services

Ah, there he is again! How time flies! It’s time for the general election already! Why don’t services work for poor people? By R. K. Laxman

PRONASOL expenditures according to party in municipal government Source: Estevez, Magaloni and Diaz-Cayeros 2002

Citizen-policymaker Political economy of public services Formal channels Importance of non-formal channels Role of information –Citizen report card (initiatives in Vietnam, Indonesia, Philippines) –Publicizing textbook distribution in Philippines—and engaging communities as monitors

Schools in Uganda received more of what they were due Source: Reinikka and Svensson (2001), Reinikka and Svensson (2003a)

A framework of relationships of accountability Providers Policymakers Poor people

Policymaker-provider “Hard to monitor” versus “Easy to monitor” Information for monitoring

Policymaker-provider: Contracting NGOs in Cambodia Contracting out (CO): NGO can hire and fire, transfer staff, set wages, procure drugs, etc. Contracting in (CI): NGO manages district, cannot hire and fire (but can transfer staff), $0.25 per capita budget supplement Control/Comparison (CC): Services run by government 12 districts randomly assigned to CC, CI or CO

Utilization of facilities by poor People sick in last month Source: Bhushan, Keller and Schwartz 2002

Ceara : increased effectiveness of government services Making Services Work for Poor People Source:

Poor peopleProviders Policymakers A framework of relationships of accountability

What not to do Leave it to the private sector Simply increase public spending Apply technocratic solutions

Of course we have progressed a great deal, first they were coming by bullock-cart, then by jeep and now this! What not to do… technocratic solutions…

What is to be done? Expand information –Generation and dissemination –Impact evaluation Tailor service delivery arrangements to service characteristics and country circumstances

Eight sizes fit all?

What are we up against when attempting to improve aid efficiency?

WDR messages to donors Harmonize policies and procedures around recipient’s systems Where possible, integrate aid in recipient’s budget Finance impact evaluation of service delivery innovations – $300 million a year in Bank projects allocated for evaluation

Making Services Work for Poor People world development report 2004

Strengths of Clients and Policymakers as monitors

Bottlenecks: Skilled human resources Physical access Quality Cost Individual Oriented clinical care High asymmetry of information Transaction intensive High discretion Levers: Direct control of users Self Regulation Sophisticated purchasing capacity Providers: Hospitals Clinics Individual practitioners (licensed or not…)

Bottlenecks: Low demand Low continuity Opportunity Cost Population Oriented Outreach Lower Asymmetry of information Less Transaction intensive Low discretion: standards Public good nature or network externality Levers: Collective action: Government Primarily Providers Integrated in clinical services (clinics, GP) Integrated in schools, workplace Outreach health post Mobile Activities Home visits, door to door activities

Bottlenecks: Knowledge Availability and cost of commodities Family Oriented Support to self care Low asymmetry of information Transaction light High discretion in taste/ values Levers: Imitate the market Direct control of users Providers Retail Community based organizations/ associations Cooperatives Social marketing, media, Women’s groups, associations etc

Poor peopleProviders Policymakers A framework of relationships of accountability

Poor peopleProviders National policymakers Decentralization Local policymakers