Partners HealthCare System

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
New America Forum April 12, 2010 New America Forum: A First Look at Implementing Health Reform The Delivery System Challenge State Implementation Issues.
Advertisements

Medical Education Outcomes Research Frederick Chen, MD, MPH Center for Primary Care Research Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality June 26, 2003.
Legislative Update Michael J. Dyer, JD Vice President for Government Relations, AACOM OME Conference January 13, 2007.
Federal Financial Support for State Health Reform Implementation Edwin Park Center on Budget and Policy Priorities From Vision to Reality: State Strategies.
Laying the Foundation for Health Equity From Vision to Reality: State Strategies for Health Reform Implementation November 12, 2010 Health Reform:
Health Reform and Medicare: Overview of Key Provisions
Overview of the Workforce Provisions in the Affordable Care Act The Health Workforce Dream Team: Who Will Provide the Care? Alliance for Health Reform.
Are U.S. Trained Residents Ready for 21 st Century Care Systems? Francis J. Crosson, MD Senior Fellow, Kaiser Permanente Institute for Health Policy AHR.
Sustainability of Public Health Programs Audrey M. Stevenson MSN, FNP, MPH.
National Perspective on Changes Impacting the Public Health System Judith A. Monroe, MD Director, Office for State, Tribal, Local and Territorial Support.
Accountable Care Workgroup December 13, Agenda Call to Order/Roll Call Discussion – Discuss Key Messages/Takeaways from the Accountable Care Workgroup.
Medicare and Medicaid GME Funding Presentation to GME Program Coordinators April 2014.
1 VHWDA Board Dec. 4, 2013 VHHA Healthcare Workforce Development Plan.
Transforming Illinois Health Care Illinois Medicaid 1115 Waiver.
What Can States Do For Graduate Medical Education? What Can States Do For Graduate Medical Education? Paul H. Rockey, MD, MPH Scholar in Residence Accreditation.
A Healthier Nevada PRESENTED BY: TRIPP UMBACH 9/29/14 1.
The OHF Medical Education Summit: a summary Sponsored by American Osteopathic Association and the American Association of Colleges of Osteopathic Medicine.
An Overview of: Federal Funding Opportunities for Oral Health Yvonne Knight, J.D. Senior Vice President Advocacy and Governmental Relations ADEA Policy.
New York State Workforce Investment Board Healthcare Workforce Development Subcommittee Planning Grant Overview.
The University Budget Debora Obley Associate Vice President
Health Reform: An Environmental Overview Jon Fishpaw, VP, Advocacy & Government Relations Catholic Health Partners May 18, 2011.
Impact of Health Care Reform
What Happens after You Sign with Missouri Health Information Technology Assistance Center?
University of Nebraska Medical Center PRIMARY CARE Definitions Millis Commission – 1966 First-contact, continuing, and comprehensive care Institute of.
Health Affairs Panel on IOM GME report Brad Poss, MD, MMM Professor, Department of Pediatrics Associate Dean for Graduate Medical Education University.
Better, Smarter, Healthier Delivery System Reform Presentation to the Health IT Policy Committee March 10, 2015 U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
Meeting the Healthcare Needs of the Public Increasing Physician Workforce Supply Issues and Challenges Florida Board of Governors Medical Education Workshop.
Capacity Task Force Virginia Health Reform Initiative January 14, 2011
GRADUATE MEDICAL EDUCATION: A PRIMER Rural Health Development Council 13 August 2009.
ORC TA: Medicare Rural Hospital Flexibility Grant Program HRSA U.S. Department of Health & Human Services Health Resources & Services Administration.
Driving Better Outcomes: Aligning State Investments With Completion Needs Typology & Principles to Inform Outcomes-Based Funding Models Presented by: Martha.
Presented by Amper’s Healthcare Services Group.  Overview of Topics ◦ Healthcare Reform ◦ Ambulatory Services ◦ Hospital Services ◦ Compliance Concerns.
Financing GME In Minnesota: MERC Program Activities Diane Rydrych Office of Health Policy, Statistics & Informatics MN Department of Health Minnesota Rural.
Graduate Medical Education What It Is Why It Matters Possible Solutions Greater Phoenix Chamber of Commerce November 19, 2012.
THE COMMONWEALTH FUND Developing Innovative Payment Approaches: Finding the Path to High Performance Stuart Guterman Assistant Vice President and Director,
Issues and Challenges Facing Medicare Mark L. Hayes.
Innovation and Health System Transformation Chisara N. Asomugha, MD, MSPH, FAAP (Acting) Director, Division of Population Health Incentives & Infrastructure,
Health Care Reform and its Impact on Michigan Janet Olszewski, Director Michigan Department of Community Health Senate Health Policy Committee May 5, 2010.
Getting Connected: Can the ACA Improve Access to Health Care in Rural Communities? Russell Senate Office Building October 13, 2010 Clint MacKinney, MD,
THE COMMONWEALTH FUND Figure 1. Barriers to Growth of Accountable Care Systems “In your view, how significant are the following barriers to growth of population-based,
ARRA and HHS Data Policy Initiatives Academy Health NAHDO All Payer All Claims Data Bases James Scanlon, HHS Deputy Assistant Secretary/ASPE.
Michelle Lefkowitz Technical Advisor Division of Acute Care Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services
Resourcing the Mission: The New Internal Financial Model.
UNC School of Medicine Basic Science Faculty Compensation Plan Proposal: Linking Performance with Resources and Rewards Robert N. Golden, M.D. Vice Dean,
Presentation to the Chancellor’s Cabinet October 14, 2013 Inspiration. Innovation. Graduation. Presented by Mr. Roy Stutzman, RvStutzman Consulting.
Education Goal: To continue to develop our innovative, efficient, system-based curriculum with a focus on basic science and its correlation with clinical.
Medicaid Managed Care Rate Reviews November
University of Michigan Medical School Academy for Educational Excellence and Scholarship Monthly Seminar – December 15, Academy Updates membership.
Meeting of the Finance Committee New Internal Financial Model November 8, 2012.
Beth Faiman MSN, APRN-BC, AOCN Cleveland Clinic Taussic Cancer Institute Pre-Doctoral Research Fellow Case Western Reserve University Cleveland, Ohio America’s.
Graduate Medical Education Failing Primary Care Bob Phillips, MD MSPH Vice Chair, COGME June 9, 2008.
AACN – Manatt Study In February 2015, the AACN Board of Directors commissioned Manatt Health to conduct a study on how to position academic nursing to.
Delivery System Reform Incentive Payment Program (“DSRIP”) New York Presbyterian Performing Provider System.
LEADING THE CREATION AND ADVANCEMENT OF HEALTH EQUITY SPRING BOARD OF TRUSTEES MEETING We are on a mission. Leveraging the State’s $35M Investment in MSM.
22 nd Annual Rural Health Policy Institute Deputy Administrator, HRSA Marcia K. Brand, PhD January 24, 2011.
Political & Policy Perspectives of GME Development in Arkansas Nate Smith, MD, MPH Director & State Health Officer Arkansas Department of Health.
Leadership to Create Change Winston Liaw, MD MPH Kathleen Klink, MD Hope Wittenberg, MA Using the Institute of Medicine’s Report on Graduate Medical Education.
All-Payer Model Update
Physician Workforce Discussion
ALAMO FAMILY HEALTH TEAM 1.
Clinical Learning Environment Review GMEC January 8, 2013
GME Modernization Bill
Medical Education and Research Costs (MERC) Program
Small Rural Hospital Improvement Grant Program (SHIP)
Compensation Committee 2017 Goals – Updated
Graduate Medical Education (GME) Policy
2018 OSEP Project Directors’ Conference
Making Healthcare Affordable
GMHC Board of Directors November 14, 2016
All-Payer Model Update
Presentation transcript:

Partners HealthCare System GME Governance and Financing: What can the IOM Committee Recommendations Accomplish? Debra F. Weinstein, M.D. Vice President, GME Partners HealthCare System dweinstein@partners.org

Context for the Deliberations: Perceived Problems Mismatch between physician workforce and population needs Insufficient physician diversity GME graduates lack some competencies needed for current practice Insufficient fiscal transparency, accountability for public funding “Overpayment” of IME Questions re: justification for public funding

Primary Focus: $10B from Medicare $15B in federal funding

Committee Observations Underlying the Recommendations Forecasting need for physicians is historically unreliable Medicare GME payment formulas are inflexible, inequitable, illogical, inscrutable and outdated Net financial impact of sponsoring residency programs is poorly understood ↑Federal funding for GME (in the current system) wouldn’t address specialty or geographic needs ↑GME trainees isn’t dependent on ↑federal funding 17.5% ↑ 2003-12 despite cap on Medicare-funded slots

Problems with Current Distribution Methodology Linked to Medicare volume Children’s Hospitals and other non-PPS orgs excluded Disincentive for ambulatory training DME linked to historic costs Significant variation in PRA’s Poor understanding of net financial impact Cap on funded slots Locks in current funding distribution Payments contingent only on accreditation Lacks incentive to improve outcomes or vehicle to influence production (e.g. specialty mix) Payment to sites (rather than sponsors) Undermines accountability

The Gist of the Recommendations Maintain stable, secure public funding for GME (at least for the next decade) Move from cost-based to outcome-based funding Improve the GME payment distribution methodology Phase in changes to minimize problems from funding shifts Incentivize, facilitate and support innovation Leave Medicaid at states’ discretion, but require same transparency and accountability as for Medicare Create a GME Policy Council in the Office of HHS Secretary and a GME Center within CMMS

Create one Medicare GME fund (i. e Create one Medicare GME fund (i.e. merge IME and DME) with two subsidiary funds Operational Fund Transformation Fund develop and evaluate innovations in education pilot alternative GME payment methods determine and validate performance measures needed for an outcomes-based payment system award new Medicare-funded GME training positions in priority disciplines and geographic areas

Overview of Proposed Funding Allocation

Modernize Medicare GME Payment Methodology Operational funds distributed via a single payment (current IME and DME streams are combined) National per-resident amount (PRA), with a geographic adjustment PRA = total value of the GME Operational Fund ÷ current # Medicare-funded training slots Operational funds provided directly to sponsoring organizations (Phase II:) Implement performance-based payments

Impact of Phase I Financing Recommendations Funding for Children’s Hospitals & Teaching Health Centers Institutional revenue (from Operational Fund) will ↑ or ↓ National PRA will ↓ during temp expansion of Transformation Fund Funds →GME sponsor requires negotiations between affiliates Coordinated collection and analysis of data relating to GME outcomes Funding, structure, ?regulatory relief support research Concerns about “empirically justified” IME become moot

Vision for Phase II Operational Fund distributes performance-based payments Transformation Fund supports ongoing R&D System is flexible and nimble Outcomes data continually evaluated Payment incentives change to address evolving workforce needs Funding shifts (gradually) across sponsors and specialties to maximize outcomes 10-year re-evaluation: data documents high value outcomes