The demolition-foreclosure-equity connection Michael Schramm Research Associate, Center on Urban Poverty and Community Development, Case Western Reserve.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Thriving Communities Institute From Vacancy to Vitality A Program of Western Reserve Land Conservancy Thriving Communities Institute From Vacancy to Vitality.
Advertisements

Richland County Land Reutilization Corporation.
PRESENTATION Sequencing a Property’s Path Towards Vacancy Presented by the Institute for Housing Studies at NNIP Partnership October.
Update on Foreclosure and Vacant Property Frank Ford Senior Vice President for Research and Development Neighborhood Progress, Inc. October 26, 2012.
Foreclosure Trends Frank Ford Senior Vice President for Research and Development Neighborhood Progress, Inc. June 15, 2012.
Targeting NSP Funds Todd Richardson HUD Office of Policy Development and Research.
CDBG Supplemental Assistance For The Redevelopment of Abandoned And Foreclosed Homes Title III, Section 2301 of the Housing and Economic Recovery Act of.
Neighborhood Stabilization Program (NSP) Orange County, Florida.
HUD Parcel Data Activities Exploratory Develop Tools for Neighborhood Recovery in the Gulf Region – focus on parcel boundaries County Data Records Project–
Stabilizing neighborhoods affected by the foreclosure crisis Alan Mallach Nonresident Senior Fellow The Brookings Institution.
The Clumper: Finding Needles in a Property Haystack Research Associate, Center on Urban Poverty and Community Development, Case Western Reserve University.
UPDATE ON FORECLOSURE AND VACANT PROPERTY IN CUYAHOGA COUNTY Frank Ford Senior Policy Advisor Thriving Communities Institute November 1, 2013.
Sustaining the Single Family Portfolio Post Hardest Hit Fund Rhode Island 2014 NCSHA Conference October 21, 2014 Leslie McKnight, Director of Loan Servicing.
Vacant Property Working Group (VPWG) Pittsburgh Community Reinvestment Group 1901Centre Avenue, Suite 200 Pittsburgh, PA (412) Staff Contact:
City of Pittsburgh – Department of City Planning The Pittsburgh and Philadelphia Stories John Carpenter REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY of the CITY OF PHILADELPHIA.
A New Future for Our Old Places Liz Hersh, Executive Director, Housing Alliance of PA.
PROPERTY TAX REVENUE GOT YOU DOWN? CSMFO Conference Los Angeles – February 18, 2009 The HdL Companies Sales Tax Property Tax Municipal Software.
CUYAHOGA COUNTY HOUSING ISSUES IN THE SHADOW OF THE FORECLOSURE CRISIS Prepared for the Fair Lending and Vital Communities Conference Frank Ford Senior.
Cause for Concern? “Vacancies create a downward spiral for neighborhood housing markets that is difficult to correct, even with large infusions of public.
Neighborhood Stabilization Program (NSP) Quarterly Report August 25, 2009.
The Effects of Different Land Uses in Missouri on Local Fiscal Conditions – Cost of Community Services Project Update – 4/12/02.
Delaware Community Investment Fund Committee of 100 Economic Roundtable June 26, 2015.
Transactions Based Commercial Real Estate Indices: A Comparative Performance Analysis 1 QIULIN KE, 2 KAREN SIERACKI, AND 3 MICHAEL WHITE 1 UNIVERSITY COLLEGE.
THE FORECLOSURE CRISIS BAY AREA CASE STUDY. Overview 2  Research Focus  Neighborhood Stabilization Program (NSP)  Bay Area Demographics  Foreclosures.
Chapter 3 Finance Theory and Real Estate © OnCourse Learning.
Atlantic Conference The Market Environment Challenges and Opportunities July 14, 2010 Bill Monagle, Partner and Senior Strategist.
Frank Ford, Senior Policy Advisor Thriving Communities Institute Cleveland, Ohio April Hirsh, Research Assistant Center on Urban Poverty and Community.
New Approaches to Complex Urban Problems Georgine Welo, Mayor, City of South Euclid Scott Lynch, Councilman, City of Euclid Jim Rokakis, Vice-President.
We’ve Done It Our Way Carolyn Rice County Treasurer & Board Chair Montgomery County Land Reutilization Corporation.
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania October 6, 2011 The Partnership Potential of Municipal Land Banks and Community Land Trusts: Land Banks 101 Dan Kildee, Center.
February 7, Presentation Outline Background Program Implementation Program Accomplishments Additional NSP Activity-Rental Summary.
Neighborhood Stabilization Program (NSP) Orange County, Florida.
Neighborhood Stabilization Program (NSP) Update February 16, 2010.
Weak Market Cities Detroit: A Ground Level Perspective September 21, 2006 Anika Goss-Foster Senior Program Director Detroit LISC.
Thriving Communities Institute From Vacancy to Vitality A Program of Western Reserve Land Conservancy Thriving Communities Institute From Vacancy to Vitality.
1 Working with CDCs – the Providence, Rhode Island experience Amintha K. Cinotti, Deputy Director Planning and Development David N. Cicilline Mayor.
University of Michigan TARP Consequences: Lending and Risk Taking Ran Duchin Denis Sosyura.
Neighborhood Stabilization Program Redevelopment of Abandoned and Foreclosed Homes.
CLEVELAND CODE ENFORCEMENT PARTNERSHIP AND DATA
Mission The Mission of the Cuyahoga County Land Reutilization Corporation is to strategically acquire properties, return them to productive use, reduce.
PRESENTATION Demystifying Data: IHS’s Approach to Data Development and Applied Research Presented by the Institute for Housing Studies for the Reclaiming.
Emre Ergungor Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland Foreclosures In Ohio: Does Lender Type Matter?
Housing Trends In Cuyahoga County __________ Is The Foreclosure Crisis Over? It Depends On Where You’re Standing. Frank Ford Senior Policy Advisor, Thriving.
Asset Allocation Portfolio Management.
1 Using Data to Strengthen a Community’s Foreclosure Response Efforts – The NNIP Model Center on Urban Poverty and Community Development Case Western Reserve.
COUNTY LAND UTILIZATION CORPORATIONS: LAND BANKS Perrysburg, Ohio September 17, 2015.
Community Stabilization in the Wake of the Foreclosure Crisis Ali Solis, Vice President, Public Policy & Industry Relations Enterprise Community Partners.
The Role of Investors in the One- to Three- Family Market: April Hirsh Center on Urban Poverty and Community Development Case Western Reserve University.
Best Practices for Neighborhood Stabilization Ken Wade, CEO NeighborWorks ® America.
County Land Utilization Corporations, aka Land Banks Ildi Pallos Piqua, Ohio October 20, 2015.
A Briefing to the Housing Committee Housing/Community Services Department October 5, 2015.
Housing Trends In Cuyahoga County __________ Is The Foreclosure Crisis Over? It Depends On Where You’re Standing. Analysis by Frank Ford Senior Policy.
FIVE YEAR FINANCIAL FORECAST OCTOBER 2012 Cleveland Municipal School District The primary goal of the Cleveland Municipal School District is to become.
Thursday, October 1, 2015 Collier County, Florida David A. Jackson, Visiting Advisor, Community Economic Development, Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta.
Rethinking Revitalization: A Data Driven Approach to Addressing the Foreclosure Crisis Jeff Matson CIC Impact Summit Nov. 16, 2012.
University Center For Social and Urban Research Data-Driven Organizing Information-Based Foreclosure Prevention and Response in Pittsburgh’s Hilltop Communities.
This is the type so far. This is bullet size What’s the problem? Tax collection system flawed Contagious Blight Regional Inequity Land Use and Tax Policy.
Leveraging Land Administration for Transparent, Diversified and Predictable Internally Generated Revenue (IGR) Jill Urban-Karr | Exec. Director, Consulting.
Expanding Ohio’s County Land Banks Carolyn Rice Montgomery County Treasurer Chair of Montgomery County Land Reutilization Corporation.
The Financial Crisis Act I: Mortgages. The Actors home buyers banks rating agencies investors construction industry Fannie Mae The government.
City of Patterson 2013 Bond Refunding Transactions Review City Workshop December 18, 2014 Prepared by:
Beyond REO: Properties Transferred at Extremely Distressed Prices, Cuyhoga County Michael Schramm Center on Urban Poverty and Community Development.
Fast Track Foreclosure Legislation __________ House Bill 463 Frank Ford Senior Policy Advisor, Western Reserve Land Conservancy
Frank Ford Senior Vice President for Research and Development Neighborhood Progress, Inc. June 28, 2013.
The Work of the Cleveland NNIP Partner
Cuyahoga County Housing Study and Plan
Housing Policy Meeting #2
Emerging Financial Markets 12: Real Estate Investment
Housing data: Cuyahoga, Lucas, and state trends
Mission To engage and strengthen Maryland’s community development industry and encourage comprehensive community development through advocacy, partnerships,
Presentation transcript:

The demolition-foreclosure-equity connection Michael Schramm Research Associate, Center on Urban Poverty and Community Development, Case Western Reserve University Michael Schramm, Director of IT and Research Cuyahoga Land Bank 1

* Most of this presentation was created by the Thriving Communities Institute at the Western Reserve Land Conservancy for a Cleveland City Council hearing and briefing

Research Team Griswold Consulting Group Case Western Reserve University –Center on Urban Poverty and Community Development Cuyahoga Land Bank Calnin Consulting Services GeoDa Group – Luc Anselin (Arizona State University – Spatial Weights Matrix) Western Reserve Land Conservancy – Thriving Communities Institute

Primary Purposes of Study Conduct objective research to test the hypothesis that strategic demolition reduces mortgage foreclosures. Determine how property values are impacted differently by vacant lots and by distressed properties. Leverage objective evidence based on findings to support an argument to the U.S. Treasury and White House Economic Advisors that would permit re-allocation of a portion of TARP housing funds for demolition of blighted properties.

Genesee County Land Bank: (Michigan) [pre real estate crash] –Unique Dataset Tax-foreclosures Demolition Vacant Lots –Counterfactual: Valuing an Urban Demolition Program 435 Demos = $3.5 million $112 million equity hedge –Value of Investment-Based Programs? Data Issues Original Study

Data Sources NEO CANDO –Property transfers – County Fiscal Office –Demolitions – municipalities, land bank –Foreclosure filings – Common Pleas Court –Sheriff’s sales – County Sheriff –Tax billing file – County Fiscal Office –Postal vacancies – Semaphore United States Postal Service Address Scrubber –Property characteristics – County Fiscal Office Quarterly snapshots of each distress indicator from Q2 – 2009 to Q1 – 2013 Distress counted within 500 foot buffer (“ Generate Near Table” tool in ArcGIS)

Research Methods Impact of Demolition on Mortgage-Foreclosure –Neighborhood Distress Index –Pattern-Based Model (Correlation) Impact of Demolition on Real Estate Equity –Hedonic Pricing Theory Sales-based valuation –Process-Based Model (Causation) Predictive simulation

Evidence suggests demolition activity is beneficial in lowering mortgage-foreclosure rates across all neighborhood distress indices.

Submarkets Place matters. Cleveland area divided into 4 submarkets: –High functioning; –Moderately functioning; –Weak functioning; –Extremely weak functioning.

Distressed Property Variable HighModerateWeak Extremely Weak Vacant lot-1.0% -1.2%* Vacant structure-2.6%-2.2%** Mortgage foreclosed-2.6%-1.6%+2.4%+4.1% Mortgage foreclosed & tax delinquent *-4.2%** Vacant & mortgage foreclosed **** Vacant, tax delinquent & mortgage foreclosed *-8.6%*-7.0% Tax foreclosed-20.1%-5.2%** Vacant & tax foreclosed -10.8%-6.5%** Tax delinquent-3.8%-4.0%-3.6%-1.6% Vacant & tax delinquent -8.6%-5.1%*-2.8% Value Impact from Nearby Distressed Properties * Coefficient not statistically significant

Findings: Impacts of Distress on Property Values Different types of distress have different impacts on property value. Turning distressed structures into vacant lots (demolition) often offers a real estate “equity hedge.” Impacts of distress vary across submarkets. Values in higher functioning submarkets are more sensitive to nearby property distress.

Findings: Cost-Benefit of Demolition Submarket Return on $1 of demolition High Functioning$ Moderately Functioning$ 4.27 Weak and Extremely Weak Functioning ~ $ - 1* ACROSS ALL MARKETS$ 1.40 * Limited statistical significance on key distress variables in weaker submarkets limits predictive power related to demolition, thereby lowering robustness of findings.

Summary Distressed properties negatively impact property values. An equity hedge is often identified when distressed structures are turned into vacant lots (demolition). Demolition of distressed properties has a greater benefit in higher functioning markets. Evidence suggests that a reduction in foreclosures is related to demolition activity.

End Result Using Data = $$$$ $120 million in unspent federal funds freed up for Demolition (Treasury changed fund allocation based on preliminary study results, Summer, 2013) –$60 Million in Ohio –$100 Million in Michigan –Other states considering Cuyahoga County considering $50 million in bond funds for demolition 15