The Other Socialist State: People’s Republic of China The China of Mao Zidong and the Chinese Communist Party (CCP)
“Never Forget National Humiliation” Wall, Old Summer Palace, Beijing, P.R.China
Context of the CCP Revolution Marxism: Revolutions to overthrow Capitalism will happen in advanced industrial countries PROBLEM: Neither Russia nor China Industrialized; primarily agricultural countries Solution: Vanguard party seize power, crush dissent and build modern industrial state Political order will be authoritarian dictatorships
Context of the CCP Revolution 1920s-1937, : Civil War Communist and Nationalist struggle for power: Inside: both want to unite China GMD: change from above CCP: union of peasants, workers, soldiers -- revolution from below Outside: End unequal treaties, foreign exploitation Nationalize Communists want to close China to Western capitalism
Appeal of Marxism-Leninism Explains West’s technological-industrial lead; better weapons Lenin’s Theory of imperialism as highest stage of capitalism explains colonialism Export contradictions of capitalism to Africa, Asia China: Treaty Ports, foreign exploitation
Communists win Civil War, establish PRC Goals Self-sufficiency Development … but economic equality Self-defense
GREAT LEAPS Building Socialism in the PRC People’s Republic of China Liberation from Feudalism and Semicolonialism Ends 5 millennia of aristocratic-landlord exploitation and a “Century of Humiliation”
Like USSR, Visual Culture used to remold minds with images
Within China: Build Socialism In the countryside --- In the City
Outside: Friendship with Oppressed Peoples & Socialist Countries
Anti-Imperialism
Women Hold Up Half the Sky
Soviet Model of Development: Central planning of the economy State ownership of enterprises. Workers were state employees. Planned production targets and supply of inputs. Managers were administrators of state property and enforcers of the output plans. INITIAL PHASE:
Goal of model – rapid industrialization, self- sufficiency Extract surplus from agriculture to finance industrial development – Rationalize process through centralized planning – 5 year plans – production targets
China’s Problems Overwhelmingly rural, and backward (85%) -- tenancy, share-cropping common Huge population: 400+ million 1950 Peasants backbone of revolution; different than Russia where peasants seen as obstacle to progress Land reform -- get agriculture moving
More problems Industrial sector less than half Russia in 1917 with 4 times the population Industry located in former treaty ports, not linked to internal development (cheap labor, products for foreign consumption)
China’s First 5-year plan Emphasis on industry steel, machinery, railroads, electricity plants, metallurgy, chemicals Embrace rational planning – experts, bureaucrats lead
Results: rapid industrial development, but … Growth of bureaucracy New patterns of social inequality, privileged elites Growing gulf between modernizing cities and backward countryside Ideological decay, loss of revolutionary fervor
Mao’s Intervention Not building a Socialist utopia of equal prosperity for all Instead uneven development inequalities common in capitalism Making new classes
Mao’s Theory of Economic Development Past economic stagnation led to mental stagnation To Make Socialist Person -- Not sufficient to introduce new technologies or alter Mode of Production as had been done in USSR
From “Poor and Blank” to Permanent Revolution Present unburdened by Past Change a matter of human will to overcome objective obstacles extreme volunteerism, optimism “Our revolutions are like battles; after each victory, we must put forward a new task,” Mao 1958
Permanent Revolution Constant process of ideologically inspired mass activism Producing “Great Leaps” Forward and “Cultural Revolution”
Ideology and Politics in Command Central planning abandoned
Economic Development Maoist Vision: De-centralized System Close gap between urban-rural Industrialize countryside Xiafang: technicians, intellectuals, youth to the countryside commune
To create a Socialist Utopia: Dazhai Commune
ORGANIZE POPULATION INTO PRODUCTION UNITS TOTAL CARE -- HEALTH, EDUCATION, WELFARE INSPIRE WITH CONTUNOUS IDEOLOGICAL WORK
Great Leap Forward The Commune is Like a Mighty Dragon, Production is awe- inspiring
GLF Fails Ends in massive famine -- 3 lean years Struggle “Experts” vs. “Reds” Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution Failure of Ideologically based Mass Campaigns
Accomplishments of Maoist Era Technology and Technical expertise transferred to Countryside Infrastructure: education, electrification, roads, rural industry, health care gap between urban-rural narrowed
PROBLEMS: POPULATION EXHAUSTED FROM POLTICAL CAMPAIGNS INDUSTRIAL AND AGRICULTURAL STAGNATION Population triples (1.3 billion), 85% still in agriculture
Post-Mao Modernization Socialism with Chinese Characteristics
Strategies: Opening to Outside Joint enterprises Phase 1: 10year ownership, profits remain in China Phase 2: removal of % of profits; permanent joint ownership Phase 3: full ownership, greater % of profit Technology transfer
Foreign experts: colleges, universities, industries Education abroad Develop export based manufacturing, build on cheap labor Constant: tight control of currency -- no international exchange
Reform of Inside De-collectivize agriculture, markets De-regulation of economy privatization of state assets private enterprises tourism
Political Change Devolution: decentralization of power, local elections legal reform lingering problems of political rights/loss of economic rights
Successes Fastest growing national economy in world 8-10% annually since mid-1980s Reconstruction of almost all major cities; huge infrastructure investment