The Dynamics of Discourse: Ideology, Science and Public Policy in the Kyoto Debate Dr. L. Graham Smith Department of Geography University of Western Ontario.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Climate Change, Energy, and Security NS4053 week 8.
Advertisements

UNIT CONFERENCE1 SNC2DT-CLIMATE CHANGE NICOLE, ROBIN, AND RICHARD.
History and Geography: The Foundations of Culture
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT CRITERIA TO GUIDE ENERGY TECHNOLOGY RESEARCH FOR CLIMATE MITIGATION Sanford E. Gaines Guest Professor, Department of Law Business.
The science of climate change Sir David King Chief Scientific Adviser to HM Government British Council/Warsaw University Centre for Environmental Studies.
Geologic evidence of recurring climate cycles and their implications for the cause of global warming and climate changes in the coming century Don J. Easterbrook.
Historical Perspectives on Climate Change James Rodger Fleming STS Program, Colby College Some highlights.
Your Name Your Title Your Organization (Line #1) Your Organization (Line #2) Global warming.: Matthieu BERCHER, Master M.I.G.S., University of Burgundy,
Explaining the Evidence Activity 2: Clearing the Air.
History and Geography: The Foundations of Culture
Global warming-the debate The fact that the Earth is warming is not a matter of debate, the evidence is clear The fact that global carbon dioxide levels.
Adaptation to Climate Change
Climate Change & Energy Climate is always changing.
The Arguments CLIMATE CHANGE SERIES Eric Jackson
The Basic Science of Climate Change Janina Moretti September 6, 2012.
Sustainable Use of Resources
The Earth’s Changing Environment As preparation for the final exam, consider the 10 following issues and be sure that you could answer the accompanying.
History and Geography: The Foundations of Culture Chapter 3 McGraw-Hill/Irwin© 2005 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. PowerPoint presentation.
Center for International Climate and Environmental Research-Oslo: Research Priorities and Interest in China Lin Gan SINCIERE Member Workshop October 19,
CLIMATE CHANGE THE GREAT DEBATE Session 10. CLIMATE CHANGE? If we have learnt anything from this course, it is that climate is not constant It is, and.
Global Sustainable Development – a Physics Course or Sex, Lies, and Sustainable Development The transformation of an Environmental Physics Course for non-science.
1 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency – Climate Change Division 1 Communicating Climate Science Kevin Rosseel Communications Director Climate Change Division.
UDA: Global Warming.
Skeptics’ Arguments A guide to counter the arguments of global warming skeptics.
Dana Brown Haine, M.S. Program Director, UNC-Chapel Hill’s Climate Leadership and Energy Awareness Program E MPOWERING P RE - COLLEGE S TUDENTS T O E NGAGE.
Economics, Policy, and the FutureSection 1 Section 1: Economics and International Cooperation Preview Classroom Catalyst Objectives International Development.
Economics, Policy,and the FutureSection 1 Section 1: Economics and International Cooperation Preview Bellringer Objectives International Development and.
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT: A Challenge for Engineers Ata M. Khan March 2002.
POSC 2200 – International Political Economy Russell Alan Williams Department of Political Science.
Climate Change: Challenges and Opportunities Dr Frank McGovern.
A current world debate. Colorado Prepared Graduate Competencies: Evaluate evidence that the Earth is a complex system of interactions between the geosphere,
16469 Low Energy Building Design Sustainability – an overview Dr Nick Kelly ESRU.
GA Regional UN Conference on Sustainable Development By: Emma Bunting and D’Andra Brown.
Company LOGO CHAPTER 7 CONSUMPTION: CONCEPTS AND PATTERN ZURONI MD. JUSOH DEPARTMENT OF CONSUMER AND RESOURCE MANAGEMENT, FACULTY OF HUMAN ECOLOGY.
Unit 6 Vocabulary Review. Ecosystem A community and the abiotic factors that affect them.
Air Canuk and the Green Engine Decision Dr. Jennifer Lynes Environment & Resource Studies University of Waterloo Dr. Jennifer Lynes Environment & Resource.
Climate Change and Greenhouse Effect Notes. What we want to know? What is climate change? What is the greenhouse effect? How will climate change affect.
Face the Facts of Climate Change. Face the Facts Activity: 1.Form small groups. 2.Listen while a climate change statement is read aloud. 3.Discuss the.
Global Sustainability: The Case for Collaboration Environmental Issues.
All Rights Reserved to Kardan University 2014 Kardan University Kardan.edu.af.
Modern Climate Change Darryn Waugh OES Summer Course, July 2015.
Global Warming Definition: an increase in the earth's atmospheric and oceanic temperatures widely predicted to occur due to an increase in the greenhouse.
Global Warming (Climate Change) The Greenhouse Effect Sunlight streams through the atmosphere and heats the Earth. Some of the heat radiates back out into.
Warm Up: 2-21 What are the impacts of climate change on humans?
Climate Change The Debate Is Done. Climate Change In the scientific world there are very few doubts about the far reaching effects of climate change The.
1 Geology 1001/1101 Sec 003 Chris Paola Class 14: the Anthropocene.
Philip Wright Head of Climate Change and Air, ERAD Changing our Ways Executive action on climate change.
Chapter 16 Human Impact on Ecosystems
Four Economic Questions About Global Warming
How nature works. How the environment effects us. How we effect the environment. How we can live more sustainably without degrading our life-support.
Climate Change: An Inter-disciplinary Approach to Problem Solving (AOSS 480 // NRE 480) Richard B. Rood Cell: Space Research Building.
Presented by Jacob Igono, Alexia Lochmann & Gaby Regalado Are we Collapsing? A Review of Jared Diamond’s Collapse By Scott E. Page Are we Collapsing? A.
NS4054 Fall Term 2014 Climate Change, Energy and Security.
Strand One Sandy Wenzel Toffler (1980), argued:  Clashing events and trends are interrelated patterns that evolve civilization.  When one wave.
Chapter 05 Natural Resources and Environmental Sustainability McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2012 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.
HOW DO ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES INVOLVE POLITICAL AND ECONOMIC DECISIONS What are environmental issues What is the relationship between the environment, economics.
Chapter Meeting Ecological Challenges Key Questions: 1)How does the average ecological footprint in America compare to the world’s average?
1 POLITICAL IDEOLOGIES AND THE ENVIRONMENT. 2 Introduction Focus:  the environmental challenge to modern political ideologies: solutions offered by Political.
Unit H Being Green Chapter 23: Ecological Economics.
Climate change, employment, UNFCCC and trade unions.
Facing up to the Challenge of Climate Change: Policy and Politics Dr Robert McIlveen Research Fellow, Environment and Energy Unit
SCI 256 UOP Course Tutorial For more course tutorials visit
Severe Weather and Climate Change. Adapted from: Severe Weather and Climate Change –DR. CATHY CONRAD & –TREVOR ADAMS, ED.D. (ABD) –DEPARTMENT OF GEOGRAPHY,
Natural Resources, Climate Change and Religious views…
Environmental Science 1001 Elden Hawkes, Instructor.
© Cambridge University Press 2014 Fiona Tonizzo Chapter 1 Sustainability.
Energy Sources and Sustainability
Science and Sustainability: An Introduction to Environmental Science
Climate Change: Science and Beyond
Presentation transcript:

The Dynamics of Discourse: Ideology, Science and Public Policy in the Kyoto Debate Dr. L. Graham Smith Department of Geography University of Western Ontario

debate over ratification of the Kyoto accord served as a window on the public awareness of climate change, global warming, greenhouse gasses and the correct public policy response to perceived scientific imperatives. served to highlight the role that ideology plays in the communication of these various concepts between scientists, politicians, stakeholder groups and the lay public illustrates the role of information arbitrage in public policy.

Premises climate change exemplifies the role that ideology plays in the use of science in public policy contemporary environmentalism is predicated upon a scientific imperative that both justifies its ideology and compels its acceptance within public policy environmentalism rests with the certitude of its science: if the science is unclear, inconclusive and/or contradictory, the ideology of environmentalism loses its power

Responses to technology

Principles of Global Sustainability (Stasis) Natural resources are scarce Natural resources should be conserved Intergenerational equity should be maintained Modern technologies necessarily degrade the natural environment Environmental protection leads to sustainable economic development Government's role is central to ensuring sustainability

Global Climate Change: Stasist Perspective The world is experiencing unprecedented warm temperatures due to accelerating rates of greenhouse gasses primarily due to human use of fossil fuels This warming will have catastrophic effects and the world must act now to reduce greenhouse gas emissions There is scientific consensus that most of the warming observed over the past 50 years is attributed to human activity

Global Climate Change: Stasist Perspective (Cont’d) Warmer temperatures are bad as they result in: more severe weather events increased air pollution more droughts decreased water quality increased flooding Solutions require increased government regulation of energy use, increased use of renewable soft energy options and decreased use of and dependency upon the automobile

Principles of Sustained Globalization (Dynamism) There are no permanent resource scarcities Increased consumption can increase the resource base and improve the economy and the environment Intergenerational equity does not exist Technological innovation improves environmental quality Economic development improves environmental quality Government intervention in economic and environmental activities often does more harm than good Markets and technological innovations protect people from vagaries of nature

Global Climate Change: Dynamist Perspective The global warming scare has little foundation in fact: historical climate records for the last 10,000 years record cycles including the Holocene maximum, the medieval climate optimum and the little ice age not only is climate change natural, temperatures today are neither unprecedented nor abnormal the science of climate change is very complex and beyond our present level of understanding

Global Climate Change: Dynamist Perspective Cont’d Predictions of climate warming are based on poorly developed models which: can not even provide accurate short-term forecasts are imprecise and rely heavily on economic and social conjecture for forecasting the future are routinely contradicted with respect to key components by empirical data Human-induced global warming is a theory with considerable scientific disagreement and dissent

Global Climate Change: Dynamist Perspective Cont’d The fraud of the warming scare is seen most vividly in that the solutions proposed: ignore nuclear power ignore increasing trends in reduced carbonization of world energy use focus on global re-distribution of wealth

Ideology and Discourse Why do environmental myths persist, even when science invalidates them? e.g. Why do environmental myths persist, even when science invalidates them? e.g. climate change deforestationdesertification What structures the public policy narrative? What structures the public policy narrative? science -- stakeholders -- education

Most people don't want raw data. They want information, or knowledge, or perhaps even wisdom. They want someone else to take the time to sift through the data, to select what is true or interesting or important, and to tell them about it. (Postrel) thus, in age of abundant media and new media communities, it is the age of the editor wherein producers and audiences create ‘powerful, overlapping communities with far different assumptions from those of the mass media’ (Postrel) Bloggers