Critiques/Kritiks Baxter MDAW 2013 “Strange things are afoot at the circle k…” --Ted Theodore Logan.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

The Search for Equality

Advertisements

IR THEORY IR 5001.

How to Run a Kritik Affirmative

Is Empire the new world order?

Literary Theories in very brief summary.

MDAW 2013: DCH & MBK.  Realism  Idealism  Liberalism  Marxism  Critical Theory(s)

Capitalism Kritik. -AN IDEOLOGY -A MINDSET -“AN ECONOMIC SYSTEM BASED ON THE PRIVATE OWNERSHIP OF THE MEANS OF PRODUCTION, DISTRIBUTION, AND EXCHANGE,

Introduction to Kritiks Ryan Galloway Samford University.

UNDERSTANDING THE KRITIK by Lurp Lank and Alex Kosmachavelli.

The World of Literary Theory Feminist/Gender Psychological Marxist Cultural.

Feminist Literary Theory The Second Sex. Feminist Literary Theory SIMONE DE BEAUVOIR ( ) F The Second Sex n Questioned the “othering” of women.

Truth and Power Philosophy 157 G. J. Mattey ©2002.

INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS THEORY IN POLICY DEBATE Houston Urban Debate League.

Shirin M Rai.  Provocation: how is what we know framed as knowledge through particular systems of representation and the practices of colonial governance.

Critical Theory Why “critical theory”? Critical of what?  Current social conditions  Standard social science.

Cultural Studies General Intro. & Subcultures. Cultural Studies: Main Concerns u Subjectivity and power relations (Race, gender, class relations) in culture.

OUR SOCIAL CONTEXT FOR THEORIES OF GENDER AND SEXUALITY: THE 3 WAVES OF FEMINISM IN U.S. G205 Borders of Desire: Sex and the Nation State.

Colonizing the Soul Cesaire Wrote about colonization, colonialism What is it?  Race, class, gender discrimination  Thingification (Object)  Both idea.

2.4. The Postmodern and Constructivist Challenge Learning Objectives: Understand the principles of constructivist and postmodern thought Identify postmodern.

INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS THEORIES: CONSTRUCTIVISM

Continental Political Philosophy What is continental political philosophy? continental philosophy? the concept will be treated ‘lightly’ in this course:

‘Ecofeminism and the Gendered Politics of Consumption’ Socialist Feminist Day School Christchurch 26 th April 2014 Sionainn Byrnes.

ITS OUR PARTY WE CAN DO WHAT WE WANT: TOPICALITY AND PROCEDURALS Thursday, 6/27 Baxter and Dave.

A Feminist Reader. A Feminist Reader is -- A reader who approaches texts prepared to respond empathetically to both female authors and characters A reader.

INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS THEORY INTRODUCTION HC 35.

Lit Crit Round Two: Marxist and Feminist Lit Crit

Examples we talked about in class Ferguson, Missouri You tube commercials Movie trailers / Parodies Unnecessary censorship

Sociological theory Where did it come from? Theories and theorists Current theoretical approaches Sociology as science.

THE CONVERSATION: POST STRUCTURALISM An Attempt to Join Maddie Blair & Sarah Arbogast.

Postmodernism What is modernism  The modern period is characterised as western society since the industrial revolution.  Modernity.

What is literary analysis? Interpreting a text and presenting an argument for how it might be understood. What is rhetorical analysis? Analyzing the means.

Nature of Politics Politics: Science or Art?.  Political science as a discipline involves the study of political ideas, institutions, processes and events.

LITERARY THEORY 101.

ANTEWORTA. Antworta seeks for an answer. Who I would be if I was not me?

Plan Today: (Neo-)Marxist & Feminist Approaches to IR 1. Completing group discussion of postcolonial theory vs. Marxism. 2. Evaluation of Marxist and Neo-

Critiques: Or, Why Everything You Ever Learned Is Wrong (And How to Do Better)

1 In the Waiting Room of Democracy. The aim of this study is, from a Critical Postcolonial view, to conduct discourse analysis of International Documents.

“Society is fundamentally dead,” says Derrida. Thus, subconstructive dialectic theory holds that the establishment is capable of social comment, given.

ITS OUR PARTY WE CAN DO WHAT WE WANT: TOPICALITY AND PROCEDURALS Tuesday, August 5th Baxter and Steve.

MDAW All debate is performing Form and content are inseparable. The norms of debate performance are conditioned by systems (and histories) of oppression.

Theory Debating Baxter MDAW  It Really is  There are 4 Components of a Theory Argument  Interp  Violation  Standards  Voting Issue  You.

Feminism: belief in the social, economic and political equality of the sexes and the movement organized around this belief.

Negating Space June 29 th, Exploration Beyond Exploration What can we ACTUALLY explore? FX Topicality Not Earth Topicality.

Baxter MDAW Overviews: What they are For Meta-level debate Stuff with no place on the flow Increase judge comprehension Overviews: What they aren’t.

Chapter Five Critical Perspectives on Theory Development Copyright © 2005 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display.

Critical Debate Don’t Fear the Reaper. What Is A Critique? Way of understanding information Aff and Neg Tool.

Introduction to Sociology

Judging Policy Debate Rich Edwards Baylor University July 2013.

Constructivism: The Social Construction of International Politics POL 3080 Approaches to IR.

The Great Debates in International Relations 1 st Great Debate (20s & 30s) 2 nd Great Debate (50s-80s) 3 rd Great Debate (80s & on)

POLICY DEBATE. WHAT IS POLICY DEBATE? A structured format for fairly arguing a topic of policy TEAM DEBATE: two teams of two students each 8 speeches.

LG514: International Relations Theory Lecture 7: Postpositivism – Critique or Crisis? Ken McDonagh School of Law and Government.

 Philosophical or performative advocacy  Rejects Traditional policy focus  Micro vs Macro resistance to oppression.

Judging Policy Debate Rich Edwards & Russell Kirkscey June 2015.

Lit Crit Round Two: Marxist and Feminist Lit ~define Marxist Lit Crit ~define “false consciousness” ~define “ideology” ~define “reification” ~define “patriarchy”

Kritiks and Critical Theory – a Primer With Rodrigo Paramo, Tyler Haulotte, and Eric Emerson.

‘May you live in interesting times’. IRPG841/L1 Introducing IR Theory: Concepts, Methods and Approaches the nature and scope of IR the role of theory.

Theories explaining globalization

What is ideology? Ideology is a belief system. A plan how to improve society and how it should work. Ideologies are not supposed to be calm and even rational.

KRITIKS Melissa Witt.

CRITICAL THEORIES Dr. Mrs. Anisa Mujawar.

Critical Approaches to the Topic

Critical Theory Sam Kniknie.

Critical Approaches to Communication Theory

UNDERSTANDING THE KRITIK

Marxist and Feminist Criticism

LEGAL PHILOSOPHY DISCUSSION CLASS

? POSTSTRUCTURALIST FEMINISM

The K. Luis M. Andrade ADI, 2014.

Post-Structuralist and Postmodernist Approaches to Gender Theory

Presentation transcript:

Critiques/Kritiks Baxter MDAW 2013 “Strange things are afoot at the circle k…” --Ted Theodore Logan

Uniqueness Links Causality A  B Impacts Kritiks vs. Disads

Fiat Permutations Kritiks vs. Counterplans

Value to Life Why every kritik is the same Why should language matter Kritiks vs. Counterplans (2)

Do we need an alt? Kritiks vs. Counterplans (3)

By Lav

Framework=filter

Dumb Framework Aff: the Neg can only read a CP or advocate the status quo Neg: the judge should only listen to kritiks!

Why is this dumb? No “best type” of argument Aff is whiny Is necessarily not “real world”

Smart framework!! Interpretation of knowledge vs interpretation of arguments

Smart framework examples Only evaluate impacts that have been justified [read cards why marxism is a way to justify impacts]

More Smart Framework Aff: Only evaluate impacts that are justified [read cards about why social science is the best]

Framework Cheating! Allows you to not answer arguments on the aff and the neg and or Beat people JUST on framework

reify elide conflate utopia/dystopia Dichotomy us/them, self/other, inside/outside General Vocab

otherization normalization normative v. descriptive objective v. subjective subject cooptation General Vocab(2)

enlightenment rationality modernism Ontology Epistemology Ethics Kritik/Philosophy Words

Deontology Utilitarianism Ideology Discourse Kritik/Philosophy Words

capitalism Marxism Socialism Anarchy Commodification/commodity Fetish Empire (Hardt/Negri) Multitude Proletariat Bourgeois Objectivism (Rand) Frankfurt School (Adorno, Marcuse) Economics

Realism Idealism Securitization/Environmental Securitization Eurocentrism Occident Orientalism Self Fulfilling Prophecy/Error Replication Nuclearism Nuclear Numbing Chaloupka/Love the Bomb Development Global/Local (Nayer) Human Rights K International Relations

Identity Politics Waves of Feminism: 1 st, 2 nd, 3 rd Feminist International Relations Public/Private Dichotomy Patriarchy 3 rd World Feminism Ecofeminism Performativity (Butler) Sex v. Gender Heteropatriarchy Identity Politics

Heterosexism/Homophobia Phallocentrism Phallogocentrism Standpoint Epistomology Subaltern (Spivak) Essentialism Strategic Essentialism Intersectionality Victimology Narratives (Delgado) Violence (Fanon) Identity Politics (2)

Critical Race Theory Critical Legal Studies Indeterminacy Masking Trashing Normativity (Schlag) Role Playing Rights Talk Legal

power discipline micropolitics panopticon geneaology death of the author repressive hypothesis confessional bare life Homo Sacer (Agamben) State of exception Biopower Foucault

logocentrism trace erasure deconstruction differance Derrida

psychoanalysis Freud Lacan Zizek Metaphoric condensation Letter of the law Symptom Lack Fidelity to the Event (Badiou) Jouissance Desire Object A Psychoanalysis