Opening the black box: The social construction of search engines Astrid Mager HUMlab, Umeå University/ Sweden Wits School of Arts, University.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
From: what users want To: sustainable business models Els van de Kar and Xiaofeng Ma Beijing Workshop
Advertisements

Technopolis Group 1 The Governance of ERA A critical perspective 6CP Patries Boekholt October
Ubiquity of Grey Literature in a Connected Content Context Julia Gelfand University of California, Irvine Paper presented at GL5 Conference.
1 Collective Awareness Platforms "The views expressed in this presentation are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the European.
1 Opportunities and Challenges of Social Computing Kirsti Ala-Mutka European Commission, JRC Institute for Prospective Technological Studies Information.
IP and Business Models for Cultural Heritage Institutions Rina Elster Pantalony WIPO Conference on Intellectual Property and Cultural Heritage in the Digital.
Change, agency and partnership: new models for new times.
INTERNET MARKETING CHAPTER4 Social Media Marketing Pranjoy Arup Das.
Sports in Society: Issues & Controversies
photo credit: dbarefootdbarefoot Social Media is Consumer generated media It is media that is designed to be shared, sharing means that it is easy to.
Frameworks for the sharing of memory in a digital world Darren Stephens MBCS CITP
A platform of for knowledge and services sharing Fernando Ferri IRPPS-CNR.
An annual EU event since 1985 To mirror the cultural variety within EU. European Capital of Culture.
NewsCorp Manager Workshop
Privacy: Facebook, Twitter
E-Business First meeting e-Business Lecturer’s team.
Can public libraries & their users benefit & profit from Europeana ?
Ministry of Enterprise, Energy and Communications Sweden Cultural and creative industries - a buzzword or valuable activities for innovation and growth?
Innovating in the Digital Ecology: Social Issues and Consequences Professor Robin Mansell London School of Economics and Political Science HEPTech Academia.
ERASMUS IP Cultural Management Policies and Practices for the Creative Use of Cultural Heritage.
Human-centric digital age Technologies, networks and digital and social media are changing the way people think, behave, apprehend neighbouring objects.
Theory of media and society
COMMUNICATING TO STUDENTS Using Social Media and Digital Marketing.
Definition of Feminism The theory of the political, economic, and social equality of the sexes. Organized activity on behalf of women’s rights and interests.
Building Inclusive Knowledge Societies Session organized by the UNCT in India and other UN entities.
The Internet of Everything meets the Internet of Place Digital Together Jon Pratty.
Impact, measurement and funding Jane Tinkler RENU RESEARCH EXCELLENCE AND FUNDING 28 APRIL 2015.
 Examines the nature of culture and the diverse ways in which societies make meaning and are organized across time and space. Topics include cultural.
+ TIPS & TRICKS TO HELP YOU MAKE MONEY ONLINE! Tricia Belmonte LikeUs ns.
Modernization Modernization represents the effort to transcend traditional ways of organizing social life that are perceived as obstacles of progress.
Information and Communication Technology Week 4. Agenda Check – In / Questions Overarching questions Lecture – Feel free to interrupt! Give me “wows and.
+. + Media: A Critical View Using Media to Study World Issues.
Black Box Brussels EU Journalism: Lapdog or Watchdog? Claudia K. Huber, Brussels, March 19, 2009 Talk to me, Europe! AER Communication Atelier Debate.
2010 Summer Training Series Teaching & Learning: Professional Development Institute Don Blake, NEA.
Universities and Regional Economic Development: The Entrepreneurial University of Waterloo Allison Bramwell and David A. Wolfe Program on Globalization.
Legal Aspects Related to Brownfield Regenerations Prof. Maros Finka, M.arch., Ph.D. „This project has been funded with support from the European Commission.
Incorporating Social Media Into Your Everyday Recruiting Activities It’s about connections not sales! Chicago NPA Meeting August 2010.
2009 Mid West Region Leadership Conference Social Media: Meeting the Potential of Meeting Spaces Don Blake, NEA.
Opening the black box of search engines Astrid Mager HUMlab, Umeå University/ Sweden HUMlab, April 6, 2011.
HEFCE/Higher Education Academy/JISC cc-by-sa (uk2.5) Image source – flickr (cc-by) OER and the Open Agenda Malcolm Read, Executive Secretary, JISC.
6 March 2008 Digital Industries: Fabchannel&Cultureplayer project Lyon, 6th of March, 2008 City of Amsterdam Jan Heeren Strategic Policy Advisor on Arts.
is concerned with the balance (or imbalance) of power and control and how content is shaped through the varied influence of the participants.
Social Media and Parkinson’s Disease [Insert Name] [Insert PAN Title] Parkinson’s Action Network.
Facebook is Good group | Economics and Helps you connect and share with the people in your life. facebook is Good.
MA “International Relations, Global Economy and Strategic Analysis” COURSE OUTLINE.
Economic, Political and Social Identity in the European Union Professor John Wilton Lecture 3 Social Constructivism and an E.U. identity.
Critically Thinking about Digital Media. Basic Media History Gutenburg Movable type, c (before? … ) Newspapers / magazines Telegraph (1844) / telephone.
TECHNICAL WRITING 2013 UNIT 3: DESIGNING FOR CHANGE.
R&D Operation Best Practice for Start Up Start a Business And Change the world Alfred Boediman, Ph.D.
The Institute Centre for Policy and Development Practice The Institute Centre for Policy and Development Practice Barnabas Mwansa Founder & Institute Director.
Social Media and Activist Participation Jakob Svensson Cyberculture and Politics 2015.
Public Policy Process An Introduction.
Engaging with End–Users of Research OCTOBER 2015 Cathy Harris MBA, MInstKT Research Engagement Manager Research & Enterprise Extn 6755,
‘Unlocking the VLE': a Collaborative approach to developing online learning resources to support and scaffold learning Exploring and Sharing Innovative.
The Impact of New Media A Level Media Studies. Key Questions Has new media democratised the production of media texts by shifting the control of media.
Vision of Information Society cont. Jakob Svensson 24/
Sports in Society: Issues & Controversies
Dr. Victoria Banti-Markouti
© Shuang Liu, Zala Volčič and Cindy Gallois 2015
Elements for an AGORA Studio
Philine Warnke and Gaston Heimeriks IPTS
Real Estate Development
Principles of Marketing
Public Policy Process An Introduction.
Human-centric digital age
DIGITAL MARKETING COMPANY Digital marketing is a broad term that encapsulates all marketing channels and methods you can use to promote.
Trends and developments in eGOVwork – a resesearch perspective
DIGITAL MARKETING AGENCY Digital Marketing.
Presentation transcript:

Opening the black box: The social construction of search engines Astrid Mager HUMlab, Umeå University/ Sweden Wits School of Arts, University of the Witwatersrand/ Johannesburg, March 2011

HUMlab founded in 1997/ 2000 (studio space) meeting place for the humanities, culture and information technology/ Umeå University, Sweden „digital humanities“ – work at the intersection of computing/ new media & humanities (social sciences) / Patrik Svensson International collaboration/ 2 year postdoc fellowships

Googlization of Everything? (Vaidhyanathan) © Joel Saget/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images Microsoft

Critique of search engines/ focus on implications - „Googlepoly“ (Pasquinelli) / gatekeeper of knowledge -Algorithm: ordering of knowledge based on popularity/ scientometrics (Mayer) -Business Model „service for profile“/ surveillance (Elmer/ Rogers) ©

Opening the Black Box i)How are search engines socially constructed? - Who are the dominant actors shaping the technology? - What interests do they follow & what implications result from that? - What is expected from the future? ii) What „information politics“ do search engines trigger? - How do search engines present, hierarchize, display their results? - Who succeeds in the battle for attention? - What broader consequences does this ordering mechanism trigger?

Analysis I

Analysis II

Social construction of technology (SCOT) Basic idea: Innovation is not a linear process, but involves complex negotiations of actors/ interests „Ordinary bicyle“ back then & now – how did this happen? Stabilization in actor-network of engineers, different types of cyclists & industry – within the societal context of the emancipation of women => Innovation develops in the context of economic & social relationships/ within society © Skoda Museum, Chech Republic, photo by: Agnieszka Kwiecień Nova

Core Actor-Network

Universities Start-Ups Server FarmsWebsites SEO Money Interests Skills Technology

Economic relations Universities Start-Ups Server FarmsWebsites SEO Money Interests Skills Technology

Economic relations Universities Start-Ups Server FarmsWebsites SEO Money Interests Skills Technology Business Model Brand Value Advertising Spamming User Profiles Feed-Back

Tensions & Negotiations information retrieval: "more data means better results" engineer: „that improves the quality of the information (...) and makes your site actually more valuable“ critical scholar: „ahm, yeah, I use Google constantly and I do love it, (...) it is a great search engine for giving me what I want“

Tensions & Negotiations politics: "it clearly concerns the business and they don't deny that" SEO: „I mean there is dirty things you can do to make your website more prominent“ critical scholar: „that’s to worry, that’s information we would not wanna have a state to have of us“

Information society/ economy Competitors Search Engines Facebook, Twitter & co. Mobile Technology Contracts User Data

Information society/ economy Media Activists Hacker Open source community China Street View Competitors Search Engines Facebook, Twitter & co. Mobile Technology Contracts Education Civil society Alternatives User Data

Information society/ economy Legislation Politics Nation states EU UNO FTC Media Activists Hacker Open source community China Street View Competitors Search Engines Facebook, Twitter & co. Mobile Technology Consumer/ Data Protection Contracts Education Civil society Alternatives User Data

Information society/ economy Legislation Politics Nation states EU UNO FTC Media Activists Hacker Open source community China Street View Competitors Search Engines Facebook, Twitter & co. Mobile Technology Consumer/ Data Protection Contracts Education Civil society Alternatives New Actor? Controlling Institution Foundation data protection Mediator Custodian User Data

First conclusions SCOT perspective shows that search technology is developed/ shaped/ stabilized in a complex actor-network  Search engine may be seen as a location where societal values are negotiated Core network is dominated by an economic logic – political, legal, cultural actors stabilize the actor-network through inaction  Incorporates the ideology of the information economy/ capitalist society  Search engine bias/ „exploitation of collective intelligence“ (Pasquinelli)/ commercialization of knowledge

Future developments? Not enough to blame the „Googlepoly“ (Pasquinelli)  understand the mechanisms behind power creation and stabilization  understand that we are all part of the picture Future is not set  open to debate and potential social intervention Questions to ask: Do we really want to leave the task of „organizing the world‘s information“ to a private firm with a clearly commercial agenda? Who else could/ should take part in the shaping of search technology/ the culture of search/ our access to knowledge/ construction of social reality? How could we – as a society – strengthen these actors & their interests?

Further info/ contact Thanks for your attention!