Chapter 16 Professional Liability
The Legal Environment Affecting Litigation against Auditors Liability that affects CPA firms is derived from the following laws: Statutory law Common law Contract law
The Legal Environment Affecting Litigation against Auditors (cont’d) Joint and Several Liability Audit Time and Fee Pressures Audits Viewed as an Insurance Policy Contingent-Fee Compensation for Lawyers Class Action Suits
Legal Concepts The Auditor must understand Concepts of breach of contract and tort Parties who may bring suit Legal precedence and statutes that may be used as a standard Defenses available to auditors
Legal Concepts Causes of legal action Breach of contract Negligence Gross negligence (constructive fraud) Fraud Scienter
Legal Concepts Parties that may bring suit against auditors Liability to clients Breach of contract Negligence Misleading financial statements
Legal Concepts Common-law liability to third parties Foreseeability and Negligence: Common Law The Ultramares case: The third-party beneficiary test Expansion of Ultramares: The identified user test Foreseen user test Foreseeable user test Current status
Legal Concepts Statutory Liability to Third Parties Securities Act of 1933 Securities Act of 1934
Legal Concepts Criminal Liability to Third Parties Continental Vending (U.S. v. Simon) Equity Funding
Legal Concepts Liability Impact of Internet Dissemination of Audited Financial Information Summary of Auditor Liability to Third Parties Auditor defenses Due diligence Statements not materially misstated Audit not the cause of loss Auditor has no duty to the plaintiff
Approaches to Mitigating Liability Exposure Continuing Education Requirement Membership Requirements for Firms Quality Control Programs External peer reviews Internal peer reviews
Defensive Auditing Engagement letters Client screening Evaluating the firm’s limitations Maintaining accurate and complete working papers Limited Liability Partnerships (LLP) Role of insurance Tort reform
Effect of Court Cases on Auditing Standards and Practice Engagement letters Audit Procedures Subsequent Events Related-Party Transactions