Causes of Civil Wars Political and Economic Factors in contemporary civil wars Johan M.G. van der Dennen.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Political parties, lecture 1 of 3
Advertisements

Central America Introduction. Key issue: Agrarian Transformation “a major change in the organization of agrarian society” What is the relationship between.
GV 506-week 7 1.Types of intrastate wars 2.Causes of intrastate wars 3.Are intrastate wars fundamentally different from interstate wars?
CONTEMPORARY VIOLENT CONFLICT S Mansoob Murshed Institute of Social Studies, the Netherlands and the University of Birmingham, UK
Key Findings of Collier & Hoeffler On Economic Causes of Civil War (1998) Civil war is overwhelmingly a phenomenon of low income countries. Possessing.
Lecture 5: Radicalization
Marie-Joëlle Zahar Associate Professor, Political Science Research Director, Francophone Research Network on Peace Operations Université de Montréal
HGS 12 – 20 th Century Background Information Part I This presentation was designed for HGS 12 students at Millwood High.
What is the definition of an International System? There have been four International Systems in the 20 th Century, what was the most recent system? What.
USII.8a Rebuilding Europe and Japan Emergence of the United States as a Superpower Establishment of the United Nations.
INTL 190: Democracy in the Developing World Spring 2012.
Colonial Democracy : Electoral Systems The Idea of Colonial Democracy 2. The Nature of the functioning of Colonial Democracy.
Today’s Topics: Future of IR Will the world become safer or more dangerous in future? Will the world become safer or more dangerous in future? Will international.
Lecture 18: Triumphalism and the 1990s February 18, 2009.
Global Conflict, Global (Dis)Orders. Global Peace Index: data/#/2008/scor/ data/#/2008/scor/
Topics for today Events of the day/week  Kenyan parties agree on peace deal Catching up with readings/PowerPoints  World War II  Cold War  Comparing.
Review Political Economy of the Global South Prof. Tyson Roberts.
“Newly Industrializing”. High Poverty, Low GNP, Trade Dependency, Weak Infrastructure.
African Development Report 2008/09 Conflict Resolution, Peace and Reconstruction in Africa Dakar, May 10th 2009 Presented by : Léonce Ndikumana Director,
International Politics on the World Stage WORLD POLITICS INTERNATIONAL POLITICS ON THE WORLD STAGE ******** International Politics.
The Changing of Russian Politics Liberal Democracy or Dictatorship?
Transitioning to Democracy: Possible Traps Educational Initiatives
October 5, 2015Introduction to Political Science1 The State Frank H. Brooks.
Medical Peace Work Online Course 4 Structural violence & root causes of violent conflict.
Conceptual Approach to Comparative Government & Politics.
Racial, Ethnicity, and Immigration Chapter 3 Does race still matter? What’s the difference between prejudice and discrimination? Are you colorblind? Why.
CULTURAL PERSPECTIVE ON SOUTHEAST ASIA: CONTEMPORARY POLITICS AND GOVERNMENT IN SOUTHEAST ASIA 11:00AM – 11:50AM, AUGUST 10, 2013 SAN MARCOS HIGH SCHOOL.
THE STRUCTURAL FOUNDATIONS OF AMERICAN GOVERNMENT AND POLITICS
DEMOCRATIC TRANSITION IN MEXICO 3/1/2010. PHASE 1: Transitional Democracy  Breakdown of the old regime  Transition to democratic forms, procedures 
Africa Center for Strategic Studies Tuesday, 10 July 2007 Africa Center for Strategic Studies Dr. Louis A. Picard Senior Research Fellow and Director of.
Midterm Exam Review. Key Points Chapter 1: Introduction  What is the primary relationship that we are examining?  What is the difference between Most.
War in The Democratic Republic of Congo Lecture 13.
“End of History” Francis Fukuyama. T HE “E MPIRICAL ” A RGUMENT Fukuyama points out that since the beginning of the Nineteenth Century, democracy, which.
AN AGE OF REVOLUTIONS Osvaldo Jordan September 8, 2008.
Stability in Cold War Africa External –Colonial Interests and Involvement –Superpower Competition Pan-African –The Organization of African Unity (OAU)
The Spanish Civil War What was the Spanish Civil War? A war fought between the democratically elected Republican government and the Rebel Fascists.
American Political Culture. What is it??!?? Widely shared beliefs, values & norms concerning the relationship of citizens to gov’t & each other Shared.
Chapter 4 THE STRUCTURAL FOUNDATIONS OF AMERICAN GOVERNMENT AND POLITICS.
Pearson Education, Inc. © 2005 Chapter 4 THE STRUCTURAL FOUNDATIONS OF AMERICAN GOVERNMENT AND POLITICS.
P LAN FOR T ODAY : 1. Remaining theories’ approaches to globalization: Marxism and feminism. 2. Will international politics fundamentally change in future?
NGO/CSO Experience in the Philippines Capacity Building Conference for Iraqui NGOs organized by the UNDP and LEADING POINT Management Advisory Services,
2015.  Political reforms and development had a symbiotic relationship with economic development  Q at 21:00.
Growth accelerations and collapses. Highlights 1.Igniting growth requires a relatively narrow range of reforms, targeted at relaxing the “binding constraint”
SHOULD, CAN, AND WILL COUNTRIES WORK TOGETHER TO ALLEVIATE WORLD POVERTY? Why should we care about the developing world?: What are the ethical issues involved?
LIBERALISM. Origins and development of liberalism Liberalism: was a product of the breakdown of feudalism in Europe (19 th c.) and influenced by the Enlightenment.
Chapter 32.  How did the Cold War affect politics in Latin America and the Middle East in the 1970s and 1980s?  What forces led to the collapse of the.
REVISION GOVERNANCE- Two questions in three hours Remember good exams techniques Allow equal time for each question Been disciplined move on after 1.30.
What do we mean by ‘causes’? Background conditions? Enabling/facilitating factors? Triggering events? Causation on what level? International? – e.g. end.
WHAT IS “SECURITY”; WHAT IS CONFLICT? Why does “intl.” security matter to us? What is “world peace”? Should we always prefer peace? “War isn’t the answer”
Issues in Latin America Cold War Period. TODAY’s OBJECTIVES: Explain the political context in Latin America after WWII Explain how the Cold War affected.
Latin America in the 20 th Century Chapter 32. Mexico: Revolution  : Diaz’s repressive dictatorship Export economy w/ elite land ownership Foreign.
A country uses all its human, economic and military resources to fight the war.
Economic Development, Inequality, War and State Violence WAYNE E. NAFZIGER AND JUHA AUVINEN Andrea Bittnerová,
Types of War.
El Salvador San Salvador.
Gender inequality / Sexism
Welcome to AP COGO.
WHAT IS THIS COURSE UNIT ABOUT AGAIN?
Modern European Revolutions: Review
Coach Rausch Intro to A.P. Comparative Politics
Major Topics of Comparative Government and Politics
SA Army Seminar 21 Change and Continuity in Global Politics and Military Strategy (with special reference to Human Rights, the Nature of War and Humanitarian.
A.P Black history month.
Nations and Society.
CH. 1 Introduction to Comparative Politics
Early Early Warning Prof. B. de Gaay Fortman.
Policy Recommendations for Negotiations with US
“Pathways for Peace”: Key Substantive Findings and Future Research Charles T. Call Senior External Advisor for the Report Associate Professor of International.
From Debt to Democratization,
Part One: Intro to Comparative Politics
Presentation transcript:

Causes of Civil Wars Political and Economic Factors in contemporary civil wars Johan M.G. van der Dennen

Causes of Civil Wars Byman & Van Evera's (1998: 23) main thesis is that, in recent years, civil war has replaced international war as the dominant form of war and has nearly replaced it as the only form of war (cf. Murshed, 2001). The Persian gulf war of has been the only major old-fashioned interstate war since The war problem is now largely synonymous with the civil war problem.

Causes of Civil Wars Byman & van Evera hypothesize that seven causes of civil violence stand out in importance (that is, in their potency and prevalence) in the cold war and post-cold war periods. They are:

Causes of Civil Wars 1. The collapse of post-Second World War empires;

Causes of Civil Wars 1. The collapse of post-Second World War empires; 2. A lack of regime legitimacy;

Causes of Civil Wars 1. The collapse of post-Second World War empires; 2. A lack of regime legitimacy; –reform trap: democratization hunkering down

Causes of Civil Wars 1. The collapse of post-Second World War empires; 2. A lack of regime legitimacy; 3. State weakness;

Causes of Civil Wars 1. The collapse of post-Second World War empires; 2. A lack of regime legitimacy; 3. State weakness; 4. Communal hegemonism;

Causes of Civil Wars 1. The collapse of post-Second World War empires; 2. A lack of regime legitimacy; 3. State weakness; 4. Communal hegemonism; 5. Revolutionary ideology;

Causes of Civil Wars 1. The collapse of post-Second World War empires; 2. A lack of regime legitimacy; 3. State weakness; 4. Communal hegemonism; 5. Revolutionary ideology; 6. Aristocratic intransigence;

Causes of Civil Wars 1. The collapse of post-Second World War empires; 2. A lack of regime legitimacy; 3. State weakness; 4. Communal hegemonism; 5. Revolutionary ideology; 6. Aristocratic intransigence; 7. Superpower proxy wars

Causes of Civil Wars All seven cause operated both during and after the cold war, but some were more prevalent during the cold war while some have been more prevalent afterward. Specifically, the first three causes listed above (collapse of empire, regime illegitimacy, and state weakness) grew more abundant after 1989, the fourth (communal hegemonism) stood roughly constant across both periods, and the last three (revolutionary ideology, aristocratic intransigence, and superpower competition) abated sharply after 1989.

Causes of Civil Wars Murshed (2001) adds the following economic origins to the complex chain of causative factors culminating in civil wars:

Causes of Civil Wars Inequality of income and opportunity should form the basis of a grievance that causes violence and ultimately civil war.

Causes of Civil Wars Inequality of income and opportunity should form the basis of a grievance that causes violence and ultimately civil war. Agrarian societies with high income inequality - for example El Salvador, Guatemala, the Philippines, and Zimbabwe - have high asset inequality, and are very prone to conflict.

Causes of Civil Wars Inequality of income and opportunity should form the basis of a grievance that causes violence and ultimately civil war. Agrarian societies with high income inequality - for example El Salvador, Guatemala, the Philippines, and Zimbabwe - have high asset inequality, and are very prone to conflict. Economic mismanagement.

Causes of Civil Wars Greed disguised as grievance? Greed might indeed drive civil war, but poverty and grievances also play a part.

Causes of Civil Wars Greed disguised as grievance? Greed might indeed drive civil war, but poverty and grievances also play a part. Two main types of resource exploitation and protracted warfare (warlord competition): point resources and diffuse resources.

Causes of Civil Wars Conflict as the breakdown of social contract: State failure.

Causes of Civil Wars Conflict as the breakdown of social contract: State failure. The role of democracy in internal conflict prevention.

Causes of Civil Wars Greed, creed, and governance in civil war, (De Soysa, 2002)

Causes of Civil Wars Greed, creed, and governance in civil war, (De Soysa, 2002) –Abundant mineral wealth

Causes of Civil Wars Greed, creed, and governance in civil war, (De Soysa, 2002) –Abundant mineral wealth –Ethnicity

Causes of Civil Wars Greed, creed, and governance in civil war, (De Soysa, 2002) –Abundant mineral wealth –Ethnicity –Political liberalization

Causes of Civil Wars Greed, creed, and governance in civil war, (De Soysa, 2002) –Abundant mineral wealth –Ethnicity –Political liberalization –Creed

Causes of Civil Wars Greed, creed, and governance in civil war, (De Soysa, 2002) –Abundant mineral wealth –Ethnicity –Political liberalization –Creed –Governance and trade