Topics to be Covered 1. Capacity Planning 2. Aggregate Planning in Perspective 3. Scope of Aggregate Planning 4. Factors Impacting the Supply Capacity 5. Strategies for Aggregate Planning 6. Techniques for Aggregate Planning 7. Mathematical Techniques 8. Disaggregating the Aggregate Plan
How Does Capacity Planning Fit In The Production Cycle. Make or Buy Forecasting Facility Definition Resource Planning Aggregate Plan Master Production Schedule Rough Cut Capacity Planning MRP Detailed Capacity Planning Purchasing Shop Floor Control
Capacity VS Utilization - Peak quantity created over a period of time - Peak Capacity does not include scheduled breaks & planned maintenance - Effective Capacity does include scheduled breaks & planned maintenance & other planned events. Utilization the relationship between what is actually produced vs what can be produced. (Actual/Capacity x 100%) Capacity Cushion - The difference between full capacity and Utilization (Cushion = 100% - Utilization)
Facility Planning Economies of scale vs Diseconomies of scale Need to be part of the total operations strategy and not a series of capital budget decisions Amount of capacity; size of unit; timing of capacity changes; long run needs Economies of scale vs Diseconomies of scale Factors: Predicted demand Costs of facilities Likely behavior of competitors Business strategy International Considerations Economies of scale are based on the notion that large units are more economical because fixed costs are spread over more units. - capital costs are not linear to volume but are more of a block type Diseconomies of scale refer to the excessive increase in the size which reduces communication, increased transportation cost to varied customers coming from one plant. Too bureaucratic. Make rules because we can not be every where.
Facilities Strategy Cushion? Styles: Try not to run out Build to average demand Maximize utilization Cushion? Timing is an issue which is defined by the corporate strategy towards how it introduces products into the market. Preempt strategy says we are market leaders; hoping to get market share and create a brand name Wait & See says we will let the competition make the mistakes and then we will enter because we already have brand loyalty with our other products or we have a competitive advantage of reengineering. Try not to run out means we have much cushion Build to average demand says we use cushion to level our work force output Max utilization says we will use a minimal operations because the customer will wait. No or negative cushion Which cushion is best; Large is best when market is expanding or when the cost of building and maintaining goods is less than the cost of running out. Make to order Medium is best when cost of running out vs cost of building is about the same Small is when cost of building is more than cost of running out. - product is at a high utilization and such as a make to stock Timing: Preempt the competition Wait and see
Strategy & Facility Types Product Focus (55%): One product family; large market Transportation costs low & high economies of scale Market Focused (30%): located in singular or few market served; service oriented High transportation cost & quick service needed Process Focused (10%): 1 or 2 key technologies; component parts General Purpose (5%) several product types; several different processes low volumes of any one product type Product focus – typically a high volume product layout type; Centralized manufacturing and engineering Market focus -
Aggregate Planning in Perspective Capacity Decisions are on Three Levels. Long Term Intermediate Term Short Term Long Term Decisions - Decisions necessary to decide the absolute max capacity. Product or Service Selection Facility Size & Layout Location Equipment Type Intermediate or Aggregate Decisions - Decisions necessary to meet expected demand not in the immediate future. General levels of employment Output per year Inventories (Average Target) Long Term decisions set the baseline or constraints for the intermediate decisions. Short Term Decisions This month’s output Machine loading Job sequencing Aggregate decisions set the constraints for short term decisions
Minimizing Costs thru Balancing Aggregate Planning seeks to balance Demand and Capacity by minimizing total costs. (Big Picture) Demand Capacity Labor Equipment Capital Inventory Subcontracting Backordering Pricing Promotion Backorders New Demand $ Costs When: Demand > Capacity Capacity > Demand
Factors Impacting the Supply Capacity Hire & Fire Workers Low Morale; Costs; Restrictions Overtime Good Short term solution; Burn-out; Lower Production Part-Time Workers Good for certain industries Possible restrictions Inventories Good Supply Control Costs: Warehousing; Obsolesce; Deterioration; Breakage; Spoilage; Cost of Capital Subcontracting Make or Buy Sometimes cheaper for one of your non-core capabilities Constraints: Quality Control; schedule control; transportation Backorders Cost depends on Product, market position & customer loyalty
Scope of Aggregate Planning Aggregate Planning combines the capacity requirements for the demand of all products or services provided by the company. Why do we Use Aggregate Planning? Match Supply and Demand. Plan for adequate production capability is available. (Rough Cut Capacity Planning) Plan for adequate input resources. (labor & raw materials) Plan for adequate product demand. Aggregate Planning begins with a Forecast of Demand. Time horizon is typically 1 year. Combine individual product demand forecast. Forecast aggregate demand directly. What do we need to Know to Begin Aggregate Planning? Facility Capacity. Available Resources, Raw Materials, Labor, etc. Forecast Demand For each period. Any Special Company Constraints. labor policies; Inventory policies
Strategies for Aggregate Planning The Operations Manager generally has control only over capacity. Several Strategies are Available Maintain a Level Work Force. Maintain a Steady Output Rate Match Demand period by period Abrupt changes in Output and Workforce required. Use a combination of decision strategies The most common and flexible is to use a combination of strategies. The specific strategy will depend on the market trend. If there is only a short term change in demand then maintaining a steady workforce is preferred. If there is a long term change in demand then a change in Output and workforce may be required. Use variations in inventories, subcontracting, backlog, & overtime to supplement short term changes. The preferred strategy is sufficiently flexible to feasibly match supply and demand within legal constraints, Company policy and at a minimal cost when faced with varying conditions.
Aggregate Planning Problem Demand: Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun 650 700 850 500 Supply: Regular Workers: 120 units per worker per month Inventory: 200 units at beginning; need 100 at end Overtime: 15% max Subcontract: 10% Backorder: Not allowed Total units = 4050 # of workers = 5.62; if inventory is allowed then select 5 Costs: Regular Time : $15/hour per worker Inventory: $1/unit /month OT :150% of Regular Subcontract: $20 per unit Hiring = $100 Firing = $250
Techniques for Aggregate Planning Aggregate Planning techniques fall within two categories: Informal & Mathematical Informal is used most, as Mathematical requires some model development. General Procedure for Developing an Aggregate Plan: 1. Determine demand for each period. 2. Determine capacities for each period. (Regular time, overtime, subcontracting) 3. Determine company policies that are pertinent. (Safety stock, max inventory, allowable overtime) 4. Determine unit costs for regular time, overtime, subcontracting, holding costs, backorders, and other relevant costs. 5. Develop alternative plans and compute the cost for each. 6. Select the most satisfactory feasible solution. Informal Approach Consists of developing simple tables or graphs that enable the planners to visually compare projected demand requirements with existing capacity. (spreadsheets) Alternatives are usually evaluated in terms of their overall costs. The chief disadvantage is the significant amount of time to achieve an optimal solution. Alternatives are not always feasible nor optimal based on company constraints. The main advantages are the simplicity and the visual nature. Persistence, experience and luck are part of defining a good plan
Informal Method Reg = $10 OT = $15 SC = $13 Inv = $ 1 BL = $ 5 Hire = $ 17 Fire = $22
Mathematical Techniques Linear Decision Rule (Holt, Modigliani, & Simon) Management Coefficient Parametric Production Planning Search Decision Rule Production Switching Heurestic Linear Programming Transportation Method Goal Programming’ Mixed Integer Programming Simulation Objective Equation: Minmize Z = Reg Prod Costs + Hiring Costs + Firing Costs + Holding Costs + Subcontracting Costs + Overtime Costs Minimize Z= (Cw Wt + Ch Ht + Cf Ft + Ci It + Cs St + Co Ot) Constraints: W t-1 + H t - F t = W t (Balance Work Force) I t-1 + k W t + S t + O t - D t = I t ( Balance of Inventory) D t - k W t + I t = P t (Balance Production)
Disaggregating the Aggregate Plan As the short term plan is dependent upon the aggregate plan, it is necessary to translate this plan into meaningful numbers in the short term. Breakdown the aggregate plan into specific product requirements. To determine labor, material and inventory requirements A general plan was developed in units that applied across product lines. Now how do we convert those units into specific product lines? This can be difficult. This disaggregation results in a Master Production Schedule. Shows quantity and timing of specific goods
Review of Aggregation The Purpose of Aggregate Planning is to develop a feasible Production Plan on an aggregate level that achieves a balance of expected demand and supply, while considering the minimization of cost. Because the Supply of resources and the Demand for product can vary, Aggregate Planning tries to provide a leveling effect to reduce abrupt changes to the factors of production. Aggregate Planning is medium range capacity planning typically 3 to 18 months horizon Aggregate Planning is essentially a big-picture approach to planning. The focus is on capacity Think in terms of units that are common across product lines Labor hours Machine Hours/ month Output rates of similar products