Panel: Are IRBs Efficient, Effective or Redundant? Gary L. Chadwick, PharmD, MPH, CIP Associate Provost Associate Professor, Medical Humanities University.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

The Role of the IRB An Institutional Review Board (IRB) is a review committee established to help protect the rights and welfare of human research subjects.

Advertisements

IRB Issues in Medical Education Research – OHRP Perspective American Association of Colleges of Osteopathic Medicine 2 nd Annual Meeting – June 24-26,

SIMPLIFYING PRIVACY: HIPAA PRIVACY STANDARDS AND RESEARCH Angela M. Vieira General Counsel Childrens Hospital and Health Center June 5, 2004.

The Radioactive Drug Research Committee Approval Process for Tracer Use Anthony F. Shields, M.D., Ph.D. Karmanos Cancer Institute Wayne State University.

Open Library June 4, 2004 Informed Consent Process and Federal Regulations That Must Be Met to Waive Informed Consent Tracey Craddock Regulatory Compliance.

Criteria For Approval 45 CFR CFR Minimized risks Reasonable risk/benefit ratio Equitable subject selection Informed consent process Informed.

The Institutional Review Board. What is an IRB? An IRB is committee set up by an institution to review, approve, and regulate research conducted under.

IRB Determinations 1. AAHRPP Site Visit Results Site visitors observed a real commitment to human subject protections Investigator and research staff.

Evaluating Risk 1 IRB CELT Presentation Colleen Donaldson – IRB Administrator Julie Wilkens – IRB Coordinator.

1 Developed by: U-MIC To start the presentation, click on this button in the lower right corner of your screen. The presentation will begin after the.

Informed Consent and HIPAA Tim Noe Coordinating Center.

Ethical Issues in Research

Response to FDA Audit 483 MX-4501N : Nine Category 483 Citations Meetings Minutes: Votes for, against, abstention and reason not recorded;

Avoiding the Pitfalls of an IRB Submission Chris Ayres Chair, Institutional Review Board Social & Behavioral Science & Chair, Department of Kinesiology,

International Research & Research Involving Children K. Lynn Cates, MD Assistant Chief Research & Development Officer Office of Research & Development.

Taking the Plunge: Facilitating and Monitoring Collaborative Research and IRB Authorization Agreements Charles Hite Director, Biomedical & Research Ethics.

Adverse Events and Unanticipated Problems Presented by: Karen Jeans, PhD, CCRN, CIP COACH Program Analyst.

 Understanding the IRB Process University of Tennessee Health Science Center Institutional Review Board.

Regulatory criteria for approval Bob Craig, July 2007.

“What’s Ethics Got To Do With It” Presentation to the Canberra Evaluation Forum Gary Kent Head Governance Australian Institute of Health and Welfare.

1 The Perspective of a Local IRB Challenges related to human subjects research protections in the context of disasters Presented to SCAHRP October 30,

Institutional Review Board for Human Subject Research: Does Your Research Need One? Merle Rosenzweig Michael Unsworth.

RESPONSIBLE CONDUCT IN HUMAN SUBJECTS RESEARCH MARGARITA M. CARDONA DIRECTOR OF SPONSORED RESEARCH Institutional Review Board.

Privacy and Confidentiality. Definitions n Privacy - having control over the extent, timing, and circumstances of sharing oneself (physically, behaviorally,

The Institutional Review Board: A Community College Toolkit Dr. Geri J Anderson.

How to Successfully Apply to the IRB Richard Gordin, IRB Chair True Rubal, Administrator / Director For the Protection of Human Participants in Research.

IRB BASICS: Issues in Ethics and Human Subject Protections Prepared by Ed Merrill Department of Psychology November 12, 2009.

Chapter 5 Conducting & Reading Research Baumgartner et al Chapter 5 Ethical Concerns in Research.

Human Research Protection Program & IRB Responsibilities Marisue Cody, PhD Director Center on Advice & Compliance Help.

Institutional Review Board Issues for Classroom Research Sharon McWhorter IRB Administrator, The University of Akron (With assistance from Phil Allen,

TUN IRB: The Basics February 26, IRB Function Review human-subject research Ensure the rights & welfare of human subjects are adequately protected.

CUNY Human Research Protection Program (HRPP) School of Professional Studies April 18, 2013

APPROVAL CRITERIA AN IRB INFOSHORT MAY CFR CRITERIA FOR IRB APPROVAL OF RESEARCH In order for an IRB to approve a research study, all.

WELCOME to the TULANE UNIVERSITY HUMAN RESEARCH PROTECTION OFFICE WORKSHOP for SOCIAL/BEHAVIORAL RESEARCH (March 2, 2010) Tulane University HRPO Uptown.

Joni Barnard IRB Information Session: EHE Workshop 10/13/2015.

Conducting Research at Lincoln IRB/HRPP Policies, Procedures & Good Clinical Practices B Kanna MD, MPH, FACP Associate Program Director of Internal Medicine.

Protecting Human Subjects in Research A Primer on Understanding the Scope, Purpose, and Process of the Kaplan University IRB Prepared by the Office of.

Chapter 5 Ethical Concerns in Research. Historical Perspective on Ethics Nazi Experimentation in WWII –“medical experiments” –Nuremberg War Crime Trials.

Medical Research in Times of Bioterrorism - OHRP’s Perspective Michael A. Carome, M.D. Associate Director for Regulatory Affairs Office for Human Research.

Legal Responsibilities for Studies Conducted or Supported by HHS Michael A. Carome, M.D. Associate Director for Regulatory Affairs Office for Human Research.

Human Subjects Update E. Wethington, Chair, UCHS.

PRIMER: Human Subjects, Past, Present, and Future Susan Metosky, Arizona State University Debra Murphy, Arizona State University.

Institutional Review Board for Human Subject Research: Does Your Research Need One? Merle Rosenzweig Michael Unsworth.

THE INSTITUTIONAL REVIEW BOARD. WHAT IS AN IRB? An IRB is committee set up by an institution to review, approve, and regulate research conducted under.

Protecting Human Subjects Overview of the Issues Applications to Educational Research The IRB Process.

Conditional IRB Approval

IRB BASICS Ethics and Human Subject Protections Summer 2016

International Human Subjects Research

Introduction to IRB (Institutional Review Board)

Conducting Human Subjects Research

Overview - Introduction

Changes to Exempt Categories

Jeffrey M. Cohen, Ph.D. CIP President HRP Associates, Inc.

Conducting Human Subjects Research

Overview - Introduction

Overview - Introduction

To start the presentation, click on this button in the lower right corner of your screen. The presentation will begin after the screen changes and you.

IRB BASICS: Ethics and Human Subject Protections

Elements of a Successful Informed Consent

Conducting Human Subjects Research

Jeffrey M. Cohen, Ph.D. Associate Dean,

Secondary Research with Identifiable Information and Biospecimens

CUNY Human Research Protection Program (HRPP)

Making Your IRBs and Clinical Investigators HIPAA-Ready

Exploring 45 CFR , Criteria for IRB Approval of Research

13 Managing Medical Records Lesson 3:

Office of Research Integrity and Protections

Event Reporting in Human Subjects Research

Protocol Approval Criteria

Research with Human Subjects

Presentation transcript:

Panel: Are IRBs Efficient, Effective or Redundant? Gary L. Chadwick, PharmD, MPH, CIP Associate Provost Associate Professor, Medical Humanities University of Rochester © Gary L. Chadwick, PharmD, MPH, CIP 2004

IRB Mission The primary purpose of [IRB] review is to assure the protection of the rights and welfare of the human subjects. 21CFR56.102(g)

IRB Approval Criteria IRB determines the following: 1,2) risks to subjects are minimized and reasonable 3) selection of subjects is equitable 4,5) informed consent is obtained and documented 6) adequate monitoring of study data 7) adequate privacy and confidentiality 8) additional safeguards for vulnerable subjects 21CFR / 45CFR46.111

Optional Extras rules HDE review Repositories/Banks COI reviews Subpart C reviews / reporting Exemption ( b) determinations Adverse Event reporting / reviews HIPAA Contact Databases Scientific Review (lit) Certification* Accreditation* Let the IRB do it

Why? Everyone is running scared –high-profile closures –law suits (institutions, PIs, IRBs) –sense of lack of control (or out of control) Conservative interpretations –Federal regulators –Institutional offices (legal / risk management) –IRBs When in doubt – just say no.

Stress Greater workload –do more, document more Less enjoyment / satisfaction –more staff / member turnover Has the level of Human Subject Protection changed for the better?

Reponses Networking –ARENA membership / meetings –IRB Forum –IRBNet Electronic submission / review Central Review

Centralized Review Models –NCI –Contract IRB –Co-operative IRBs Cooperative Review (45CFR46.114) –Cooperative research projects are those projects covered by this policy which involve more than one institution. In the conduct of cooperative research projects, each institution is responsible for safeguarding the rights and welfare of human subjects and for complying with this policy. With the approval of the Department or Agency head, an institution participating in a cooperative project may enter into a joint review arrangement, rely upon the review of another qualified IRB, or make similar arrangements for avoiding duplication of effort.

Really Why? Trust or, more correctly, lack of trust

Solution – System Change Return the concept of trust back to the system Accept that some will fail / abuse Focus on the outliers - do not regulate / manage to the 1%