Community Identity: Peer Prestige & Academic Hiring in the iSchools Andrea Wiggins, Mick McQuaid, & Lada Adamic iConference 2008 2/28/2008.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Presented by: Jerry Legge Associate Provost for Academic Planning (Interim), and Professor of Public Administration and Policy (SPIA) Provost Advisory.
Advertisements

I.T. Works Principal Investigator: Peter D. Blanck, Ph.D., J.D. Project Director: James L. Schmeling, J.D. Co-Investigator: Kevin M. Schartz, Ph.D., M.C.S.
Keith D. Lee, MA, MFA, PhD Nonprofit and Arts Management Consultant Association of Arts Administration Educators 31 May 2014 From Research to Practice:
Remaking the Climate for Graduate Education: DECADE Frances Leslie, Susan Coutin, Kelly Ward & Marina Corrales UC Irvine.
CYPRUS UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY Internal Evaluation Procedures at CUT Quality Assurance Seminar Organised by the Ministry of Education and Culture and.
Roberta Spalter-Roth, Ph.D Director of Research American Sociological Association Enhancing Diversity in Science: Working Together to Develop Common Data,
1 CAMPUS FORUM September 12, Review Priorities Academic Program Support Compensation Diversity Financial Security Recruiting and Marketing.
A Commitment to Excellence: SUNY Cortland Update on Strategic Planning.
Discussion The Future of Sociology: Minorities, Programs, and Jobs Most of the data I will discuss comes from surveys and membership data published by.
Points to Remember The majority of undergraduate majors do not go on to graduate school in sociology. We must do a better job of counseling them, because.
כנס צייס Economics of information Goods: An interdisciplinary Subject for Israeli LIS and MBA Curricula Dr. Noa Aharony Library and Information.
Campus Climate for UNC Charlotte Faculty Findings from the 1998, 2001, & 2004 UCLA HERI Faculty Surveys Cathy Sanders Director of Assessment Office of.
Merage Student Association Rankings Discussion Gary Lindblad, Asst. Dean and Director, Full -time MBA Tony Hansford, Executive Director, FEMBA Debbie Moysychyn,
Process Management Robert A. Sedlak, Ph.D Provost and Vice Chancellor, UW-Stout Education Community of Practice Conference At Tusside in Turkey September.
STEPPING STONE PROJECT STEPPING STONE PROJECT designing a new engineering discipline presented by team 1.
Board of Regents Strategic Planning Study Session A Brief Discussion of UCB Peer Financial Comparative Data April 10, 2006.
Cluster Analysis on Perceived Effects of Scholarships on STEM Majors’ Commitment to Becoming Teachers versus Teaching in High Needs Schools Pey-Yan Liou.
Trends in LIS Education Michèle V. Cloonan Dean & Professor Simmons College GSLIS.
Issues in interdisciplinary teaching and learning John Canning Subject Centre for Languages, Linguistics and Area Studies University of Southampton.
Employers’ Expectation for Entry-Level Catalog Librarians: What Position Announcement Data Indicate.
Provocation on the Core of STS Stephen Hilgartner Cornell University.
History of Political Science  Traditional Historical, Legalism, Philosophy, Descriptive  Modern – “Behavioralism” Political science as “science” Facilitated.
1 Reinforcing the “I” in IT Education Ronald L. Larsen School of Information Sciences Copyright Ronald L. Larsen This work is the intellectual property.
Annie Downey Starr Hoffman University of North Texas ASHE Conference November 2009 UNT EDHE 40 th Anniversary November 2010 THE VALUE OF THE DOCTORATE.
Networks Among Black Studies Professors Fabio Rojas Department of Sociology Indiana University.
Utilization of Service Learning in Emergency Management Programs in the U.S. UCF SCHOOL OF PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION Claire Connolly Knox, Ph.D. Assistant.
Learning with Purpose UMass Lowell College of Fine Arts, Humanities & Social Sciences Strategic Planning Retreat June 4 th, 2013 Luis M. Falcón, Dean Julie.
Roberta Spalter-Roth Director, Research and Development Department American Sociological Association Beyond the Ivory Tower: Professionalism, Skills Match,
How FSU Stacks Up To Its Peers: National Views of FSU THE FLORIDA STATE UNIVERSITY.
Technology Support on a University Campus Contingency Theory and Collaboration.
Program Review Discussion. Unit Defined Core Questions 1) What progress has the Program made toward each one of these objectives? 1. Reach national prominence.
Benchmarking supervisor development Stan Taylor. ∂ Historically... Necessary and sufficient condition was to be research-active; Reason was, as Rudd (1985:
Goals of General Education Program Statement of Philosophy "General Education is a part of our curriculum that challenges students to develop the intellectual.
STUDENT LEARNING OUTCOMES STATE CENTER COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICT BOARD REPORT, DECEMBER 7, 2010 SLO Coordinators: Maggie Taylor (FCC) and Eileen Apperson(RC)
On the Scale and Performance of Cooperative Web Proxy Caching University of Washington Alec Wolman, Geoff Voelker, Nitin Sharma, Neal Cardwell, Anna Karlin,
Increasing the Representation of Women Full Professors in Academe Barbara A. Lee Dean School of Management & Labor Relations Rutgers University.
SCHOOL OF INFORMATION UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN 1 Ethics, Information Technology and Today’s Undergraduate Classroom Ethics and the Undergraduate 2008 iConference.
UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH CAROLINA Department of Computer Science and Engineering CSCE 190 Careers in Computer Science, Computer Engineering, and Computer Information.
Using Transactional Information to Predict Link Strength in Online Social Networks Indika Kahanda and Jennifer Neville Purdue University.
Wasanthi Madurapperuma Social Network of Entrepreneurs & Small Business Growth Related Literature & Research Gap Unit of Analysis - Small Retail Businesses.
“Diversity and Its Discontents”: A Report on Graduate Student Experiences in PhD-Granting Institutions ASA Annual Meeting 2012 Denise A. Segura.
Marcus Bellamy Alun Jones Session 6: Knowledge & Collaboration Networks.
From a galaxy far, far away... The Compact Process A View from 40,000 feet Laura Coffin Koch Associate Vice Provost University of Minnesota.
Ph. D. Completion and Attrition: Analysis of Baseline Data NSF AGEP Evaluation Capacity Meeting September 19, 2008 Robert Sowell Council of Graduate Schools.
4/6/20061 Are Sociologists Different? Findings from Social Science PhDs- 5+ Year Out: A National Study of PhDs in Six Social Science Fields Panel: Satisfaction.
Building Graduate Communities: A Policy Imperative for Knowledge-based Societies University of Alberta and China Scholarship Council Conference “Quality.
HERI FACULTY SURVEY Surveys mailed through campus mail to all Full-Time faculty during the Spring 2005 semester A follow-up second mailing for non- respondents.
Derek Alderman Department of Geography. Purpose O Discuss why I take data analysis seriously O Departmental Health & Sustainability O Reflect on Academic.
Access to "pedagogic rights" in social science teaching and learning: findings from a study of English universities The ‘Pedagogic quality and inequality.
A Graph-based Friend Recommendation System Using Genetic Algorithm
1 Faculty Motivation and Policies Steven R. Hall Professor of Aeronautics and Astronautics Chair of the MIT Faculty.
Dominic Sachsenmaier Global History. Thinking Globally About History Terminological Options World History Transnational History International History.
Committee Meeting, June 9, 2008 Strategic Institutional Research Plan.
Week 2 The lecture for this week is designed to provide students with a general overview of 1) quantitative/qualitative research strategies and 2) 21st.
National Research Council Assessment of Doctorate Programs: The Methodology Report E. L. Fink & S. Chai University of Maryland.
Hugo Horta Center for the Advancement of Higher Education, Tohoku University Japan CIES-ISCTE, Portugal.
Building an Inclusive Faculty: Stakeholders, Standards, and Strategies Luis Ricardo Fraga Associate Vice Provost for Faculty Advancement Russell F. Stark.
Pastors Report Mixed Economic Signs Survey of 1,000 Protestant Pastors.
MAKERERE UNIVERSITY Developing and Nurturing the Next Generation of Academics: Focus on emerging scholars A presentation BY` Prof. Lillian Tibatemwa-Ekirikubinza.
Outreach at an Academic Library: Targeting the Gatekeepers Bredny Rodriguez, MLS AHIP Health & Life Sciences Informationist Louise M. Darling Biomedical.
Are There Fast Tracks in Economics Departments? Valerie Smeets (UC3M & CCP, ASB) Madrid, October 2007.
Quality assurance and graduate student support Fred L Hall Former Dean of Graduate Studies at University of Calgary, McMaster University,
Key Findings from Research Understanding for Improvement Key Findings from Research Understanding for Improvement NSF/NIH/CGS Graduate Support Workshop.
Documentation and Assessment of Scholarship in Extension and Engagement: A National Perspective Amy Driscoll Associate Senior Scholar Carnegie Foundation.
An Evaluation of Pipeline Interventions for Minority Scholars An Evaluation of Pipeline Interventions for Minority Scholars Roberta Spalter-Roth, Jean.
Health and Aging Education in Accredited Public Health Programs L. Cricel Molina, MPH Steven P. Wallace, PhD 135th Annual Meeting of the American Public.
How High Schools Explain Students’ Initial Colleges and Majors
The Future of Sociology: Minorities, Programs, and Jobs
Fig. 3 Faculty placement distributions.
Fig. 1 Prestige hierarchies in faculty hiring networks.
Presentation transcript:

Community Identity: Peer Prestige & Academic Hiring in the iSchools Andrea Wiggins, Mick McQuaid, & Lada Adamic iConference /28/2008

Problem Statement iSchools are defining an intellectual community identity as a new breed of interdisciplinary researchers. Members of the community must align individual identities with the iSchool community identity.

Practical Problems of Identity From 2005 iConference Survey: –Academic legitimacy Organizational survival –Student recruitment –Student placement –Development of scholarly community Publication Funding Interdisciplinary research

What is an iSchool? Interdisciplinary focus on information, technology and people, with diverse institutional characteristics Common roots in computer science, library science, information studies, and more 19 schools form the I-Schools Caucus –Members are expected to have substantial sponsored research activity, engagement in the training of future researchers, and a commitment to progress in the information field.

Survival & Emergence The prevalent survival strategies for LIS schools in the 1980’s: merger with a larger partner or expansion into IT-related fields (Hildreth & Koenig, 2002) Over half of the iSchools are represented as LIS school mergers or realignments –Merger: Rutgers, UCLA –Realignment: Syracuse, Pittsburgh, Drexel, Florida State, Michigan, Washington, Illinois, Indiana

Identity, Legitimacy & Prestige Academic survival strategy to achieve organizational legitimacy and stability underlies the way an emergent intellectual enterprise develops its identity (Small, 1999) Academic institutions undergoing strategic change often use prestige ratings to indirectly influence identity (Gioia & Thomas, 1996)

Prestige in Academic Hiring Departmental prestige is shown to be an effect of the department’s position in PhD hiring networks in: –Management (Bedeian & Feild, 1980) –Finance (Bair, 2003) –Sociology, history & political science (Burris, 2004) –Sociology (Baldi, 2005) –Political science (Fowler et al, 2007)

Research Question What is the relationship between peer prestige ratings and hiring network measures in iSchools and in Computer Science (CS) departments?

Network Data Census of 693 identifiable full-time faculty of iSchools with manual data collection from Internet resources in January 2007 –674 PhD degrees with 100% complete data –Year of degree not available for other terminal degrees (MLS, JD, MD, etc.) Similar data collected by Drago Radev and associates for top CS departments Ranking data from US News & World Report (2006)

Network Construction Combined each iSchool’s individual ego network into one community ego network –An ego is an iSchool, for which we gathered data on faculty degrees; an alter is an institution from which iSchool faculty were hired –Indiana’s 2 schools were merged to maintain the institution as the unit of analysis Directed 2-mode network reduced to 1-mode –Was: School A -> Person -> School B –Now: School A -> School B, with edge weights

Comparing CS & iSchools Network Characteristic CS NetworkiSchools Network Nodes Egos2918 Alters94134 Edges Average Degree Total PhD Degrees Density Betweenness Average Distance Diameter5 (random = 7)4 (random = 11) Clustering Coefficient0.23 (random = 0.05)0.15 (random = 0.08)

Visual Comparison

Prestige & CS Hiring Regressed USNWR rankings on network characteristics, both node-based (eg. degree) and topologically derived (eg. PageRank) CS: – Weighted PageRank, betweenness & indegree explain 79% of the variance in USNWR ratings –F = 31.7, p << , all 3 variables reach at least p ≤ 0.01 –Negative coefficient for indegree lowers ratings for schools with diverse hiring sources

Prestige & iSchool Hiring iSchools: –Smaller subgroup has USNWR LIS ratings, 11 of 18 –Weighted PageRank, betweenness, hiring diversity (information entropy) & output (number of graduates in the network) explain 77% of the variance in USNWR ratings (F = 9.3, p < 0.01) –Positive coefficient for hiring diversity rewards schools with faculty from a wider selection of institutions

Self-Hiring 26 of 29 CS egos, and 17 of 18 iSchools, have hired graduates of their own institution On average, 13% of faculty in iSchools are self-hires; 64% of those (approximately 8% overall) graduated from the program that now employs them In most cases, self-hires from an iSchool involved faculty in library science

Discussion of Self-Hiring Several reasons for self-hiring in iSchools –Network structure (PhD -> iSchool) does not reflect intermediary employment –Limited availability of PhDs with specific expertise; data suggest this is more often the case for LIS faculty –University as the unit of analysis may hide greater interdisciplinarity due to hires from other departments (e.g. PSU)

Faculty Areas of Study

Disciplinary Diversity Faculty size matters –< 25 faculty represent 5 or fewer disciplines –25+ faculty represent disciplines Information entropy measure of distribution of faculty areas of study for each iSchool –Most diverse: Michigan, Syracuse –Most focused: Toronto, North Carolina, Georgia Tech, UC Irvine –May differentiate hiring strategies that favor disciplinary diversity versus subject focus

Conclusions Hiring network statistics reflect some aspects of peer prestige captured in USNWR rankings, more strongly in CS than iSchools –More data, more established field In iSchools, balancing hiring from within the community and from a diversity of other sources may improve perceptions of prestige Diversity in faculty pedigree may be part of the iSchools’ “special sauce”

Thank you! Questions?

References Bair, J. H. (2003). Hiring Practices in Finance Education. Linkages Among Top-Ranked Graduate Programs. American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 62(2), Baldi, S. (1995). Prestige Determinants of First Academic Job for New Sociology Ph.D.s The Sociological Quarterly, 36(4), Bedeian, A. G. & Field, H. S. (1980). Academic Stratification in Graduate Management Programs: Departmental Prestige and Faculty Hiring Patterns. Journal of Management, 6(2), Burris, V. (2004). The Academic Caste System: Prestige Hierarchies in PhD Exchange Networks. American Sociological Review, 69(2), 239. Fowler, J. H. et al (2007). Social Networks in Political Science: Hiring and Placement of Ph.D.s, 1960–2002. PS: Political Science & Politics, 40(4), Gioia, G. A. & Thomas, J. B. (1996). Identity, Image and Issue Interpretation: Sensemaking During Strategic Change in Academia. Administrative Science Quarterly, 41(3), Hildreth, C. R. & Koenig, M. E. D. (2002). Organizational Realignment of LIS Programs: From independent standalone units to incorporated programs. Journal of Education for Library and Information Science, 43(2), Small, M. L. (1999). Departmental Conditions and the Emergence of New Disciplines: Two cases in the legitimation of African-American studies. Theory and Society, 28(5),

CS Regression Table BSE Bt cs-weighted pagerank * cs- betweenness *** cs-indegree *** * p <.05, *** p <.001 R 2 =.8121, Adj. R 2 =.7865, F(3,22) = 31.7 ***

iSchool Regression Table BSE Bt lis- betweenness ** lis-weighted pagerank ** lis-output ** lis-hiring entropy p <.1, ** p <.01 R 2 =.8605, Adj. R 2 =.7675, F(4,6) = ***