NORMA B. COE UNIVERSITY OF WASHINGTON AND NBER GOPI SHAH GODA STANFORD UNIVERSITY AND NBER How Much Does Access to Health Insurance Influence the Timing.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Health Reform and Private Insurance Gary Claxton Vice President Kaiser Family Foundation April
Advertisements

Health Reform in Kansas Murphy Society University of Kansas School of Medicine October 25, 2012 Suzanne Schrandt, J.D. Kansas Health Institute 1.
Projections for Coverage and Exchange Participation Special Committee on Financial Institutions and Insurance Topeka, Kansas October 24, 2011 Suzanne Cleveland,
Overview of Health Care Coverage and Cost Trends in Minnesota Presentation to the State Budget Trends Study Commission April 22, 2008 Julie Sonier Director,
The Social Security Earnings Test and Retirement: New Evidence from Behavior Near the Exempt Amount Discussion at the 16th RRC Meeting Washington, DC April.
Mission: To promote responsible and equitable fiscal policies through research and education Joy Smolnisky, Director 808 N. West Ave., Sioux Falls, SD.
The Patient Protection & Affordable Care Act (ACA) implements broad, historic changes to U.S. health care Expanded access to health insurance and care.
ITriage University Denver, Colorado June 12, 2013 Health Reform is Here Colorado’s Changing Health Insurance Landscape.
Background on Employer- Sponsored Health Insurance in the U.S. Jim Reschovsky, Ph.D. Senior Researcher Center for Studying Health System Change (
The Michigan Healthcare Marketplace Eileen Ellis Health Management Associates Initial Observations.
Health Coverage in Retirement Presentation at Citizens’ Health Care Working Group by Gerry Smolka, Senior Policy Advisor AARP Public Policy Institute July.
Affordable Care Act (ACA) Where Are We and Where Are We Headed Locey & Cahill, LLC Presentation to: New York State Association of Management Advocates.
Major Health Issues The Affordable Healthcare Act.
Employer-Sponsored Health Coverage Release Slides Tuesday, September 11, 2012 March 15, 2013.
Affordability of Insurance: Application of ACA Definitions in a Linked Employee-Employer Data Set G. Edward Miller Thomas M. Selden Jessica P. Vistnes.
Employer Health Benefit Survey Release Slides Tuesday, August 20, 2013.
Congressional Budget Office Presentation to The Tax Policy Center and the American Tax Policy Institute Taxes and Health Insurance February 29, 2008.
Unpaid Care and Labor Supply of Middle-aged Men and Women in Urban China Lan Liu Institute of Population Research, Peking University Xiaoyuan Dong Department.
Employee Benefits Chapter 13
The Hilltop Health Care Reform Simulation Model Hamid Fakhraei, Ph.D. July 2012.
Self-Select Voluntary Separation Program (SSVSP) 1.
Return to KaiserEDU Tutorials
Marital Disruption and the Risk of Losing Health Insurance Coverage James Kirby AHRQ.
Premium Tax Credits under the ACA Cynthia Cox, MPH Kaiser Family Foundation
Health Reform: What It Means to Our Community. Health Reform: Key Provisions o Provides coverage to 32 million uninsured people by o Changes insurance.
Health Care Costs and the Long-Term Fiscal Imbalance Colorado Human Services Directors Association June 6, 2012.
Health Insurance for Utah Children and Small Businesses November 15, 2006 Expanding Health Insurance Coverage for Utah’s Uninsured Citizens.
An Overview on the Affordable Care Act and Its Impact on West Virginia SBHC Back-to-School Workshop August 9, 2011.
Affordable Care Act and Public School Employees Health Insurance November 1, 2012.
Understanding Health Reform CHOICE Regional Health Network.
Use of a Simulation Model to Inform State Policy: The Case of New Jersey’s Non-Group Health Coverage Market Alan C. Monheit, Ph.D. Joel C. Cantor, Sc.D.
HEALTH IN COLORADO GOVERNOR HICKENLOOPER’S VISION.
Health Care Reform: The Top 10 Things You Need to Know.
Spotlight on the Federal Health Care Reform Law. 2. The Health Care and Education Affordability Reconciliation Act of 2010 was signed March 30, 2010.
Assessing the Value of the NHIS for Studying Changes in State Health Coverage Policies: The Case of New York Sharon K. Long John A. Graves Stephen Zuckerman.
Does Access to Health Insurance Influence Work Effort Among Disability Insurance Recipients? Norma B. Coe, Center for Retirement Research at Boston College.
The Impact of Health Expenses on Older Women ’ s Financial Security Juliette Cubanski, Ph.D. The Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation AcademyHealth 2007 Annual.
Medicare, Medicaid, and Health Care Reform Todd Gilmer, PhD Professor of Health Policy and Economics Department of Family and Preventive Medicine 1.
Nongroup Health Insurance Gary Claxton Vice President Kaiser Family Foundation.
The Incidence of the Healthcare Costs of Obesity Presented by Kate Bundorf Coauthor: Jay Bhattacharya Academy Health Annual Research Meeting June 6, 2004.
Employer Health Benefit Survey 2015
The Great Recession, the Social Safety Net, and Economic Security for Older Americans Richard W. Johnson and Karen E. Smith Urban Institute Presented at.
The Effect of Health Reform on Retirement Presenter: Helen Levy, PhD Coauthors: Tom Buchmueller, PhD Sayeh Nikpay, PhD University of Michigan August 2015.
Capital Hill Briefing January 24, 2011 How the ACA impacts the
Competition, Subsidy and Requirement Regulations -Effects of State Policies and their Interactions on Hospital Uncompensated Care Provision L EI Z HANG.
State & Federal Approaches to Health Reform: What works for the working poor? June 9, 2008 Ellen Meara Meredith Rosenthal Anna Sinaiko Katherine Baicker.
Tax Policy Options Sherry Glied, Ph.D. Mailman School of Public Health Columbia University
How Health Reform Helps Missouri: Today and in the Future Brian Colby MO Health Advocacy Alliance.
Employer-Sponsored Health Insurance for Early Retirees: Impacts on Retirement, Health and Health Care Erin Strumpf, Ph.D. McGill University AcademyHealth.
1 The Implications of Declining Retiree Health Insurance Courtney Monk and Alicia H. Munnell Center for Retirement Research at Boston College 11 th Annual.
Labor Force Participation and Health Insurance Coverage A Dynamic Interaction Catherine McLaughlin Economic Research Initiative on the Uninsured University.
An Overview of the Affordable Care Act An Overview of the Affordable Care Act.
Modeling Health Reform in Massachusetts John Holahan June 4, 2008 THE URBAN INSTITUTE.
Taxes and Health Insurance Conference Washington, DC February 29, 2008 The Effect of Tax Preferences on Health Spending John F. CoganR. Glenn HubbardDaniel.
THE COMMONWEALTH FUND Exhibit 1. Employer Coverage Continues to Be Major Source of Coverage for Employees of Larger Firms Percent of firms offering health.
Actuarial Research Corporation1 Inside the Black Box: Adjustments and Considerations for Public Policy Proposals AcademyHealth Annual Research Meeting:
Average Annual Premium Increases for Family Coverage,
Trends in Health Insurance Coverage in the U.S. Sherry Glied, Ph.D. Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation.
The Financial Feasibility of Delaying Social Security Gopi Shah Goda Shanthi Ramnath John B. Shoven Sita Nataraj Slavov SIEPR/Sloan Working Longer Conference.
Muskie School of Public Service University of Southern Maine Who Uses Individual Health Insurance & For How Long? Erika Ziller Andrew Coburn Timothy McBride.
Explanations for the Decline in Health Insurance Coverage Michael Chernew, Michigan and NBER David Cutler, Harvard and NBER Patricia Keenan, Harvard This.
Health Reform: An Overview Unit 4 Seminar. The Decision The opinions spanned 193 pages, upholding the individual insurance mandate while reflecting a.
Children’s Emotional and Behavioral Problems and Their Parents’ Labor Supply Patrick Richard, Ph.D., M.A. Nicholas C. Petris Center on Health Markets and.
Premium Sensitivity Among Workers Chapter What Is the Relevant Premium? The “risk premium”? The “risk premium”? The “loading fee”? The “loading.
A Look at the Individual Mandate: Massachusetts and California.
ACA policies and market outcomes: rating regions, age-rating, and APTC
August 3, 2017 How Do Retiree Health Costs Affect People and Programs?
Discussant: Lauren Schmitz University of Michigan
Medicaid: Big Decisions Ahead
Leslie E. Papke Michigan State University
Presentation transcript:

NORMA B. COE UNIVERSITY OF WASHINGTON AND NBER GOPI SHAH GODA STANFORD UNIVERSITY AND NBER How Much Does Access to Health Insurance Influence the Timing of Retirement?

CBO: ACA  Large Reductions in Labor Supply `“CBO estimates that the ACA will reduce the total number of hours worked, on net, by about 1.5 percent to 2.0 percent during the period from 2017 to 2024, almost entirely because workers will choose to supply less labor—given the new taxes and other incentives they will face and the financial benefits some will receive.” Source: CBO (2014), Budget and Economic Outlook: , Appendix C: Labor Market Effects of the Affordable Care Act.

ACA Provisions Affecting Labor Supply 1. The subsidies for health insurance purchased through exchanges; 2. The expansion of Medicaid eligibility; 3. The penalties on employers that decline to offer insurance; and 4. The new taxes imposed on labor income. Source: CBO (2014), Budget and Economic Outlook: , Appendix C: Labor Market Effects of the Affordable Care Act.

Another Channel: ACA Rating Regulations Guarantee issue/renewability Rating variation based only on:  Age (3:1 ratio)  Premium rating area  Family composition  Tobacco use (1.5:1 ratio) Affects individual market, small group market, and exchange Source: Kaiser Family Foundation Summary of the Affordable Care Act, April 2013,

Regulations Will Affect Near-Elderly Retirees Prior to Medicare eligibility, retirees generally access health insurance from one of four primary sources:  Retiree health insurance from previous employer/union  Spouse’s employer  COBRA coverage  Individual market Regulations are likely to reduce premiums for older and sicker individuals in the individual market

Research Question and Empirical Strategy How do rating regulations affect the timing of retirement? Exploit variation in state regulatory environments over time to estimate the impact of regulations on retirement hazards  Code a state as having a “Strictly Regulated Market” if it has both guaranteed issue and community rating regulations in place (Herring and Pauly 2006)  Data on state regulations compiled from Kaiser Family Foundation (2010), Georgetown University Health Policy Institute (2004), and Wachenheim and Leida (2007)

Previous Literature Relationship between health insurance and retirement behavior  COBRA (Gruber and Madrian 1995, 1996)  Retiree health insurance  Reduced form (Karoly and Rogoski 1994; Rogowski and Karoly 2000; Johnson, Davidoff and Perese 2003; Gruber and Madrian 1995; Linsenmeier 2002; Marton and Woodbury 2006; Blau and Gilleskie 2001; Gruber and Madrian 2002; Nyce et al. 2013)  Structural models (Gustman and Steinmeier 1994; Rust and Phelan 1997; French and Jones 2011; Blau and Gilleskie 2006, 2008)  Public sector (Leiserson 2013; Shoven and Slavov 2013; Fitzpatrick 2013) Rating regulations and premiums (Herring and Pauly 2006; Belloff and Cantor 2008; LoSasso 2011)

Number of States with Strict Health Insurance Regulations

Health and Retirement Study, Linked to restricted geographic identifiers Hazard framework (following Behaghel and Blau 2012) Outcomes  Exiting the labor force  Retirement self-report  Claiming Social Security retirement benefits

Sample Restrictions Unit of observation: person-months Being in sample conditional on not having claimed, retired, or exited labor force in month prior to 60 th birthday Exit the sample via  failure (claiming, exiting, retiring),  death,  survey attrition,  reaching age 65 or calendar year 2010

Hypothesized Interactions Fair/poor health status: Since regulations usually decrease the premiums for sicker individuals, effect should be stronger among those in worse health status Spousal health insurance: Those with other sources of health insurance should respond less to regulations because they are less likely to obtain health insurance in the individual market

Effect of Strictly Regulated Non-Group Health Insurance Markets on Labor Force and Claiming Decisions, by age Age Panel A: Exit the Labor Market Strictly Regulated Market ** *** (0.0062)(0.0053)(0.0122)(0.0037)(0.0201) Mean of Dep Variable Adjusted R Observations26,29125,89322,86720,31319,160 Panel B: Self-Reported Retirement Strictly Regulated Market (0.0157)(0.0038)(0.0145)(0.0042)(0.0139) Mean of Dep Variable Adjusted R Observations29,64629,53623,45219,56217,226 Panel C: Claiming Social Security Strictly Regulated MarketN/A (0.0120)(0.0058)(0.0288) Mean of Dep Variable Adjusted R Observations 32,340 22,285 19,263 Standard errors in parentheses

Effect of Strictly Regulated Non-Group Health Insurance Markets on Labor Force and Claiming Decisions, by age and health status Age Panel A: Exit the Labor Market Strictly Regulated Market *** *** (0.0060)(0.0054)(0.0120)(0.0038)(0.0203) Strictly Regulated Market * Poor health * (0.0046)(0.0040)(0.0103)(0.0140)(0.0066) Panel B: Self-Reported Retirement Strictly Regulated Market (0.0154)(0.0037)(0.0146)(0.0047)(0.0139) Strictly Regulated Market * Poor health ***0.03*** (0.0038)(0.0033)(0.0061)(0.0095)(0.0039) Panel C: Claim Social Security Strictly Regulated MarketN/A (0.0121)(0.0059)(0.0285) Strictly Regulated Market * Poor health * * (0.0055) (0.0065) (0.0043) Standard errors in parentheses

Effect of Strictly Regulated Non-Group Health Insurance Markets on Labor Force and Claiming Decisions, by age and spousal access to health insurance Age Panel A: Exit the Labor Market Strictly Regulated Market ** *** (0.0063)(0.0051)(0.0122)(0.0039)(0.0196) Strictly Regulated Market * Has access to Spousal HI *0.0092**0.015* (0.0022)(0.0028)(0.0043)(0.0041)(0.0086) Panel B: Self-Reported Retirement Strictly Regulated Market * (0.0157)(0.0043)(0.0141)(0.0045)(0.0126) Strictly Regulated Market * Has access to Spousal HI ***0.0081*0.0119* (0.0032)(0.0028)(0.0044)(0.0040)(0.0066) Panel C: Claim Social Security Strictly Regulated Market ** (0.0118)(0.0051)(0.0292) Strictly Regulated Market * Has access to Spousal HI *** (0.0034) (0.0042) (0.0066) Standard errors in parentheses

Next Steps Sensitivity analysis by current source of health insurance Understand intensive measure responses on hours of work/FT status Obtain average individual health insurance prices by state and year from MEPS  Instrument with regulatory environment Incorporate state-level changes in Medicaid eligibility

Implications for ACA and Retirement Little evidence that regulatory environment influences retirement timing Effects of ACA on retirement behavior may depend more on changes in retiree health insurance and employer-sponsored health insurance