Procurement in PPPs February 27, 2009. 2. When do you start thinking about procurement? Preliminary Scoping & teaming Viability assessment Choice between.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
PRE-QUALIFICATION/ SHORT LISTING OF CONSULTANTS PRE-QUALIFICATION/ SHORT LISTING OF CONSULTANTS.
Advertisements

Office of Purchasing and Contracts Research Funded Procurement Outreach Training Level III Procurements $50,000 and Above.
Energy supply procurement services to improve the transaction process and help you get the most competitive prices Florida Public Service Commission July.
Tendering Yuck!.
PUBLIC PRIVATE PARTNERSHIPS Taking a Balanced Look…. Development Equity Associates Inc. Nov. 14,
Enable Procurement Agencies to Fulfill their Roles Push Smooth Implementation of Project Procurement Foreign Debts Management Center, Hebei Provincial.
1 2 Tips for Tenders Presented by: Rebecca Clarkson Director of Fundraising and Business Development Hackney CVS Training Team.
Indicative Business Case
Iain Menzies The World Bank St. Petersburg - 23 May 2008
Inter-American Development Bank Procurement of Goods, Works and Consulting Services in projects financed by IDB Washington, DC – February 2004.
Session 8 Implementing PPPs
Tendering Procedures in Lagos State under the Public Procurement Law 2011 Presented By Engr. Akin Onimole | February 13, 2013 GM/CEO, Public Procurement.
Gene Shawcroft, P.E. Central Utah Water Conservancy District April 29-30, 2013.
1 Opportunities Related to EPC Initiatives Support Services Management - NWC.
Multi-Stage Bidding.
Need to Invest Investment Objectives and Case for Change Determine Potential Value for Money Strategic Case: Economic Case: Financial Case: Affordability.
v1 The Future of PPPs in Hong Kong Project Chambers Forum 28 May 2010 Presented by Sam Farrands.
1 Use and content of the RFP  Request for Proposals (RFP) is similar to bidding documents and include all information of the assignment, selection of.
Procurement and Tendering Presentation to [NAME OF CLIENT] [YOUR NAME] [DATE]
New Procurement Rules Training Purchases Greater Than $25,000.
Selection of Consultancy Services
Procurement of Consultancy Services. 2 Differences between.
Syed Zaidi, P.Eng. PM (Stanford), PhD. Director, Strategic Partnerships Alberta Infrastructure. Government of Alberta Canada Richard. B. (Dick) Innes,
Phases of A BOT Project Prepared By :Afaf Bu-khawa Course title: Technology Implementation,MGT 620.
1 Business Opportunities Istanbul, Turkey 30 April 2010 Asian Development Bank.
PROCEDURES FOR SELECTING THE CONTRACTOR
PRESENTATION TITLE Presented by: Name Surname Directorate Date Briefing Session: W 1059 WTE APPOINTMENT OF PROFESSIONAL SERVICE PROVIDER (PSP) FOR VALIDATION.
Jeff Delmon FEU Financial Solutions World Bank. Why PPP? Procurement efficiency Lifecycle management Design/construction/operation management Monetizing.
Project Detailed Business Case
INTRODUCTION TO PUBLIC PROCUREMENT
Working with EBRD – Consultant Opportunities for Dutch Consultants Selection & Contracting of Consultants under EBRD’s Procurement Policies and Rules (PP&R)
A SOUND INVESTMENT IN SUCCESSFUL VR OUTCOMES FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT.
Developing and Issuing the RFP. Why should qualifications be your procurement focus? n Having the necessary range of capabilities is more important than.
United Nations Procurement Division
Advanced Project Management Project Procurement/Contract Management Ghazala Amin.
Building Blocks for a Successful Public- Private Partnerships Presented by Igor Abramov Counsel & Co-chair, Eurasia and Russia Practice Group, Heenan Blaikie.
WELCOME TO UNB. MARK McGEEHAN Assistant Manager, Procurement Services 3 plus years with UNB 28 years in Healthcare Procurement Current member of APPA.
1 Department for Work and Pensions The Work Programme Prospectus Supplier Briefing 8 th December 2010.
Public Procurement Reforms
© OECD A joint initiative of the OECD and the European Union, principally financed by the EU Ensuring Good Quality PPP Projects Martin Darcy United Kingdom.
UNDP Bangladesh Procurement Fair Objectives of the Fair; - UNDP Procurement principles; - Procurement plan ; - UNDP Procurement Roadmap;
Introduction Procurement of Consultant Services (based on PPA 2004 and Best Practices) Presented by: NM Lema Macrh, 2013.
Need to Invest Investment Objectives and Case for Change Programme Option Identification and Assessment Analysis Strategic Case: Economic Case: Financial.
Project Procurement Management
PPP Legal & Regulatory Framework. PPP Policy In July 2008 GOK approved the PPP policy directive through which: PPPs are identified as a method for investing.
Interoperable e- Procurement System for SMEs 28 October 2015, Paris.
 Contract by Public Authority for provision of asset and/or services  With private entity  Private finance used to fund asset/service  Long-term in.
1 Office of the State Comptroller Bureau of Contracts Basics of Request For Proposal Procurement Presented by Nisha E. Thomas Elizabeth Jaggers Peter Vander.
Learning the lessons 2012 and 2014 procurements of audit services.
Seminar on Public Private Partnerships February PPP Experiences – Challenges and Way Forward Administrative Staff College of India.
CLC1501 Introduction to the PPP Procurement Approach – Principles of PPP Procurement.
Extra Care Housing The Next Generation 16 September 2015.
Evaluation. What is important??? Cost Quality Delivery Supplier Expertise Financial Stability Coverage Product Offerings Do you intend to negotiate?
Assessment of the Bidding Process in Construction Project ABDULLAH H. ABU ZANT. AYMAN K. ILAIWI. MOHAMMED FADEL. SODQI M. ALHNAINI. AN-NAJAH NATIONAL UNIVERSITY.
FIDIC Tendering Procedures
Construction Tender Process Tender steps between Client, Contractor and Subcontractor Dr A Kimmance.
Project Management – PTM712S
NHCA Education Series Contractor Pre-Qualification CSST
PRESENTER Jose A. Galan ▸ Division Director, Internal Services Department, Real Estate Development Division ▸ Current Chair of the Florida Council For.
Procurement Management
Guide for the use of framework agreements
MELD- Maharashtra V. Giriraj
Developing and Issuing the RFP
Tips for tenderers Liz Frizi: Head of Procurement
© 2017 Universal Service Administrative Co.
Public Private Partnerships
PROJECT DELIVERY METHODS
PPP MODEL IN DRY BULK & LIQUID: SUCCESS OR FAILURE ??
United Nations Procurement Division
HMPPS Innovation Grant Programme (2020 – 2022)
Presentation transcript:

Procurement in PPPs February 27, 2009

2. When do you start thinking about procurement? Preliminary Scoping & teaming Viability assessment Choice between Public funding and PPP Identify and allocate risks Select the contract type Define implementation structure Plan and manage procurement Choosing between public funding and PPP Choosing the structure of the PPP arrangement Procurement

3. What should you achieve with procurement? Process promotes healthy competition, not speculation Award is controversy free, publicly defendable and is transparent Process assures level playing field and attracts available competition

4. Tendering stage is not end of all A good tendering process cannot salvage lapses in –Project preparation and structuring –Contract design –Negotiations –Dispute resolution mechanism

5. Designing the procurement process Procurement process Procurement method Procurement steps Bidding parameter Qualification parameter (s) Define all of these… … to design the procurement process Procurement

6. EoI/ RFQ Queries/ Response Shortlisting Issue of RFP Pre bid meeting Amend bid documents Two cover submission Technical shortlisting Financial bid opening Financial evaluation Issue of LoI Negotiation and contract signing

7. Bidding parameter should flow from the contract Service improvement that we want to achieve should be reflected in the contract Bidding parameter should ideally be the cost of service Possible bidding parameters –Cost of bulk water supplied –Tariff per KL –Viability gap in Rs crores –Lease payments to Government Avoidable –Return on equity –Level of service –Amount of investment operator would make

8. Selection criteria should be a single objective parameter Preferable to have a financial parameter Better not to combine two or three parameters into one score, for e.g –70% weightage for tariff –30% weightage for coverage No carry forward of technical evaluation –80:20 does not work in PPP procurement –Technical ranking or scores not to be carried forward into final selection Results should be obvious to anyone the moment bids are opened

9. Best technical evaluation is a Go/ No Go stage Marking or scoring of technical proposals is complex and is open to subjectivity Best to define minimum standards that a proposal should meet Best to identify proposals that meet this requirement Qualify all proposals that meet the minimum threshold

10. Final proposals can go for a toss if pre-qualification is compromised The only place to disqualify poor bidders is in the pre- qualification stage Once that bidder is pre-qualified –Other bidders fear rogue bidding/ speculation –Faith in level playing field goes down –It is difficult to eliminate that bidder in technical proposal

11. Pre-qualification evolves with the sector In the initial stages of PPP, one should be open to a wide variety of participants –International players with relevant experience –Domestic players with relevant experience –Domestic contractors/ suppliers in the same sector –Domestic players with similar skills in other sectors –Financially strong domestic players with an international partner Best to look for a consortium that provides –Technical experience –Financial capability Treat international experience (or) domestic presence factually and rationally –No need to over depend or over emphasise either of them

12. Depend on simple documents and criteria The simpler and open the process is, the results will be more sustainable There should be enough confidence to make all documents publicly available –Bid documents –Evaluation reports

13. What should you achieve with procurement? Process promotes healthy competition, not speculation Award is controversy free, publicly defendable and is transparent Process assures level playing field and attracts available competition

Thank You